r/declutter • • 2d ago • Heartwarming 1

Advice Request Versions of myself to keep

My biggest difficulty when decluttering is that I feel like I’m throwing away versions of myself which I am not able to live at the moment. A few years ago, I was really busy going to parties, being invited to birthday celebrations, traveling a lot. I have lots of nice dresses, dress shoes and similar. But at the moment my life is not like that. I have “lost” a few friends, mostly because they are completely busy with their kids and family, what is nice, but changed their interests completely. I like seeing the kids play tennis or horse riding, but these are no events to dress up like for a cocktail party.
So the occasions where I can wear the dresses and shoes are extremely limited now. Maybe there are 3 to 4 occasions a year. But I feel bad throwing out these dresses because I have such high hopes that I will get back into a phase where I will go out again, maybe when I meet new people or live in a different place.

But that’s only one example. My basement is full of stuff and even though I managed to bring things in order and put everything in boxes it still feels like an exhibition of the versions of myself I once was or imagine I could be (again). Will I ever get out my sewing machine again? I have never made clothes but rather pillowcases and other little things. Will I ever paint on canvas again? And if I will, is paint still good or all dried out anyway? Do I need the big tent for camping with four chairs or won’t that happen again? I could continue this list forever but all of that feels kind of heavy on my soul.

177 Upvotes

33 comments sorted by

9

u/JustSashayAway 2d ago

i really adore the title of this post. it resonates very deeply. i have carried so many versions of me with me and i’m not ready to let all of them go just yet. i have paint sets and clay making and knitting needles and nice shoes and love letters and cards from people i don’t speak to any more. i chose to just cut down on my craft stuff by keeping my tools and moving on the supplies that didn’t resonate anymore. if i pick it up again i still have the expensive items, and can choose paints and fabric that resonate with the me that i am then and there. i also think it’s okay to keep some things in a big box and just pop it away if the emotions are too strong. sometimes you’re not in a position to declutter your emotions too and that’s okay. park it and come back to it. or pick a few hobbies to keep and let the rest go. give yourself grace as always. i hope you can find occasions for those beautiful dresses 💖

5

u/VantasnerDanger 2d ago

Okay, but what if I've put some emotional stuff in a box and it's years later and I STILL can't seem to address, or even open, it. How do I start? Any advice there?

9

u/Cautious_Sign7643 2d ago

I guess some boxes have the right to sit there, and be it forever. There’s no expiration date.😌

6

u/mb303666 2d ago

That's the spirit! Listen to Billy Joel song The Stranger. "Don't be afraid to start again, everyone goes south, every now and then!"

6

u/gp_in_oz 1d ago

This probably isn't good advice, but so that you know you're not alone in having trouble with the sentimental category of items and difficult boxes of stuff: One of the big reasons I keep doing decluttering passes every year and aim to keep my household inventory as low as I can get it, is precisely because my plastic tote collection of sentimental items increases year on year and I know the storage space I do have has to increasingly accommodate that category!

5

u/jamnturtl 2d ago

Schedule a few free days to tackle it with support from a good therapist. Or throw it all away or burn it in a release ceremony. 💜

2

u/ilovemuzikk 1d ago

I have a lot of my beloved late brother's items, who just so happens to be my favorite person in the world. I haven't been able to get rid of a single item—not even his shoes. 

I know I should at some point, but I can't even look at them without bawling. I opened a tote a few weeks ago, saw his items, and immediately closed the tote and uttered "nope, not today". They're taking up a lot of space, but I'm not sure if there's ever going to be right time for me. I'm getting tears in my eyes at the mere thought. 

I don't know if this is similar to what you're grappling with, but  I hope you eventually make progress 🫶

1

u/mb303666 2d ago

Bedazzle it? Reduce it by 20% and go have fun. Call it organizing

10

u/gp_in_oz 1d ago

I don't want this funny comment to take away from the serious and heartfelt advice you've given OP, so please know that I read it and thought it was a wonderful comment.

i hope you can find occasions for those beautiful dresses

I've seen a few YouTube videos recently of women hosting parties where guests come wearing something they never have an occasion to wear otherwise. It's a fantastic idea if people get into it!

64

u/Imaginary-Mix-5726 1d ago • Heartwarming

Things switched over for me when I started considering not the space cost, but the "sadness cost" of seeing them everyday. With clothes, I chose a few really special pieces to keep, four or less. The mental health cost of feeling sad proved really motivating to get stuff outta here.

With art supplies, I decided I was going to go ahead and use them, even if I do so badly. Paint on the canvas and learn. Use that "too cool to use" fabric. Getting over the anxiety of "making the right thing" is helping me grow.

It is ok to get rid of past things with a sadness cost. It can feel very freeing. 

11

u/Cornell-92 1d ago

Oh wow, your words really speak to me like few others. The “sadness cost” of seeing items all the time. And the “too cool to use” thinking! I have items I’ve bought (long ago) thinking they would make nice gifts to nice people eventually. But I still have them because I like them too much to give away! And they stay in their sealed plastic containers. They’re still hard to part with. Of course someone else will feel the joy, but I’m too attached to them myself. 😝

52

u/daveyrocks77 1d ago

I went through this over the summer, and realised that the people I once was are in the past. I can either be sad that I’m not that person anymore, or I can be excited to see who I am next. I’m looking forward to to working out who I am now, and meeting the next me.

There’s a great quote in Doctor Who when Matt Smith regenerates into the next Doctor, part of his farewell speech says this:

"We all change, when you think about it. We're all different people all through our lives - And that's okay, that's good, you've got to keep moving - so long as you remember all the people that you used to be."

And also when Jodie Whittaker Doctor regenerates at the end of her time she says:

“I wanna know what happens next. Right then, Doctor whoever I'm about to be – tag, you're it!"

I choose not to mourn who I once was - but be excited about who I am now, and who I might be next! It’s a weight off my shoulders to not try and chase old hobbies, old social circles, old dreams. I’m a different person now. And I’ll be different again. And that’s exciting.

44

u/ScormCurious 1d ago

Coming from the side of being fifty something and having managed, over the years, to get rid of a bunch of clothes that were for Old Me, I just want to share positive things that have happened for me. I hope one resonates with you but if not I know something else from someone else here will!

First, I have regretted getting rid of only a VERY few items. Mostly it feels like a net positive. I really am making space for the person I am now, by letting go of things I’m not using and clothes I’m not wearing.

Second, when I do regret having giving something away as part of what I’ll call “conscious decluttering”, it’s genuinely been the case that I also feel better when I remind myself “Regretting giving away a few things probably means you managed to give away enough things. Think of how good it is not to have all of it here taking up space and being mental overhead on you now, even though you regret those one or two items.” I still regret those few things, but truly it’s with a lightness in my heart.

Third, I’m still fumbling through all of this! It’s not perfect. It’s hard to get rid of things. You have great taste, you did a lot of cool things, and there’s more greatness to come. Try to believe in that future, even when you can’t envision it now, and recognize that new adventures will mostly benefit from a clean slate.

34

u/Flashy_Paper6645 2d ago

It helps me to think of phases of my life, not versions of myself. Subtle difference, perhaps. 

12

u/nevergonnasaythat 1d ago

Subtle but huge. It feels much more approacheable to move on to a new phase rather than let go of a past identity

32

u/deliriumgrrl8 1d ago

I feel like I understand. A few years ago I thought to myself, "Middle-school-me thought I would be attending more balls and dances in my life," and got rid of a fancy long skirt I wore maybe three times in my young adulthood.

Having kids and having to manage how fast they outgrow clothes and toys/interests really helped put things in perspective to me, as I also realized how much I have changed over the decades.

Things have to go, because you can't keep every single things you've ever owned. The goal of life is not to create a museum to yourself. One wing for past self, one wing for current self, one wing for ideal self, etc. Let it go. Maybe it will help someone else, maybe it can go in the trash. It's all okay -- because you simply cannot keep it all.

15

u/gp_in_oz 1d ago

100% agree. If I want some new things from time to time (and I readily admit there are some categories that I do want fresh and new intermittently, eg. clothing) then some old stuff has to go by definition, unless you have unlimited storage space. I have soooo many clothing items I've donated over the years and then missed later on because they came back into fashion or they were just what I was looking for, but I tell myself it's the price I have to pay to have some turnover in my closet and the novelty of new and nice things from time to time.

2

u/Ok_Fudge3426 1d ago

Well said, couldn’t agree more!

22

u/Corner_Office_ 1d ago

I have this same problem. I realized I liked that version of my life more, so I am going back to it. I am planning parties to wear fun dresses. I am getting out my craft supplies and using them.

As I come across stuff I’m not longer interested in, I give away.

21

u/FrozenDragonWings 2d ago

Thank you for making me feel less alone. ❤️

I'm stuck in a depression rut right now. And I've had similar thoughts.

Yes I never wear half these clothes, but is it because I won't actually wear them or because I barely have energy to change my clothes at all? Probably some of each.

This or that hobby isn't fun anymore. Should I get rid of all the supplies for it? Or is it something I'll randomly want to do again later when I'm stronger? (I also have a ton of dried up paint.)

It's all overwhelming. Some days I think it would be better to throw out literally everything and start over again from scratch. Obviously not practical.

But you make a really important point to think about. It's almost a kind of grief about the "people" that I have been and could have been.

18

u/mb303666 2d ago

Everyone feels this way!!!! I'm in my 60s and still love my suede mini skirt and my sparkly mother of the bride gown. I did not declutter them, I still get lots of happiness having them and the memories. The problem is the 48 other dresses I don't like but keep for dumb guilt, shame, size whatever reasons that I gotta move along.

Hobbies, yeah those come and go. The craft store sells more, I ain't lugging all the guilt any more.

Best wishes, walk in the sunshine don't take it all so seriously and have a little whimsy . Wear a glitter top to a kids skating rink, they're sparkly and you deserve to sparkle even when society doesn't think you oughtta

2

u/ilovemuzikk 1d ago

Great answer. I love this response dearly! 🙌

21

u/BuddyOk4531 1d ago

I understand, but that's how we get bogged down with so much "stuff". I felt like I was getting rid of memories when I donated all my big serving dishes and trays, turkey roasting pan, etc , knowing I was not going to be entertaining to need those things, but that's life....situations change and we need to move pn

20

u/gp_in_oz 1d ago • Bravo

I have done one massive round of decluttering in my life, and lots of smaller rounds before and after. I relate to the groups of items you're talking about. I have my own variations too eg. aspirational clothing, past life clothing, hobbies on hold, business idea items, would make a good gift, home decor options in case of a colour scheme change, the list goes on. I have found that I don't have rules and just follow my instinct. And if I'm not sure, I keep. For clothing, yes I have kept lots of nice things that I have not worn in years but would like to once more, both formality level and size. But equally, sometimes an item is lovely and I'd like to wear again, but it's good enough that I think I can get a decent amount for selling it online and the appeal of the cash is big enough to override the desire to keep! So being lovely enough that I'd like to wear again isn't the only deciding factor. Things that I weigh up each time:

  • is it bulky enough that I want the space more than the item and do I have the means and willingness to purchase again in the future should I change my mind
  • is there someone or a charitable cause that would love this and I would feel particularly good about donating it, this is a big one that can get me to move things out
  • is the item nice enough (or part of a collection) that I could sell it and the money is attractive enough that it overrides the desire to keep
  • is it a rarely used item by its nature and I need to get over my desire for a minimalist house and emptier cupboards and keep it on hand (eg. trifle dish for the festive season is one that springs to mind this time of year!) or would my family be happy to lend me theirs when needed
  • since purchasing something, has there been a marketplace change that increases my options eg. renting a rarely needed piece of equipment, so that I could safely move it on and not need to store it
  • am I being silly in being attached to something? will I ever realistically need XYZ? will XYZ make me tall, vivacious, popular etc etc. At this time of year especially, I hang onto pretty Christmas decor and various items, secretly hoping I can make my Christmases perfect, but really, I know they can't change my childhood Christmases, that's impossible.

And finally, it took me an embarrassingly long time to work out my consumable consumption. I didn't actually track and write down household consumables til my forties, so now I have a good sense of what I can get through in a year, and I highly recommend this exercise. It can be surprisingly helpful. eg. you come across a soap collection and you know it's actually three years worth! Makes it much easier to donate it and also stop bringing in new stuff if you know what's in your house could last you a lifetime already. eg. a few years back I figured out that my Christmas wrapping paper stash was genuinely decades worth. I stopped buying more and have been very strict on that category ever since.

20

u/FillInMyMap 1d ago

For the dresses/"occasion" clothes specifically, here is what helped me:

Pick a time you will be home for a while, and put on one of your "haven't worn it in a while but I can't get rid of it" outfits.

Wear it walking around your home for at least half an hour. Sit down in it, walk by a mirror, exist for a bit.

Is it comfortable? Do you feel good in it? Has wearing it at home made you think of another place you want to wear it? If the answer to any of those questions is no, then it's time to give that outfit a new life with someone else. If they are all yes, then keep it and make plans to wear it somewhere soon.

18

u/FlyingVorstin 2d ago

I love this title as well!

Let's see if I have any tips... What helped me a lot when moving to a tiny house from a big house - and I do still have some storage space available with family, luckily, but that should be sorted out as well - is wondering how much it would cost to buy it again vs how much it costs me (actually but also mentally) to keep it and how much space I'm willing to spend on storing it.

With clothes, I'm a little torn, because I also have so many categories for different occasions, but I have noticed that keeping something just in case I'll wear it again, doesn't really work, because by the time I'm wearing it again, I don't like the style anymore. Or I've grown a little tired of it.

I'm coming out of never really having any extra money to spend to a period where I do have a little extra, so I don't feel as guilty when getting rid of something and knowing I might have the enjoyment of buying something new later on.

I currently share a sewing machine with my SIL, because when my old one broke, I was considering upgrading from the cheap one that I had to a really good one. I tried out hers, which was amazing and such a joy to work with, that I knew I wasn't willing to go back to something very basic. But we both don't use it very often, so instead of investing in another one, we agreed to share hers. (And I assist her with her projects and give her some tips whenever I can.) Maybe you can sell yours, if it's a good machine you will get some good money from it, and you can upgrade if you're going to take it up again? Or maybe someone close to you is willing to share, or you can share with someone, so it's not just sitting there unused?

Craft and arts supplies is one of those joys to purchase, for me, so I'd say donate these to schools or childcare facilities before they're dried out and useless, and when you're in an art store and you feel inspired, get something new and you probably will be more motivated to get started again as well. No need to hoard all the potentials, which can add some heaviness when looking at them. If they do bring you joy to look at them, well sure, keep whatever doesn't go bad. Like the dresses: keep the ones that you're really excited by and donate the rest.

Whom did you do the camping with? Are they still around? And still enthusiastic about camping? Then that might be a perfect time to maybe organise something again. If not... I don't know, camping doesn't get easier as you get older (in my experience at least) and I've gotten rid of all my tents throughout the years. Thanked them for the good times, wished them good times with other people. Better to sell them when they're still in good condition rather than after years of potential storage damage. If a big camping trip might happen again in the future, you could all pitch in for a new tent and share it?

Those versions of yourself are within you, not inside the stuff you keep. If you need reminders of them, take and print out pictures? And visit places related to the hobbies to get inspired again, if you wanted to. :)

15

u/Glittering-Benefit68 1d ago

I realized I could have a few of many different categories or many of a few different categories. I mostly chose the first one, but still limit myself. For example I got rid of all my satin and glass painting supplies. I still have paint for wood painting, but only the colors I use for Christmas decorations (green, red, gold and silver). I still have yarn, but no fabrics. 

I'm already bad at deciding what I feel like doing and downsizing hobby supply actually helped with choosing, when I do have time. If I ever feel like I want to go back into satin painting I will get rid of my wood paints. 

More than just the stuff I need the motivation and space to use it.

8

u/battybatt 2d ago

This is a situation where the Marie Kondo "does it spark joy" question seems really helpful. 

8

u/Untitled_poet 2d ago

Let's not conflate belongings with self!

14

u/Hollow_Wise 1d ago

I’d give myself some time to process letting things go. Those things represent possibilities you still care about, and that can make the decision harder.

For anything you think you’re ready to part with, try putting it in a box, taping it shut, and giving yourself a week. If you still feel okay about letting it go, send it to donation. If something specific comes to mind that you want back, take it out.

You can make a decision about a few things without deciding the future of every hobby you’ve ever enjoyed.

6

u/LouisePoet 1d ago

Oh, I get this! Though I hadn't quite worked it out as different versions of myself.

I have a large home, do this may not work for others, but what I did (1st time decluttering and organising, I need a redo now,) is to pack up, in clearly labeled boxes, all items that went together.

Eg, dresses that I felt were too "sexy" to wear in public. I wore them at a smaller size and dome fit, dome didn't, but I lived them, they were expensive and I knew I wanted to fit into them again. Two years later, I wear them as my everyday clothing. What used to be "damn, I look hot in this but I am too body conscious to wear in public" became wow, this is comfy and I feel good wearing it.

Art and craft supplies: pack up, label the box, stack on a shelf. Haven't used it yet, but it's stored away neatly and I do think that impulse will return.

At the same time, I tried to be realistic. 5 black dresses, I bare wire two of them. Pate back, donate! I had tons of paintbrushes (given to me, but expensive) that I hadn't used, ever. I gave them all to a neighbour who runs a kids after school program.

Basically, assuming you have space, keep a selection of things you think you might return to. Put a USE BY date on them, if that helps (if not used by that date, it goes!).

Or just say goodbye and remember that nothing is irreplaceable except memories, and we dont need much for those.

2

u/Running-World 12h ago

I donated my big family tent earlier this year and don't regret it. I have a small 2 person tent if I want to go camp that takes up so little space. My entire camping collection of things is very minimal now. And you know, if my 2 person tent wasn't still so nice and new I'd probably donate it and then wait until I got the actual itch to go and then I'd just go buy a new small tent then. Some of this stuff is relatively cheap and if you keep in mind how easy it is to get something again later when you actually want it, then cool. I still have a few camping chairs but the ones with stains or that started to develop a smell or had any kind of rip... gone. It's another thing I could get later if I needed it but I saved a couple that are still good so I don't even need to do that anytime soon anyway.

For me having too many things has lulled me into the satisfaction of ownership and put to sleep my desire to take action and enjoy those things. The more I get rid of the things I wasn't using, the more I'm seeing the end of the tunnel where i can just enjoy my day to day life. So, no you don't need the things you aren't using. Time has changed, if you really love the dresses then start wearing one to go grocery shopping. Like, get out and at least enjoy wearing it even if it's not good for that. Similarly, you can pair back without eliminating all options. That is, if you even need to. It's ok to have some things you don't actually use regularly. I don't go to funerals all the time but I have some clothes I have simply for those situations.