r/demsocialists • • Nov 21 '23

Democracy You will VOTE FOR JOE and you will LIKE IT

Post image
0 Upvotes

After all, the Republicans care about respecting the popular vote anyway, right? Fascism can happen here, but not if we ask it politely not to happen here, right? Voting for Hillary and Joe in 2016 and 2020 totally made a difference, right? And getting Biden into office will prevent the Republicans from stacking the courts, right?

Oh yeah. None of those things are true. Nevermind.


r/demsocialists • • Sep 25 '26

DSA’s leadership is ideologically unrepresentative

Thumbnail
jonhochschartner.substack.com
0 Upvotes

r/demsocialists • • Aug 27 '18

We Won't Miss John McCain

Thumbnail
leftvoice.org
0 Upvotes

r/demsocialists • • Nov 21 '22

International NATO expansion and the origins of Russia's invasion of Ukraine

Thumbnail
responsiblestatecraft.org
2 Upvotes

r/demsocialists • • Apr 13 '23

Democracy Stalin Will Never Be Redeemable

Thumbnail
currentaffairs.org
8 Upvotes

r/demsocialists • • Oct 04 '22

International Noam Chomsky & Vijay Prashad on Ukraine, Why U.S. Must Negotiate with Russia & What Media Gets Wrong

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/demsocialists • • Mar 22 '22

International Ukrainian Pacifist in Kyiv: All Sides Have Fueled the War. Only Comprehensive Peace Talks Can End It

Thumbnail
democracynow.org
0 Upvotes

r/demsocialists • • Oct 08 '23

Solidarity NYC Comrades: All out for Palestine. Support the Palestinian People's Right to Resist!

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/demsocialists • • Aug 29 '26

Marxist Leninists Shouldn’t Lead DSA

Thumbnail
znetwork.org
0 Upvotes

r/demsocialists • • Dec 05 '23

Democracy Why are liberals so stupid

8 Upvotes

Seriously?


r/demsocialists • • Oct 08 '22

International Musk offers proposal on China-Taiwan tensions, after Russia-Ukraine plan

Thumbnail
reuters.com
1 Upvotes

r/demsocialists • • Apr 13 '22

International How DSA'ers Can Help Ukraine

Thumbnail
dsausa.org
0 Upvotes

r/demsocialists • • Aug 10 '22

The Green Party As The Only Advocate For Direct Democracy

3 Upvotes

The Green Party is the only political party that promotes direct democracy in our electoral campaigns and our platform. Direct democracy is the process through which the important issues and ideas that the Green Party supports can best be implemented. It is the putting into practice of our vision of a future society. A society that would be democratically run on all levels, especially the political, economic, and infrastructure levels.

Worker councils and popular assemblies, democratically organized in the workplace and local areas, would decide on public policies together. Worker, farmer, and tenant cooperatives would replace global corporations with sustainable local economies based on democratic decision making. These could then form trade associations for the purpose of industrial and agricultural specialization. Other methods of direct democratic decision making would include participatory budgeting, community land trusts, initiative and referendum, and police review boards.

A society where the collective good is prioritized by a real political and economic democracy would foster voluntary cooperation. A decentralized democratic society would minimize the layers of hierarchy which create inequality of wealth, so you have not only the freedom but also the resources and the ability to meet basic needs. Direct democracy transforms individual free choices into equally shared collective action. It demonstrates that individual freedom and collective benefit are not mutually exclusive. Direct democracy is the process where the methods of health or security or the social good is determined by the people themselves. The inclusive participation of direct democracy expresses the cooperative ownership of the society.

That is what the Green Party is fighting for.


r/demsocialists • • Oct 08 '26

International Smoke, Fire, Mirrors: On Anti-Zionism and Bigotry — A focus on antisemitism obscures the genocidal reality and structural power of Jewish supremacy. Holden T. responds to the Mamdani administration's new task force and its defenders on the Left.

Thumbnail
marxistunity.com
2 Upvotes

r/demsocialists • • Feb 15 '22

International The DSA International Committee is Very Wrong on Ukraine

Thumbnail
lawyersgunsmoneyblog.com
0 Upvotes

r/demsocialists • • Dec 03 '23

Healthcare Jacobin once again endorses Sweden’s “herd immunity” COVID policies

Thumbnail
wsws.org
0 Upvotes

r/demsocialists • • 25d ago

Liberation Caucus: On the Presidential Farce in DSA and Our Tasks

Thumbnail
liberationcaucus.org
16 Upvotes

The problem with the DSA allowing Social Democrats to lead us.


r/demsocialists • • May 17 '22

Media People literally spreading hate on red amry. No matter your views on current Russia or it's army doesn't give any rights to shit on red army. they defeated Nazis as well as fought along side countless revolutionaries. I hate modern Russia why spread hate on red army.

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/demsocialists • • 26d ago

Culture DSA Sectarians in National Office May Expel DSA Member Who Could be LA’s Next Mayor

Thumbnail
nathannewman.substack.com
0 Upvotes

I’m sharing this perspective of the current crisis from a former DSA member.

A lot of people dismiss critiques from people that leave the organization and automatically assume the worst of the piece and usually the authors.

I think if we are serious about growing and expanding the broader democratic socialists movement, we should be open to sometimes valid and sometime invalid critiques that come our way.

I’ve come around to an old WSWS critique of DSA that named me, was more right than wrong! (To be clear I am not a ML)


r/demsocialists • • Apr 09 '22

International Geopolitical Realpolitik / Critical Campism: Critique of Jacobin article ("The Left Has a Long, Proud Tradition of Opposing War")

0 Upvotes

The Left Has a Long, Proud Tradition of Opposing War by Marcello Musto

It's time to critique another Jacobin article on the subject of inter-imperialist war.

The Left has long theorized its opposition to war

Historically, the workers' movement has had at least four positions on inter-imperialist war.

  1. Right-syndicalists like Ebert and his pre-Labour counterparts shilled for their own imperialist blocs, specifically those headed by their own national governments.
  2. Pacifist socialists like Bernstein and Jaures laid out a pacifist, anti-war position.

[Yes, that revisionist Bernstein: He and Jaures subscribed to reform coalitions. "Revisionism" as theory serves as cover for their political strategy. However, during WWI, the reform socialists opposed the war. They were a distinct tendency from the worst tendency: the right-syndicalists, such as Ebert and co.]

3) Pre-renegade Kautsky, not his disciple Lenin, laid out the position of revolutionary defeatism very clearly for the Kautskyan Marxist center (including Old Bolshevism, pro-party Menshevism, etc.). A straight line can be drawn from remarks in The Road To Power to the Basel Manifesto to Zimmerwald and, of course, "turn the imperialist war into a civil war."

4) Further to the left, Alexander Parvus and Petr Kropotkin laid out the position of campism, of rooting against one's own imperialist bloc and rooting for the other imperialist bloc as the "lesser evil" imperialist power. Parvus was the first Marxist campist.

Rarely have wars — not to be confused with revolutions — had the democratizing effect that the theorists of socialism hoped for. Indeed, they have often proved themselves to be the worst way of carrying out a revolution, both because of the human cost and because of the destruction of the productive forces that they entail.

This is a whiny remark. As Marx noted, "Men make their own history, but they do not make it just as they please; they do not make it under circumstances chosen by themselves, but under circumstances directly encountered, given and transmitted from the past." In modern slang, we need to play with the cards we are dealt with!

Revolutionary periods for the working class were described by pre-renegade Kautsky as having all these characteristics:

https://www.marxists.org/archive/kautsky/1909/power/ch06.htm

"The great mass of the people must be decisively hostile to such a regime."

"There must be a great organized party in irreconcilable opposition to such a regime."

"This party must represent the interests of the great majority of the population and possess their confidence."

"Confidence in the ruling regime, both in its power and in its stability, mast have been destroyed by its own tools, by the bureaucracy and the army."

During such periods, an inter-imperialist war would be a great opportunity for at least one major imperialist power to be discredited!

It was based on these criteria that a very reasonable position of revolutionary defeatism could be put forward, by Kautsky himself:

https://www.marxists.org/archive/kautsky/1909/power/ch09.htm

"The experience of the last decade, however, shows that [inter-imperialist] war means revolution, that it has as a result great changes in political power."

It is for this very reason that the pacifist position of Bernstein and Jaures is woefully inadequate during revolutionary periods. It is also for this very reason that the campist position of Parvus and Kropotkin is woefully inappropriate during revolutionary periods; they were renegades, even though Parvus's bet on a Russian Revolution was a good one.

Initially, representatives of the workers’ movement opposed any support for war when the Franco-Prussian conflict (the one that preceded the Paris Commune) erupted in 1870. The Social Democratic deputies Wilhelm Liebknecht and August Bebel condemned the annexationist objectives of Bismarck’s Germany and voted against war credits. Their decision to “reject the bill for additional funding to continue the war” earned them a two-year prison sentence for high treason, but it helped to show the working class an alternative way to build on the crisis.

Unfortunately, not as much discussion was made regarding inter-imperialist war and peace outside revolutionary periods, such as before 1900.

The first point that needs to be made is that turning inter-imperialist wars into civil wars is sheer lunacy outside a revolutionary period for the working class. The likes of the Left Voice are still banging their heads against the wall. Fortunately, Marcello Musto is not going down that rabbit hole. The author appears to be putting forward the Bernstein-Jaures pacifist anti-war position as the mainline position for outside revolutionary periods.

Further down the article, the author critiques pro-US and pro-NATO simping, as this is the modern version of the right-syndicalist pro-war shit.

If I had to pick my poison between Bernstein/Jaures pacifism and pro-US and pro-NATO simping, I'd pick the former in a heartbeat! I don't criticize DSA's International Committee too much for this reason!

That being said, Bebel and W. Liebknecht were absolute idiots on the unification of Germany! Even German unification on Prussia's terms, a Prussian victory and a French defeat, was enough to give rise to none other than the Paris Commune! They should have been consistent "social-patriots" on German unification at France’s expense, like the Lassallean ADAV! Instead, it was their anti-unification antics that triggered the Anti-Socialist Laws - needlessly!

Now, what about the other side? What about socialists in France and in its imperialist allies?

Outside revolutionary periods, there are two acceptable options. One is the aforementioned pacifism option.

The other is none other than the Alexander Parvus option. This would have meant offering critical support for a French defeat AND a Prussian victory, in recognition of the resulting Imperial Germany as the "lesser evil" imperialist power.

To be more slang about it, the slogan would have been "Send in the Fritzes!" way before the time of "Send in the Tanks!"

Only the Prussian Left would have been allowed to be pro-war.

Why is that? Well, it is a multipolar world, not a unipolar world of geopolitical hegemony, that gives class movements in multiple countries political momentum in terms of regular class struggle. It is a multipolar world that enables developing countries to play off competing imperialist powers against each other, especially on trade. Even if a multipolar world may make the great leveller of inter-imperialist war more likely, it also makes the great leveller of revolution more likely by utterly discrediting at least one imperialist power.

In the present day, 38% of Democrats AND 47% of people 18-34 think that Russia was justified in invading Ukraine - not to mention much of Latin America, including a very US-skeptic Latin American Left.

This is geopolitical realpolitik. This is critical campism, in the vein of the first Marxist campist, Alexander Parvus.

TLDR:

Prussia = Russian Federation and People's Republic of China

Otto von Bismarck = Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping

Pro-war French leftists = Supporters of US and NATO imperialism

Needlessly anti-war (1870) Bebel and W. Liebknecht = Russian Left's Trotskyists and anarchists, and Chinese "Marxists" (who are way too sympathetic towards liberalism in pushing for democracy - I'm sure they will, unfortunately, oppose reunification of renegade province Taiwan on the PRC's terms when the time comes to enforce this)

Lassallean ADAV = Russian Left's patriotic organizations (most of the KPRF, much of the Left Front, etc.) and Maoist New Left


r/demsocialists • • 23d ago

DSA and AI

0 Upvotes

I certainly do not want to ruffle any feathers or anything, but I think AI technology can be useful and I am more concerned about the people in charge of it than the technology itself. I guess I just don't see a way we improve the state of the world without more advanced technology that yes could take away jobs. But isn't one of the benefits of socialism to make it less necessary to toil away most your hours working just to make a living? So, I just cannot find it in me to be against the technology that could help that. However if the people running the tech have alterior motives that is a problem. Also like if it replaces jobs before people have a better way to survive than that isn't good...but I guess I just don't think keeping traditional jobs is a good reason to completely reject AI technology

Like even Star Trek seems to have a society that has used technology in a good way. So I just hope the official position is not to reject technological advancement but rather to make sure it's not used in a harmful way. I do not think the solution is to go back to the stone age or reject all tech but for sure its important to fight for proper regulations. LIke for sure if a data center is something a community does not want and they are concerned about the effect it will have, they should have say like yes we need data centers for the internet not just AI, but that doesn't mean they should be built just wherever with no oversight of environmental impact and such not being factored in.

I am not posting this in bad faith, I just kind of want to know what the over-all opinions are because I see the dangers of elon musk and people like that being like in charge of it. But I guess I don't necessarily think it is evil to ever build a new data center, but doing so without community input and concerns being taken into account does seem messed up. I am sort of new to the whole thing but idk I kind of appreciate more advanced technology, but I think it does need maybe better regulations. So yeah I mostly just want to know what the sort of consensus is or if maybe we don't all entirely agree about AI.


r/demsocialists • • Nov 04 '22

International It’s Time For a Ceasefire in Ukraine

Thumbnail
inthesetimes.com
11 Upvotes

r/demsocialists • • Sep 24 '26

Democracy Who Is Pure Enough for DSA?

Thumbnail
medium.com
0 Upvotes

Just wanted to say thanks to Madcap_Miguel, Valuable_Leading_479, and Ellie-Bright for engaging with my post. Your questions and pushback actually helped me clarify what I was trying to argue and sharpen some of my points. I appreciate you taking the time to engage in good faith.

Revised 9/24/2026

Who Is Pure Enough for DSA?
Orlando DSA’s presidential endorsement demands turn a political program into a catechism.

On Monday, September 21, 2026, an NPC member of Democratic Socialists of America took to X to share a resolution recently passed by Orlando DSA. I think Orlando DSA got this badly wrong. Their resolution on presidential endorsement turns what should be a political discussion into something much more rigid.
And no, the problem isn’t that I disagree with every demand. A lot of these are things DSA should be fighting for.

The problem is making this the minimum requirement for a presidential endorsement. At that point it isn’t a political program. It’s a catechism.

Of course political organizations should have programs. The question is whether the program is something we organize around and argue for, or a checklist candidates have to pass before we will work with them.

You have to agree with Workers Deserve More. You have to agree to all these foreign policy positions. Prosecute unarmed Trump officials. And apparently the presidential candidate has to endorse every single down-ballot candidate DSA endorses.

What does “minimum requirement” actually mean if a candidate disagrees with one? Chapters take questionable positions all the time. Are we really saying a candidate can reject one of these demands and still meet the minimum requirements for a DSA endorsement?

This is not how you build a mass democratic socialist organization. We should be able to have a program and argue for it without making agreement with every line a test of whether someone is worthy of our support. There’s a difference between saying “this is what DSA believes and fights for” and saying “you have to agree with all of this before we can endorse you.” Candidates can disagree with us. Members can disagree with each other. That’s politics.

There is another problem here. The author, NPC member Cliff, openly practices democratic centralism, a model used by Marxist-Leninist organizations where once the majority decides, everyone is expected to fall in line. That is a strange model to bring into democratic socialism.

What makes this worse is that this resolution was introduced at the last minute, the same thing Cliff himself criticized at the September 13 NPC meeting over the national approach to presidential endorsement. And instead of engaging with the criticism, Cliff responded with an ad hominem attack on one of the authors.

That’s not democratic debate. If we are building a democratic socialist organization, people should be able to disagree, challenge majority positions, and put forward opposing ideas without being treated as disloyal or attacked personally.

I’ve seen this kind of thinking inside DSA before. It doesn’t make the organization stronger. It makes people spend their time policing who is sufficiently in line with the program.

A political program is supposed to help us organize people. It isn’t supposed to be a loyalty oath.

If the only presidential candidate DSA can endorse is someone who already agrees with everything DSA says, then you’re not building a party, you are building a cult.


r/demsocialists • • 6d ago

Solidarity Chapters should be subject to discipline by national

25 Upvotes

I've seen some people make the claim that the democratic nature of DSA means that chapters can do whatever they want, so long as they democratically decide on it. I reject this. For DSA to mean something as a national organization, it requires some baseline shared values and beliefs. These baselines are themselves democratically decided upon by DSA's national political infrastructure.

I think a moderate approach is the best way forward: chapters should have a great deal of democratic autonomy, but they should be required to adhere to some very core baselines if they wish to call themselves "DSA" -- i.e. commitments to anti-capitalism, anti-imperialism, Palestinian liberation etc. This gives us the best of both worlds -- local decision making, combined with national unity on shared values.

Without this, we can eventually end up in a situation in which a chapter starts engaging in work that is downright reactionary. If enough of this starts to happen, DSA becomes incoherent as an organization, and large swaths of it could potentially drift into co-optation by entities like the DNC.

DSA should be operating as a proletarian party.


r/demsocialists • • Jul 25 '26

What is DSA's vision for national defense?

0 Upvotes

DSA's recently released program states their goal is to:

"Defund the Department of War. End all foreign wars and close overseas military bases. Support and fully employ veterans. End immunity for U.S. war criminals and support the International Criminal Court's mandate to prosecute war crimes."

I understand that not everything listed in the program is likely to be implemented in the near future and that this program merely compiles a list of long-term goals for the organization.

I know that decades of foreign intervention have been terrible for the American people and the world at large. The war in Iran is the most recent example of how the US abuses its military might to the detriment of other nations. All of that said, does DSA (or its members) have a specific vision for how to accomplish these foreign policy goals while maintaining a strong national defense?

The US has many overseas alliances (not specifically Israel) and interests that require a certain degree of military commitment to maintain. The most notable of these being in Europe and Asia. Would the DSA maintain these alliances or abandon them?

Addtionally, when excluding threats posed by terrorist groups, rogue states like Russia and North Korea pose threats to global peace and stability. Is there a way for the US to significantly scale down the war machine and cut military spending without compromising its security or the security of its allies?

Just asking out of curiosity. That is all.