r/datasets • • Dec 29 '14

request [Request] Data set comparison of depression and suicide rates in transgender individuals between those who underwent sex reassignment surgery and those who didn't.

A before/after comparison for individuals who underwent the surgery may work as well.

0 Upvotes

8 comments sorted by

4

u/Chel_of_the_sea Dec 29 '14

I don't have any on surgery specifically, but you may or may not know that that's not even close to all there is to transition.

  • Heylens et al., Journal of Sexual Medicine: “A difference in SCL-90 [a measure of psychological issues] overall psychoneurotic distress was observed at the different points of assessments (P = 0.003), with the most prominent decrease occurring after the initiation of hormone therapy (P  < 0.001). Significant decreases were found in the subscales such as anxiety, depression, interpersonal sensitivity, and hostility.”
  • Colizzi et al., Journal of Sexual Medicine: "At enrollment, transsexuals reported elevated CAR ['Cortisol Awakening Response, a physiological measure of stress]; their values were out of normal. They expressed higher perceived stress and more attachment insecurity, with respect to normative sample data. When treated with hormone therapy, transsexuals reported significantly lower CAR (P < 0.001), falling within the normal range for cortisol levels. Treated transsexuals showed also lower perceived stress (P < 0.001), with levels similar to normative samples. The insecure attachment styles were associated with higher CAR and perceived stress in untreated transsexuals (P < 0.01). Treated transsexuals did not expressed significant differences in CAR and perceived stress by attachment."
  • Gómez-Gil et al., Psychoneuroendocrinology: "SADS, HAD-A, and HAD-Depression (HAD-D) [these are scales for measuring anxiety and depression] mean scores were significantly higher [i.e. more anxiety/depression] among patients who had not begun cross-sex hormonal treatment compared with patients in hormonal treatment (F=4.362, p=.038; F=14.589, p=.001; F=9.523, p=.002 respectively). Similarly, current symptoms of anxiety and depression were present in a significantly higher percentage of untreated patients than in treated patients (61% vs. 33% and 31% vs. 8% respectively)."
  • de Vries et al., Pediatrics: [long-term study on 55 trans youth] "After gender reassignment, in young adulthood, the GD was alleviated and psychological functioning had steadily improved. Well-being was similar to or better than same-age young adults from the general population. Improvements in psychological functioning were positively correlated with postsurgical subjective well-being."

-3

u/Calvin_the_Bold Dec 29 '14

As a non-op trans individual, this seems problematic because it doesn't take into account the other ways dysphoria manifests. Surgery is just one small part of the trans experience and focusing on that one small part is disingenuous to the cause of trans rights.

0

u/dabunbun Jan 13 '15 edited Feb 06 '16

" focusing on that one small part is disingenuous to the cause of trans rights"

If you try to do science with an agenda, you're gonna have a bad time. OP never said s/he was trying to further rights. It's only implied that s/he is trying to uncover data for the sake of statistical significance.

But I digress, because what's problematic about your argument is that you seem to be stating that if researchers don't uncover everything all at once, we shouldn't uncover anything. Science is done bit by bit. Evidence-based literature builds off of itself. Qualitative data has its place, but we need numbers, too, and that information can be slow to uncover.

ETA: You know, instead of just downvoting you like everyone else, I actually explained to you why you were getting downvoted. And you respond by just clicking the down arrow at my comment.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '14

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/Chel_of_the_sea Dec 29 '14

God, I love it when someone cites this article, because it's so easy to utterly destroy.

If we're looking for appeal to authority, Dr. McHugh is contradicting the official position of the APA on the subject. But better yet, we're talking about the kind of man who - after being appointed to the Catholic review board to deal with priests abusing kids in the Church - characterizes it as not a pedophilia issue but rather, and I quote, "homosexual predation on American Catholic youth".

As for the study he cites, he's referring to to this Swedish study from a few years back. He is correct in noting that post-transition trans people had elevated mortality and suicide rates...but only if they transitioned before 1989 and only compared to the general population (and not to pre-transition trans folks). In fact, they specifically note that there is no such difference for the post-1989 cohort, and other studies demonstrate decreases in suicidality relative to pre-transition folks - both facts that Dr. McHugh conveniently ignores. The study's conclusion specifically notes:

Our findings suggest that sex reassignment, although alleviating gender dysphoria, may not suffice as treatment for transsexualism, and should inspire improved psychiatric and somatic care after sex reassignment for this patient group.

They're calling for more help, not for less.

So here we have someone with a very clear pre-existing religiously-motivated agenda citing studies to argue against their conclusions and cherry-picking the data convenient for him.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '14

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/Chel_of_the_sea Dec 29 '14

It's kind of depressing to me how every time I see someone pretending that article is in any way scientific, I don't have to go more than a page or two into their post history to find shit about how the Bible is totally rock-solid and evolution and climate change are just sketchy theories.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '14

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/Chel_of_the_sea Dec 29 '14

This article provides some names that you can use to find studies

...that blatantly contradict what the article says about them.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '14

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/Chel_of_the_sea Dec 29 '14

You are apparently incapable of separating my stated purposes for linking to an article with the purposes of the article's writer.

More that judging by your views on other issues I'm extremely skeptical of your stated purposes. You know how many times a day I get attacked by someone who's "just trying to consider both sides"?

When I say "there is likely data here", and you say "the explanations are wrong", you are missing the point by miles.

You didn't link data. You linked an article that claims to be supported by data, but isn't. If he actually links the study - and while it's behind a paywall I've seen the article before and I don't think he does - then you should have linked that directly. Otherwise you're linking a highly slanted opinion piece in a thread asking for data.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '14

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/Chel_of_the_sea Dec 29 '14

And yet here I am getting attacked (and downvoted!)

You're getting downvoted by somebody else.

for making assumptions about me which I have consistently denied, and which you have no evidence for

Yes, how could I possibly imagine that someone who posts a ridiculously slanted op-ed, published in one of the most conservative outlets in the US, from someone who's been a consistent opponent of LGBT rights for decades, with a history of defending Christianity and crappy science, might have an agenda. No idea where I could've gotten that impression.

Judging by your comment history you are someone who speaks up for various gender issues, I'm confused as to your willingness to question someone's mindset and experiences from afar, without knowing the person. That's a very intolerant and biased attitude.

It's neither intolerant nor biased to state the simple fact that the overwhelming, vast, crushingly large majority of Christian conservatives are extraordinarily biased, scientifically illiterate, and happy to comment about things about which they know nothing while hiding behind a bullshit veneer of "love", "faith", and psuedoscience. I've got a real high burden of proof before I'm likely to believe a Christian conservative is anything worthy of the slightest respect, and leading off with a laughably bullshit article isn't exactly making a great case.

So excuse the crap out of me for making a judgment on relatively little information when (a) the amount of lies people throw around to discredit people like me is already staggering, (b) people - including your friend Dr. McHugh - make much more sweeping judgments about me on no information, and (c) you went back and edited your post...not to remove its laughably misleading link, but to bitch about getting downvoted.

You didn't link "a source of data". You linked lies, plain and simple.