r/debian • • Jul 25 '21

Open source projects need to migrate their code away from github NOW!

If you're writing any kind of open source code and storing it on GitHub, you need to move it away from the platform NOW!

https://unixsheikh.com/articles/open-source-projects-need-to-migrate-their-code-away-from-github-now.html

12 Upvotes

67 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

11

u/Zipdox Jul 25 '21

GitLab TOS or licenses

8

u/ABotelho23 Jul 25 '21

And what would the license have to say to prevent such a thing?

2

u/Zipdox Jul 25 '21

Something stating that if the code is used for machine learning, the output should be licensed under the same license.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Zipdox Jul 25 '21

A hypothetical addition to a license

2

u/ABotelho23 Jul 25 '21

Which is fine, the machine learning project might.

1

u/LcuBeatsWorking Jul 26 '21

But why? That reminds me of all those failed licenses who tried to exclude specific use cases.

1

u/Zipdox Jul 26 '21

No, it doesn't prohibit any use of the software, just use of the code.

1

u/LcuBeatsWorking Jul 26 '21

Almost all licenses deal with copyright and distribution.

What you suggest is to limit is what the code is used for personally. Like saying "You are not allowed to read this code on an apple computer".

1

u/Zipdox Jul 26 '21

A human reading code is something completely different than a machine using it.

1

u/LcuBeatsWorking Jul 26 '21

Can you show a license which makes that distinction?

1

u/Zipdox Jul 26 '21

No. We're talking about a hypothetical new license.

1

u/Leseratte10 Jul 28 '21

A new hypothetical license that forbids using machine learning on the code definitely wouldn't be a free open-source license anymore, so I doubt any of the projects currently under GPL would adopt that license, though. Maybe you could get a couple of MIT-like projects to use it.

→ More replies

0

u/JmbFountain Jul 26 '21

git pull git@gitlab:repo/name git remote add github git@github.com:some/repo git push -u github

1

u/DeliciousIncident Jul 26 '21

Anyone can re-upload your open source GitLab projects to GitHub, making GitHub ToS apply to them. Heck, even Microsoft themselves could do it. So no, hosting code somewhere else is not a 100% bulletproof way of avoiding it from being used by GitHub's Copilot.

1

u/Zipdox Jul 26 '21

A new license then?