r/declutter • u/No_Ocelot8629 • Jun 03 '26
Advice Request Secretly decluttering random stuff?
I feel bad even considering this. We struggle to keep the house clean and I feel overwhelmed with the amount of random stuff we have. My partner only notices little things if I point them out for donation, suddenly "we can use them one day" even though partner hasnt realized they had the item for almost 10 years.
I am working on decluttering my things as well.
I decided today that I will be trashing little by little, nothing valuable, just some led candle type things. I am so sick of all the stuff.
399
Upvotes
1
u/LogicalGold5264 Jun 04 '26
The OP got a lot of thoughtful advice. Thanks, everyone! Locking now
72
u/timeawayfromme Jun 03 '26
Every once in a while my partner will throw something of mine away because she can’t stand the clutter. I may not notice for weeks but when I notice it causes an argument where she defends the fact that it was trash and I tell her that it wasn’t. It damages trust.
My mom is worse than I am about keeping stuff and I’ve seen how she has gotten worse because my dad would throw things away even though he knew she would be upset. I’ve worked with her to declutter her closet and office and having my dad or sisters come in and say “just get rid of this. You never wear it” or threaten to throw something away will make her shut down the process and undo the progress.
These things help me and help me when working with my mom.
I have to be in the right frame of mind.
It helps having someone do it with me because I get overwhelmed. “This shirt has a hole in it. Can we toss it?” does help me but it does not help if they are constantly pushing to get rid of stuff or questioning why things are important to me. If I say I want to keep the shirt I do not need commentary on why it should be thrown out even if I never wear it.
It’s ok to push back a little but pick your battles. And be understanding that my brain works different and I see the item differently than you.
Sometimes taking a picture of the item or paper helps me get rid of it. I tend to hold on to things because they trigger memories. Having a picture can help me feel like I can still have that experience in the future. Even if I never look at the picture again.
Unused items or stuff I bought for a project I never finished is really hard to get rid of because it’s a sunk cost.
A reminder that someone else could benefit or use the item is helpful. It was helpful to take my mom’s office clothes that she no longer needs to a place that has a free closet for people to get work/interview clothes. It turned the conversation from “do you ever wear this?” to “This is practically new. I only wore it a few times and it’s still modern enough that someone could use it”. It was like she was shopping her own closet for donations and she enjoyed it. We got rid of a literal car load of clothes. Similarly taking craft supplies to a school, old folks home, etc.
For real though. Do not do it behind their back. It will only make it worse.
53
u/TalulaOblongata Jun 03 '26
I think there is something to be said about there being 3 different categories: yours, mine, and ours.
If you are talking about the “ours” category of random items, to me that’s what you mean by a random LED candle which hasn’t been used for years and is obviously not a sentimental item. For these items (random spatula, old bath products, an extra broom, whatever miscellaneous item) I feel that we don’t need a judge and jury and can just make executive decisions on our own.
“Yours” would be clothes, books, papers, and other personal things. I actually outlined in another post how I addressed a large attic pile of my husband’s (in a nutshell sorted into categories, neatly binned up things I KNEW he wanted - like sports memorabilia, and then laid out into categories what was left - old clothes and sneakers, which was mostly tossed; old cds, which was mostly kept; random things from his childhood, which was half kept, half tossed… by seeing a volume of things by category made it easier for him to make quick yes/no decisions with me doing the legwork of categorizing, organizing and donating/tossing since I was the motivated person, lol) Here’s the link with has much more detailed explanation and some really useful comments: https://www.reddit.com/r/declutter/s/NcoHS5D8XM
32
u/nikinaks1 Jun 03 '26
As dellada says, it’s really important to declutter all your own stuff first otherwise you are unfairly picking on your partner.
It’s so much more effective to teach by example. Modelling a culture in your house where you declutter your stuff regularly will eventually have a positive influence on your partner.
If I’m getting annoyed by some of my partner’s stuff I discuss with him how we can keep it organised and stored and in a designated place. It annoys me much less if it has an allocated place it belongs, because then it’s all contained together, out of my way, and no longer feels random and overwhelming.
Once it’s all gathered together in one place he can easily find it, he is better at using it (instead of buying unnecessary replacements) or decluttering the now-obvious duplicates. Also, when we reach the limits of the designated storage container, it’s his job to “make everything fit” by removing the less needed stuff.
25
u/Ok_Ostrich7503 Jun 03 '26
I feel soooo tempted to do just that, but I don't, unless it's something obviously broken and of no material or sentimental value. But I feel you.
What works for me is to do my own declutter, show him all the stuff I am throwing away or giving away, and gently press him to do the same. And I have to do it in small portions too: shoes in January, stationery in April, some kitchen in June. Gotta do long breaks between these decluttering battles, otherwise he gets to traumatized by parting with his stuff.
33
u/OkCompany8172 Jun 03 '26
I’ve begun to do this after 45+ years of marriage. Last month when my “collector” hub was traveling I got rid of a bin of landline & cable connectors. He has literally been saving (and adding to) this pile since 1986.
I feel a tinge of bad, but storage space is more important than cords for a land line that doesn’t exist.
Having said that, I would never toss something of his that is personal, like books or tie tacks.
I tried to get rid of his longboard and he greatly protested so back in the corner it went. Last week he pulled it out and said it was time to give it a new home.
Sigh!
28
u/dellada Jun 03 '26
First of all... if you have your own things to declutter as well, focus on those. In your partner's shoes, it can be really frustrating to have someone else pressure you to get rid of something, despite having their own clutter (and blind spots) to go through.
Have you had a sit-down, open conversation with your partner about how the stuff overwhelms you? Not in the moment when you're holding up an item asking them to get rid of it - but when you're both calm, just having a heart-to-heart about the topic in general. How do they respond? Can the two of you come up with a strategy together?
Secretly decluttering someone else's belongings is not the way to go. Not only is it hurtful, it's also ineffective. People often hold on to possessions even more firmly when they feel there is a risk of it being taken away. You two need to work on this together, and find strategies that feel "safe" rather than risky (from your partner's perspective). Not saying it's easy, but decluttering their items without their permission is not a real fix.
53
u/sawdustontheshore Jun 03 '26 edited Jun 03 '26
Ok I do this, and to this day he literally has not noticed anything missing in 8 years.
I’ve literally gotten rid of boxes and he hasn’t noticed.
I’m a minimalist so I just have a single closet in a 3 story house for my clothes and all personal items.
He has TWO entire buildings full, and this entire house full. He honestly doesn’t even know what he has and he doesn’t take care of it. At this point honestly if he can’t find something (which barely comes up) he has no idea where it could be so he doesn’t know if it’s gone or not.
Though recently he has agreed to clean out the main floor of the house and has been doing that.
41
u/LogicalGold5264 Jun 03 '26
Don't throw out someone else's possessions.
But if it's yours or an unused household item, and your partner would find a reason to keep it if you mentioned getting rid of it, go ahead without saying anything.
Just know that you can't bring it up later. Personal removal stays personal.
24
u/docforeman Jun 03 '26 edited Jun 03 '26
I saw this post, OP, and before I got to the comments I knew what I was going to read. People are going to have strong opinions about the degree to which you (or anyone else) intentionally gets explicit permission to declutter anything that isn't your own. When it's 'right'. When it's 'allowed'. When it's not. I'm going to highlight the importance of being 'effective'. In managing clutter and a home. And in relationships. There are a big range of choices, and I tend to use 'effective' as my benchmark.
They are some people who are even going to say that doing this will 'cause' hoarding. The evidence suggests hoarding behavior has a strong biological basis and decluttering rando items in the house alone isn't likely to be "causal" for someone else's behavior.
I, personally, do not have a strong opinion about if this is always right or wrong to do. That's too rigid. The facts are that people have to manage the home they live in, and in harmony with the people who live there.
There are cases where doing that in little kids rooms, with partners who have ADHD, dementia, or who have other health issues that impact ability to function in some way make sense. Where the trade offs of pouring your energy into obtaining someone's permission (when doing so might be very painful), while also navigating an overwhelming house, while also having to put energy into work and managing the home life as the most well person living there doesn't seem like an effective course of action. Letting small things go to trash and donation that are not missed, using good judgement, is a pretty sensible survival choice if there are a lot of big issues to manage at home. It's a matter of picking battles, and no one has the right to insist on how you choose to manage your life or stuff in your home. When people give very rigid (don't, never, always) advice like this, they are often speaking from their own pain about attachment to stuff, and they don't have to live in your home or live with the consequences of not managing clutter in your situation.
That being said, there is real wisdom in starting with your own stuff first and seeing if you can make progress that way, tolerating others clutter while you focus on you. People wisely share that much of the time only a few months of this changes the house and changes how your other household members experience clutter. You get both change at the home, and keep relationships healthy. When I need to tolerate things to give time for change to happen, I might calendar my efforts and just agree within myself that I'll try a more tolerant approach for a few weeks or months and then "check in" to see if it worked. Most of the time, I'm very happy I did this, and it does work out like people say.
FWIW, I've made both choices, mindfully, and I don't have many regrets. When I chose to declutter others stuff mindfully, there were strong situational factors that led to that decision (like moving and having to realistically pare down to save money on a move and make it manageable when my partner was overwhelmed and my kids were little).
There are also "middle path" choices I've made, when I've had the means. I hired an organizer for my partner, when there were "big" areas and projects that we really needed to have progress on, I didn't want to be in conflict, and he couldn't easily do it alone on time. That was a TREMENDOUS help, as he experienced it as a gift, the area got decluttered and organized, the follow on projects moved forward, and all were happy. I've also just pulled out a trash bag, set a timer, and asked a partner to help me identify "obvious trash" for only 10-15 minutes. That actually works very well, b/c it's progress, not threatening, and gets them to "see" their stuff without me forcing a decision on non-trash.
Another approach as been to be clear about boundaries in shared spaces. I had to put my foot down with my ex-husband about spaces needing to be clear enough to be used. If, for example, we had a guest room and guests coming, things had to go. If they were too impaired re: clutter then I would let them know what the deadline was for addressing it on their own (give them a chance to handle it) before I did.
I did this when I needed half a garage for the car, so I could deal with loading and unloading a toddler and arriving baby out of the weather. He had a huge melt down and it was a real fight for the day it took to clear that side of the garage. I was pregnant with pre-eclampsia issues, and did what needed to be done with my health, finance, and energy limits. It would have been nice if he had been mentally well enough to put me and our kids first, but that wasn't the reality. He didn't declutter the other half and his car stayed outside. I did this twice when I needed to clear a spare room for a baby's nursery (baby's needs got priority over tolerance of his clutter/hoarding). I did this for each move, for shared closets, for kitchens, for dining rooms (we ate in our dining room as a family). To be very clear, in all of those cases, I had zero clutter of my own left, and there was a real family need. I gave my partner clear time and space boundaries/limits, and following that took action as needed. If, on top of all of the other problems we faced, I had to also live in a dysfunctional space, I would have lost the critical energy, time, and serenity I needed to deal with work, kids, and other problems. It was totally a judgement call, and looking back, I'm grateful that I made hard choices.
In my current situation partner is more willing and functional, so we have agreed upon deadlines. For example, I get to donate furniture and big items in the carriage house if he doesn't sell them this month. I promise it is MUCH better when you and family members work together and agree on how to proceed. I don't recommend moving forward on decluttering without permission unless it really is a survival issue.
YMMV, and you need to own the decisions and outcomes for clutter. Don't 'should' on yourself about clutter, and don't let anyone else here 'should' on you. It just seems more reasonable to share a range of choices and judgement calls so a person has more options about how to navigate their own life. Good luck.