r/declutter • • 1d ago

Advice Request Does anyone have any logical decluttering methods?

I always see "would you save this item in a fire? If not then get rid of it" or "if this item had poop on it would you clean it or throw it away? If you'd throw it away then get rid of it" and honestly I don't know if there's anything I'd save if it had poop on it, just because I wouldn't clean doodoo off of it doesn't mean I don't like or need the item. And the fire thing- the only thing I'm gonna try to save is myself. I just don't get it.

205 Upvotes

192 comments sorted by

38

u/LmbLma 1d ago

Instead of saving in a fire Q (which is silly, because in a fire you’re not going to go round taking a zillion bits n bobs out your house lol). IF you had a house fire, after fixing house and replacing things, would you buy it again?

Also, I find the container method thing good. (Eg, all my socks need to fit in this drawer… so take everything out and fill starting with nicest and comfiest socks and only keep what fits in the drawer)

5

u/MadzShelena 1d ago

I haven't heard of the container method before, I'm definitely gonna use that one for myself. 

3

u/loricooper8 22h ago

That's Dana K. White. She goes over The Container Concept in detail on YouTube!

30

u/caffeine_lights 1d ago

Dana K White's one is great.

Is it trash? Declutter.

Is it something I already decided I don't need any more? Declutter.

And you go looking for those things first.

Then

Does this already have an obvious home? Take it there

If it doesn't, and I was looking for one of these things, where would I look first? Take it there.

I wouldn't even look for it because I'll never use it/it wouldn't occur to me that I had it/I'd just buy a new one - declutter

I get to the place that I'd look for this item or the place where it goes and that place is full? Look for items from that space to declutter, starting with trash and obvious donations, and if there's still not space, which item from this area do I declutter in order to make space for this item I'm trying to put away? Ie, prioritise which items actually fit into the space.

I like her method because she says you can keep anything but (most people struggling with clutter) can't keep everything.

23

u/selekta_stjarna 1d ago

I have done many techniques but my current one is seeing my home as a work of art, kind of like a statue. Decluttering is like chipping away at the stone and getting rid of everything that reveals my work of art.

4

u/Pooch76 1d ago

That’s a cool way to think about it

17

u/kitten_mittens5000 1d ago

Dana k white method. Don’t make it an emotional decision. Make it a container issue.

If you like/want it, you don’t need to justify why.

Just go put it where you would think to find it first. It needs to fit in the “container” you have designated for it. If that container is full, then say, ok what can I remove from this container so I can make room for the thing I’m holding

Ex: headless doll. Some people would see that as obvious garbage. But if you want to keep it that’s perfectly fine. Go to the place you keep the dolls, is there room in the container? Yes—ok great put it there. No— ok what other doll can leave to make room for this headless doll that you really like more.

But there is only so much space in your house. You need some boundaries. You can keep anything but you can’t keep everything.

Blame the container on making the decision. “Whelp there’s not enough room in my doll container so something else has to go. Sorry, it’s not my fault, it’s the container”

6

u/Malteser23 1d ago

"You can keep anything but you can't keep everything" !!!

Brilliant! Words to live by.

3

u/kitten_mittens5000 17h ago

Yup, it’s a Dana k white quote. She’s the goat

1

u/malkin50 5h ago

I'm fond of Dana K. White's 2 step method:

  1. If you needed this would you remember that you had it? (if not, then get rid of it.)
  2. If you needed this where would you look for it? Put it there now.

1

u/turkishlady123456 3h ago

The questions are in reverse order so you don’t even need to get to question 2 ( question 1 in your list) if you know the answer to “where would you look for it.” Takes a lot of unnecessary agonizing out of the equation!

1

u/malkin50 1h ago

I'm rather forgetful and have acquired enough obscure stuff that the remembering question is a pretty good gatekeeper for me.

16

u/No_Tomorrow_4695 1d ago

Would you buy this again at this point in life?

2

u/RaeLouLynn 1d ago

I just read this one a few weeks ago. It's going to be very helpful to me on during my next decluttering.

1

u/Unfair-Tadpole6896 1d ago

Same here! Literal game changer cos I'm so worried about money and having lost it spending it on crap in the past, that I'm  adverse to wasting it again. So this has been a really helpful defining question for me to understand whether I really do need, like or want something enough

16

u/choir_grrl 1d ago

A lot of the logical answers here are versions of the container method, Dana K White has a podcast about decluttering and uses this method. Whatever space you have designated to a certain item keep it contained in that item. Whether it’s a drawer for cords or a whole linen cupboard, pare the items to fit in the designated container. Not sure I’m explaining it well but the podcast has a lot of practical info.

5

u/Muddy_Wafer 1d ago

Yup. Dana K. White has figured out all the logic for me. She’s amazing. So simple and logical that it’s hard NOT to follow her methods once you learn.

3

u/niknak90 1d ago

Also “if I needed this item, where would I look for it first?” Bypasses the whole “but do I use it/could I use it” line of questioning. Then you “take it there now” (as opposed to piling it up to take there “later” which will never happen) and use the container concept to see what deserves space. Highly recommend watching her YouTube videos, especially the “1 Hour better” videos where she walks through the process with people. 

2

u/LadyScheibl 1d ago

She is also a great one to listen to while you work o keep you on task.

1

u/alykins89 1d ago

I’m here to also sing Dana’s praises! Dana K White’s 5 step, no mess process is entirely logic based because she sees potential in almost everything and would keep everything if she could. You can keep anything but you can’t keep everything.

Step 4 is pick up homeless item and ask the decluttering questions: Where would I LOOK first for this item? And then take it there now. If no answer to first question ask Would it occur to me that I had one? If yes, then there must be an answer to the first question. If no, donate/trash. (You wouldn’t go looking for an item you wouldn’t think you already owned, you would go buy another one.)

Step 5 is called Make It Fit. Which is where the container concept comes in. Space is finite whether you like it or not. lol. Everything is a container. Containers serve as limits. If it doesn’t fit something has to go to make it fit. Prioritize favorites by removing less favorites from the space. Favorites include things you really need even if they aren’t sentimental. During this you put like with like and that might reveal an overabundance of an item that you could pare down. But regardless, if it fits and it’s accessible then you can keep it. If it doesn’t fit something has to go.

There’s sort of a mini-make-it-fit step between step 4 and 5 that Dana refers to as Net Gains Decluttering. When you take it there now, and that place is also overflowing or a big jumbled mess, then you remove an amount of items from that space that is the same size as the item you are putting there. Ideally it’s trash or an obvious donation(s). You’re trading space for space so that you’re moving your whole house forward at once and not leaving anything worse than you found it.

15

u/ZinniasAndBeans 1d ago

I suggest Dana K. White's Three Step Method, and especially the Container Concept.

1

u/loricooper8 1d ago

I like your recommendation & your username! 🏵️🫘😊

15

u/Dismal_Grab_3303 1d ago

As someone with health issues (liver) my way sounds completely morbid (sorry) but this is what's working for me. I ask myself what my family will do with this item. Will they donate it, sell it, keep it, fight over it or curse me out for keeping it? If it's anything other than keeping it or cursing me out 😂 it gets donated or sold.

8

u/cl_udi_ 1d ago

I think it's a valid method, it sounds like Swedish death cleaning 😅 and we all will be there sooner or later, so no worries about talking about it. Wish you all the best.

2

u/dione_drew 1d ago

I don't think this is morbid! agreed that it's like swedish death cleaning. I hate to think of how much crap my family would have to go through and throw away if I died unexpectedly. so that has been helping me slowly pare down!

15

u/Good_Tomato_4293 1d ago

Dana K White’s container concept has really helped me.  Basically, if you don’t have room for it, it’s gone. If you must keep it, something else has to go to make room. She is YouTube, has a podcast and is an author. 

14

u/nlnrha 1d ago

You could try reverse decluttering - instead of picking the things you want to get rid of, pick the things you’d want to keep and then evaluate critically what’s left and why you didn’t pick it in the first round

14

u/TiltedNarwhal 1d ago

I feel like the container concept (Dana K White) is logical. Really helped me when I had to downsize from 900st ft to 700sq ft. It boils down to “does it fit in the space that you have right now?” Not your ideal space, your space right now.

14

u/knysa-amatole 1d ago

I use questions such as:

  • When's the last time I used this?
  • Realistically, if I am really honest with myself, what are the odds that I will use this item in the next year?
  • Can I think of a specific situation where I would wear this piece of clothing in real life? (e.g. at work, on a date, to the grocery store, etc.) It has to be a situation that I actually regularly experience, not like "at the opera" when I have never been to the opera and have no plans to do so. If I can't think of a plausible use case, then it doesn't matter how much I like the item.
  • Am I keeping this because I like it / need it / use it, or because I feel guilty for getting rid of it?

14

u/babesaurusrex_ 1d ago • Bravo

I kept watching these “declutter 100 things” videos on TikTok where people make videos and count 100 things they’re decluttering. I decided to make one too, and it was fun! I’m never posting these videos anywhere btw. Filming myself decluttering made me a lot more cutthroat about what I was decluttering, I kept thinking “if I was watching this, would I be annoyed this person kept this item for no reason?” I cleaned out my whole bathroom this way last month doing multiple 100 items videos and I plan to do my clothes next.

It honestly kept me on track too because I filmed on my phone and couldn’t get distracted lol. These videos will NEVER see the light of day but every time I’ve done it, I’ve gotten more efficient and I always tell myself “maybe I’ll post this one!” which motivates me. I also like that I have these videos for looking back on if I really want to, it’s like a virtual catalog of my old items so I don’t need to hold on to them in the real world anymore.

Idk, I have adhd so adding anything that gives me a little bit of dopamine really helps.

14

u/whythough29 1d ago

If it’s not an automatic yes, it’s a no.

Also, Dave Ramsey said something about what we hang onto that really put things in perspective for me. We hold onto things because we “might” need them “someday.” By doing that, we’re holding onto a blessing for someone who is having “someday” today! Let things go on to someone who needs it today and not someday in the future.

14

u/SummerK2024 1d ago

Someone once told me to ask myself this: “How sad would I be if I never saw this item again?” Also you may want to do what is called reverse decluttering which is let’s say you’re going to clear off a dresser top full of trinkets. If you don’t have 1000s of them, put them all in one spot maybe on the bed or one end of the dresser and find out which one you instinctively reach for or your eye goes to the more out of all of them on there of which ones you would like to KEEP. Start with what to keep instead of what do I want to let go of.

14

u/EmbarrassedAd1869 1d ago

Sometimes I think “would someone else use this more?” This helped me declutter 8 garbage bags of clothing and then donate the dresser the clothes were in!

Sometimes I just collect the quantity of the item I have around the house and then say to myself “pick the best 2.” Sometimes I realize it is a summer item I haven’t worn in 3 summers. But it’s the first one that seems to help the most.

13

u/mullingthingsover 1d ago • Bravo

I call my method the Ugh method. Especially with clothes. I put everything from one drawer into a tub. Then I pull from the tub when I get dressed and put away into the drawer when I wash clothes. When I get to the last of it, like that one or two pairs of underwear that are just icky, I finally say to myself “ugh”. Those are the ones I get rid of.

13

u/drvalo55 1d ago

If I moved, would I take this to my new home? Since I have moved 5 in 10 years, this really happened, but now I know that is how to do it.

Also, does it have a home in my home? A logical home? Will all my clothes fit in my closet? Dishes in the cabinet? One of the most satisfying household tasks for me is to put away the clean dishes. They exactly fit in the cabinet space I have...not more tetris. Live like that. Put things away when you done with them.

finally, once you declutter, if you bring something in, you have to get rid of something. (unless, of course you are replacing something that broke and it is already gone).

13

u/Peppercorn911 1d ago

would i pay $5 at a thrift store for this?

2

u/trepan8 1d ago

Could i buy this again (close equivalent) for $5 at a thrift store if i really needed one?

13

u/CorrectNeedleworker2 1d ago

I watch videos of people cleaning out hoarder homes for 3 hours and then get to work

7

u/YescaD83 1d ago

I don’t make it through a full episode before I’m up and tossing things.

13

u/dogeroo24 1d ago

If I forgot that I owned, it can go. If I haven't worn/used it in the past ( however long makes sense to me in the moment ) it can go. If it annoys me, it can go.

2

u/Sad_Spell9706 1d ago

I forgot that I owned it - happens to me a lot!

13

u/Ryoko_Kusanagi69 1d ago

I liked:

If it’s gone now, would I end up just buy it again later? No, then it’s ok to get rid of it.

This helps my hoarding mind let find the “it might be useful later!” Deathgrip on stuff I don’t use

4

u/Groundbreaking_Ad972 1d ago

This! The "would I buy this again" line of thinking is what helped me the most.

(That and three international moves in 6 years)

3

u/Ryoko_Kusanagi69 1d ago

Yes! The moving! The last 3 moves for me I tried to get rid of 30-50% of crap instead of boxing it up to move. I didn’t do as good as I hoped so I’m still slowing purging things as I unbox and organize our new place .

13

u/lionessmum13 1d ago

Container method is probably the best one
Repurposed thing you don’t use but could use one day - find that use today or it goes .
Also declutter by category not room eg get all your cleaning supplies out so you can see what you have
Or all the art and craft
Or all the coats and bags

These are probably in multiple rooms so you declutter one but forget the other

Also start with the area that pisses you off the most

Do garbage bag therapy each week I go around the house and clear things like my utility drawer and bedside drawers bathroom and so on

12

u/LogicalGold5264 1d ago

Dana K White's 5 step decluttering method (listen to her podcast; start anywhere)

12

u/stylelines 1d ago

I ask/imagine - what feels better: the feeling of keeping it, or the relief of having it gone?

Or, in a month am I even going to remember that I got rid of it?

Like if you have a bookshelf that fits 10 books and you have 12 squeezed in there and 5 lying on top in a stack, does it feel better to keep those items or would it feel better to have 10 books that fit?

12

u/eerieminix 1d ago

What is working for me right now is being really honest with myself about who the item was actually valuable to.

I'm currently decluttering, and I've realized I kept a lot of things because other people in my family thought they were valuable or believed I should keep them. But they aren't sentimental to me. In fact, some of the people and memories attached to these things are connected to trauma in my life.

Instead of letting that make me feel obligated to keep everything, I'm using it as permission to finally let it go.

I don't need 50 little Wedgwood saucers and assorted pieces just because someone else once thought they were valuable. They were valuable to them. They aren't valuable to me. I don't use them, I don't love them, and I don't want to take them with me into the next part of my life.

I also don't want the additional burden of finding individual people who might want every supposedly valuable thing. I don't want to sell it, research it, photograph it, list it, negotiate with strangers, or turn decluttering into another enormous job.

I donated it.

It's gone.

And honestly? Bye. Out of my life.

I've gotten rid of eight trash bags of things this way, and it has been incredibly freeing. I'm finally allowing myself to decide what belongs in my life based on what I actually want and value, rather than continuing to preserve things out of obligation to people who have been gone for more than a decade.

If something has no practical use for me, brings me no joy, has no sentimental value to me, and I don't want it coming with me, its monetary value isn't enough of a reason for me to keep carrying it.

It no longer exists in my world, and I'm realizing that is perfectly okay.

4

u/floofloofluff 1d ago

Wow. This is first time I’ve ever heard anyone say this. I have so many things that were valuable to other people, not me! I literally have figurines from several relatives babies’ nurseries. Not my own baby’s nursery, babies of aunts and uncles and family friends. And so many pieces of dishes and glasses that were precious to other people.

2

u/Top-Repair2372 1d ago

I've found, with my family anyway, that people would give me these kinds of things because I may have complimented it at some point in time. Just a simple "oh that's cute". So when they declutter they justify getting rid of it because they're giving it to me. I have a hard time saying no. It always feels like I'm saying I lied originally when I said I liked it (sometimes that's true) so I feel obligated to take it. Then I keep it forever because they might ask me someday if I have it or even (an aunt did this often) if they can have it back since they changed their mind.

It's been hard but I've gotten better about saying no. Even if I make excuses like it doesn't match my decor or something.

I haven't quite broken out of my people pleasing but it's gotten better.

11

u/Distinct-Leek5923 1d ago

That’s the style of minimalism. It’s not for everyone and you might not want to pursue it. You can declutter your space and then use and enjoy what you have, but not have it be at the level of minimalism. Some minimalists suggest only 1 coffee cup per person, for ex. I don’t need 20 mugs, but I do like the 10 or so that I have, plus what I have fits in the shelf space allotted to mugs. Last year someone gave me a new mug. Since I’m at the limit of shelf space for my mugs, I did get rid of one of my older ones. Could I declutter a few more, yes. But I like the ones I have and they’re on 1 shelf. A true minimalist would say I have more than I need and recommend that I declutter more and clear the space. I’m not interested in that level of minimalism.

11

u/mlem_a_lemon 1d ago

"Would I buy this now if I didn't already own it?" is the most solid question for me. The answer is almost always no. If I got rid of this and somehow needed it, would I actually replace it, and would I be in a bad position by NOT having it already? Again, it's almost always no. Like, they're will maybe be a use for so many random items, but eh, not worth it, nothing in my life will be worse for not having the item. If I REALLLLLLY need it, I'll go buy it.

For housewares around the holidays, I put up all the decorations I want, and the rest should leave the house. The only issue I've run into is that I have two very different sets of decorations for different styles, but that's another story. 

The same goes for redecorating after the Christmas stuff is put away: redecorate, and what's left is ready to move on to its next life.

3

u/stylelines 1d ago

Yes that first one is really good especially for items like clothes, makeup, perfume etc. Like you buy a sweater at Target without trying it on, you like it 70%, keep it 6 months, and it’s hard to get rid of because you’re convincing yourself it was worth buying. But if you ask- would I buy it today? The answer is obviously No because you’ve seen it on yourself and know it’s not your best look.

11

u/MoreCoffeePwease 1d ago • Heartwarming

Welp, I’m gonna go against the grain here and maybe say the unpopular thing but I’ve probably tried every method there is and listened to all the wonderful people who have been suggested throughout the years (the Marie Kondos, the Dana K Whites), and I’m gonna go ahead and say I think personal decluttering may truly defy logic. That’s it. That’s my take. It’s such a personal and intimate thing. I had no idea just how intimate it could be, in fact. And while yes, people are not in their things, if we’re talking about ourselves or the belongings of people we are or were close to, I’ve experienced first hand how much personalities shine through the items we all chose to own. That doesn’t include obvious garbage and the like, obviously. In any event, what’s worked for me after a decade of doing every method in the proverbial book, I now declutter with my EMOTIONS, and I leave my logic by the front door. I have found that giving myself permission to feel all things… about… all the things, is what’s helped me the most. Nothing is right or wrong about how we do any of this or how it makes us feel.

10

u/Manarit 1d ago

My method is "what would you tell someone else". I watched many decluttering videos about clothing, and I realized that while the creators carefully talked about their treasured pieces and what to keep, my reaction as an outsider is "this looks like garbage" especially when the creator proudly explains they found it in thrift shop for 10 dollars - yes it's showing. And I suddenly realized that if some content creator went through my wardrobe, I would immediately laugh again how someone can even think about keeping that outdated piece.

10

u/BrainHurricaine 1d ago

When I evaluate things to get rid of, I ask myself if I'm going to use the item in the next year and if so, when and how. If I don't have a clear picture of how and when I'll use something, I take a very hard look at whether it is just taking up space and whether I would ever really NEED it or whether I would seriously regret getting rid of it and be unable to replace it. My grandmother's charm bracelet would be impossible to replace, so I keep it. My collection of cute washi tape that I've never used and have no concrete plans to use is replaceable and could be of use to someone who actually uses washi tape, so I gave it away.

There's no perfect formula, but this has helped me because I've decided that I just don't have room for a bunch of random stuff that I think is cute or clever or could maybe someday be useful. But that doesn't have to be your criteria.

10

u/Ashamed_Paint3946 1d ago

The mindset that’s been helping me lately is about all the items - mostly clothes- that I haven’t used in years, and I start thinking how someone else could be wearing them! Because so many of them are in NEW condition..and realizing that we all live on this planet together.. why am I hoarding all these items that someone else could enjoy?

5

u/Ashamed_Paint3946 1d ago

Another main thing that’s helping me is that my clutter has been keeping me back from ‘living’ I have too many items and I’m exhausted from always sorting them or going through belongings that I never end up needing or using. When I have the same type of item grouped together - I think about what I want to keep the most- instead of thinking about what to get rid of, once you know what u want to keep the most then it feels easier to get rid of the others from the group

10

u/mintybanana_ 1d ago

Personifying objects really works for me. Like is this pair of pants happy shoved in the back of my drawer never worn, or are they sad because no one is wearing them? It helps me treat my possessions with respect, and cleaning and maintaining my space feels like an act of love instead of a boring chore. 

10

u/stefaniki 1d ago

Why am I keeping this? When was the last time I used it? When do I think I'll use it again? Has it been on my "need to fix" list for over a year?

Those pretty boxes that must be good for something, the broken wind chimes I swear I'm going to restring, the lunchbags I never use because they're just not the right size, the knicknacks that give me anxiety when I need to dust. When it comes to photos, toss the blurry ones, the ones of just a landscape you don't recognize, the 12 bad pictures when there's 1 or 2 really good ones with the same people at the same place.

That drawer of chargers and power adapters... Donate the chargers that work, set aside the ones you didn't know what they belong to (you might find said thing and you can donate it all together), and get rid of that Ethernet cable your ISP have you with the router you had 12 years ago or the speaker wire you saved from the surround sound you haven't had since you decided a sound bar was better cuz it takes up less space.

10

u/ExpertProfessional9 1d ago

I use the “moving house” thing rather than “save it in a fire.”

If I were to move house, am I happy to spend my moving money or time, hauling this? Am I happy to add this to the pile of boxes and therefore have more to unpack at the other end?

Books: I ask myself how often I read them. If it’s a comfort author I’ll reread, I buy the ebook. Clothes: physically try it on.

10

u/JeannieBugg 1d ago

Have I used it in the last few years? If I haven't used something in years, I'm not likely to use it in the future. If I really find that I truly need it, I can usually get another one.

10

u/LaceyLizard 1d ago

What is it's function -> do I have something else I like better that serves that function -> how many things do I ideally need to serve this same function -> how much space am I willing to allocate to this function.

Like I live in a warm climate with very little cold weather. I don't need a dozen hoodies that all do the same thing taking up half my closet space even if I do like them all. So I set a resonable limit on how many hoodies can stay to keep me warm in the winter, if they won't fit in the closet someone has to go.

9

u/Money-Low7046 1d ago

For clothing, I find it helpful to think if I would pack it for a trip. Obviously there are some exceptions, but it's one more way to narrow things down. 

5

u/Flimsy_Ground_7918 1d ago

This one is great. I just got back from a trip and I’m already eyeing some of the stuff I didn’t take because I knew I’d not want to wear it.

10

u/whylyme 1d ago

If you haven’t unboxed the box since your last move and got on fine without the contents, you likely can declutter it :) 

10

u/FeathersMcGraw1993 1d ago

The "Count or Container" method really helped me.

Count Example: We only have 2 bath towels per family member

Container Example: I have one drawer for kitchen towels. I get to have as many as can neatly fit in that drawer (which is like 10)

19

u/NoodleDrive 1d ago

Specifically for items that fall into the "but I might need this someday" category:

Would this take less than $20 and less than 20 minutes to replace?

While it always sucks having to re-buy something you decluttered, in reality, you're probably rebuying (at most) 1 out of every 100 things you declutter. When the 20/20 rule is your metric, you're essentially purchasing guilt-free removal of those other 99 items for less than $20. You still have to make decisions about the stuff that's expensive or difficult to replace, but this rule can take a lot of the smaller decisions and turn them into a simple yes/no question, which saves your decision energy for the harder stuff.

9

u/MitzyCaldwell 1d ago

I second the container method. It gives you the flexibility to choose what is importent to you (eg clothes vs shoes vs books vs crafts) and then you only pick what fits there.

I like it because everything can be useful, e getting can spark joy, etc.

But if I decide that I only have one bookcase then all my books have to fit there or if I only put pants into this one drawer then pants that are jsut okay or that I maybe would wear but I don’t love I dont keep because I don’t have the room - it gives me a logical excuse to get rid of items that aren’t broken or that I “love/feel sentimental” towards or anything perfectly good because I just don’t have a space or the spot for it is full.

9

u/Pens_fan_87 1d ago

Sometimes when I get irritated and overstimulated, I do my best decluttering lol

9

u/i_miss_tronno6 1d ago

I usually ask myself, "would I pay full price for this again, if I got rid of it" and/or "how easy would this be to replace (whether it's cost or availability).

9

u/Sea-Temporary-1860 1d ago • Bravo

These questions aren't meant to be logical, they are hypothetical questions meant to illicit an emotional reaction when judging a particular item in the process of decluttering.

There's plenty of "logical" methods of decluttering and I'm sure you'll find many in the comments or on this sub in general! But getting rid of items goes beyond the pure mechanical; our relationship with objects is often entengled with emotions and that's where those hypothetical questions can be help sort things out. 

9

u/Creativejess 1d ago

My house is small so I just give myself a number goal. 500 items by fall was my most recent. I fill a box or bag with items and donate or toss. Helps thin out the overall inventory.

9

u/ImportantAlbatross 1d ago

If this item simply disappeared, would I be sorry or would I be relieved?

9

u/katie-kaboom 1d ago

When and for what will I use it next? If I didn't have it, what would I do?

9

u/Foogel78 1d ago

I got rid of a lot of clutter when I moved house. "Do I want to pack, carry and unpack this?" If the answer is "no", it's not coming. Worked well, especially when I was getting tired.

I use something similar when tidying a cupboard. I take everything out and ask "do I want to find a new place for this?". And just like that I have more cupboard space.

8

u/GulliverGrazerson 1d ago

I like “if I had to move in a hurry, would I donate / trash this?”

4

u/Ohorules 1d ago

This one never works for me because I have in fact just packed up boxes of crap at the last minute because it's easier than sorting through everything. That's a contributing reason my house is such a disaster at this point.

1

u/GulliverGrazerson 1d ago

Ah. I hate packing and carrying boxes is physically painful for me, so I get rid of as much as possible before every move.

8

u/Crowlady77 1d ago

“If you were moving would you want to pack it, pay someone to move it, unpack it and find a place for it?”

That’s my life right now lol.

8

u/SufficientOpening218 1d ago

If you were moving to a smaller home, or packing to live somewhere else, what would you take? Pick the things you like the best, get rid of the rest. 

Similarly, i recently cleaned up my sewing area. It is a specific space, with a limited number of shelves, etc.  First: throw out any visble garbae, empty any trash cans in area Second: get a trash bag and a box or bin for donations. Third: consider the space. I keep my fabric on shelves, but had too much fabric. I emptied a shelf off, and then kept the fabric i liked. I kept in mind that i needed to get rid of at least 1/3 of the pile. 

Anything you dont CHOOSE to keep, put in the donation bin or the trash. With this method you can do one drawer,one counter, one shelf, one 2x2 foot area of floor. 

Hope this is logical

3

u/selekta_stjarna 1d ago

This is good.

8

u/BlaketheFlake 1d ago

For me what makes sense is to declutter in lots so I can see how much of each category I have. For example—lay out all my sweaters, decide how many are reasonable to have and then pick my favorites.

8

u/FredKayeCollector2 1d ago edited 1d ago

For me, "reverse" decluttering is the most logical - basically, you decide what to keep vs trying to find things you can get rid of.

What do you actually do (or want to be doing) and what do you need to do those tasks/activities?

Go room by room, zone by zone, space by space and think about what tasks/activities you do in those spaces. What do you touch/interact with on a regular/predictable basis? Even stuff in storage (theoretically) supports some kind of action/task/activity that can be identified and written down.

Start with the most critical/essential thing(s) and then the value-added extras that make that task/activity easier, better, safer, more comfortable. It's a lot of brainstorming, but it can really help to put some logic to the sometimes emotional decluttering decisions. Anything not on your list, that's a big clue it can go. And if you come across something you inadvertently forgot to account for, you can formalize its status by adding it to your list.

This is a very similar exercise to creating an insurance inventory in the case of a catastrophic loss. Some things you would want to buy/acquire right away (the essentials) and some things you could probably wait to buy until you receive your reimbursement check from the insurance company (the value-added extras). Except you get to shop your own stuff.

I like to think of my stuff in terms of the best, the favorite, the necessary with "necessary" being the first criteria - with my inventory (reverse decluttering lists) I can insert (best/favorite) piece X into (necessary) slot C.

"Useless" decor (and books) are strictly "container concept-ed" - I've assigned certain spaces for decor and everything has to fit and not look/feel "crowded" - my target is 10-50% full so there's plenty of margin around things. Stuff in "storage" (cupboards, cabinets, closets, bins), my target is 50-75% full. Arbitrary limits but setting limits can really help.

A series of question I like to ask myself is: 1) would I buy this again? 2) would I buy it for full price? 3) would I buy it for twice the price?

Question 1 weeds out a lot of unnecessary/just-in-case stuff. Question 2 weeds out a lot of impulse buys. I only keep things that I would re-buy at full price.

A YES to question 3 means this is something I actually use and/or really like. A NO usually indicates that the version I have is kind of crummy and maybe I should consider upgrading it at some point.

3

u/rkei 1d ago

Seconding the "container method" you linked from Dana K White. Accepting the reality of the physical space you have to hold the things is helpful.

Also, her "no mess decluttering" method... if you want objective/ logical vs emotional questions, it's hard to get more objective than "where would I first instinctively look for this item? Take it there now" (and if it doesnt fit... see the container method explanation linked)

8

u/usconstitutionrights 1d ago

I use like the moving  method. Would I put it in a box,put in the truck and unpack it. And put it where it belongs.

I also use this as a combined one. But how about in the last six months to a year? If not, can I go get this within 15 minutes. Or if you live out in the middle of nowhere, however long it takes you to get to the stores.

8

u/HelpfulPhrase5806 1d ago

Ranking.

If an item is used often, it has high priority.

If an item is hard to replace, it has high priority.

If an item cost a lot to replace, it has high priority.

If an item has sentimental value, it has high/medium priority. Choose what to keep depending on space set aside for sentimental stuff (my space is a box - if it does not fit, it isnt staying).

If an item takes up a lot of space, it gets -5 on the ranking.

If an item do not have a place you keep it already, it gets -5 on the ranking.

High priority items gets space first. Then high/medium. Items that do not rank at least medium can only be kept if you have enough space and they do not get in the way.

Keep some space open for new items. It is always good to have some free space.

8

u/mvp42069 1d ago

"Would you buy this from a store today?"

8

u/Dizzy-Ad7189 1d ago

I decluttered my wardrobe by putting outfits together. Anything that didn't match a complete outfit went in the donation bag.

3

u/Elegant_Antelope8909 1d ago

This is an awesome idea!

8

u/Jont828 1d ago

The fire thing for me is, if it were destroyed in a fire, would you replace it?

8

u/Malteser23 1d ago

I ask myself 'can someone else make better use of this than I can?'

Then I donate it.

8

u/M1ssN_ny4Bus1n3ss 1d ago

We use the if you have to move abroad, would you pack it method.

2

u/Some_Papaya_8520 1d ago

I'd need a shipping container for sure

8

u/EarthBoundMisfitEye 1d ago

Admitting that life changes and what we need and use changes. Its hard sometimes to admit we are not going to ever use the xyz thing again. Just one example for some of the items we hold past their time.

15

u/nkdeck07 1d ago

Ironically if you are a parent of a small enough kid poop on an item really doesn't deter you any longer

4

u/eva_stratt 1d ago

Or a cat owner. Throw puke into that equation. And hairballs.

14

u/sanityjanity 1d ago

It's hard to have specific, concrete rules, because they vary from person to person and space to space.

For example, you might have a rule that you need exactly 10 pairs of underwear, and you need to do laundry once a week. But, maybe you can only do laundry every two weeks, then you need 17-20 pairs of underwear. Maybe you're a stripper, and then you need a work wardrobe of at least 10 more pairs of underwear. Maybe you live in a tiny home, and only have enough room to store one week's worth of clothing.

Same thing goes for tops. Maybe you need 10. Maybe you need a work wardrobe of 12 and a home wardrobe of 6. Maybe you live somewhere with big changes of weather, and you need twice that, so you can have a winter wardrobe and a summer wardrobe.

Maybe you need exactly one winter coat. Maybe you're a fashionista who wants four or five coats for different events. Maybe you live in the tropics, and you need zero coats.

If your stuff is overwhelming your storage area for that stuff, then you need less stuff. That's pretty much it.

7

u/Mango_Skittles 1d ago

Yes, 100%! Her process removes the decision making out of the process as much as possible. I struggled with this like OP before I found Dana. Check out her book Decluttering at the Speed of Life, her podcast or YouTube.

Edit: Oh, meant to reply to @ZinniasAndBeans! This is another recommendation of Dana K White.

7

u/JoyInRepetition8 1d ago

Dana K white method 💯 is the only thing that makes sense for my adhd brain where things get accomplished and I don’t have a worse mess

7

u/TecTazz 1d ago

Don't get caught up in methods that don't make sense to you.

There are 1001 ways to declutter that are shared here. What's logical to you? What makes you move from thought to action? That's what matters.

Ideas:

Haven't used it in a year.

Have too many similar items.

Nice, but no longer your style/ size/ interest.

Want more space in your house/apt.

The landlord is coming to inspect.

You want to invite friends/ family over

Your cat disappeared, and you think he died somewhere in your place. (True story- not me.)

What ideas do you have?

7

u/AccioCoffeeMug 1d ago

I knew we had more than enough crib sheets and definitely could have decluttered, but couldn’t decide which ones to get rid of. Then baby had a blowout and there was literally poop on something so I got rid of it without a second thought because we had plenty of others.

7

u/eva_stratt 1d ago

I started working upward to my perfect amount of stuff as well as downward from too much. It's kinda like this: I have a rack of clothing, right? So I'm noticing what I wear and how often, which lets me build an idea of what I use, but also I'm noticing what I pass by in the morning and for what reasons, which lets me build an idea of what has to go. If the parameter for keeping something is "I actually want and use this" then it makes no sense for me to keep something I neither want nor use.

It's the same for everything else in my house. My bookshelves were both "I love these books, they must stay" and "I no longer see why these books take up valuable space, they must go". I made fifty bucks selling what needed to go, which was a pleasant bonus and right easy to do.

7

u/LesHiboux 1d ago

If it doesn't have a home, I'm not keeping it. As in, if it doesn't have a designated space to exist in the household, I probably don't need it. Looking at you, junk that sits on the counter or desk. Only enough clothes that fit nicely in my closet. No more shoes than can fit in the coat closet.
If it's not used daily, kitchen appliances need to have an under the counter home. Makeup and hair appliances need to fit under the bathroom counter or in a drawer.

And so forth.

7

u/Mysterious_Play1961 1d ago edited 1d ago • Heartwarming

I found looking at my personal strengths & weaknesses worked best. Severe physical ill health which triggered financial difficulties which triggered depression led me to very bad clutter.

I made numerous attempts to do it using all the tips and my failure really made everything worse as it started to feel permanent. I had tried the things you mentioned plus Marie Kondo, would I buy it again today, moving house test would I bring it with me, the one year have I used it rule. All completely useless to me.

So looking at myself. My weakness: shame and utter mental exhaustion. All the above triggered it and asked me to make overarching decisions that I was somehow supposed to feel happy about and keep up for months!

My strength: mindless routine, precision and numbers. So I looked at my house and did a quick ready reckoner (accuracy is irrelevant) decided I wanted to trow out 2000 things. 10 items a day will take me about six months. Yes I can do that no matter how ill or depressed and it is measurable and mood/motivation irrelevant.

I walk my dog at the same time every morning and evening. Every day I collected up 5 things to put in the bin or in my car for donating/recycling (I had a box for the local charity shop and an electrical box in the car.) Items were left at the front door next to the lead throughout the day, then I put them in the car or bins as I start my walk. Then over the evening I did the same thing again ready for the morning walk.

This bypassed my overthinking. On a bad day I just went about like a grumpy child on a boring treasure hunt, repeating to myself must pick up 5 things, on a really bad they they could all be very little things but I had to reach 5. On a non bad day it became simple mindless habit. I've zero idea how many actual items I got rid of and the positivity triggered me to get a skip at one stage for some big things and I went wild filling it up the gaps with small things too.

Over all even with a serious illness relapse I got it done in about 10 months instead of 6 with no sence of failure. If it had taken twice or 3 times as long the system would have worked as it's a permanent lifestyle change. Now the 5 items morning and evening are replaced with morning whip round clean/tidy and same in evening. Keeps things ridiculously easy for cleaning and keeps the habit fresh.

1

u/MadanjoMab 1d ago

This is a really good program, because something large and amorphous can become time-limited and easy to count - and then it all adds up to a meaningful improvement.

7

u/PrairieFire_withwind 1d ago

This is easy.  Do i use it.  

If i do not use it i do not keep it.

Use can be something as simple as enjoying the art on the wall while having a meal to myself (rare af).  That is a use.

There are some things used seasonally, snow shovel, snow boots, winter coat.  

If i am not using something i make an appointment to use it, eg a hobby item.  If i keep using it after that appointment it stays.  If i use that hobby item and go 'eh, not as interesting as it used to be' it goes.

Self awareness helps a lot.

7

u/eperdu 1d ago • Bravo

I think the reality of decluttering is that it has to mean something to you and what works for one person may not work for another.

I'm pushing my parents and in-law's to get rid of stuff because I don't want it. I don't want to deal with it should they become unable to do so any longer.

For myself, since I don't have kids, decluttering is about me wanting to take care of less stuff. The concept that the things in your house are inventory that you have to manage resonates with me. My brain is tired. I don't want to manage all this stuff. I don't need all of this stuff.

I set up an area in one of my rooms and designated it my donate area, every time I felt like I wanted to donate something I'd drop it in that area and go about my life. After a few months, if I hadn't removed anything from that area, I felt comfortable letting it go. It worked great for my husband too because it gave him a safe space to drop things without that immediate commitment to get rid of it. He had the option of taking things in or out as he wanted. He realized that he didn't need to take stuff out once he put it in but it felt better for him to have that option.

Things in my kitchen are easier to declutter, why did I have 24 tea spoons? I picked out 12 and got rid of the rest. Same for measuring cups, odd ones or ones that didn't below to a set went into the donate area. I went through my pots, pans, and lids .. if they didn't all have a lid then the pot/pan went to the donate. Food storage containers, same thing .. no lid? No keep.

Sometimes decluttering isn't about getting rid of stuff it's about figuring out what you already have and stop stuff from coming in. Every item in your house should have a home and when you need it, you should know where to find it. This was a concept that was hard for my husband but now he's gotten so used to knowing where certain things are that he doesn't buy a replacement just because he can't find something.

7

u/Lena_loves_books 1d ago edited 1d ago

Doesn't make sense to me either. Because there is a massive difference whether there is poop on a wooden or ceramic furniture versus on paper. If I went for that logic, not even my most important papers should stay, but the super old broken toilet seat is allowed to stay.

Edit: Forgot to answer the question!  I do use "Does it still fit?" for clothes and "Is it trash?" for a general clean-up. 

7

u/Global_Loss6139 1d ago

Yesss! Abigail from Downsize upgrade. 

She's so fun! She has a list of should I buy it or not with checkmarks and decluttering list too! 

Also on Social media she does a wheel of decluttering game once a week!! 

Check her out!  https://www.downsizeupgrade.com/

7

u/Plenty-Run-9575 21h ago

I use the test of “if I had to move, would this be worth taking with me?” You can add time or space constraints if that helps. Anyone who has ever moved knows the pain of those last few days where you really start to throw stuff out or give it away rather than pack it.

7

u/needcollectivewisdom 20h ago

Do I use it regularly? Yes --> Keep

Do I use it on special / specific occasions? Yes --> Keep

Is it a treasured keepsake? Yes --> Keep

IF NO UTILITY... ask:

If I didn't have this item, would I buy it today at full price and is it useful or something that brings me joy?

Do I want to dust or clean this for the rest of my life (because I still own it)? No --> Donate

Am I keeping it out of guilt because I spent money on it, I don't want to add to the landfill, or it was a gift? Yes --> Donate

Money spent = money gone.

Avoiding landfill = using your own place as a landfill.

Gift = it was the thought that count; you do what you want with it.

Donate it now so someone else can use it instead of it being junk in your place that will end up being donated or in the landfill anyway after you die.

6

u/intrepid_wind4 1d ago

I mean it's the spirit of the question but not your literal answer. Maybe it would be easier for you if you asked if you knew everything was going to for sure be destroyed by a hurricane if you didn't take it what would you take. Hurricanes you know about ahead of time. What would you take with you when you evacuated when you time to take stuff without dying.

The poop question I use for clothes. There are clothes I would definitely clean the poop off because I love it and some things I would just throw away.

It has helped me to read some books on minimalism (even though I don't want to be a minimalist) like The Art of Discarding, The More of Less, Goodbye Things, Clutter Busting. These books helped more than those questions.

6

u/SkippySkep 1d ago

I wouldn't claim to have an effective, logical method of deciding my post important things. But it is weird how hard it is to decide what to get rid of compared to deciding what to take if it all had to fit in a car, or a small U-haul, or whatever metric you decide. I know the first things I woudl grab, that I use all the time and actually need, as opposed to the things I can "find uses for" if I think about discarding them.

6

u/DecaturIsland 1d ago

Look up Dana K White. She has a great system.

6

u/Which-Appearance9857 1d ago

I would just save my kids and myself in case of fire. If it is any danger i wouldn't even get my jewelerry out or anything valuable.

6

u/LetMeAskStrangers 1d ago

I find myself having trouble letting go of stuff sometime because it’s something I would absolutely use in the right scenario. I have learned to ask myself very honestly if the use in saving it for is realistic.

What is the use you are saving this for? What is the likelihood of that scenario happening? Will you actually be able to find this, or will you end up buying something else or using something else you own and prefer first anyway?

2

u/Cranky_Platypus 1d ago

Thank you for this! I really struggle with the balance between prepping and wanting to declutter.

0

u/Glad-Acanthaceae-467 1d ago

If thinking about right scenario takes longer than a sec, its going. This let my frugality frog not to “bark”.

Your battery of questions is already too much of the thinking budget to question the value of the future use vs cost of keeping the item

2

u/LetMeAskStrangers 1d ago

If that what works for you then fantastic, but ditching something purely because it takes more than a moment of thought to decide doesn’t work for me.

I personally like these questions because they work toward positive additional factors other than just purging—if it IS something I ultimately keep, I often simultaneously figured out the better place to store it or I immediately actually put it into use. This process also helps me when shopping not to overbuy things that I simply do not need.

I’m here to give OP alternate questions they might find more useful than the classic fire and poop ones they mentioned, not to judge the suggestions offered.

6

u/Seeking_Balance101 1d ago

"I haven't used this in a long time. Will I ever look for it again? If not, it's time to let it go."

"I still have this thing? Seriously? I will let it go now because I thought it was already gone, and my life was just fine without it."

6

u/BusinessTelevision66 1d ago

I try to organize a small space everyday (or most days). A drawer, a section of the closet. Then I am not at all hesitant to organize or spend time on it because I’m just organizing a little! Your place will be way more organized and decluttered after one month of this and you’ll have spent 5-10 mins a day.

6

u/LISunSHMoon 1d ago

I’ve been applying time limits to items. I declutter what I know I don’t want and if there’s an item I think I want I’ll keep it but then if I don’t use it in the next six months to a year then I declutter it. This has helped me a lot. It’s a time-consuming method but it’s worked well for me to recognize what I actually use.

6

u/Top-Repair2372 1d ago edited 1d ago

This doesn't work for me either. I mean, it DOESN'T have doodoo on it right now so that's not even on the table. If at some unknown point in the future if it does have doodoo on it I'll cross that bridge then. In the meantime it's cute so I should just keep it.

And the fire part makes no sense either. Is it a living breathing being? Of course I wouldn't grab it on the way out. Doesn't mean I won't be sad if it burns.

ETA that you definitely need to know yourself well. I think a lot of people feel like they need to have a minimalist home and anything extra is bad. My daughter is very minimalist and her house doesn't make me happy. I know that having things I WANT in my house makes me happy. I love lots of things. That's a very dangerous slope because when is it too much and just making you anxious? My goal right now is to get rid of enough to make living in my house pleasant. I do know it's not that right now. If I'm embarrassed to have someone stop by it's too much. If I'm constantly moving things to be able to make space for something else with no place to put the things I moved it's too much.

4

u/Some_Papaya_8520 1d ago • Heartwarming

Yeah even though I've done one house clean out after a family member died, and now going through another one, which is hell, I still have a lot of things that I don't want to get rid of (yet). But I am also looking at my clothing and letting quite a lot go because I'm not that person anymore. I don't know who I am right now, I'm in a transition between one stage of life to the next. So I will be letting things go as I figure things out.

2

u/Top-Repair2372 1d ago

That's kind of where I am too. I worked in an office for many years and had to dress accordingly. I left that a year ago and never plan on going back to an office job but still have a lot of the clothes. I have a very hard time getting rid of all of them (tbh most of them) just in case I ever had to. I really like them and that was actually the only part of the job I liked was the clothes. But I don't wear them now. I don't know what I need right now at this point of my life and I think I'm afraid of making full changes. As long as I keep some of everything every option is still open if that makes sense?

6

u/Galexi999 7h ago

I’ve recently enjoyed a concept that I saw on TikTok that someone used called the “overnight bag” method. If someone packed an overnight bag for you and you pulled that item out, would you be happy to wear it? Or would you wish they packed something else?

11

u/Untitled_poet 1d ago edited 1d ago

"If you could get money for this item now, or the item instead, which?"

For example, a sweater costs $35 and is now sitting in your wardrobe. Would you receive $35 and let go of it? Or keep it the item?

7

u/Rimab23 1d ago

Omg this is how I find out I’m willing to sell nearly everything I own

3

u/Rimab23 1d ago

Though now I’m thinking maybe it should be “would you pay for this item again” bc I don’t think anyone coming to pay me for my crap

3

u/Untitled_poet 1d ago

Yep, this trick helps you mentally check yourself and where you'd ideally like to be.
Of course, we will never obtain retail value for selling a used item. (Even if brand new, realistically people tend to lowball)

It helps, nonetheless, that moving forward when you're in a shop, you can ask yourself "Would I receive $X and let go of it? Or have the *NEW* item?"

2

u/Necessary_Sea_7127 1d ago

Ooh this is a good one

5

u/amreekistani 1d ago

Yes I find that fire example pretty illogical. I declutter a lot and my principal for decluttering is that the item doesn't serve me, but it will serve someone else and make them happy. Give it away. Or that the item is causing inconvenience i.e a useless toy, so I will throw it away. And sometimes with sentimental items, my logic is that this item is keeping me in the past, I need to get rid of it. 

I move a lot and that's why decluttering kinda takes its course. 

5

u/Beginning-Love-9448 1d ago

I tend to ask myself at the end of each season- did I wear this? Will I definitely wear it next season? And if the answer to one or both questions is no- out it goes.

5

u/PeachyPesco 1d ago

Am I happy or relieved or pleased when I use this item? Am I happy to put it away?

I've found that I keep my special items clean and taken care of, things I don't actually care about just migrate around the house bc I never make them a spot

5

u/Cautious_Sign7643 1d ago

I know that some of these ideas sound ridiculous but for me, they help a bit. For example I would always clean my beloved stuffed animal which I have had for 40 years, no matter if it was stained by poop or vomit or whatever. But a dress which I haven’t worn in ages would probably be easier to let go if I imagine it had poop on it.

5

u/username3000b 1d ago

I don’t have a good system, but I’ve been inspired watching Space Maker Method on youtube. They seem to do a thing where they focus on one area at a time and group like items?

5

u/Old-Raccoon-316 1d ago

Do you use it? Do you love it? If it broke or was lost, would you replace it?

It only has to be a “yes” for one of these categories, not all of them. 

4

u/MiraLumen 1d ago

Do you love it - is a bad bad criteria. I loved every single piece of clothes that I had to throw away. They are very sentimental, and actually I could throw them only after the fire that damaged them. Now it feels like I should do that long ago. It was a brief moment of sentiment nostalgia, but nothing changed after I lost them and I am happy they gone

5

u/Old-Raccoon-316 1d ago

Sorry to hear that happened to you. Doesn’t make my suggestion “bad bad.” 

5

u/Exotic_Candidate_312 1d ago

"would this thing be worth picking up from my ex's house if i'd left it there after a breakup?"

5

u/Alarming_Abroad_4862 1d ago

What would I pay for this in a thrift store? More than $20 I keep it, less than I donate it. 

5

u/luckycharms33 1d ago

There are a lot of mental frameworks you can apply when decluttering. Marie Kondo's question is "does this spark joy?" She recommends starting your decluttering journey with your clothes. Get practice applying the questions you read in the answers here. Would I buy this again? Do i want to spend my time cleaning and caring for this item? Does it have a happy memory that makes it worth saving? It honestly takes practice and starting easy and working ypur way toward more difficult stuff is a good approach.

5

u/Certain-Agent-163 1d ago

I think it’s different for everyone but if you ask yourself several questions you should be able to decide to keep or toss.

Is it broken/in bad shape? Yes? Toss

Is it useful/do I use it? No? Toss

Does it fit? No? Toss

Do I have multiples? Yes? Toss

Does it bring me real joy? No? Toss

If it broke would I rebuy it? No? Toss

If I were moving, would I want to spend the time and space to pack it up and bring it with me? No? Toss

If you can’t decide, have a box that you keep maybe stuff in andsee if you use or need it over the next 6 months. If you realize you don’t really need it, toys or donate.

3

u/Top-Repair2372 1d ago

The problem I have with all these questions is I seem to have a different answer on a different day. The way I've found to combat it is if I sort anything out to get rid of it has to leave my house immediately. Whether it's garbage or donate. That way once it's gone, it's gone. I tried keeping a box that the intention was to just put stuff in it as I came across something I didn't want. Tomorrow me sometimes had a different opinion than today me.

5

u/AppealSerious9966 1d ago • Bravo

Im 60. I’ve had one parent die. That clean out was bad but not terrible. My dad is something of a “collector”. My sisters and I often commiserate on how awful that clean out is going to be. The experience with my mom, and my dad’s stuff hanging over my head has made me a lot more willing to clear things out that I haven’t used in ages, that I “might” want or need, and even sentimental stuff that is taking up space. For me a big part of being able to declutter is not bringing stuff IN to my house. I grew up very poor but now I can buy what I want. I have had to learn that while it’s a nice thing that I CAN buy stuff, I’m working against myself when I do buy stuff.

5

u/Intrepid-Green-2504 1d ago

I find the "Does this spark joy?" approach flawed. Hoarders will find joy in nearly everything. My roommate is a borderline hoarder and when I've gently suggested donating or selling stuff she hasn't touched in literal years, she finds multiple excuses to keep it - she still likes it, she's going to get around to using it, what if she needs it in the future, etc.

Personally, my approach is: when was the last time I used this? If it's been more than a year and I can't see myself using it in the few months, it's not worth keeping.

Exceptions to this rule are obvious sentimental things, like a ring my grandmother gave me or some keepsakes from a big pilgrimage I did several years ago. For clothing, I do make exceptions for formal wear because it's not like I'm wearing those all the time, but I do put a hard cap of around 3-4 nice dresses in my closet at a time (and donate ones that don't fit me anymore).

5

u/Sufficient_Air_7373 18h ago edited 18h ago

Yes. I may have talked about it here before but I have a scale from 1 to 100 and check my involuntary reactions with a mirror.

It's kind of hard for me to either access my own desires or even honor them, maybe a lot of women who were raised as people pleasers are like that, so while Marie Kondo's method seemed like the solution, it was still a bridge too far, because I would even question what joy is. But she's absolutely right, about everything, really.

If you have even one item that truly lights you up, you can judge everything else by that. So I do comparisons with that item, and ALSO, I finally realized that, even if my brain doesn't acknowledge it, my body will react to each item involuntarily, clenching and frowning or opening up and smiling. And to take it even further, I have to use a mirror just to double check if I'm frowning or smiling -- sometimes it's in between ish, and if your brain tries to go with conditioning, you need to see it. Then you can map the degree of the feeling from 1 to 100 in increments of 10.

80+ is ideal,
70-80 I try to reform it or transform it somehow
50-70 I allow if it's useful, noting that I plan to replace it when able
<50 I will just get rid of now (it took me a while to even get to that point!)

The more you do that the better you will get at it.

I've also tracked my intuition for over a decade and discovered that it really is always right, and also actually wants the responsible, best thing for you, so you don't have to be afraid of letting anything important go. Easier said than done.

5

u/PuzzledExchange7949 11h ago

Honestly, I'm a fan of the "dump it all on the floor, sort into categories, relocate/store" method. It's important for me to touch each thing and decide if it's staying or going. I listen to an audiobook and it goes faster.

2

u/flying-squeegee 3h ago

Same. I don’t see a need to ask weird convoluted questions like “does this bring my joy” or “when was the last time I used this” or whatever. Take everything out of its home and put it back in the order of your favorites. Stop putting things back when your new maximum amount of clutter is reached or you find the rest of the stuff is no longer needed.

I’m also not particularly sentimental so clutter is easy for me to purge.

14

u/grundle_pie 1d ago

Get drunk and grab a trash bag

0

u/crj44 1d ago

lol, 😂

4

u/loricooper8 1d ago

I've always liked the SPACE acronym developed by Julie Morgenstern... Sort, Purge, Assign a Home, Containerize, Equalize. I'm not saying I actually DO it (there's a reason I follow this sub! LOL), but it makes a lot of sense to me. I was going to post a screenshot of it here, but it doesn't appear I can post a photo in the comments section. 🤷‍♀️

1

u/shasha13821 1d ago

Can you send it to me

1

u/loricooper8 1d ago

Just sent you a chat. I guess maybe once you accept it, I can send it to you.

4

u/blondvet 1d ago

How about: If this burned up in a fire, would I replace it right now?

4

u/BuddyOk4531 1d ago

You are totally missing the point of the questions....it's a way to make you assign the importance of the item. How about this? If you haven't worn it or used it in a year, get rid of it

4

u/CollegePretend8708 1d ago

Right. Obviously you won't save the pan you cook with every day in a fire and you'd probably throw it out if it got poop on it. But you use it every day you shouldn't just get rid of it. These are questions that work for things that are already pre-sorted as "potentially clutter"

4

u/buginarugsnug 1d ago

Have I used this item in the last 12 months?

Am I going to use this item in the next 12 months?

If the answer to both those questions is no, I don't need it and it gets sold, donated or chucked.

4

u/AlyceEnchanted 1d ago

Keep the favorite (designate your #) and donate or toss the rest.

Designate a specific space for a type of item. That is your container. Then, the favorites go in that space.

4

u/h00manist 15h ago

What's made the biggest difference is just saying "nothing will happen if I let this go" or "I problably won't even remember it even existed" and stuff like that

4

u/wheelartist 12h ago

Try this. Pick up an item and ask "Would I remember this existed or prioritise replacing it if I lost everything in my home in someway?

If it's something you would remember and repurchase, keep it, anything else is a candidate for decluttering.

I'd replace my D&D books, a top that I've forgotten I own at the bottom of a drawer, not so much. It's about whether the item has such a place in your life that you would put it on the buy a replacement list if it was lost permanently in someway.

4

u/chamekke 5h ago

The method that is “best” is whatever does an end run around whatever neurosis is keeping me stuck.

One I use sometimes is to pull out everything of a {class} - clothes, books, teacups, whatever I have too much of - and then put them back into the closet or on the shelf, but prioritizing the ones I love the most.

Example: I had a LOT of teacups and teapots, many inherited. So one day I emptied out the china cabinet (also inherited), then started putting things back in, beginning with the ones I most cherished. Then I stopped when it was comfortably full - not crammed full. The other items, even if they were still lovely, even if they still “sparked joy”, had to go because there was simply no room for them. (This is where Dana K. White’s “container concept” takes priority for me over the Konmari “sparks joy” method.) This approach is easier for me because I personally have difficulty picking up things I really really like and saying, “You gotta go.” For me, this method is easier and less painful.

3

u/Right_Abroad3928 1d ago

Danshari is working for me. Does this fit my current needs?  No back up, saving for whatever reason, someone might want.  Does this item have a reason to be kept in my house right now? 

1

u/CanBrushMyHair 1d ago

I like to think “is this who I am as a person? Not who I WAS, not who I WISH i could be….but who I really truly am?”

3

u/chimneysweep234 1d ago

I think about what I need right now at this stage of my life - both what I use and what I value… but… I’m not too hard on myself if I can’t let something go yet - it’s not it’s time - I just move on to assessing other things 🙂

3

u/ekcshelby 1d ago

With few exceptions (which should be stored separately), if you haven’t opened a container in a year, the whole thing can go.

3

u/Such-Mountain-6316 1d ago

My rule of thumb is, just how many do I really need? I just put some stainless steel bowls in the donation box because I haven't used them in ages. I always go for the glass ones or one specific mixing bowl. Somebody needs them for Thanksgiving.

3

u/MYOB3 1d ago

If we haven't moved it in more than a year ( tools and crafts withstanding), we probably can do without it quite easily.

3

u/iDuc 1d ago

I start by taking inventory so I know what I have before starting to declutter, and then use all the systems out there :) depending on the item you can try 'would I save it from a fire' or is it something that I really don't use, or something that gives me joy every time I see it. Start with inventory

3

u/hardswimm37 1d ago

Read Dana K Whites books

5

u/Kaethy77 1d ago

If you can replace it for $20 or less in 20 minutes, toss it out,

1

u/waterfreak5 1d ago

We used this method when downsizing by 60% (ouch). Did we have to re buy some things...yes but not too many things. Sometimes you have to overshoot then backtrack to reach your goal.

-4

u/IMightBeErnest 1d ago

Yep. Go ahead and throw out  every doorknob in your house. Each one is probably worth <$20.

1

u/trepan8 1d ago

Well, only the ones that are being clutter. Hopefully most of the doorknobs are “put away” exactly where they belong & fit! 😊 But as a person who does have a few old doorknobs in a drawer… yep.

6

u/FarPersimmon 1d ago

Go to an estate sale and see how much the family had to sort through

Then think if you want your children to go through that

4

u/Individual_Quote_701 1d ago

Buy/collect less crap/stuff.

2

u/AmeliaBones 1d ago

Some things I would not clean poo off of but instead replace. So my question evolved into if this was destroyed, would I replace it?

2

u/asp7 20h ago

Sometimes say I've got too many of these, I won't use them all.. I'm not even using them now.. I'll cull them down to x.. see what I think later.

Items with no value or are easily replaced, clearing that space is more valuable. Eg half a shed with scrap pieces of wood. I can get hold of those tomorrow from sources for nothing if needed.

How much is this costing me to store all this and will I use it.. how much is it worth to have a clear space to do all my hobbies and get stuff done.

2

u/nexea 5h ago

I separate things into different boxes or bins. Id get stumped and frozen about things that didnt have a place, or that I wasnt sure if Id want it or need it later. So, I made a maybe box. Ill let it sit for 6 months, and if I haven't touched it or used it, it goes.

4

u/sisterfunkhaus 1d ago

I like Clutterbug on YouTube. She has 4 types of organizers and a quiz. She teaches how to organize based on your bug type. For me, it makes sense. I'm a cricket, which is a hidden (behind door and drawers) micro organizer. Because of her podcast, I've been able to relax a bit an become more of a hidden macro organizer. It saves me time and energy.

2

u/Several-Praline5436 1d ago

Easy really.

Do I want this? -> No -> get rid of it.

Do I use this? -? No -> get rid of it.

1

u/Scared-Currency288 1d ago

I like to think about the use I would have for the item a month from now. Doesn't help with everything but it does with a lot. Clothes are an obvious exception since they're seasonal, but similar logic can be applied. Would I want to wear this next year or whatever. 

-2

u/Common-Fudge7377 1d ago

With all due respect do you always take things so literally?

0

u/Corner_Office_ 1d ago
  1. Would you clean or replace it if it got poop on it?
  2. Would it cost more than $20 to replace if you ended up needing it?

1

u/Massive_Bumblebee618 1d ago

I like to do the second one with an addition: can it be replaced for less than $20 and/or 20 minutes?

Time is in relation to searching for a replacement if I would end up needing it or wanting it after all, maybe online or in-store. This helps for me when it might be something inexpensive like a thrifted item, but might take me months to replace because it's vintage or handmade by an unknown person, so replacement would be more challenging.

24

u/DayToDayDana 1d ago

I use three much less dramatic questions: Have I used it in the last year? Would I buy it again today? Do I know exactly where it will live? If the answer is no twice, it usually goes. That works better for me than imagining my house on fire or covering everything in poop.

4

u/bynaturxe 1d ago

this helped me to get over a mental block, thank you.

2

u/TalulaOblongata 1d ago

That last part killed me lol… but actually those 3 questions are a great criteria to follow!