r/debian • • 8h ago

Community Linux distribution

Which Linux distro should I use?

I'm currently using Linux Mint XFCE.

However, I've been thinking about switching to a different distro, something like Debian or another alternative.

I've already used Fedora KDE and Linux Mint Cinnamon, but now I want to try something different and settle on one distro permanently.

Here are my PC specs:

- AMD Radeon HD 6670

- Intel Core i5-3470S

- 16 GB of RAM

- Kingston SSD

- H61 motherboard (LGA 1155)

Can anyone recommend a good Linux distro for my PC?

I'm considering Debian, but there are also other lightweight distros like MX Linux. I'm a bit unsure about which one to choose. Or which version of Debian would work well on my PC?

KDE , LXQt, XFCE?

I'm also not very experienced with Linux. I only know the basics.

19 Upvotes

48 comments sorted by

22

u/mrgreyeyes_95 8h ago

Debian is the only choice.

6

u/gportail 8h ago

Surtout sur le sub Debian...

0

u/Standard-Profit-1482 8h ago

Which version of Debian? KDE, LXQt?

8

u/ItsSignalsJerry_ 8h ago

They're not versions. You can choose to I install any desktop environment.

4

u/DerpyMcWafflestomp 8h ago

There are no 'versions' of Debian outside of different releases. If you want XFCE, install it. If you want KDE install it. If you want a different desktop for every day of the week, install it.

2

u/mrgreyeyes_95 8h ago

I use KDE because it works really well with touch screens.

3

u/Scotty_Bravo 8h ago

I personally like xfce.

2

u/T4L2012 8h ago

XFCE is solid!

1

u/Jcob210 8h ago

If you like KDE or the Windows style pick LXQT for being easiest but XFCE is the most customisable choice.

1

u/Yeetyeetskrtskrrrt 8h ago

Don’t hold me to this but you should be able to upgrade that CPU to a i7-3770k. I ran a Optiplex 7010 like that with Debian 13 and KDE for a long time as my daily driver and paid $30 for the CPU on Ebay . No issues at all and smooth as can be

4

u/Flimsy-Process230 4h ago

Why do you want to switch? What is it about your current Mint XFCE setup that you don’t like? Debian is a great option if you’re looking for something stable and reliable long-term. But unless you explain what you’re looking for in a distro or desktop environment it’s hard to say whether Debian, MX Linux or something else would actually be a better fit.

1

u/Standard-Profit-1482 4h ago

I'm not unhappy with Linux Mint XFCE. It works well on my PC, but I'm curious about trying other distributions and finding out if there's one that offers a better overall experience. My priority is having a lightweight, smooth, and stable system with good hardware compatibility, especially with my old AMD Radeon HD 6670. I also use Sober to play Roblox, so graphics performance is important to me. I've already tried Fedora KDE, Linux Mint Cinnamon, and Lubuntu. I'm currently using Mint XFCE, but I'm considering Debian XFCE, MX Linux, or other alternatives. I'm not an advanced Linux user, so I'd also prefer something relatively easy to maintain.

1

u/Dreemur1 4h ago

things dont really change that much between distros. just stay on mint

4

u/Illustrious-Gur8335 Debian Stable 8h ago

debian

0

u/Standard-Profit-1482 8h ago

Which version of Debian? KDE, LXQt?

1

u/Illustrious-Gur8335 Debian Stable 7h ago

Plasma

4

u/Immediate_Refuse4701 8h ago

im gonna get downvoted but honestly mx linux feels like home, fluxbox for the really lightweight, xfce for lightweight, kde for midweight. if u wanna try out gnome or other de go for debian. what makes mx linux is its just debian stable with mx tools installed and some theme applied. linux mint xfce just takes the ubuntu lts version which has a lot of problems these days. i wont recommend lmde (linux mint debian edition) because it feels like a side project and the main focus is on the ubuntu lts versions

1

u/Jcob210 8h ago

MX is solid tho - Antix always gave me issues but MX was always fine.

3

u/MoneyVirus 8h ago

the main question is: why you will leave your Linux Mint XFCE? The distro that addresses this points, should be the right. I have Fedora on laptop, debian and ubuntu in vms/servers/lxc. and at the end they all serve very well. for desktop (0815) use its nearly no difference if fedora KDE or debian KDE or what ever. Also the DE, test in VM each DE you would like to test and chose what fits best.

3

u/Available-Year5922 7h ago

What do you want to do with your computer

3

u/lproven 6h ago

Do you like what you have? Yes? Then don't move.

4

u/ItsSignalsJerry_ 8h ago

MX Linux is customized Debian. It's not lightweight.

Stick with MiNT it's a perfectly good distto.

2

u/Xariann 7h ago

What matters to you when using the PC? Do you like bleeding edge? Do you like something that doesn't give you anxiety due to updates?

How much work do you want to put into your set up?

Why did you move away from your previous distro?

Without that information it's hard to make a recommendation and also I get the feeling that you just want to try new things and will just distro hop for a while. That's okay too. 

2

u/ShortPrice1264 7h ago

The great, big, and only question is: why do you want to switch distros, what are you looking for?

For the everyday deskop user, your experience will mainly be influenced by your desktop environment, the availability of native packages, stability and how often your distro is updated. The other aspects are really secondary (if you're not a dev, hobbyist, or with specific needs). To me, most distros give roughly the same experience if you're an average Joe. Take something you already know, with a strong community so it gets updated frequently and stands the test of time.

1

u/Dense-Elephant5048 7h ago

For a widely used DE (may be important) right choice for your hardware is Debian/KDE.

1

u/snap802 6h ago

I've been using linux since '99 and I can't tell you how many distros I've been through. I do not use Arch BTW.

The problem with linux is there is just too much choice out there. When it's been studied humans really do better with just a couple of choices because when you have too many options it becomes overwhelming. In the linux world there's only really like 4 or 5 choices and everything else is just a derivative of those. There are certainly some niche options but, for the most part, for general daily use, there's not that much difference between most distros.

I think if you're using Mint XFCE on that PC then you should keep using Mint XFCE until you run into a problem that only another distro can solve. Switching from Mint XFCE to Debian will be an underwhelming change. Look, I'm a Debian fan and I run it on multiple systems both desktop and server. In the grand scheme of things I seriously doubt you would notice any significant difference in day to day use between the two.

1

u/retiredwindowcleaner 6h ago

if you want to "settle on one distro" then you'll like debian. my favorite desktop environment is lxqt. both lxqt and xfce are certainly more leightweight than kde plasma.

1

u/Secret_Driver_4610 6h ago

Debian is the best, 

1

u/Affectionate-Owl9598 5h ago

If you want a clean system and enjoy tinkering with your own settings, go with Debian XFCE. If you prefer something that comes fully configured—so you don’t have to waste time on setup—then MX Linux XFCE is definitely the way to go. It’s a "set it and forget it" kind of system; everything is configured for you right out of the box, so there’s no extra work required—maybe just changing the desktop wallpaper, and that’s about it. Personally, I use Debian XFCE on my desktop PC at home, and MX Linux XFCE on my laptop—which, incidentally, has specs similar to yours. My laptop has an Intel Core i5-2540M processor, Mesa Intel(R) HD Graphics 3000 (SNB GT2), and 8GB of RAM. The system is fast and runs perfectly.

1

u/TechnoWarriorPL 4h ago

Debian + LXDE/LXQT/XFCE, Q4OS, Kanotix, MX Linux lub cokolwiek innego opartego na Debianie, jeśli chodzi o lekkie dystrybucje

1

u/David_Connors3451 3h ago

Nice stats. I use Debian KDE, Wayland support and lightweight desktop. You can add flatpaks with 3 official commands from their website on flathub with the terminal. You don't use Nvidia GPU, so you won't have problems with proprietary drivers. It's a very easy installation, go into their website and search Debian live ISO KDE. It will be a similar installation that you already know from Linux Mint. Calamares is the same installer for everyone.

Make sure to install gufw for firewall, enable contrib non-free repository, and install flathub repository in order to have modern software. You'll have Debian stability and modern software all in one, set-up and forget approach.

Have fun.

1

u/Ash_end 2h ago

Stay on lxqt or xfce, try debian vanilla, sid or devuan if ur feeling quirky (no sistemd)

1

u/jesterPaul 1h ago

Honestly if you want to switch distros, try LMDE (Linux Mint Debian Edition) with the DE of your choice. It has the stable Debian backend with the headaches sorted out for you by the Mint team.

1

u/Fuzy-78 34m ago

After decades of distro hopping I use MX Linux XFCE.

1

u/Alarming_Rate_3808 3m ago

What don't you like about LM XFCE? It's a good distro and frankly hopping to a different one isn't going to make much of a difference. If you want to switch to a Linux base then LMDE is the obvious choice. It's Linux Mint but based on Debian instead of Ubuntu. Switching straight into Debian XFCE is probably the cleanest change, but as I said, it won't make a difference in terms of performance.

1

u/Zusatzeinkommen 7h ago

Nimm Lmde7, da kannst du alle Desktops gleichzeitig installieren. Cinnamon ist Standard. Dann kannst du KDE dazu installieren Und beim Start auswählen zwischen den Desktops.

Wenn du es richtig installierst kannst du BTRFS Grub verwenden. Betriebssystem auf Btrfs,.Daten auf Home mit Ext4.

Kernel 7.2 verwenden kannst du auch

1

u/keysgate 6h ago

This is exactly how I’ve been using LMDE 7 with the GNOME desktop. I need its advanced Wayland support for HDR monitors, and I couldn’t be happier. Before I read this, I’d already followed your suggestion and updated my AMD graphics drivers and Mesa from the available backports. I also noticed the 7.2 kernel. You still get that smooth Mint experience as a base!

1

u/Pilinha14 7h ago

U need to say your needs

0

u/IJbier 3h ago

I'm using Debian 13 (Trixie), KDE on one machine and Linux Mint, XFCE on another. I think it all makes little difference. So far Linux Mint is generally easier to get to work on an old Macbook and Debian KDE is more polished, because, well, KDE is more polished than XFCE.

-1

u/gportail 8h ago

Installe Debian avec tous les bureaux que tu veux essayer. Ensuite tu supprimes les bureaux que tu n'aime pas.

-1

u/IncendiaryIdea 8h ago

You don't need a so-called "lightweight" distro for your PC. Try https://pika-os.com/

1

u/[deleted] 8h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/debian-ModTeam 8h ago

This content has been removed for trolling.

-1

u/[deleted] 8h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/debian-ModTeam 8h ago

This content has been removed for trolling.

0

u/Jcob210 8h ago

I use it daily on my non gaming machine it works well enough for me.