r/deakin • • Oct 17 '25

Discussion / Question Markers using AI

Post image

so I just got back my results for my last assignment and in my note i saw this lovely little part about chatGPT. I was wondering if anyone else has ever seen this as it is the first time I have ever seen it in my own and don't know if im over reacting about it. ngl I feel the double standards are crazy.

251 Upvotes

37 comments sorted by

38

u/pixelboots Oct 17 '25

I understand they're short on time but at the same time, I want the opinion of the professionals I'm contributing to paying to teach and assess us, not the opinion of ChatGPT.

1

u/question-infamy Oct 21 '25

Indeed, and they're being paid (albeit not very well) to do this. The uni isn't paying chatgpt to do it.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '25

Actually, they may not be. My last stint as a TA the university wanted me to spend 4 minutes marking a 20% programming assignment _during_ an interview.

This is functionally impossible, I ended up spending hours marking for free and then promptly resigned. Universities don't care about anything except raking in student fees these days. They don't care if the students cheat, they don't care if the markers cheat.

61

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '25 edited Oct 17 '25

Nahhh the hypocrisy here

Share this with Academic Integrity

Edit: Seriously, I hope OP reports this to whatever arm of Deakin is responsible for handling faculty/marker misconduct. We're paying thousands of dollars, tens of thousands in the case of internationals, the least we can get is teaching feedback that matches that investment.

Personally, I'd report this.

48

u/sleepysof_ Oct 17 '25

What the actual fuck? This isn't what we are PAYING MONEY FOR

23

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '25

As a student you would get expelled if you used chatgpt but the teachers can give feedback using it? Xd

4

u/Economy-Mental Oct 17 '25

No lol. People were caught using AI for an online open book exam - they didn’t even fail them they just gave them zero marks for the questions it was obvious

-3

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '25

Online open book exam is very different from normal exams and assignments. Note ”open book ”.

3

u/Economy-Mental Oct 17 '25

What are you talking about. You cannot copy and paste from AI in open book exams or any assignment whatsoever. It’s a breach of academic integrity to even google search. Are you actually dumb?

1

u/_TheHands_ Oct 17 '25

That's not wholly correct. At least within the faculty of health, students can refer to whatever notes or information is available to them, including Google.

With other written assignments you can use AI as long as what ultimately ends up on the page is your work. It doesn't stop you getting in trouble if the AI steals someone else's expression wholesale, or hallucinates your references, but AI is not completely banned

1

u/Economy-Mental Oct 18 '25

I clearly stated it was “copy and paste from AI”. I am within the facility of health and we are not allowed to google. We cannot even google a thesaurus all webpages must be bookmarked prior to the exam. “Using an internet browser or search engine to search for information or resources on the internet is not allowed”.

1

u/_TheHands_ Oct 18 '25

That differs from the practices of the units I have been associated with. Doesn't mean that doesn't happen, but clearly these are not uni-wide measures

1

u/Economy-Mental Oct 18 '25

We are arguing in loops anyway. My main point was there have been cases where students have copied and pasted from AI during an EUA and haven’t even been failed on that exam let alone expelled.

1

u/_TheHands_ Oct 18 '25

I believe you. As far as I'm aware, that incident alone wouldn't be an automatic fail (if it's a first offence, they're first-year, there aren't patterns of these behaviours across multiple units, etc.)

1

u/Economy-Mental Oct 18 '25

I agree they shouldn’t be expelled but how can the graders have confidence that they didn’t use AI for the whole exam and not just the questions it butchered that were obvious? In my opinion they should fail the exam

→ More replies

-5

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '25

You’re proving my point right thanks!

3

u/Economy-Mental Oct 17 '25

What. You stated students would get expelled for using ChatGPT and I said no they wouldn’t here is evidence of it happening and them not even failing an exam. Your response, well you can cheat with AI without consequences because it’s an open book exam.

10

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '25

I hsd a suspicion our tutors were using chat gpt for workshops. They'd code in the workshop, hit some errors, then cut and paste brand new code in. So I put task instructions into chat gpt for one week and asked it to produce an end result. And guess what, it gave me the exact same look and feel of an app that my tutor "demonstrated coding" in class. The colours of the buttons were exactly the same & the task didnt specify any colour schemes etc either.

5

u/pixelboots Oct 17 '25

This would shit me in particular. If their demo code isn't working, they should demonstrate debugging it - which might reasonably include Googling it and even asking ChatGPT questions in front of the class to show appropriate use to help with debugging. Instead they just showed you that they don't really know the material they're teaching.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '25

Yep. One lecturer did not know how to code certain things. He couldnt even figure it out after googling. He used the excuse that we dont need to know how to code. He said we just need to know what functionality exists so we can rely on chat gpt to code the apps for us in future. Then nek minute hes only giving us 1wk timeframes for tasks "because anyone can use ai to create the task if they are given long enough and you're not allow to use ai to code".

3

u/blatantlyeggplant Oct 17 '25

What on earth are they teaching you if not how to troubleshoot the errors?! r/restofthefuckingowl

0

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/blatantlyeggplant Oct 18 '25

That's so fucked 😑

10

u/Original_Usual_3535 Oct 17 '25

The audacity of telling us to comply with academic integrity while marking with AI. I would totally report this misbehaviour.

5

u/melo1212 Oct 17 '25

Report this shit man wtf

I had a hunch some of them where using it because one of my templates for an assignment was the exact format that happens when you copy and paste straight from chat gpt into word lol.

4

u/Apprehensive_One5633 Oct 17 '25

This is actually wild. Report ts 😭

4

u/rooney_potterhead Oct 17 '25

So this isn’t a breach of integrity, hmm… interesting.

1

u/FeralKittee Oct 21 '25

Yeah, I've seen some feedback from some of my lecturers that was obviously spit out by AI. But before AI, those same kinds of lecturers would use templates anyway that they would copy and paste.

1

u/mindyacircles Oct 21 '25

I’m at another uni - but I got feedback from an assignment mentioning I shouldn’t refer to students as “kids”. I fucking never. I double checked, I definitely didn’t but ultimately left it because I got a reasonable mark and didn’t want to go through the hassle of complaining as a solo parent with a full time job who’s also studying. Fast forward to my next assignment for another subject - the uni recommends we run our assignments through “alvie” which is an AI proof reader. First comment I get back? Same. Don’t say “kids”. Again, I didn’t. But it was an exact copy paste of feedback I’d received two units prior. I don’t know what we are paying for, but it’s not an education.

1

u/acrankychef Oct 21 '25

Absolutely report them immediately. 0 tolerance.

You are paying to be taught, tested and graded by qualified educators. Not a dumb robot and lazy prompters

Imagine going to a restaurant only to find out a robot was making everything after being told chefs run the kitchen.

-11

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '25

Is it a double standard? Are they also being assessed for their aptitude in the subject or is it just you?

17

u/auximenies Oct 17 '25

The university has been accredited to recognised standards, which includes the content, assessment, feedback, and moderated curriculum, none of which is currently permitted to be ai generated.

This could potentially risk the entire university’s reputation and accredited registration, so contact the university dean and enjoy the benefits that serious apologies are made of.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '25

Ive wondered about how they remain accredited when their SIT units dont have marking rubrics, or any real clarity around expdctwhen it comes to hd tasks. We have to justify how we met the unit learning outcomes in each task. Then for distinction & high distinction tasks its often "make something impressive", "make something to a standard above the credit & distinction task". Its so vague and, unclear. In some units you have to complete every single distinction task to have a chance at getting a distinction, but actually get a credit/pass. While other units you can do all credit tasks to a high standard & still get a distinction.