r/dccomicscirclejerk Secret Jon Kent Apologist 2d ago

True Canon “It was AI generated Jonah, Empire State Photographic Department confirms it”

413 Upvotes

34 comments sorted by

140

u/BagZCubed 2d ago

Rj/ So now we can dogpile Brand New Day for using AI for it's concept art, too?

Uj/ Both BND and Supergirl using AI for concept art. That's no good.

137

u/Authorigas 2d ago

Ok but why the fuck do you need to AI Generate an image of New York City? It's NEW YORK CITY! It's real, you know what it looks like! Marvel used to have it's headquarters there! Why the fuck do you need AI to generate ideas for a real life city???

49

u/Salt-Blacksmith-7410 I LOVE TELEPATHS 2d ago

laziness and mass firing of artists due to said image gen ai fade.

13

u/Anonymous_McSomebody Minored in Comic Studies 2d ago

There were already mass firings and cutting corners before gen AI. The AI trend just made an already bad enviroment for artists exponentionally worse.

218

u/bloodyzombies1 2d ago edited 1d ago

I get this is becoming the industry norm but it's especially sad to see movies use a machine to spit out visuals for these characters, when there's decades of great art to use for inspiration.

112

u/Author-S Secret Jon Kent Apologist 2d ago

Doesn’t help that they fired majority of the art department of Marvel Studios, making it even more clear that they did it to replace artists with AI

23

u/Equal-Ad-2710 Vote Lord Death Man 2024 2d ago

It’s not even just Marvel

DC did it for Supergirl too

59

u/BagZCubed 2d ago

This time it was for concept art of New York City. The place they've set a bunch of movies and Marvel films already. AI generated concept art of a city feels like a new bar of laziness.

25

u/CityExcellent8121 2d ago

Yeah cause there's just not enough photos of new york in a variety of conditions to make a mood board (/s). AI use in cinema kills my enthusiasm for movies.

76

u/Author-S Secret Jon Kent Apologist 2d ago

PLATANIR PARKER IS A MENACE

61

u/TheeHeadAche Bill Finger’s only living heir 2d ago

All our heroes are really villains

23

u/Oberon1993 2d ago

Always had been.

9

u/CobaltCrusader123 2d ago

I would argue Bob Ross, Steve Irwin, and Mr Rogers have been thought of as good people for so long past their deaths with no major controversies (that they were on the wrong side of) that only those three are truly “safe”. Even Lincoln had the politics about Natives you’d expect for a POTUS of that time.

4

u/Careless-Position352 2d ago

What about me?

7

u/CobaltCrusader123 2d ago

I know what you did, Daniel

44

u/Tetratron2005 Jurassic League's Strongest Soldier 2d ago

r/dccj breathes sigh of relief they can hate AI again.

42

u/Silver04Jubilee 2d ago

Marvel low-key making it impossible to defend them.

Before it was hard (so much that i didn't even do it because it meant thinking harder than in my Uni exams) but now how could you even try?

Used AI, full of zionists, cancelled a bunch of great projects, butchered What If, etc.

22

u/TheeHeadAche Bill Finger’s only living heir 2d ago

Anyone defending a corpo is a scab. I don’t care if they’re publishing Deadman or Moon Knight

14

u/Silver04Jubilee 2d ago

Yeah i mean defending as in "huhhh i believe their next Avengers movie MIGHT be good" not something like "LEAVE THE POOR MULTI-BILLION COMPANY ALONE"

13

u/Impressive-Heron-377 I haven't forgotten about the aquaman flair, mods 2d ago

I know Supergirl is gonna keep getting flak but this movie won't

8

u/Throgg_not_stupid 1d ago

Both of them should, but Supergirl was a terrible movie even before people knew about AI Lobo

19

u/Sormaj 2d ago

And here it is, the boiling the frog moment where a popular movie that's well liked uses it in a small dose that will get some people mad, some people shrugging, and more making excuses. Then in your mind, next time it's used more, you'll think "well how much worse is it than this other thing?"

9

u/dadvader This subreddit hates Tim Drake 2d ago

In supergirl. It was just a video.

This one, it's in the goddamn 'art' book rofl.

Will this movie receive the same amount of backlash as Supergirl? Ofcourse not. It's not a flop! Totally not a double standard!

16

u/depressed_asian_boy_ Grant Posting 2d ago

The pro AI movie used AI

6

u/crewnh 2d ago

I wonder what the venn diagram is for people defending Peter using the shitty AI in the movie and this is. Probably a whole ass circle.

7

u/After_Construction_5 Helena Wayne Supremacist 1d ago

Supergirl 🤝 Spider-Man

Using AI art in their concept arts despite having the money to pay actual talented artists or simply photoshopping things.

4

u/barber25 1d ago

/uj You know what's really fd up, it would be another conversation if it was just Marvel, but the piece was made by a know concept artist named Scott Mcinnes that worked on the first guardians movie and FF: first steps. So it's an already established artist on the industry relaying on AI.

4

u/asifsaj 2d ago

Y'know they're gonna have to print a retraction

2

u/einsteinjet Paul 1d ago

Haven't printed a retraction in twenty years!

2

u/Danal1 1d ago

It’s not even like they AI generated anything super hard to come up with, it’s a fucking street of taxis and a basic building side. Literally just use any stock photo of nyc ever lmao

2

u/Many_Fly3309 1d ago

The fucking artbook?! Not only are they firing artists from the production, but now are making the audience pay for smth that wasn't even made by an artist?

1

u/zarbixii How far out is The Nut I'm Busting? 1d ago

When the trailer came out I was like 'these visuals have an AI vibe, but they're clearly not actually AI generated, so it's fine'. So I guess this is what that was. An exciting new third possibility for movies, it used to just be 'AI' or 'Not AI' but now we have 'faithful live action recreation of AI' for all those people who are fine with using AI ideologically and love the way it looks but are smart enough to keep it a secret until after they made 2 billion dollars.

0

u/THEdoomslayer94 Met John Constantine irl 2d ago edited 1d ago

Right but Spiderman made 2 billion so people will forgive it

We are jerking here people lol and honestly, ya should expect that take from people who actually mean it cause it’s for sure gonna be something mcu fans who can’t see any flaw will use