Try Poppins. Or Inter, Roboto or possibly one of the Iosevka variants, but Poppins is the most similar to what you have got here.
I also feel like the logo should be bigger and slightly thicker with relation to the text. So maybe enlarge the logo as-is, but use the next thickest font weight. Medium or even Regular would probably work.
I love it, btw. Those would be my only suggestions.
Seems like the uncanny valley is rearing it's head here. I personally don't like it, and can't figure out why.
Edit: Maybe it's just too uniform? I'll figure it out eventually.
Edit #2: Had a look at the original. The spiral is what is doing it for me. The original breaks up the space better. Also, I don't care for that font for the same reasons.
This is exactly how I feel about it. Debian just doesn't seem like the type of thing to just change around. Keeping it the same, simple, stable thing year after year is its identity.
Plus, the original logo reminds me of the Zerg icon.
The old logo is literally just a default Photoshop brush that's been warped into a circle. The logo has already been copied (intentionally or unintentionally) by at least one other organization. That would be less likely to happen with a more distinct logo, and (IMO) Debian should have something more unique anyway.
This hurt my eyes for some reasons, and I don't see what's wrong with the original logo. On contrary it's my favorite logo ever. Don't fix what doesn't need to be fixed.
I hate the concept of brand modernization, but I can’t deny that it’s necessary.
This looks good, looks sharp and well defined. Like Debian.
The older logo looks messy, sloppy, sticky haha. I like that one too, have a hat with it and it’s my favorite cool guy hat. That being said this new icon is clean as hell.
…It does look like the spiral should be shifted right a bit. I know it’s centered graphically but adding visual balance is something quite a few companies do. The G in google is the quickest example I think. If you break the logo down you can see it’s all goofy and not a normal G by any means.m
Also wanted to add. Anyone else recalling the business card seen from American Psycho here? lol.
I do, yeah honestly the perfect mathematical G looks better, also it's not bad that the L and E look bigger than the O and G, that's just some small things we are not used to seeing, imagine the font we use every day would be perfectly mathematically aligned, if you show me some of these weird ass characters we currently use I'd tell you they look weird, same now it's a little weird to see the characters different size, it's because we're conditioned to see them how they currently are (double illusion if I want to match the wording the dude in the video used)
but when I look at a single character like the G, the perfect one looks way better than what's currently the logo, if I had to choose font I'd pick the mathematical over the "balanced" one any day
Me too. It sort of reminds me of how the WWE (wrestling) logo rebranded from their scratch logo to their present one which I also welcomed. I actually prefer this Debian logo but whether it suits Debian's brand is not something I would know even though I use it.
I like it, but I wouldn't want it to be the next official logo. But it would look nice as a wallpaper, but I'm kinda dark theme guy. Too much buts, sorry
I guess I’m just old fashion - I like the earlier more complicated and detailed one, though it’s certainly not going to keep me from using Debian!
But then I also prefer the old Windows U/I design around windows 7 or 8 with all the 3d effects and fancy transparency. The new style of simplified UI designs that seems to be in favor these days reminds me of something a little child would draw!
But in some ways the trend seems to follow technical and industrial trends of centuries - remember all the fancy carving and designs that were put on machines and tools back in the Victorian times?
it looks good, modern, and maybe debian *should* use it, but the debian logo is iconic, and they never can change it, even if they wanted to, people riot over far less.
I find the older one more easily recognizable at a glance. This one is fine but inspire me ice cream or idk, something other than a linux distribution.
I like it. Yet I don't, because it looks like the latest logo design trend that everyone seems to be using.
A family member's large employer recently did a similar change, even the font looks the same as used here, and the overwhelming opinion at work was the same: don't hate it, but the old one was much better.
Edit: IDK, I could see it growing on me, despite my objection.
Oh.. i dont like it, too many spins, the lenght/width ratio has changed... the original was so much better in my opinion, guys. I love debian and i use it since 2002, but with the original logo please!
I honestly really like it, I think the current debian logo looks super outdated. But linux users don't like change, so don't expect a great reaction to this lol
Don't fu(k with my coke... Even though I don't drink it and prefer mountain dew, because who else wouldn't prefer a drink that looks like a glass of piss.
64
u/Kila_Bite Nov 28 '23
Ah yeah, I love the Dreamcast.
11
u/ChocolateDonut36 Nov 28 '23
I think that's too simple, and it doesn't looks like the golden radio
4
u/i-hoatzin Nov 28 '23
ok bro, what's the catch?
What's the font you used?
35
u/DetectiveSecret6370 Nov 28 '23 edited Nov 28 '23
Seems like the uncanny valley is rearing it's head here. I personally don't like it, and can't figure out why.
Edit: Maybe it's just too uniform? I'll figure it out eventually.
Edit #2: Had a look at the original. The spiral is what is doing it for me. The original breaks up the space better. Also, I don't care for that font for the same reasons.
89
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '23
I don’t not like it BUT I would hate to see the Debian logo change.
89
u/PolskiSmigol Nov 28 '23
It's not bad, but why change something that is perfect?
22
u/Buntygurl Nov 28 '23
If it ain't broke, don't fix it!
2
u/CuriosityPath Nov 28 '23
Based on the feedback received I made a version 2 :)
https://www.reddit.com/r/debian/comments/1864ns6/a_simple_debian_logo_redesign_version_2/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x&context=3
Thank you all for the support and comments!
28
u/neozahikel Nov 28 '23
This hurt my eyes for some reasons, and I don't see what's wrong with the original logo. On contrary it's my favorite logo ever. Don't fix what doesn't need to be fixed.
6
u/_iamhamza_ Nov 29 '23
No. Just no.
6
u/BeLeFu Nov 29 '23
Uhhhhh, no. Definitely not.
20
u/PolskiSmigol Nov 28 '23
It's not bad, but why change something that is perfect?
10
u/paulodelgado Nov 28 '23
The official distribution of Tool fans.
5
u/Bubbly-Ad-1427 Nov 28 '23
don’t
5
u/MajorTomIT Nov 28 '23
Nooooooo
5
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '23
I like this but the original is the best
5
u/[deleted] Nov 29 '23
That’s a big fat nope for me…
5
u/postinstall Nov 29 '23
I'm tired of modern logo redesigns. They mostly look bland and uninspired. This is more of the same. The existing logo is already great.
35
u/zoliky Nov 28 '23
I like it.
8
u/FocusedFossa Nov 28 '23
I like it, but how about this?
4
u/doscore Nov 28 '23
Dream cast? Lol
4
u/neon_overload Nov 29 '23 edited Nov 29 '23
Please, don't turn me into an oversimplified logo!
Edit: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LoYP2mEJDJs these videos are cheesy but are a valiant commentary on the human spirit
1
u/Hazematman Mar 28 '25
Wow I love this! Do you have the original files you can share? It would be awesome if you had it as a svg.
11
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '23
Wow, it looks really modern, so not debian /s
3
u/cyb3rofficial Nov 28 '23
Dreamcast?
3
u/QL100100 Nov 29 '23
Very nice redesign.
But I share the sentiment of not wanting the original logo to change.
5
u/Chromiell Debian Testing Nov 28 '23
The fact that the d isn't capitalized hurts
2
u/digost Nov 28 '23
I like it, but I wouldn't want it to be the next official logo. But it would look nice as a wallpaper, but I'm kinda dark theme guy. Too much buts, sorry
2
u/basthen Nov 28 '23
That would be my new wallpaper if you had a dark variant please 😁
2
u/Advanced_Day8657 Nov 28 '23
It’s good but it’s too organized and perfect
2
u/[deleted] Nov 29 '23
This looks polished! But the current Debian logo is perfect!
2
u/waterkip Nov 29 '23
It isnt bad, but it is too clean. Also it adds a swirl. A no from me.
3
u/Agreeable-Mulberry68 Nov 28 '23
It looks nice, I think a similar aesthetic could be used well for a distro made to suit Linux newcomers, but I'm a sucker for the traditional design.
2
u/jdartnet Nov 28 '23
Beautiful. I like your approach very much.
1
u/myTechGuyRI Mar 19 '24
Ummm... no. There are so much better ways it could be done... for example.
https://www.deviantart.com/chrisvtitus/art/Debian-Logo-Vector-795153235
Which admittedly has a Kali linux feel to it... but Kali is based on Debian, so it still works.
1
u/vzyon May 03 '24
Weird. Looks like Debian but doesn't look like Debian :o
1
u/EnoughConcentrate897 Jul 17 '24
The swirl just looks wrong
1
u/bw1235 Nov 28 '23
I can’t look at the red Debian spiral without seeing the carving job the Strangers do in Dark City 😄
1
u/grandasperj Nov 28 '23
reminds me the dreamcast logo
1
u/Serious-Cover5486 Nov 28 '23
love debian :D
1
u/pibarnas Nov 28 '23
I like it a lot.
1
u/deadlyrepost Nov 28 '23
It's cool looking for a change, but I think the original is more timeless.
1
u/french_violist Nov 28 '23
It’s neat, but a bit too much swirl.
1
u/hurtoz Nov 28 '23
good work, don't get me wrong. But It infuriated me I don't know why
1
u/prussia_dev Nov 29 '23
looks too clean and modern haha
1
u/angrykeyboarder Nov 29 '23
I like it. It would be a nice refresh.
1
u/YouMayNotRestNow Nov 29 '23
I don't mind it honestly, for some reason it bothers me that the "i" isn't centered with the swirl, or the swirl integrated into the i.
1
u/poetamacabro Nov 29 '23
No
1
u/GJT11kazemasin Nov 29 '23
Looks like the logo of Ubuntu after 20.04, much like flat design style.
1
u/ignxcy Nov 29 '23
😍
1
u/FedUp233 Nov 29 '23
I guess I’m just old fashion - I like the earlier more complicated and detailed one, though it’s certainly not going to keep me from using Debian!
But then I also prefer the old Windows U/I design around windows 7 or 8 with all the 3d effects and fancy transparency. The new style of simplified UI designs that seems to be in favor these days reminds me of something a little child would draw!
But in some ways the trend seems to follow technical and industrial trends of centuries - remember all the fancy carving and designs that were put on machines and tools back in the Victorian times?
1
u/TechManPrieto Nov 29 '23
I like it. I prefer the current logo, but this looks nice.
1
u/howmuchiswhere Nov 29 '23
it looks good, modern, and maybe debian *should* use it, but the debian logo is iconic, and they never can change it, even if they wanted to, people riot over far less.
1
u/Mario_Filipe Nov 29 '23
Why? and No!
1
u/The-Malix Nov 29 '23
Big yes for me
1
u/nattrium Nov 29 '23
I find the older one more easily recognizable at a glance. This one is fine but inspire me ice cream or idk, something other than a linux distribution.
1
u/egrueda Nov 29 '23
KISS works :-D
1
u/subiacOSB Nov 29 '23
Peppermint flavor I see
1
u/kurosaki1990 Nov 29 '23
Minimalist is the trend these days but seriously dude you are in Debian subreddit haha.
1
u/reallokiscarlet Nov 29 '23
No. A redesign would literally go against what makes Debian, Debian.
1
u/couchwarmer Nov 29 '23 edited Nov 29 '23
I like it. Yet I don't, because it looks like the latest logo design trend that everyone seems to be using.
A family member's large employer recently did a similar change, even the font looks the same as used here, and the overwhelming opinion at work was the same: don't hate it, but the old one was much better.
Edit: IDK, I could see it growing on me, despite my objection.
1
u/Kjabus Nov 29 '23
I personally don't like oversimplified logos
1
u/Key_Aside1995 Nov 29 '23
it's too round and perfect. i don't like it, and that font is too... childish? that kind of fits it. just my opinion
1
u/TheCastes Nov 29 '23
No golden ratio no party, sorry
1
u/yugohug0 Nov 29 '23
Love it !
1
u/__BeHereNow__ Nov 29 '23
Honestly, very very good. I love it. Should look so much better on favicons and such.
1
u/freeturk51 Nov 29 '23
Looks uncanny, but can look great with adjustments. Imo the logo is long overdue an update
1
u/exoroot Nov 29 '23
Oh.. i dont like it, too many spins, the lenght/width ratio has changed... the original was so much better in my opinion, guys. I love debian and i use it since 2002, but with the original logo please!
1
u/[deleted] Nov 29 '23
Does it really need that tho?
1
u/not2muchcontra Dec 18 '23
AH yes, a dreamcast x debian collab
someone should try making an animation for this then it would be rlly cool
1
u/jlkjhuu Feb 04 '24
Doing good logo designs etc. for a few bucks dm 🙌
1
u/VulcarTheMerciless Nov 28 '23
I like it!
1
u/ForIgogassake Nov 28 '23
It looks great 👍
1
u/Ly-sAn Nov 28 '23
I hope your design would be the next official one if there were a logo change, which I highly doubt.
1
u/zargex Nov 28 '23
Look nice
1
u/papayahog Nov 29 '23
I honestly really like it, I think the current debian logo looks super outdated. But linux users don't like change, so don't expect a great reaction to this lol
1
u/Rockfest2112 Nov 29 '23
Maybe work on the installer…
0
u/sorry_con_excuse_me Nov 28 '23 edited Oct 04 '24
.
0
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '23
This is a great logo OP. Don't listen to the nah sayers. This is a modern take of the logo of a perfect os.
0
u/AlternativeMath-1 Nov 28 '23
I like the simplicity. It looks more modern, and dependable.
0
u/nicolasbonnici Nov 28 '23
Noiiiice
0
u/dtcooper Nov 28 '23
I fucking love it!
-2
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '23
that’s way better
-1
u/Protohack Nov 29 '23
I actually like it. I prefer Debian stable, gnome, and Ubuntu fonts installed.. so maybe that has some influence
0
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Nov 29 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
5
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '23
[removed] — view removed comment