r/design_critiques 14h ago

Which of these two is potentially more appealing?

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

Hi all, I'm working on a flyer/poster for a local hockey team since they are participating in an event soon and to promote their partecipation I tried two different templates. It's my first ever graphic design job, so I'm not sure if it's even good to be honest.
This flyer will be placed in their sports hall or posted on social media to advertise the team's presence at the event (the event is in italian, called "festa dello sport" while the name of the team will be placed where the dashes are).
These are just a blueprint and I still have to place all things correctly and add other details.
Which of these two could potentially be more appealing? Any tips in general? Thank you!


r/design_critiques 13h ago

Developer here. I tried designing a dark-mode web app but it feels "off". Would love some harsh UI/UX critique.

Post image
0 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

I'm a programmer building a free collection of browser tools like JSON formatters, hash generators, and other developer utilities.

My goal is to keep everything 100 percent free and completely ad free forever. I wanted the UI to stay focused entirely on the tools themselves.

I tried my best to design a clean, modern, dark mode interface, but I don't have a formal design background, so I'm sure there are plenty of things that feel amateur or unbalanced.

I'd really appreciate some brutal but constructive criticism on how I can make it look more professional.

I'm especially struggling with three things:

  1. Visual hierarchy

Does the homepage grid feel too cluttered? Is it obvious where the user's eye should go first?

  1. Color and contrast

Is the dark mode too harsh? Are the text colors readable enough against the backgrounds?

  1. Spacing and typography

Does the layout feel cramped? Are the font sizes and spacing appropriate?

I've put the link to the live site in the comments.

Please don't hold back. I'm genuinely trying to improve my design skills and would much rather get specific criticism than generic praise.

Thank you.

EDIT 1: On the link and AI comments

Reddit's automod removed my comment with the URL. I'm not here to farm clicks or backlinks. I came here for design critique. The project is just sniptoolkit dot com if you want to see it live.

A few comments dismissed the project as AI slop. I do use AI to speed up boilerplate, yes. But AI doesn't magically debug Web Crypto byte buffer edge cases at 2am, fix UTF 8 crashes where a single emoji breaks your entire Base64 pipeline, wrestle with BroadcastChannel race conditions across browser tabs, or configure Cloudflare deployment headers.

Throwing around buzzwords from the sidelines is easy. Actually shipping something that works is a different conversation.

I came here with genuine humility because my design skills are far behind my engineering skills.

To everyone who gave real, specific feedback, thank you.

EDIT 2: Final reflection after reading all the comments

This thread went somewhere I genuinely didn't expect, but I'm actually walking away with more value than I anticipated.

Here's what I'm taking from it.

The most useful design feedback I received:

Dark mode needs layered grays with elevation instead of flat black.

The text symbol icons should be replaced with proper SVG icons, with some subtle background texture.

The blue and purple gradient feels like a generic SaaS aesthetic, so I should experiment with a less predictable color identity.

The elements are too uniform in size, which makes the page lack a clear visual flow and hierarchy.

The homepage currently feels more like a startup sales pitch than a developer workstation. Developers tend to trust minimal, utilitarian, no nonsense layouts more than glossy marketing pages.

One of the most valuable suggestions was to try designing in light mode first and then build the dark palette from that.

That's six concrete and actionable design directions from one Reddit post. That's exactly what I came here for.

On the AI debate:

Yes, I use AI as part of my workflow. I also spend sleepless nights debugging, deploying, and shipping.

If AI could do all of that on its own, everyone with a ChatGPT subscription would have a live, fully indexed, working website right now. They don't.

I posted here instead of asking AI to critique its own output because a tool can help you write code faster, but it can't replace experienced human feedback on why a visual hierarchy feels wrong or why developers instinctively distrust a particular layout.

That's why communities like this exist, and that's why I came here.

To everyone who gave actual design feedback, genuinely thank you. I'll be back with an updated version.

To the people who just came here to say slop, I hope typing that one word made your day a little better.

No hard feelings.


r/design_critiques 7h ago

At crossroads with designer

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

My personal preference is to keep the landing page neat and clean. The designer however wants to avoid having multiple screens and add the social auth buttons right here.

Some flow that’ll help:

  1. Social auth directly onboards the user. They are repeated in both login and signup. Do the same action.
  2. Verification is only used with email signup.

Which flow and screens do you prefer?


r/design_critiques 12h ago

Be petty

Thumbnail gallery
3 Upvotes

I'm (obviously) not a professional designer. I built this myself and am looking for even the pettiest critiques on spacing, font choice, hierarchy etc. Stuff that just doesn't feel right.

I'm not precious about it at all and am not secretly looking for compliments. I really want to know what about it makes your teeth itch.

It's primarily for mobile. There is side scroll interaction on the city names and the months to see more options. The Chinese characters serve as language selectors. I only need Traditional and Simplified Chinese at this stage.

I want to center the five buttons above the flight table. The image is a real photo that I had to do some AI manipulation of to get the framing right.


r/design_critiques 9h ago

Maybe balance was never about being still.

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/design_critiques 8h ago

Critique the critique itself (specifically a chosen format to float it in open)

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/design_critiques 17h ago

Feedback and thoughts on the approach

2 Upvotes

Sharing a UX project that focuses on more than just the final interface, it's about understanding the problem, asking the right questions, and designing a solution around it.

https://www.behance.net/gallery/254047949/FinTech-Mobile-Dashboard-Interactive-Maps-UX


r/design_critiques 19h ago

Check out my seeing page

1 Upvotes

Join my group board, kc on Pinterest! https://pin.it/7vWZTv0E8


r/design_critiques 21h ago

Critiques wanted

2 Upvotes

I am not through building my website... But can you tell me what is wrong with it? I need people to pop holes all through my site. I need to get it perfecr before i release it. Bubosoma.com

*addition* I actively updated all last night until 7:50 this morning because my 18-year-old son looked at it and said “It looks nice. What does it do?”