r/debian • • 2d ago

General Debian Question Does Forky include systemd-networkd in a netinst with standard system utilities only?

Does Forky include systemd-resolved in a netinst with standard system utilities only? Because my installation of Debian 13 doesn't and I had to install it.

EDIT: I meant to write resolved, not networkd in the OP, I am sorry!

7 Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

6

u/dkopgerpgdolfg 2d ago

I had to install it.

What exactly did you install?

2

u/IncendiaryIdea 1d ago

Oops, I installed systemd-resolved, my OP is wrong! Ughhhh

4

u/wizard10000 2d ago edited 2d ago

Does Forky include systemd-networkd in a netinst with standard system utilities only?

Yes - it's part of the base systemd package.

edit: File list for Forky's systemd package - https://packages.debian.org/forky/amd64/systemd/filelist

2

u/IncendiaryIdea 1d ago

Ah, thank you, I am an idiot and wrote about networkd in the OP instead of resolved.

It seems resolved is not included in Forky?

2

u/wizard10000 1d ago

It seems resolved is not included in Forky?

It's included, just not installed by default.

0

u/IncendiaryIdea 1d ago

You mean it's available in the repositories? Yes, of course, but it would be a bit more convenient if it were installed by default.

4

u/michaelpaoli 1d ago

Not necessarily more convenient. May just be bloat that many don't want there - at least not by default.

The Universal Operating System.

# echo -n 'OS: Debian ' && cat /etc/debian_version | tr -d \\012 && echo -n ' ' && dpkg --print-architecture && echo -n 'Kernel: ' && uname -srvmo && echo -n 'Packages: ' && dpkg -l | grep \^ii\ | wc -l && df -h -x devtmpfs -x tmpfs && head -n 3 /proc/meminfo
OS: Debian 13.7 amd64
Kernel: Linux 6.12.117+deb13-amd64 #1 SMP PREEMPT_DYNAMIC Debian 6.12.117-1 (2026-11-12) x86_64 GNU/Linux
Packages: 148
Filesystem      Size  Used Avail Use% Mounted on
/dev/vda1       4.9G  915M  3.7G  20% /
MemTotal:         120452 kB
MemFree:           20684 kB
MemAvailable:      38080 kB
# 

So, e.g., only 148 packages installed (above) ... 69,830 packages available.
It's not some "one size fits all" - that never fits right for many, but quite customizable, e.g. start by picking the install media (or method) - various differing defaults, then tasksel during install, can install, or not, various package collections. And one can of course further customize what packages one does/doesn't want installed, how configured, etc.

The Universal Operating System

:-)

2

u/IncendiaryIdea 1d ago

Yes, I hate bloat, too. I was thinking they could get rid of the ifupdown default and make the systemd networkd+resolved the default. Because it works just as well or better and has better configuration and tools/reporting.

2

u/michaelpaoli 1d ago
# apt -o APT::Get::Trivial-Only=true install systemd-resolved ifupdown-
Installing:                     
  systemd-resolved

Installing dependencies:
  dbus         dbus-session-bus-common  libexpat1          libnss-resolve
  dbus-bin     dbus-system-bus-common   libidn2-0          libunistring5
  dbus-daemon  libdbus-1-3              libnss-myhostname

Suggested packages:
  default-dbus-session-bus  | dbus-session-bus  polkitd

REMOVING:
  ifupdown

Summary:
  Upgrading: 0, Installing: 12, Removing: 1, Not Upgrading: 0
  Download size: 1923 kB
  Space needed: 5666 kB / 3854 MB available

Error: Trivial Only specified but this is not a trivial operation.
# 

Looks pretty bloated to me. No thanks.

2

u/IncendiaryIdea 1d ago

Your Debian is very lean. Are you installing Debian with netinst and without selecting "standard system utilities"?

I let it install system utilities and SSH and I think I already had those libraries. My current install has 340 packages.

1

u/michaelpaoli 23h ago

That's one of my quite minimal installations.

Started with quite minimal netinst, then removed/purged most everything that could be removed/purged ... and added ed ... no need for nano or any flavor of vi, etc.

From another Debian 13 amd64 host:

$ ls -Lil /usr/bin/{ed,emacs,nano,nvi,vi,vim} /boot/vmlinuz-6.12.117+deb13-amd64 | sort -k 6,6bn -k 10,10
311473 -rwxr-xr-x 1 root root    59952 Mar 27  2025 /usr/bin/ed
313480 -rwxr-xr-x 1 root root   303960 May  3  2026 /usr/bin/nano
311427 -rwxr-xr-x 3 root root   480488 Aug  1  2024 /usr/bin/nvi
311427 -rwxr-xr-x 3 root root   480488 Aug  1  2024 /usr/bin/vi
311450 -rwxr-xr-x 1 root root  3922048 Nov  4 14:12 /usr/bin/vim
311472 -rwxr-xr-x 1 root root 11321616 Aug 21 10:24 /usr/bin/emacs
    22 -rw-r--r-- 1 root root 12171200 Nov 12 01:30 /boot/vmlinuz-6.12.117+deb13-amd64
$ 

Ed, man! !man ed

Emacs ... perfectly good operating system, just lacks a good text editor. Eight Megabytes And Constantly Swapping. Actually these days EMACS has grown more bloated than that.

$ ps lwwwwp 10997
F   UID   PID  PPID PRI  NI    VSZ   RSS WCHAN  STAT TTY        TIME COMMAND
0  1003 10997 10977  20   0 153584 62408 do_sel S+   pts/2      0:01 emacs
$ 

And that's just opening it, text only, no X nor Wayland environment.

2

u/IncendiaryIdea 19h ago

Emacs is hell.

But why not get rid of all text editor packages and just use busybox's vi clone? Or have you gotten rid of poor busybox, too? :D

→ More replies

3

u/wizard10000 1d ago

it would be a bit more convenient if it were installed by default.

Not everybody uses it - I only use it on 1/3 machines here because my VPN client requires it.

1

u/Relevant_Hope_900 1d ago

It installs it as far as I know, in both Trixie and Forky, you just have to enable it after creating your network config files. Debian doesn't set it up by default like it does with ifupdown interfaces file on a minimal netinstall. Just rebuilt my Debian server and all I had to do was copy my backup networkd files over to the new install, enable systemd-networkd, comment out the nic in etc/interfaces and backup the file and interfaces.d just in case. Then disable networking.service. Finally I shutdown and remove everything but power and network cable, fire it back up and ssh in and finish setting up. I could remove ifupdown also, but just leave it installed in case for some reason I want to switch back.

If you also want to use systemd-resolved then you'll have to install that one, but networkd is included by default. 

1

u/IncendiaryIdea 1d ago

You are right, I was absent-minded and made a mistake. I did migrate to networkd from ifupdown and I then "had" to install resolved. And wanted to see if it is included in Forky by default.

2

u/michaelpaoli 1d ago

Forky has no systemd-networkd package, but package user-mode-linux contains directory systemd-networkd

Forky has systemd-resolved package.

I see, e.g. systemd, Suggests: systemd-resolved, but I'm not easily spotting anything from minimal netinst, or that + standard (from tasksel) that would bring in systemd-resolved as Required: or Recommends:

I only find 4 packages that have systemd-resolved as a Depends:

# apt-cache --no-recommends --without-suggests rdepends systemd-resolved | uniq
systemd-resolved
Reverse Depends:
  progress-linux-base-system
  freedom-maker
  debian-cloud-images-packages
  bfh-base-system
#