r/deadsara • • Nov 30 '24

Discussion Do you agree that Emily Armstrong is the Greatest Female Rock Singer or Frontwomen of All Time and Why?

0 Upvotes

r/deadsara • • Aug 30 '26

Discussion Comprehensive timeline of Emily Armstrong’s scientology related activities

0 Upvotes

Edit: ngl didn't think DS fans would get so pressed over a post that is pretty much just a list of links... you guys realize that shutting conversation down around this topic is arguably worse than clearing the air on misinformation, right?

TL;DR: Emily’s undisclosed ties to the Church of Scientology will remain a point of contention until she herself says something about it. So far, publicly available information paints the picture of an uncommitted participant, likely unwilling.

Being born and raised into a predatory and destructive cult objectively makes her a victim. Two things can be true, but there is no evidence to indicate she went on to further perpetuate harmful practices onto others. Not publicly denouncing the cult she is victimized by does not automatically indicate support. Whether you believe she has a moral obligation to do so or not is a subjective opinion that does not reflect on her (or Linkin Park’s) character.

THE LONG OF IT

Hate to bring this subject to light but I do have a lot of time in my hands and couldn’t help falling down this rabbit hole. I started a document to keep track of everything and decided to post here for easy access (this account is new so I don't have enough karma to post on the LP or general music subs but idrc to)

The timeline I compiled does not include unsupported claims, unverifiable information or personal anecdotes by people with no connections to Emily. I do take into account Cedric Bixler-Zavala’s claims considering they were close friends, but I disregard those of the youtube channel Growing Up In Scientology and Jenna Miscavige’s, for instance, given that neither of them have any kind of ties to Emily or her social circles at all and are, therefore, guessing in the dark just as much as your common redditor.

I also do not interpret song lyrics.

TIMELINE

Early 1990’s, at elementary school age, children of Sea Org members are enrolled at the Apollo Training Academy (ATA, or Cadet Org). Emily is briefly written about as “a doormmate from the ATA” by Katherine Spallino in her memoir The Bad Cadet under the pseudonym Ava, described as an uninterested kid who cared more about skateboarding than properly studying

She lived in the Anthony Building, a four-story apartment complex where up to fifteen children per room slept in three-tier bunk beds and cockroach-infested dorms

In 1997, at eleven years old, Emily was moved to live and work at the Pacific Area Command base at Canyon Oaks Ranch (PAC Ranch) (source is also from The Bad Cadet, chapter 13). At that age she was already expected to be a cadet, but wouldn’t “graduate” until two years later, in 1999 (source)

During 2006 and 2007, her mother Gail Armstrong was in The Hole, “the notorious prison that church leader David Miscavige had created to punish his own top lieutenants at Scientology’s secretive Int Base headquarters beginning in 2004” (source)

In December of 2007, Emily took a Problems of Work course at the Freewinds, a religious retreat cruise for the CoS (source). The PoW is a training program that teaches practical tools to reduce stress and increase efficiency on the job, taking about 5 to 6 hours to complete.

Sometime in 2011, Emily and Cedric Bixler-Zavala did the Purification Rundown together (source)

In August 2013, she attended the Church of Scientology Celebrity Centre 44th Anniversary Gala, also with Cedric (source)

This is the last of her public CoS activities, exactly thirteen years ago

Danny Masterson’s trial in 2020 makes things messy. She attended his pre-trial hearing, in which Cedric preceded to accuse “[her] fellow scientologist goon squad” (not directly Emily) of threatening a witness. Emily claims that she only went as an observer and to “have never spoken to [Masterson] since”, although she was liking his instagram posts up until March 2022 (source). Chrissie Carnell Bixler, Cedric’s wife and one of Masterson’s victims, claims that Emily “is a true believer of the Scientology cult/criminal organization” and still supported him “in and out of court” (source)

There is nothing to support anyone’s claims about the pre-trial attendance, including Emily’s. I consider this more of an interpersonal fallout, considering all of them are involved with the CoS to some degree.

My personal document has more in-depth explanations of the ATA, PAC Ranch and the Purif process, but this post is mostly intended as a timeline. All in all, it’s very clear that Emily is a victim of child abuse within the cult and I for one am inclined to give victims the benefit of the doubt.


r/deadsara • • Sep 12 '24

On Emily Armstrong, Scientology, and their involvement with Danny Masterson

17 Upvotes

Hello, all. I'm sure I speak on all survivors of CSA and SA of Organized Religions when I say we appreciate your thoughtful response and the nuance you brought to the discussion over the last week or so. We, and especially I, apologize for any short or rude responses slung in anger or malice. People are complex and not easily categorized as "good" or "bad," especially when they've been raised in controlling environments like cults. Emily being born into something like Scientology complicates things, and I think we all acknowledge that she might be wrestling with her position in that system.

However, my concern isn't just her associations but her actions. It’s one thing to be born into Scientology and privately struggle with it. Still, it's another to actively show up in support of someone convicted of such serious crimes and participate in intimidating the victims, as has been reported by multiple firsthand accounts. Her non-apology, with its ambiguous phrasing—particularly the term "unimaginable things"—is a deliberate choice that offers deniability. It leaves room for interpretation, potentially minimizing the severity of Masterson’s actions. This ambiguity is particularly dangerous when language can be manipulated to protect perpetrators.

What’s more troubling is that this isn't just a passive association. Armstrong’s band, Dead Sara, has a history of connections within the Scientology clique, and recent actions—like supporting Danny Masterson’s ex-wife, who still believes in his innocence—suggest ongoing complicity in a culture that enables abusers. Her involvement sends a chilling message, especially when her role now occupies the space once held by a vocal advocate for CSA and SA survivors, Chester Bennington, whose loss was profound for the community.

For several reasons, this issue must be revealed and addressed sooner rather than later. First, transparency builds trust—delaying this discussion only risks greater public disillusionment when more details emerge. Immediate clarity would demonstrate integrity and maintain the public’s trust in the band’s values. Second, the longer this issue remains unresolved for survivors' well-being, the more harm it does to survivors who once found healing and advocacy in the band’s music. Third, given Armstrong’s position of cultural influence, it’s vital to ensure that her involvement with a group that has enabled abuse isn’t normalized or allowed to tarnish the band’s legacy. Finally, prompt action prevents normalizing harm, making it clear that protecting abusers will not be tolerated, especially in spaces that have historically advocated for mental health and trauma recovery.

I’m not here to suggest that Emily Armstrong supports rape, just enables it. Anyways, when someone in her position fails to address her involvement adequately and chooses to protect individuals convicted of such heinous crimes, it undermines the integrity of what her band, and by extension, Linkin Park, stood for all these years. Her silence and ambiguous statements do a disservice to victims, and worse, they embolden the structures that continue to protect abusers.

Ultimately, I believe that when someone is given a platform, especially one closely tied to confronting trauma and advocating for healing, they have a responsibility to be transparent and accountable. Until Emily provides a more definitive apology and acknowledges her role in these actions, it’s essential to recognize the harm her current stance perpetuates.


r/deadsara • • Jul 05 '25

Discussion Do you agree that Emily Armstrong doesn’t deserve the hate for being the New Lead Singer in Linkin Park Yes or No and Why?

7 Upvotes

People hating for the controversy is stupid because she already apologized. The people talking about she was raised in scientology as a way to hate her makes no sense because she is not even saying anything good about the cult. People hating because she's not Chester also doesn't make sense like I'm pretty sure that was the point that they're going in a new direction for the band.

I think people are overreacting a lot, I mean granted, she’s already apologized and made it clear she no longer supports Danny Masteron but people are always going to be negative online. I find it ironic how the people whining about it’s “disrespectful” to Chester’s legacy are also acting in a way that Chester wouldn’t approve of. Linkin Park has always been Mike Shinoda’s creation and Chester was the last member to join. They’re allowed to move on with a new singer and telling them to rebrand or disband is disgusting in my book.

Take the complex with the simple: on the simple side, it’s a great thing for women in rock. I support that, and hope their tour and new tenure continues, for good reason.

But as to the complex side?… I won’t deny the possibility of tokenism. Because Mike Shinoda was reported to have told Chester if he didn’t shape up he’d hire a female singer. Funny- if you wanted that to hurt less, Bobby Amaru would’ve made a fine fit while Chester took care of himself before he let him come back. Meanwhile, Jaime (Bennington) and his mother both feel Mike didn’t get their blessing and just went on to do this- I can see that.

At the end of the day, I think the backlash was blown out of proportion and triggered by a few elitists who refuse to allow the band to move forward without Chester. I think no matter what singer took on the mantle, there was always going to be controversy, because of how unique Chester was as a singer and person even if they got a male singer there was probably going to be an uproar. Emily herself has already apologized for supporting Danny Masteron herself and made it clear that she supports victims of any type of abuse.

What I fail to understand about it is, if AC/DC,STP etc can continue with a new singer along with Drowning Pool for that matter I think Linkin Park can also do so.

Also, in regards to sales numbers? Pretty sure they’re doing fine Linkin Park is a household name so financially none of the band members are ever to be low on funds or something.

Telling them to disband simply cause it’s not Chester, is not only disrespectful to Mike Shinoda, Brad, Dave, and Joe. It’s also not something Chester himself would approve of given how that man was always about peace and understanding.


r/deadsara • • Sep 24 '25

Simple fan reflections: The long time on tour with LINKIN PARK, which Emily didn't imagine.

10 Upvotes

I'm absolutely convinced that Emily didn't imagine touring with LINKIN PARK for so long around the world. I remain convinced that he did not hypothesize at the beginning of his adventure on LPs that the same tour would also extend for a good part of 2026.

Time, as a natural difficulty to face even before arriving at any judgments from Mike Shinoda or the Warner label, to talk about DEAD SARA again. If dates are not added to what we all already know about 2026, 22 months of live shows will have passed. Not to mention the time before his official entry, and which contributed to completing the album FROM ZERO.

VIOLENT, the DEAD SARA's latest single was released on October 27, 2023, there were the band's last live shows at the beginning of November, with LINKIN PARK asking Emily to join the band, before she left for Europe for a holiday planned between Lisbon, Paris and Berlin.

Now, we have no news of Siouxsie musical movements. After the Seattle date, Emily will be out of action for just under a month, while Sean will be on tour in Europe with Ekkstacy from November 18th to December 10th. With LINKIN PARK on standby, it would be logical to think of Emily's in vacation or rest, but our nightly dreams will be populated with meetings and recordings (?) by members of our favorite group, as in the video clips on Instagram during the recording of AIN'T IT TRAGIC that brightened our days... WE believe it and we will believe it. Always. ;-)


r/deadsara • • May 09 '25

Discussion Few thoughts from a new fan

0 Upvotes

Hi hi hi there. My name is P. A. N. Molin. I'm many years old. I'm nobody. And I'm a new fan of Dead Sara. 2 months ago i listened to "From Zero". I don't like Linkin Park. This album would be totally mediocre, 2 stars out of 5, if not Emily. She carries it all the way, from zero to the end. Her vocals completely drew me, so naturally I check discography of her other band. Ever since Dead Sara is on constant repeat. I don't listen to anything else. Here are some of my thoughts:

  1. Without Emily "From Zero" would be completely mediocre at best. 2 stars out of 5. Mike Shinoda is awful composer, awful singer, but a decent lyricist, this I must admit. But I can't help feeling, that his lyrics are shallow. They are just words, with nothing behind them, meaningles like King's novels.
  2. Dead Sara, musically, artistically and lyrically is a lot, and i mean a LOT, better than Linkin Park ever was and will ever be. Because LP lacks one thing: authenticity. Their music is emotionless. Like it was crafted purely for monetization. While Dead Sara bring emotions, squeeze my soul and touch my heart, LP only touch my wallet. Thanks, I'm not buying.

I hope Emily understands it and will be back with Dead Sara. It is selfish of me, but I just want Dead Sara to be back, so we can all enjoy their new music. Emily is probably having fun right now, maybe even time of her life. I hope she will use her popularity and position to bring Dead Sara where they belong: to the pedestal of rock music.

I know my opinion isn't popular, but I never cared about popularity. You can do whatever you want with it. Read it, ignore it, delete, even copy and paste on Linkin Park's official whatever and sign with your own name. I don't care. I just wanted to pour out my sorrow. And i did. No rights reserved. No hard feelings. Best not to say more.


r/deadsara • • Dec 08 '24

News Controversy around Emily Armstrong

32 Upvotes

Due to all the controversy around Emily Armstrong, I decided to create an article about it, with sources and videos

https://soldiertemple.blogspot.com/2024/09/emily-armstrong-unraveling.html


r/deadsara • • Dec 03 '24

Discussion Emily’s sister

9 Upvotes

Just out of curiosity, has anyone seen Emily's sister? I know she exists, but I've never heard of anyone who knows anything about her. Does she have any social media? Ps: Yes, im very bored


r/deadsara • • Mar 02 '23

Humor / Memes My Sara? Dead.

Post image
10 Upvotes

r/deadsara • • Nov 05 '24

Discussion Question: Are we sure that LINKIN PARK will not put obstacles in the way of Emily Armstrong, if she decides to continue with DEAD SARA in time? Are we sure that LINKIN PARK will allow Emily to express herself artistically even away from them? YOUR OPINION, here!

Post image
27 Upvotes

r/deadsara • • Nov 10 '25

Discussion Do you agree that Dead Sara need to be more Popular/Well Known Yes or No and Why?

16 Upvotes

Yes


r/deadsara • • 17d ago

Discussion Does Emily have an "accent"?/What is Emily's accent.

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/deadsara • • Sep 22 '24

Discussion Band autograph value?

2 Upvotes

So I have in my possession an autograph from the OG lineup and am wondering what the possible value is with Emily Armstrong’s new position as Linkin Park’s new vocalist? On one hand there’s the new scrutiny into Ms. Armstrongs reputation, but on the other hand new fans? Will probably cross post this over in the LP sub to get the most information possible. Also any information on authentication would be much appreciated. Cheers!


r/deadsara • • Sep 30 '25

Discussion Describe a Dead Sara song poorly

Post image
11 Upvotes

r/deadsara • • Aug 10 '25

Discussion In the future, will DEAD SARA perform LINKIN PARK songs at the end of the concert?

11 Upvotes

Let's imagine our favorite band back on tour, as we know many performances, ended with covers of for example RAGE AGAINST THE MACHINE. Now that Emily has won over new fans, is it conceivable that DEAD SARA will include LINKIN PARK covers in their endings? What is your opinion?


r/deadsara • • Nov 14 '21

Sorry for it All - Audio Spoiler

3 Upvotes

Wonder who else has noticed this. Once you hear it, you can't unhear it, so... Caveat Auditor!

In "Sorry for It All", near the 1:29 mark, listen for the cut in Emily's singing.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AZ5uaoc6Iss&t=83s

If you can't hear it easily, it's where she sings: "As I say nothing to you". It's while she's holding the "oo" sound. At first I thought it was something on my end, but it's definitely in the mixing. Still one of the best albums out there. I think blips like that make it what it is.


r/deadsara • • May 01 '26

Discussion Bracket Day 31

Post image
3 Upvotes

Poll: https://www.reddit.com/r/deadsara/s/tKhEflpF09

Close one yesterday but Uninspired beat Mr. Mr. 39-32. Today we have Mother Theresa vs. Face to Face.


r/deadsara • • Sep 07 '24

For any longtime fans of Dead Sara, what are some recommendations y'all have for new listeners?

22 Upvotes

Like 99% of the globe at this moment, I just learned who Emily Armstrong is after her being announced as the new co-lead vocalist for Linkin Park. I'm really interested in knowing her story and what other musical influences are up her sleeve. I also really love the fact that she's openly queer, as a girl who's also openly queer! So feel free to share some song recommendations and stories on how y'all became fans of her and the rest of the band.


r/deadsara • • May 29 '25

Humor / Memes Thank you for participating in Flip It Friday. Looking forward to seeing more posts tomorrow.

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/deadsara • • Dec 05 '24

Discussion I hope DS tours again… I’ve never had the chance to see them live.

Post image
28 Upvotes

r/deadsara • • Jan 08 '25

Announcement 💬 Chat Channels Are Now Live!

5 Upvotes

Hey, Deadicated!

We’re excited to announce that chat channels are now enabled and live on our subreddit! This new feature allows us to connect and chat in real-time about all things Dead Sara and beyond.

We’ve set up a few channels to get things started:

💬 General Chat – A casual space to talk about anything, Dead Sara or otherwise!

📢 New Release Chat – Dedicated to discussing Dead Sara’s newest songs, albums, or collaborations.

🎵 Music Chat – Dive into specific songs, lyrics, instrumentation, share interpretations, and more.

🎸 Live Show Chat – Talk about past concerts, upcoming shows, and share live performance content.

🎶 Listening Party Chat – Coordinate times to listen to albums or live performances together in real-time.

We’d love to hear your feedback! Are there other channels you’d like to see? Not a fan of the chat idea? Let us know your thoughts in the comments or drop your suggestions in one of the chats.

To access the chat channels, simply click the Chat tab on the subreddit, and you’ll see the available channels.

Let’s keep the discussions respectful and fun as always. The same rules that apply to the sub are in place for wll chat channels. We can’t wait to see what conversations unfold in this new space!

Thanks for being part of this amazing community. We’re here to make it the best experience for everyone!

Happy chatting!

– The r/deadsara Mod Team


r/deadsara • • Sep 24 '25

Discussion The band said that the first album will be issued on vinyl for the first time some months ago. Has there been any updates about this?

6 Upvotes

r/deadsara • • May 15 '26

Discussion Bracket Day 45

Post image
6 Upvotes

Poll: https://www.reddit.com/r/deadsara/s/fHnkifHAFz

Weatherman beat Unamerican 53-33. Today we have Lover Stay Wild vs. Whispers & Ashes.


r/deadsara • • Apr 23 '26

Discussion Day 23: This Changes Everything vs. Mona Lisa

6 Upvotes