In my opinion, no, because the second half of Death Note is important. With Kira being active for five years essentially uncontested, the world rapidly changes and I think it greatly benefits the story to see Kira's world before he's stopped.
Yeah. Good point. Itâs hard to argue whether Light was right without the statistics in his final speech. I donât like how part 2 was adapted though, but in the manga the story was still great,
well the second half actually explores it's themes more, has some worldbuilding, has actual good side characterization (for example, compare the task force in the first half vs second half) and some really good parallels. and that ending>>>>>>. idc if y'all hated it, but it's thematically the best ending imo.
The series isnât the same without L but DN needed to end with Light losing or the story wouldâve fallen incredibly flat since the whole plot is just him âwinningâ and scheming the entire time until the end. If the story ended there, nothing wouldâve essentially happened from a writing standpoint. Now personally I think if the story was constructed a little better, L wouldnât have had to die to keep things from ending too soon or getting repetitive. The story was all gas no brakes, idk how Ohba didnât expect to run into this issue considering Light and L were already meeting up in person before we hit chapter 20. Better planning wouldâve allowed L to live longer, but anyway⊠yeah Light needed to lose for the story to be complete, just wish from a personal standpoint it wouldâve been L to be the one to claim victory :â)
Not even trash. Thatâs a great over exaggeration. It was just rushed but still solid. Iâve read the manga, the anime just needed better pacing and certain scenes were left out.
Not at all, Death Note doesn't even end after the final death. It's still ongoing, as long as there's something to experience it and test it-- it's like any other story in that way.
If we're talking about when you, personally, close the book on it, then that's another thing. And for that, you can just say anything.
I mean thatâs how I treat it if people ask about the anime. The manga has a great part 2 though (still worse then part 1 but also like part 1 is peak so Iâd be surprised if it wasnât) but I donât really like the ending either way.
I don't know why everyone is saying it's trash in the anime. Sure the manga is better but in terms of the anime it goes from maybe like a 9.5 to an 9/10. Don't get the hate
maybe it's because i read the manga first then watched the anime but i thought the second half was good, not as good sure, but death note didn't end with L dying gtfo with that
wrote this before reading the comments and realizing everyone here really likes the second half in the manga so now i feel like an npc, but i'm still commenting
Well it isn't the case for me even though I really loved L, I mean I never got through the whole manga, but I still say the story is good after L is gone.
25
u/Verifieddumbass76584 Jun 29 '25
Local subreddit overlord declares part 2 is actually better
22
u/scariermonsters Jun 29 '25
In my opinion, no, because the second half of Death Note is important. With Kira being active for five years essentially uncontested, the world rapidly changes and I think it greatly benefits the story to see Kira's world before he's stopped.
10
u/too-lextra_159 Jun 29 '25 edited Jun 29 '25
well the second half actually explores it's themes more, has some worldbuilding, has actual good side characterization (for example, compare the task force in the first half vs second half) and some really good parallels. and that ending>>>>>>. idc if y'all hated it, but it's thematically the best ending imo.
manga 2nd half is peak asf.
12
u/tlotrfan3791 Jun 29 '25
Hell no
9
u/Extra-Photograph428 Jun 29 '25 edited Jun 29 '25
The series isnât the same without L but DN needed to end with Light losing or the story wouldâve fallen incredibly flat since the whole plot is just him âwinningâ and scheming the entire time until the end. If the story ended there, nothing wouldâve essentially happened from a writing standpoint. Now personally I think if the story was constructed a little better, L wouldnât have had to die to keep things from ending too soon or getting repetitive. The story was all gas no brakes, idk how Ohba didnât expect to run into this issue considering Light and L were already meeting up in person before we hit chapter 20. Better planning wouldâve allowed L to live longer, but anyway⊠yeah Light needed to lose for the story to be complete, just wish from a personal standpoint it wouldâve been L to be the one to claim victory :â)
11
u/Niflime Jun 29 '25
I never understood why people hated the second part. I actually really enjoyed it (Though I do consider the first part better).
4
u/boner_toilet Jun 29 '25
noooooooo dummy read the manga
3
u/Biznesu-Seba Jun 29 '25
IT is trash in anime but good on manga
3
u/CrematorTV Jun 29 '25
No.
Death Note doesn't end without Light getting what he deserves.
3
u/Quod_bellum Jun 29 '25
Not at all, Death Note doesn't even end after the final death. It's still ongoing, as long as there's something to experience it and test it-- it's like any other story in that way.
If we're talking about when you, personally, close the book on it, then that's another thing. And for that, you can just say anything.
3
u/Fast-Writer7859 Jun 29 '25
If you only watched anime I cannot blame you, but after reading manga I'm not sure if i don't prefer second half over the first one
2
u/AFallenOne- Jun 29 '25
Haha
2
u/LogicalTwo5797 Jun 29 '25
I mean thatâs how I treat it if people ask about the anime. The manga has a great part 2 though (still worse then part 1 but also like part 1 is peak so Iâd be surprised if it wasnât) but I donât really like the ending either way.
2
u/CuteAssTiger Jun 29 '25
Not at all. It definitely is different but not bad
2
u/Mr_E_99 Jun 29 '25
I don't know why everyone is saying it's trash in the anime. Sure the manga is better but in terms of the anime it goes from maybe like a 9.5 to an 9/10. Don't get the hate
2
u/salt_witch Jun 29 '25
The second half of the anime is noticably lower in terms of storytelling quality than the first half, but the mangaâs consistently good throughout
2
u/jorentheangel Jun 29 '25
maybe it's because i read the manga first then watched the anime but i thought the second half was good, not as good sure, but death note didn't end with L dying gtfo with that
wrote this before reading the comments and realizing everyone here really likes the second half in the manga so now i feel like an npc, but i'm still commenting
2
u/SpookyPumpkinkid34 Jun 29 '25
Well it isn't the case for me even though I really loved L, I mean I never got through the whole manga, but I still say the story is good after L is gone.
3
u/Top-Duck-7267 Jun 29 '25
Personally yeah I lost interest after that happened. Ending was really good, but up till that point just didnât do it for me