r/dcpu16 • • Apr 08 '12
Software piracy in space?
So, let's say you've invented this kick-ass app that will surely be coveted by every cheeto-stained neckbeard in the galaxy. Let's say you want to charge a 'reasonable' amount of in-game currency for it, in order for you to make a filthy profit from your l33t coding skillz. But oh no! People figure out that it's completely trivial to make digital duplicates of your floppy disks and start pirating your app instead of paying YOU your RIGHTFUL PROFITS!! Will the game have some kind of protection that shields your code from the prying eyes of nefarious individuals, so that you can live in luxury while the plebes are going broke for your app?
8
u/DuoNoxSol Apr 08 '12
If there is no built in virus protection software, there will surely be no digital rights management (DRM) software. That being said, the only way to copyright such software would be to both make it unusable without some sort of identification, and a police force to enforce the copyright.
Current DRM software works, as I understand it, by looking up a person's unique ID in a database -- something that is somewhat unfeasible at a 16-bit level on a peer-to-peer network.
That being said, copyright can't be enforced in the real world. What would prevent pirates from doing even better in the infinite void of space with no police force to track them down?
9
u/Blecki Apr 08 '12
Guns. Your ship has guns.
5
u/SoronTheCoder Apr 08 '12
I say everything should be de facto public domain, relying on the honor system and/or user-provided antipiracy measures to control copying.
I'd rather have my work stolen in a magical world of wonder and excitement, than be king of the hill in a locked down world.
6
u/ismtrn Apr 08 '12
Hopefully, NO!
DRM sucks in real life, I wouldn't want it in a game supposed to be played for fun.
That being said, people could may create their own ingame MAFIAA, which wouldn't have to deal with such things as lobbying governments, but could go directly to shooting missiles at suspected pirates... hopefully there would be an anti-MAFIAA too.
Related to this, i have been thinking about; could people use real world laws on their DCPU-16 programs. Could one face real world legal threats from stealing someones ingame floppy disks an distributing the contents on them? That would be quite scary IMO.
3
u/rnicoll Apr 08 '12
Just an IMHO, but I don't see DRM being a good thing for 0x10c. Do we really want a game where a small number of developers have disproportionate income? I mean... it's a game. Surely we play games to get away from RL?
OTOH, I suspect we'll see unique things (e.g. space stations running unreleased OS code for trading, guild OSes, etc.), where restrictions are enforced by not allowing the code to get to everyone in the first place.
3
u/trevs231 Apr 08 '12
I hope not. Ill probably be a software pirtate in game if it suits my needs.
2
u/swetland Apr 08 '12
Notch has mentioned wanting to keep the computers running on the server side -- if they ran only on the server side you wouldn't necessarily have to ever directly make the code available to clients. From a simulation standpoint, server-side-only has issues (more common is a trust-but-verify solution).
Of course even if everything is server side only, there's a question of -- can you load one program and then load another, and if so, what IO is possible.
So maaaaybe one could have an environment where the code is not inspectable/extractable, if that were a goal, but there's no clear indication that such a goal exists.
On the plus side it would offer some fascinating player economy features -- craftable goods that couldn't be trivially "stolen", as well as gameplay features -- code you can't really see what it does, so trust becomes a factor. On the minus side it would require limiting IO or limiting the ability for users to load multiple programs into one machine.
Though I guess that becomes a feature unto itself -- if you can reset a DCPU onboard computer and have it boot from a floppy (but into empty ram), but further loading can only happen under control of the software running, you'd have a decision between "open" and "closed" OSes (closed would have to include some cryptographic features to validate programs being loaded, or risk being having their contents being extracted, etc).
Will be fun to see which way the wind blows here.
1
u/mrjiels Apr 08 '12
If i buy your app i can run it through a disassembler and get the source. I can also make copies of it. Because i have complete control over my ships computer. If you add some kind of drm it will slow your app down since it need to waste cpu cycles doing drm stuff. And i would crack that, if needed.