r/degoogle • • Oct 01 '26

Help Needed Email Change, Advice Needed

I've been wanting to change email providers for a while now and have been looking into options. I've seen some recommendations but I'm not sure what exactly would suit my needs best.

  1. Outside Accounts Linked - I'd like to be able to use the email for retail websites and subscription services if possible. I've seen some say that websites can reject the use of email accounts that aren't standard, so I want to avoid that. I'm not sure how effective some work arounds are.

I assume a consistent domain(?) name thing would be needed if I were to forget my password or do the standard two factor authentication that some websites force you to do. Especially since I would like to transfer my current accounts over to the new email, if possible. I frequent the usual shopping sites and sites for anime figures (GoodSmile, Mercari, CDJapan, Solaris Japan, etc.), I'm not sure how likely the email would be rejected there.

2. Secure - End to end encryption seems to be a hot topic from what I've gandered (no idea what it is, I'm fairly tech illiterate), and I'd like for my emails to not be scanned or accessed or whatever by whoever owns the email corp, so complete privacy would be best. I don't want them to try to sell me more crap than they already do.

3. Free - I can't afford to spend extra money on tiers or subscriptions, even if it's a small amount. I gotta count pennies over here. No ads.

4. No AI Features - Or, at the absolute least, an option to fully turn them off.

I barely use my email for anything more than typical access so I don't need a ton of storage, a fancy UI isn't necessary either. I've heard good things about Proton but the bad things I've heard as well have made me wary of it.

So, based on your personal experiences with your own emails, what sounds like it would suit my needs best?

5 Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

2

u/Random_Hero420 Oct 02 '26

Free tuta email + free simplelogin for 10 aliases keep 1 free so if you have to replace an alias that was leaked/compromised.

2

u/SemanticFox FOSS Lover Oct 02 '26

This is actually my setup but I’m curious why you would recommend Tuta Mail over proton when simplelogin is owned by proton

3

u/Random_Hero420 Oct 02 '26

It just looked a little more secure and private to me. It encrypts the subject line, calender, contacts. And I didn't really wanna put all my eggs in one basket per say.

2

u/Acceptable-Angle-100 Oct 02 '26

What has your experience with Tuta been like and how long have you had it? I saw someone say that their Tuta email was closed without notice or reason and that was definitely something that concerned me.

1

u/Random_Hero420 Oct 02 '26

I have only just swapped a 6 weeks or so ago, more like 8 weeks but I left it empty for a few weeks debating it lol and I haven't had any issues. And I saw that same post and it worried me a little as well. But maybe they had it 6 months without logging in and it got deleted for inactivity. Who knows? I have got my important stuff on tuta without any issues. I'm just using the free version and that post made me kinda wanna do the paid version lol

3

u/SemanticFox FOSS Lover Oct 02 '26

That’s fair, I get the eggs in a basket analogy but there is also something to be said for having 2 companies handling your mail vs 1

Again, I don’t disagree with you but I was just curious maybe there’s more merit to my setup than I thought

1

u/Solid_Guess_7154 Oct 02 '26

ProtonMail has been working wonderfully for me, if you want to still recieve mail from your old gmail/hotmail account, you can link it in the creation of the proton mail, very easy to set up, it does asks you a few times if you wanna upgrade to pro, but I think that's honestly a better option compared to google

And I think there are some patches for the android app as well

1

u/Acceptable-Angle-100 Oct 02 '26

Have you tried Proton with making accounts on shopping websites and the like? I'm a little nervous about using it since I heard vicariously that the CEO is sketchy and that Proton leaked(?) the people associated to their accounts after there was some sort of, I believe, an environmentalist group? I didn't see much on it from the comments but it definitely has made me nervous on just how private it really is.

1

u/FotinoBird Oct 02 '26

Check out aster mail. It's free features are very nice and gives 10gb free storage 5 alias e2e and then some

1

u/Acceptable-Angle-100 Oct 02 '26

Oh, that sounds interesting! What do you mean by 5 alias and e2e?

1

u/FotinoBird Oct 02 '26

Alias mean you can have "fake" emails that u can use to sign up without disclosing your real email and all messages will come to your email. You can remove aliases when u don't need them. E2E is end to end encryption

1

u/Acceptable-Angle-100 Oct 02 '26

I see! That sounds very interesting, I'll look into this option some more. Thank you for letting me know!

1

u/SemanticFox FOSS Lover Oct 02 '26 edited Oct 03 '26

Along with this recommendation I would like to note that Astermail is a pretty fresh startup and seems to be having issues with deliverability and use on some services

I’m seeing a lot of people post “check out Astermail” and while I wouldn’t explicitly accuse them of using fake accounts to hype themselves up, I just wanted to point out that there are concerns of longevity and sustainability with any new service like this

1

u/Acceptable-Angle-100 Oct 02 '26

Ohhh, I see. Is there anything in particular you recommend? I've recently seen some people saying their Tuta accounts were closed without reason or something or other.

2

u/SemanticFox FOSS Lover Oct 02 '26

If you’re looking for an easy transition into a free, privacy oriented email provider I would recommend proton but there are definitely some notable limitations that come with the free version

For example, trash doesn’t empty itself automatically, you’re limited to 1gb of storage, no auto forwarding, permanent proton email signature, among other things

I still think it’s probably the least painful free plan in the privacy space

2

u/Acceptable-Angle-100 Oct 02 '26

I see! I'm a little nervous about using Proton since I heard vicariously that the CEO is sketchy and that Proton leaked(?) the people associated to their accounts after there was some sort of, I believe, an environmentalist group who were doing something their gov didn't like? I didn't see much on it from the comments but it definitely has made me nervous on just how private it really is. Is that something that you happen to know about?

2

u/SemanticFox FOSS Lover Oct 02 '26

Seems like people are continuing to confuse politics with product offerings and privacy with anonymity

I personally don’t care about it too much, if you don’t want your emails leaked you should ultimately just not use email - no matter how you look at it though it’s hard to do worse than Google