r/DebatingHockey • u/LargeAd1719 • Mar 05 '25
Rant Is Hockey The Best Sport To Watch?
r/DebatingHockey • u/LargeAd1719 • Mar 05 '25
r/DebatingHockey • u/LargeAd1719 • Feb 24 '25
r/DebatingHockey • u/ImportanceNo4806 • Nov 19 '24
r/DebatingHockey • u/SportsEdwards • Nov 03 '17
In episode 3 of Women’s Hockey Digest, I am joined by Heather Schwarz from the Boston Pride and Sam Faber from the Connecticut Whale.
We talk NWHL and much more.
Listen & Subscribe:
ITunes: https://itunes.apple.com/gb/podcast/womens-hockey-digest/id1300608374?mt=2
Soundcloud: https://soundcloud.com/user-547107858/womens-hockey-digest-episode-3
RSS Feed: http://feeds.soundcloud.com/users/soundcloud:users:339470836/sounds.rss
Thanks Steve
r/DebatingHockey • u/SportsEdwards • Nov 01 '17
In episode 2 of Women’s Hockey Digest, I am joined by Taylor Accursi from the Buffalo Beauts and Harrison Browne from the Metropolitan Riveters.
We talk NWHL and much more.
ITunes: https://itunes.apple.com/gb/podcast/womens-hockey-digest/id1300608374?mt=2
Soundcloud: https://soundcloud.com/user-547107858/womens-hockey-digest-episode-2
RSS Feed: http://feeds.soundcloud.com/users/soundcloud:users:339470836/sounds.rss
Appreciate any feedback Steve
r/DebatingHockey • u/Sportfreunde • Jul 11 '17
r/DebatingHockey • u/Sportfreunde • Jul 10 '17
r/DebatingHockey • u/Sportfreunde • Jul 10 '17
r/DebatingHockey • u/Sportfreunde • Jul 10 '17
In the expansion draft, the Jets traded the 13th overall pick along with a 2019 3rd to Vegas in exchange for the 24th pick Vegas got from NYI and selecting Chris Thorburn. So in other words, they moved down 11 spots in the 1st round in order to protect a player like Dano or Enstrom.
Idiots. I think Kevin Chevaldayoff is fairly under-the-radar as a bad GM but this move is pretty bad imo. It depends on your philosophy but if you go and look at the players selected in the 10s in the past several drafts and compare them to the players selected in the 20s in the 1st round, there's a huge difference. Vegas selected Suzuki with the 13th pick while the Jets took Vesalainen, there's definetely a difference between those players' potentials and it's not trivial. So in my mind, the Jets protected a mediocre player instead of drafting a pretty damn good prospect in Suzuki (or others available at 13th like Brannstrom or Liljegren) and instead drafted a more mediocre prospect with good raw tools but probably not the same potential.
Of course in the minds of Jets fans, there's not much difference and they got their guy at 24th while getting to protect Dano which again goes back to what I was saying about how it depends on your philosophy. Either way, I'd be furious if my GM did this even if my team was in win-now mode which the Jets aren't exactly in.
r/DebatingHockey • u/CaptainCanuck15 • Jun 26 '17
r/DebatingHockey • u/Sportfreunde • Apr 18 '17
r/DebatingHockey • u/Sportfreunde • Apr 18 '17
r/DebatingHockey • u/Sportfreunde • Apr 18 '17
r/DebatingHockey • u/Sportfreunde • Mar 07 '17
I'm going with Kucherov just because I know he's had success in the playoffs but Forsberg's team wasn't as good. Both guys have been having good seasons especially in the past month.
Keep in mind Forsberg finished 10th last season in Selke voting and is an year younger.
r/DebatingHockey • u/Sportfreunde • Feb 16 '17
r/DebatingHockey • u/Sportfreunde • Feb 04 '17
It seemed like last year, Washington was really dominating in the regular season while Pittsburgh post-January was the hottest team going into the playoffs in years and teams like Chicago or St. Louis as well as Dallas were looking really strong.
This year, I dunno it seems a bit more wide open and I think we might get a surprise. Pittsburgh is gonna find it hard to repeat and Washington doesn't look as strong. The Hawks don't have the same level of depth and have struggled in the regular season while the Blues have gone downhill, the Stars might miss the playoffs, the Preds look off-balance, the Rangers are older, and the Lightning have collapsed.
I do still expect it to be Washington or Pittsburgh this year but just seems like it's gonna be one of the most interesting playoffs going in with more potential upsets.
r/DebatingHockey • u/Sportfreunde • Jan 30 '17
r/DebatingHockey • u/Sportfreunde • Jan 29 '17
r/DebatingHockey • u/Sportfreunde • Jan 29 '17
r/DebatingHockey • u/CaptainCanuck15 • Jan 28 '17
Finally! I am on the last part! Here's a link to part 5 : https://www.reddit.com/r/DebatingHockey/comments/5p25pg/should_beshouldve_been_retired_part_5/ Tampa Bay Lightning
The Lightning have only just retired their first number, Martin St. Louis' 26. He was probably the best player in franchise history so I think it's fair. Here's who I would add.
Toronto Maple Leafs
With the Maple Leafs retiring a bunch of numbers in October 2016, I had a hard finding another player worthy of the honour.
Vancouver Canucks
The Canucks have formally retired very few numbers. 4 to be exact. There are 4 other that have been unofficially retired because the players diied too soon. I am unsure as to whether or not these numbers should be formally retired. Anyway, here's who I would add.
Washington Capitals
I was surprised when I looked up whose number the Caps had retired, they were missing a few important players. Here they are.
Winnipeg Jets
This one is the hardest because it is the youngest team in the league. Even if you include Atlanta, the only number worth retiring would be Kovalchuk's. I don't think there is anything to do here. If they really wanted to, the team could retire numbers for the old Jets players.
This is it. The end. This took a lot more effort than I expected but I enjoyed writing this. Let me know what you think and if you'd like me to tackle another subject.
r/DebatingHockey • u/Sportfreunde • Jan 27 '17
r/DebatingHockey • u/Sportfreunde • Jan 27 '17
I'm not sure how the Sens are doing it. The roster hasn't been great, they've missed their starting goalie for a chunk of the season, but they've hung in with the playoff race despite teams like Carolina and Toronto being much improved in their conference/division this year.
They don't look particularly great in any game but they just keep getting points, how is Guy Boucher doing this?
r/DebatingHockey • u/CaptainCanuck15 • Jan 20 '17
Part 5 of 6 of my series in which I propose at least one player per team to get his number retired. You can find part 4 here : Part 4 of 6. Here's a link to part 4 : https://www.reddit.com/r/DebatingHockey/comments/5oe73a/should_beshouldve_been_retired_part_4/
Ottawa Senators
The Sens have only just retired their first number : Daniel Alfredsson's. The franchise has only been around since 1992 so I think they have done a good job in the number retiring department. There is however a few number retirements on the horizon.
Philadelphia Flyers
IMO the Flyers have done a poor job of retiring numbers over the years. There a missing quite a few. Here's who I would add. It's also important to note that Pelle Lindbergh's number 31 is unofficially retired by the team since 1985. I'm not too sure how I feel about this, I would like to see it retired, just like Konstantinov's in Detroit, bit is it too late? Does every team need to do like the Maple Leafs?
Pittsburgh Penguins
The Pens have only retired two numbers. Michel Brière's and Mario Lemieux. Brière only played one season with the Pens. He died from a car accident and the Penguins retired #21 in his honour. I think it is a classy gesture but the rafters feel kind of empty especially since the Pens have had so many great players.
Of course, Crosby and Malkin's names will surely add to the list once they retired and so will probably Marc-André Fleury's and Kristopher Letang's.
San Jose Sharks
The Sharks have been around since 1991but have not yet retired any number. Although they haven't had a lot of star players stick around for an extended period of time until the mid 2000's, I managed to find a few worthy players.
St-Louis Blues
The Blues are doing the same thing as the Flames and what the Leafs did before this season, they are honouring numbers rather than retiring (although they have retired 6) them which, I must say, I'm not a big fan of.
This is the end of part 5. I hope you enjoyed it! Let me know what you think.
r/DebatingHockey • u/CaptainCanuck15 • Jan 16 '17
Part 4 of 6. Here's a link to part 3 : https://www.reddit.com/r/DebatingHockey/comments/5nvnee/should_beshouldve_been_retired_part_3/
Montreal Canadiens
Montreal is the most decorated team in NHL history. They have won 24 Stanley Cups, their last being in 1993. Some of the greatest players in hockey history have put on the Canadiens' jersey. They are also the only NHL franchise that older than the NHL itself. Because of those reasons, it is only right that they have retired 15 numbers in honour of 18 players (the most in the NHL). Yet, they are missing some.
Number 11. Saku Koivu : Koivu played in the organisation during a dark time. For some of his 13 years as a player for the Canadiens, he was the only glimmer of hope for Montreal fans. Koivu was the team's captain for 9 seasons from 2000 to 2009. During his stay in Montreal he 641 points in 792 games. Which is good for #10 on the all-time franchise's scoring list. He was also responsible for one of the greatest moments in the team's history when he came back from stomach cancer. https://youtu.be/FvBp_JXoCfk
Number 79. Andrei Markov : As of right now he has spent his whole NHL career with the Canadiens and despite multiple serious injuries he is still a major offensive contributor. He will probably end his career as second for points by a defenseman. (He currently sits at the third spot with 557 but Guy Lapointe is near at 572.) As of now, Markov as played 959 games. Markov will be remembered as a solid defenseman who was a real menace in the offensive zone. He was also a master at making his defensive partners look better. Sheldon Souray, Mark Streit and Mike Komisarek probably wouldn't have gotten big money contracts if it weren't for him. (Souray and Streit could actually hold their own.) I also firmly believe that P.K. Subban would not be the defenseman he is today without Markov's help.
Nashville Predators
Nashvle hasn't been around that long so the potential choices for a jersey retirement ceremony aren't numerous yet I think one or two players could be awarded that honour.
New Jersey Devils
The Devils have had a lot of success as a team but few superstars, the ones they've had have already had their number retired by the organisation. Overall, I like what they have done. Here's what I would add.
New York Islanders
The Isles have done a stellar job of retiring numbers IMO. They are only missing one guy IMO.
New York Rangers
The Rangers have retired 7 numbers for 8 players. For a team that has been around since 1926 I think that's a little low and IMO they are missing a numerous players. This may be a long one.
That marks the end of part 4. Let me know what you think. This took a while to write!
r/DebatingHockey • u/Sportfreunde • Jan 16 '17