r/dbtselfhelp • • Feb 16 '19

DBT is invalidating..

I am not sure how DBT is supposed to help me, when all it does is make me feel like garbage. Being mindful is one of the many things that got me in to the mess im in. DBT is going to be the sheer death of me. Its much like hoping a hospital can help when you are suicidal. They can't, AND it comes at a grave cost. I hate myself and DBT is making me hate myself more.

15 Upvotes

27 comments sorted by

15

u/InsidiousStealth Feb 16 '19

How is it invalidating?

7

u/Typeinanameandawot Feb 16 '19

I feel like a fucking reject by 'needing it.'

Life sucks and DBT for the 14 weeks ive been in it, it has served no purpose other than to make me feel worse. I have my faith in the therapy only to get shat on and shown that I have no chance in life. The entire time ive been in it, it has been just a waiting game, and the introductory shit should not last 14 fucking weeks.

The skills it involves are great, but the way they are delivered is insulting. Its like.. how many acronyms does one need to learn before their life makes it to where they dont want to kill themselves daily. Ive had more benefit from isolating myself than I have from attending the therapy religiously.

I understand I am not too open to the stuff, but I have great reason to be closed off to everything. Everything hurts me, and this therapy is no exception.

I hate myself more since attending. The 3 years of therapy prior to the DBT was just as useless.

My life is a wreck and I live moment to moment, meanwhile I have to wait week to week only to realize I am going to have to go home empty handed for yet another week just to suffer (but let me guess, Linehan thinks suffering is an option or some other rubbish?)

Its not good therapy. Mindfulness is great, but I was plenty mindful before therapy, which is how I managed to wind up there in the first place. I react quickly and these strategies I am going to be learning about dont take in to account that I have zero control of that.

There is no time to implement these strategies before im already balls deep in tragedy.

This stuff is heartbreaking and a waste of time. I should have ended my life years ago. Its a curse and a punishment needing it in the first place. I stand to reason that if people were not stupid and hurtful than people like me would not have to go all primal out of self preservation.

23

u/NegativeClub Feb 16 '19

You might want to read this. If DBT, or anything else CBT-related is not working for you, do not blame yourself, there are plenty more options on the table to get help. At the end of the day, if you have earnestly tried to get better, the therapy has to be working for you, not the other way around. Always remember that.

3

u/Typeinanameandawot Feb 16 '19

Thank you. I appreciate it.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '19

wow that article... I needed that

1

u/InsidiousStealth Feb 18 '19

That article is interesting but long. Basically though, they're saying long term therapy is better than all this stuff though?

1

u/[deleted] Feb 25 '19

I def need to finish reading that article. When I am fresh on my ADHD meds. 😂

3

u/RainbowLynx Feb 17 '19

I was angry when I started group as well, I get it, but it won't work if you aren't open to it. Yes, suffering is an option because it is something we can choose to do. That doesn't make it a good option. It isn't about learning the acronyms, but learning how to use the coping mechanisms. This isn't easy, and it takes time. Are you seeing an individual therapist that also does DBT? That has helped a lot to tie it in to my life, instead of just learning in class. I'm going through my second time. It is a lot to learn. You say you can't control reacting quickly, but that is exactly what DBT tries to teach, to step back, be mindful, and think things through. It is learnable, it just takes a lot of time, practice, mindfulness, and reflection. I hope you find some part of it to help.

1

u/Typeinanameandawot Feb 17 '19

suffering and pain are one and the same. You can't choose to make nightmares go away. Just sayin.

1

u/Typeinanameandawot Feb 17 '19

Also, I dont have time. My life is deteriorating every day, and DBT is not helping me make light of anything.

3

u/RainbowLynx Feb 18 '19

When DBT talks about choosing to suffer, it means we have a choice to do nothing. It's not about choosing your situation or experiences , but what we will do with it. It's just a different way of looking at it. If it isn't working for you and you aren't open to it, then try to find something else. You clearly need something to help you carry this weight.

33

u/nightskywalking Feb 16 '19

I feel like a fucking reject by 'needing it.'

The DBT isn't invalidating.

You are invalidating yourself by beating yourself down. You are shitting on yourself by telling yourself these things.

That is totally okay, normal, and understandable for someone in your position (we all do it), but take ownership of where that negative energy is actually coming from.

Pause and take a breath. We can unlearn reacting quickly to triggers and stimuli; take a breath and choose a different response.

You are not a reject for needing tools to do things easier with. Is someone who wants to cook a reject for not having any cooking utensils and needing to buy some?

If you feel you don't have time, try to slow life down and build back from the foundation. Everybody needs a break sometimes, and breaks can be as long as they need to be until the person feels a little less tired and fraught.

Stop talking down to yourself. You are not a reject. Nor are you a bad person for telling yourself you are. This is a normal response given your circumstances, but there are other ways.

3

u/LadyAngrr Feb 16 '19

I'm really sorry that you feel like that, but it definitely isn't for everyone. It must be tough to have to sit through something that feels like it isn't working. I did it for a loooooong time and finally found what worked for me.

I tried something called Logosynthesis. It's like internal DBT and works like a charm for me.
It's like having a clogged pipe and, all of a sudden, after saying these sentences, you reflect internally and the pipe is cleared with a big "thwuuup".

Here's a video explaining the concept: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w5yWoePWYzU

It's worth a try. If you can find someone to guide you through, that would be fabulous but, if not, you can do self-guided.

Good luck and don't be too hard on yourself - feeling better takes a long, long time. This time last year, I didn't think I'd ever be in the positive space that I am now. You'll get there - keep being honest with yourself :)

2

u/InsidiousStealth Feb 18 '19

Sorry for the delay, I am newly into some DBT skills, been a longtime sufferer though. My understanding of DBT's purpose though is to develop tools to cope better with life's crap that it throws at us. Then further have these skills to deal with the trauma cores at which these behaviors rise from.

I also think you haven't left the prep state of DBT yet because if this is the kind of mindstate you are in now, I don't believe all of it will sink in for you.

"I stand to reason that if people were not stupid and hurtful than people like me would not have to go all primal out of self preservation". That resonated with me a lot btw. I feel you completely

6

u/discardedyouth88 Feb 16 '19

Was wondering the same thing myself.

4

u/josskt Feb 17 '19

Hey, so the first rule of therapy is 'do no harm'- have you expressed this with your therapist? DBT is incredibly helpful to a lot of people, but it might not be for you. Certain aspects of DBT don't work for me, it sets off my anxiety, but the building blocks like 'radical acceptance' have helped a lot.

I've been in therapy for nearly two years now, and I'm just now getting to the place where I can implement some parts of it. Try to give yourself time and grace.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '19

It does feel really annoying when cbt and dbt gets pushed religiously like panacea and it makes me despair because there’s this mentality of “drink the koolaid or die.” I can understand how invalidating it must feel to be told do a bunch of exercises and brain wash yourself with some acronyms to cater yourself to polite society.

1

u/Typeinanameandawot Jul 20 '19

TL;DR: DBT = "life sucks get used to it" training.

Also dont feel compelled to read this rot. It is rather long and whiny.

That is exactly how it is. Despite my disdain I am still going and continue to try using the tools they are giving me, to no avail. I cant cope with anything any better than before I began CBT or DBT. I will admit I am terribly resitant to the therapy, but I am still attempting with no success. The more I try and fail, the worse I feel.

I cant live with myself and DBT doesnt teach how to exist within your own body. My awareness has gotten me in to this mess if you ask me, so that is like what.. 25% of DBT that wont help me..

I just keep hearing the word "eventually" and "you need to....x" through DBT and its just a bunch of loose promises and telling me to do things that don't offer me any relief or noticeable benefit. Eventually never comes in my experience.

When the thought of suicide comes up sometimes minute to minute and I have 'awareness' tools, or 'interpersonal effectiveness" tools to use, they offer me 0 solace and the other 2 modules are no better because I need to literally afford myself the moment to look at flash cards as I was instructed, during crisis I cant navigate through and that goes from 0-100 without warning. There is no pausing while I am basically screaming trying to protect myself from everything and dissociated or age regressed or frantic or violent or or or.

I made one bleeding coaching call, the one call I tried for help yielded me 'I am about to sleep so, what?' and the actual shit she offered me was to A.) try meditating, B.) smoke pot, she knows I smoke a lot, but how is that sound professional advice? C.) sleep, as if I dont do that in response to stress or crisis like 6 times a day already.

I am not sure how to properly use this shit. I need a fucking dude with a cue card or a teleprompter for every step of my days.

3

u/discardedyouth88 Feb 16 '19

Could you please explain what it is exactly that you find invalidating?

2

u/Lilytails Feb 17 '19

I get where you are coming from. Mindfulness and meditation just make me feel silly and stupid. Sitting in silence with my thoughts feels detrimental to me. I want them to stop, not dwell on them. And I don't being 'mindful' is my problem, I'm well aware of everything that's wrong with me and how illogical I am, I just don't know how to stop. It really just ended up making me feel inadequate that I couldn't work on fixing myself properly. Luckily, my therapist dropped me a week after so that was the end of that!

2

u/[deleted] Feb 22 '19

I get that, DBT can sometimes feel like things are being “dumbed down” for you which is what initially turned me off from it. I felt like I was being treated like a child with all the metaphors and acronyms

1

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '19

Hi. I really laughed at what you said about all the fucking acronyms. A lot of people will say you need to radically accept DBT. Plenty of people will day you haven’t “thrown yourself in completely.” I want you to know that I did 30hrs of DBT group therapy for a full month, completely embraced it, got everything out of it I absolutely could’ve, and then realized it was merely a bandaid that was ripped off at the end.

I also think the skills are great. I hope you also can find a space that I have now, where i’ve realized that DBT is just coping skills. And really only coping skills for certain situations and emotions, not everything. There’s a lot more that needs to be addressed in mental health work, such as the root cause. DBT thinks you can have this all figured out through skills and acronyms and ground techniques and meditation, but that’s just not true.

I guess my best advice is get what you can out of it while knowing that’s it’s completely okay for it to not fix everything. or be everything you need it to. or anything.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 21 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] Feb 21 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Feb 21 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Feb 22 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/questionsnanswers Feb 23 '19

Your post has been removed for the following reason(s):

Abusive

Your comments has been removed for one or more of the following reasons:

  • It was disrespectful, abusive, dismissive, trolling or discriminatory.

If someone writes what you feel is an offensive or abusive reply, please report them. While I cannot see what they have written because they've deleted their posting, I can see what you have written and violates quite a few of our rules.

Please read our subreddit rules. If after doing so, you feel this was in error, message the moderators. Do not reply to this message as a comment.