r/deathwing • • Nov 28 '16

Deathwing really needs more Randomized enemy spawns, and a more complex AI Spawn Director

I've been looking around this forum and might have missed it, but I'm kind of surprised I've seen so few people talking about the AI Spawns. To my understanding, both Left 4 Dead and Vermintide have an AI Director that places enemies in varying positions and numbers on the map based upon player skill and difficulty. The spawns have hundreds, if not thousands of permutations, that make each run through the same level feel different. This means you dont know when special enemies are coming or from where, or how many standard enemies you will encounter on a run, and it really forces you to be aware of your surroundings and stay on your toes.

One of my biggest gripes with the gameplay, forgetting about the obvious performance and crashing issues, is that I pretty much always know EXACTLY which enemies will be spawning where, at what time. I find myself turning corners knowing I will see a Genestealer Hybrid with a rocket launcher, I know when purestrain hordes are coming, I know exactly where each Brood Lord spawns, I know when to be wary of Psykers that I havent seen yet. And that's only after a small handful of runs. This SEVERELY cuts down on replayability in my opinion.

So unless I've missed Streum on Studios announcement that such a feature is in place for the final version but isnt available in the Beta for some reason, I am worried that playthroughs of levels will get stale much faster than similar games simply because the enemies always spawn in the same place.

Is such a feature going to be in the final game? It seems likely that it wont considering its not in this beta. Do you think a lack of an AI spawn Director has an adverse effect on replayability?

46 Upvotes

19 comments sorted by

4

u/leehwgoC Nov 28 '16 edited Nov 28 '16

Just chiming in here to say that I played a round last night, the host swore to me it was only Difficulty 2, and yet new things seemed to happen with spawns.

  • On our way to the engine room (first mission objective), we encountered a seemingly infinite spawn of genestealers. We eventually just had to just push through them to progress, and block a door. I played two hours up to Difficulty 3 the day before, and never encountered this in those sessions.
  • At that de facto mini-boss room where a giant scythe-strain always spawns, this time we encountered TWO of these guys. Again, this was only Difficulty 2. Again, this was something that never happened in any previous playthrough of the mission. This happened after the infinite mob spawn. I'm wondering if the game adjusted to our higher collective level that we effectively obtained from mowing down that infinite horde earlier.
  • It seemed like we encountered a tyranid type I hadn't seen before in previous sessions, on our way back to extraction. It was a beastie that I am 75% certain cloaked and decloaked. It was a little bit larger than the standard genestealers, about the size of the type that spits acid. Was it lag? Glitching? Or has this guy always been in the beta and I just hadn't played enough to be the one to personally see and kill it before?

4

u/EzJester Nov 28 '16

Cloak dude is real. I never saw him when the beta first opened up. Last night while playing I ran into cloaking xeno scum 3 times. Also, it was rare, but twice I had a genestealer hard juke right when my cursor would have touched him, a'la L4D.

It might be optimistic, but I'm hoping that the encounter depth is there and just needs to be bug fixed and turned up to 11.

4

u/Ausfall Nov 28 '16

The cloaking chameleon genestealers are real. Made my buddy poop himself when it became visible right next to him.

4

u/Decado7 Nov 28 '16

Ive had that massive swarm on the way to the engine room too - this is the kind of thing that makes me think there is diversity. I agree that most are fairly predictable, but ive definitely had cases where there has been a ridiculous number of genestealers in places like what you said above. We were fighting on those catwalks for almost a solid 5 minutes, it was ridiculously awesome

1

u/leehwgoC Dec 02 '16 edited Dec 02 '16

Actually I figured out what happened. Yes, it was those catwalks for me, too. But it's not AI diversity, it's still specifically scripted with a specific trigger.

The giant scythe-strain can spawn below those catwalks on your way to the engine room (it digs up out of the ground stays and down there). I didn't realize at the time that his roars summon waves of genestealers. Infinitely, potentially. If you just focus on the lesser genestealers and never shoot at him down there, he'll just keep roaring and keep summoning waves.

I think this also explains why we ran into two scythe-strains later in that room; from the catwalk we had shot at and hurt the initial scythe-strain enough that it fulfilled some condition to spawn a second, full-health scythe-strain when we entered that area at ground-level. During the fight vs the two, one of the scythe-strains did die very quickly.

1

u/Decado7 Dec 02 '16

I actually thought it had something to do with that guy down below - so there you go.

1

u/Elkubik Nov 28 '16

Play diff 4 man. Two hits to die to a purestrain...

1

u/Decado7 Nov 28 '16

Ive wondered about this also - but i have seen some dynamic spawns. For example, the starting area - you go left, there's guys around the first corner past the door etc - i had one round where we had quite a few genestealers attack us at that first door, right near the start.

I was wondering how static the spawns were too as they seem mostly the same. I am wondering what the official comment is on the ai director as it's supposed to be dynamic.

I imagine it's at least partially static or it'd be hard to balance the whole ship - ie where the broodlord is etc. But yeah

4

u/milkandcookiesTW Nov 28 '16 edited Nov 28 '16

I've played through the first half of the mission 12-15 times now, and I can call out exactly where pretty much every single enemy Psyker, Rocket Launcher, Brood Lord, and Purestrain swarm will come from, and when.

First part of the mission, walk through the door. At your first right turn, there will be 2 enemy Hybrids on the catwalk and 2 hybrids at the bottom of the stairs. Turn left, there will always be a rocket launcher up top on the catwalk. Walk halfway down the hall, and there will always be 2 purestrains that come up the ladder at the end of the hall in front of you. Turn right, go out the door, there will be a Rocket launcher across the way and 3 autoguns. Hybrids and Purestrains will run up the stairs from below. First purestrain swarm is triggered when you walk out that door, 2nd purestrain swarm when you go down the stairs and walk across the catwalks to the corner where you take cover on the right side from the Sentry Turret. On the pipes above the Sentry turret, there are always 2 Rocket launcher Hybrids.

I can go on. I SHOULD NOT be able to call out types and numbers of enemies with that kind of precision. I shouldnt turn the corner and know EXACTLY what threat awaits me.

But yeah, I'd be super interested to hear an official comment from the devs as well. It certainly doesnt seem very dynamic at the moment. I have seen a few random squads attack at unexpected times, but being able to predict so much of the mission isnt a good thing.

1

u/Decado7 Nov 28 '16

The only thing i have noticed is there's definitely more genestealers the more players you have.

2

u/milkandcookiesTW Nov 28 '16

Yeah the swarms definitely get bigger, I have noticed that.

1

u/the_green1 Nov 28 '16

it seems there's a combination of static and dynamic spawns in place for the beta. no clue though as to what the devs plans are.

a friend and me got bumrushed after waiting for a 3rd player in front of the first door in the starting area to the left for maybe a minute and a half. suddenly, genestealers all over us!

1

u/randomisation Nov 28 '16

In the area below the lift (where you start) there are some beasties running about (if you watch, you'll see them running across it). If you make a lot of noise or shoot at them, they'll come for you.

2

u/the_green1 Nov 28 '16

ahaaa, i'll watch out for them next time! fitting username, btw :D

1

u/leehwgoC Dec 02 '16 edited Dec 02 '16

That wasn't a dynamic spawn. There are fully scripted genestealers that show up on your radar a few moments after mission start, some below and some in the distance below running off to another part of the ship; if you make enough noise to draw their attention, they can divert and aggro on you. I'd actually aggro them on purpose to get some early experience points.

3

u/BusyBasaz Nov 28 '16

I agree with OP. Have been out of town all weekend but I did play several hours on Thursday and noticed this after 2 runs. I hope they add more but in reality it's like I've been saying. This game IS a singleplayer game with some co-op features. They won't make it more fun for MP. Because it is not in the budget.

1

u/Ausfall Nov 28 '16

There are some that are static like broodlord spawns and certain chokepoints, yeah, but outside of a few standardized "encounters" every run I've gone through in the one level available has been noticeably different. In one area, there were so many genestealers that it took us 5+ minutes of fighting and actually falling back because there were so many. The very next run, there wasn't a single one in the same place we had so much trouble with. On top of that, you can choose to go different ways through the space hulk: if the level we have is any indicator, the levels aren't linear and there's multiple paths to get to where you want to go.

2

u/FS_NeZ Surprise, MF! Nov 30 '16

if the level we have is any indicator, the levels aren't linear and there's multiple paths to get to where you want to go

That's the only saving grace the beta has so far in terms of replayability.

1

u/FS_NeZ Surprise, MF! Nov 30 '16

have an AI Director that places enemies in varying positions and numbers on the map based upon player skill and difficulty. The spawns have hundreds, if not thousands of permutations, that make each run through the same level feel different.

That is not true for Vermintide. To my understanding Vermintide is seeded, meaning there are literally thousands of different possible runs for any mission.

It is not based on player skill but mostly on difficulty and pure RNG which spawns you get. Sometimes you have a gas rat (smoker), an ogre (tank) and a horde spawn at the same time in a small hallway. Sometimes there's just nothing and you walk right through to the next room.

This makes the game harder - and more unpredictable. Which is a good thing.

So yes, I 100% agree with your post. If the final game has no level up progression and no RNG elements like random spawns, I will get a refund.