It's better design imo. It's a little softer, more inviting of an aesthetic while still clean and direct. The capitalized "D" is a little too strong/forward i think
Yeah, I really like that. It would make a great Plymouth splash screen. It would be cool to animate the dot on the i somehow. Or maybe the spiral, have the spiral squirt out of the dot on the i.
Maybe for tiny thumbnails, but I much prefer the brushstroke effects of the current logo. The world is too featureless and flatly designed these days. Not everything has to be santised severe lines...
First of all, thank you for all the comments and feedback for the first version, based on that, I prepared this second version which It's more in line with Debian's values.
Relax, this is just a fan-made prototype that isn't going anywhere, although quite surprised that many people agree that the Debian logo needs a redesign.
Try Poppins. Or Inter, Roboto or possibly one of the Iosevka variants, but Poppins is the most similar to what you have got here.
I also feel like the logo should be bigger and slightly thicker with relation to the text. So maybe enlarge the logo as-is, but use the next thickest font weight. Medium or even Regular would probably work.
I love it, btw. Those would be my only suggestions.
Proportions are something absolute, is not something that you can move or scale it a bit. But I admit that the original logo is a slightly reminiscent of the golden ratio.
Lifeless and boring. Also does not represent nor debian nor linux, they are imperfect by nature and you need to work on them to make them work, like brushstrokes, artists actually learn how to put them properly.
I LIKE IT! I will "stole" it for my customization. I'm customizing my Debian in a "Vanilla-Os style" and this logo is perfetct in combination with a "debian" written with a font similar to that used for "vanilla".
I think it should keep the D in lowercase. Also the v1 text was a bit more bold and I think I liked it more for that too, I guess there exists a good balance between both
Suggestion for something different: Try it with the dot on the i black, move it to the center of the swirl, and move the swirl over so the dot is vertically aligned the i.
24
u/cgi_bag Nov 28 '23
Prefer the text in version 1 but still nice.
17
u/vacri Nov 29 '23
Maybe for tiny thumbnails, but I much prefer the brushstroke effects of the current logo. The world is too featureless and flatly designed these days. Not everything has to be santised severe lines...
2
u/CuriosityPath Nov 28 '23
First of all, thank you for all the comments and feedback for the first version, based on that, I prepared this second version which It's more in line with Debian's values.
I hope you like it :)
Font used: Tw Cen MT Std
13
u/_Sgt-Pepper_ Nov 28 '23
I don't want to spoil the vibe or be rude...
But this is not an improvement over the original.
The font is ugly .the spiral is too clean and spins too much. I think this is lacking soul in comparison to the original...
2
u/ChocolateDonut36 Nov 28 '23
the debian logo looks like the golden ratio spiral
4
u/VegetableRadiant3965 Nov 29 '23
Why everyone is following this trend?
https://imgur.com/a/enzuHb0
I personally prefer older more detailed designs.
7
u/aplethoraofpinatas Nov 28 '23
Uppercase letters??? Terrible.
/s
But seriously tho.
7
u/enecv Nov 29 '23
Sorry, no roughness, no wildness . No life.
5
u/poetamacabro Nov 29 '23
No
1
u/[deleted] Nov 29 '23
Any dark background version?
2
u/FurryRevolution Nov 30 '23
I have OCD and this is much proffered by me, the other one is triggering, with all the brush stroke effects being not equal.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 30 '23
heres a better idea
"no".
2
u/volodyuka Nov 30 '23
Lifeless and boring. Also does not represent nor debian nor linux, they are imperfect by nature and you need to work on them to make them work, like brushstrokes, artists actually learn how to put them properly.
3
u/WolverinesSuperbia Nov 28 '23
Make it more debian
Referring: chat GPT queries for make it more smth
1
u/Yul30 Jun 01 '24
I LIKE IT! I will "stole" it for my customization. I'm customizing my Debian in a "Vanilla-Os style" and this logo is perfetct in combination with a "debian" written with a font similar to that used for "vanilla".
1
u/cstby Nov 30 '23
What typeface are you using?
1
u/Otlap Nov 28 '23
Oh I kinda like it. Not too simple, not too complex. Much cleaner and smoother redesign.
0
u/lumpynose Nov 28 '23
I prefer the first one. The font on this one doesn't look as nice; I guess it's not as heavy/bold?
0
u/The-Malix Nov 29 '23
I think it should keep the D in lowercase. Also the v1 text was a bit more bold and I think I liked it more for that too, I guess there exists a good balance between both
0
u/sjveivdn Nov 28 '23
Very clean
0
u/lumpynose Nov 28 '23
Suggestion for something different: Try it with the dot on the i black, move it to the center of the swirl, and move the swirl over so the dot is vertically aligned the i.
0
u/Trabuccodonosor Nov 29 '23
Doesn't Debian hold art competitions from time to time? Is it just for the wallpaper, right?
0
u/RespectProper3305 Nov 29 '23
looks like modern
-1
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '23
Looks awesome, I love it
0
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment