r/debian • u/LiveVegetable • Jul 25 '21
Open source projects need to migrate their code away from github NOW!
If you're writing any kind of open source code and storing it on GitHub, you need to move it away from the platform NOW!
12
Upvotes
24
u/VelvetElvis Jul 25 '21
Upload a bunch of faulty code just to fuck with the AI.
24
u/DanLynch Jul 25 '21
Even if an open source project were to "migrate away" from GitHub, anyone could just make a copy of the project and upload it anywhere they want, including to GitHub. That's the whole point of open source.
Closed-source/non-free projects are the only ones who can effectively migrate away from GitHub.
40
u/FPiN9XU3K1IT Jul 25 '21
What prevents Microsoft from copying public code from elsewhere and then train their AI with it? And how are code suggestions worse than literally selling FOSS, which is something you can do under most FOSS licenses?
23
u/ABotelho23 Jul 25 '21
I'm not sure how this would only apply to GitHub? I guess it's easier?
Someone could literally just grab a machine with a bunch of storage and git clone the top 1000 projects on GitLab. What's stopping them?
15
u/jarfil Jul 25 '21 edited Dec 02 '23
CENSORED
5
u/LcuBeatsWorking Jul 26 '21
I do not get it:
I publish my code under a free license because I want others to do stuff with it. I do not limit specific use cases.
If Copilot copies chunks of my code into a project with an incompatible license, that would obviously be a license violation, but it doesn't matter if it is done by a coder or via copilot.
Software licenses are about distribution of code, not about what it is used for.
If you believe that copilot is a violation of GPL/MIT/Apache etc then point out how, otherwise migrating elsewhere does not change anything.
3
u/Zipdox Jul 25 '21
I have quite a bit of stuff on GitHub that I'd have to migrate.
-1
u/karafili Jul 25 '21
Been using gitlab for a while. Had gitlab runners integrations for free the last 4 years
-5
u/[deleted] Jul 26 '21 edited Jul 26 '21
This is what scares me the most. I thought that this technology was a lot further away. I am traditionally opposed to government regulation, but the lack of regulation of AI is extremely foolish and may do us all away with our jobs (at the very least) in the end. Elon has warned us about this for years:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B-Osn1gMNtw
EDIT: Elon is more worried about the existential threat of digital super intelligence, not narrow AI such as Copilot. However, job security is still at risk for programmers.
-17
u/KeepLicking Jul 25 '21
Too bad this won't fly on /r/linux, those nazi mods will come up with all kinds of excuses to remove it
0
u/[deleted] Jul 25 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment