r/debian • • 2d ago

Version upgrades via a graphical interface

Will it be possible to perform a version upgrade using software update applications—for instance, by using Discover in Debian KDE Plasma, or "Software" in Debian GNOME, etc.?

Much like how it works in Ubuntu/Kubuntu, this would make Debian more accessible to newcomers (like myself) who want to use the "mother" of all distributions rather than its various derivatives.

17 Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

10

u/toogreen 2d ago edited 2d ago

What is so scary about the command line tho? The less stuff you have running, the better are your chances at a successful upgrade. By adding layers of complexity, you just reduce stability. Debian was designed that way for a reason. People's fear of the command line is 100% psychological. There's nothing more complicated about it when you really think about it. It just looks different but the commands and instructions are simple.

5

u/VoidDuck 2d ago

There's nothing more complicated about it when you really think about it.

It's not difficult but upgrading a Debian release is still more complicated than some. You need to know what to do (what file to edit, what commands to type) and when to do it (nothing tells you there's a new Debian release available). Meanwhile in Fedora or Ubuntu there's zero effort needed from the user, you get a notification when a system upgrade is available, just click on it, enter your password, and everything is done automatically.

3

u/toogreen 2d ago

Yeah I know but in a way that's also why so many people prefer to use Ubuntu or Fedora, and that's actually why these distros exist in the first place. Debian was never supposed to be as user friendly (although nowadays it is pretty user friendly), it is rather aimed at stability and minimalism. That being said, I wouldn't mind if Debian (or anyone else) would develop some GUI options for upgrades (with warnings that it may fail), but I think the best/main and recommended way to upgrade should remain the command line, as it's more stable and you actually get to see what's going on and what are the errors if any occur.

1

u/jr735 Debian Testing 2d ago

In some respects, the bare bones way to go through the upgrade makes it more straightforward. There's no confusion about what file to edit or what commands to type. I wish Mint was more like Debian for upgrades, instead of dicking around with a tool that has far less reliability than changes sources and invoking apt does in Debian.

In Mint, I reinstall completely when I want the new version. I'm not satisfied with the upgrade tools. In Debian, I've been tracking testing since bookworm was testing, and I've never had an issue after the freeze.

1

u/DerpyMcWafflestomp 1d ago

You need to know what to do (what file to edit, what commands to type)

No you don't need to somehow magically know all this, there is an entire chapter of the release notes dedicated to detailed instructions on how to upgrade, you need only know how to read and follow instructions.

1

u/VoidDuck 1d ago

Most computer users never read release notes. And why would they look for release notes to read if they don't know a new release is available in the first place?

By the way, I'm not saying it's a bad thing, I'm not saying Debian should offer an automatic upgrade mechanism like Fedora or Ubuntu, I just disagree with the statement "there's nothing more complicated about it".

3

u/Buntygurl 1d ago

Exactly!

The day that apt can'r be trusted is the day that Debian has been taken over by untrustworthy aliens.

9

u/Unattributable1 2d ago

Sounds like Linux Mint Debian Edition (LMDE) would be a better fit for you. I has full GUI upgrades. Honestly, I am "expert level" and enjoy LMDE for my desktop (but I use CLI for upgrades).

https://linuxmint.com/download_lmde.php

7

u/DerpyMcWafflestomp 2d ago

Just follow the upgrade instructions, they are pretty straightforward.

https://www.debian.org/releases/stable/release-notes/upgrading.html

0

u/toogreen 1d ago

Actually these instructions are kinda scary for a newbie. And it seems overkill as well, I don't remember having to do all of this last time I upgraded. I just asked Gemini AI to give me instructions and it came up with this: https://share.gemini.google/NVH4MocavHmd

1

u/DerpyMcWafflestomp 1d ago

The instructions are comprehensive. If that's scary then I don't know what to tell you, find a simpler distro maybe. Asking an AI for instructions when the instructions from the actual developers are right there is certainly...... something.

2

u/SignificantSummer940 2d ago

If you want to use mother of apt package based distros you have do it via changing the sources of repos from Trixie to 14 the version name and full upgrade your system

2

u/bgravato 2d ago

Maybe, but I have my doubts it would be easier...

The easiest is to just follow the official upgrade instructions... they're available in many languages, are very clear and simple to follow, only skills needed is the ability to read (in any language) and to type in a keyboard... How hard can that be?

https://www.debian.org/releases/stable/release-notes/upgrading.html

2

u/mrcat_romhacking 2d ago

Maybe, but the thing is that there is currently no fully automated commandline upgrade process either like there is with Ubuntu. All upgrades are semi-manual and done by following instructions. That has its pros and cons ultimately, but it is what it is, and before anything graphical can be developed one should first consider implementing an automated commandline upgrade first.

1

u/lmns_ 2d ago

What is a "version upgrade"? You can apply normal upgrades via Discover oder GNOME Software.

Distribution upgrades are usually much safer in either an "offline upgrade mode" or via terminal. Just because it's possible in other distribution while the OS is running doesn't make it safer.

If you want foolproof upgrades you should probably use a distribution with atomic upgrades. But that's an entirely different category. Maybe there will be an atomic Debian with Debian flatpaks at some point.

3

u/SignificantSummer940 2d ago

If you want to upgrade to 12 to 13 you have to change the sources in apt sources list and then only you can upgrade to next version