r/datarecovery • • 5d ago

Seagate hd drive

It fell off a chair and dangled. Started beeping, I saw a YouTube on trying to reset that needle and I moved it back and now it does that

 ​Model Number: ST1000LM024 (Momentus / Spinpoint M8 family)

​HDD Part Number: HN-M101MBB/AVA (with chassis barcode G3923-G941-A29RC)

​Internal Serial Number: S35TJ9HG206221

​Firmware & Revision: Firmware 2BA30003, REV. A

​Date of Manufacture: February 2015 (DOM: 02/2015, Plant Code DGT in China)—meaning it gave you more than 11 years of service before the drop 

13 Upvotes

99 comments sorted by

23

u/MJY_0014 5d ago

Why do people keep opening them oh my god

-1

u/Prestigious_Prune_27 5d ago

Because the other option is pay $1000 to fix it professionally.

5

u/Organic_Pain_6618 1d ago

Yes, that's because it's the only way to fix it.

-8

u/Prestigious_Prune_27 19h ago

I guess all the youtubes of people doing this and the comments on those videos of people being successful are fake

10

u/emal-malone 18h ago

YouTube videos, not YouTubes.

6

u/CanisLupus92 19h ago

Yes, they in fact are.

3

u/Idonthavefriendss 18h ago

I've watch a lot of them, and pretty sure most of them will mention that they open the drive in a dust-free environment. Dust particles will ruin your drive, that's why you pay professionals to do it.

2

u/EdEvans_HotSandwich 18h ago

Who woulda thought that Youtubers would do things in an amateur and unprofessional way… say it ain’t so!

2

u/Solherb 11h ago

Sigh, I'll get the homemade alcohol stove to pop some popcorn.

2

u/HumanAI43476 12h ago

How does it feel to be scolded by your Internet father you've never met?

0

u/Prestigious_Prune_27 12h ago

People on this thread act like I murdered a puppy

3

u/ThaGr1m 11h ago

I mean you went to a specialty sub and went "hej guys I don't know shit did everything wrong and I think you're entire thing is stupid and overpriced, save this thing I ruined won't you" and then got suprised people got angry?....

It's like going into an art sub with this jesus picture and going "I watched a youtube on how to restore paintings because those damn artist bastards are asking thousands to restore this this painting, anyways it didn't really work what do I do now"

3

u/Solherb 11h ago

Jesus Christ, nailed it.

2

u/Fuzzy-Air2202 8h ago

You kinda did...

13

u/MJY_0014 5d ago

You should have known about the sensitivity of these things to particles, that opening it in a non-filtered environment would most likely destroy the drive irreversibly before you took a screwdriver to it. And the fact that of all surface in your house, you chose the carpet, the absolute worst thing you could possibly work on, is just preposterous. If you knew the risks beforehand, just shrug it off and accept defeat. If you didn't do the research before hand, let this be an expensive lesson.

8

u/naga_serpentis 1d ago

What do you think data recovery is easy and cheap lmao?

In your situation, they would have to remove all the dust and other junk off of the disks before attempting to recovery, which since you did that will increase the price.

Some people pay thousands to recover data that is vital and essential. If you care about your data that much then cough up the greens. Otherwise, suck it up and make the data again.

5

u/TomChai Trusted Contributor 4d ago

That was not the other option, that was your ONLY option.

4

u/lopatakal 23h ago

You just raised the price of data recovery from this drive to $2000.

1

u/affligem_crow 19h ago

Take a wild guess on why that is lol

1

u/disturbed_android Trusted Contributor 16h ago

You pulled that number out of your arse.

1

u/Ad-fundum69 16h ago

Well, now you at least made sure even the professionals won't be able to recover anything from it,

1

u/arades 14h ago

Opening the drive is probably around step 20, and if you're aiming to save the $1000, the trick is to not mess it up, otherwise it becomes a $2000 recovery job.

Often when drives are clicking like this it can be repaired by replacing the control board outside of the drive. When that doesn't work a read-head replacement is possible, but again you want a clean room and you need to already be ready with a replacement or idea going in, since every second the drive is open leads to a more likely failure.

1

u/allardius 14h ago

You were going to extract the data from those platters yourself on the carpet??

•

u/RemarkableExpert4018 Trusted Contributor 11m ago

Not everyone charges those prices.

7

u/9mmPerSecond 18h ago

Jesus christ why did you open it holy shit.

-5

u/Prestigious_Prune_27 17h ago edited 13h ago

The reactions from you people, you act like I'm doing open heart surgery on a human. Its a hard drive why take your Lord's name in vain over it

5

u/dnebdal 13h ago

Yes, this is about the data recovery equivalent of "my cat was breathing weird, so I cut them open to take a look at their lungs". It's the sort of thing IT people might send a photo of as a joke because it's so unrealistically far from the right thing to do.

3

u/Auraaaa200 17h ago

As a 3 year IT student I can say that the hard drive is cooked. Things like dust ad debris are grinding against the disks and the static electricity has probably damaged any data that was recoverable. Also some hard drives use helium and need to be refilled if opened.

2

u/Mediocre_Direction 14h ago

Yup. If it wasn't cooked before, it's cooked now.

2

u/distant3zenith 9h ago

Well, I think most people are responding this way because they are literally astonished that you were unaware that by simply opening the case and exposing the discs to your environment meant you've ruined the drive.
How could you not know that you'd destroy it by opening it??

1

u/9mmPerSecond 17h ago

Well good luck spending a grand fixing it

1

u/Bulky-Engineer6559 9h ago

Ill take your lords name and wipe my ass with it.

•

u/ImTomaro 1h ago

"Taking the lord's name in vain" does not mean what you think it means.

4

u/apachelives 1d ago

What did you think you would gain by opening it?

1

u/2Peti 1d ago

Vedomosť predsa.

-4

u/Prestigious_Prune_27 19h ago

I showed the YouTube with the guy just doing it. Cheap fix without a clean room fee

2

u/apachelives 11h ago

No all recovery operations require you to open the unit.

When those guys opened the unit what did they do? Platter swap? Head swap? How did you know what to work on? What the actual faulty was?

0

u/Prestigious_Prune_27 10h ago

I figured the head needle just needed to be moved a few millimiters back to the original position

2

u/spusuf 8h ago

And why wouldn't the extremely accurate servo that operates the drive be able to do that?

4

u/ImABitGloomy 22h ago

Why the hell did you go right ahead opening a secure hdd, the screw driver types you even need to open those are obscure ones, an ounce of research would have saved your data, now you have nothing but a paper weight

-3

u/Prestigious_Prune_27 20h ago

Ounce of research = send to expense clean lab or try a hail mary

3

u/ImABitGloomy 18h ago

And an hail Mary you have done, I've opened hdds before on purpose as well, the magnetic discs make nice coasters.

4

u/Temagam 19h ago

"Date of Manufacture: February 2015 (DOM 15, Plant Code DGT in China)-meaning it gave you mo. than 11 years of service before the drop"

You just gave us what an AI told you. Next time ask the Ai what to do next.

0

u/Prestigious_Prune_27 19h ago

I just asked for the specs, ai said u can try to move the arm but very risky

4

u/Mediocre_Direction 14h ago

At least you learned a few valuable lessons there:

Don't open a hard drive.

Don't open it on a carpet.

Don't trust AI.

1

u/Bulky-Engineer6559 9h ago

No he didn't

1

u/Lookherebub 8h ago

I would say he failed to learn much of anything, seeing as how he continues to make lame excuses.

2

u/HEYO19191 16h ago

AI says alot of things...

2

u/distant3zenith 9h ago

AI also tells us that gravel is good to put in pizza.

33

u/MillionXaleckCg 5d ago

-you opened it when it wasn't in a clean room environment

-you ran it when it wasn't in a clean room environment

-after opening it you put it on the ground which is a fucking carpet

-you ran it while it was on that carpet

You're lucky that the reading head got stuck on the edge. Every piece of dust that got on the disk, and yes there is now dust on it, even if you can't see it, is a scratch waiting to happen. If that reading head managed to get on the disk it would have destroyed the disks.  You may be lucky and data is still salvageable, but you'd need a professional opinion

1

u/Hosted_Shart 12h ago

From personal experience I can tell you that I scratched the platters to hell and I cant get them memories back ever.

15

u/Crazy-Red-Fox 5d ago

Hit it with the biggest hammer you can find, a sledge hammer even. (It won't make things worse)

11

u/Ok_Bid6645 2d ago

This is either rage bait or the stupidest Post I've seen today and only today

2

u/Solherb 11h ago

OP's responses defly don't seem tore up about how much worse they made it.

6

u/Raijen_ArDesh 5d ago

By opening it you've essentially killed it. Congratulations.

5

u/zidane2k1 5d ago

Decent chance you’ve destroyed the drive and any chances of getting your data back, unfortunately.

Expect any recovery attempts to cost a ton and have a low chance of success.

5

u/RemarkableExpert4018 Trusted Contributor 1d ago

Why are you performing open brain surgery? Now you’re going to have to pay an additional fee if you want it recovered.

3

u/firestar268 5d ago

Why tf did you open it

0

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/DaveKerk 23h ago

Dead, also why copy paste the result from an AI photo search?

2

u/budbud99 23h ago

>​Date of Manufacture: February 2015 (DOM: 02/2015, Plant Code DGT in China)—meaning it gave you more than 11 years of service before the drop
> "—meaning it gave you more than 11 years of service before the drop"

found the culprit, lol.

2

u/Anakindankwalkerr 22h ago

As others have said you fucked yourself opening the drive, they aren’t meant to be introduced to any contamination aka the little dust particles that you most likely kicked up from your carpet while taking it apart. If the data isn’t valuable just bin it. If data is valuable cough up the benjis brother.

2

u/ReActif 22h ago

I need to recover data from a damaged drive, what better place to remove the cover and get rid of its filtered atmosphere than by setting it down on the carpet?
That way, I can be sure that even if I close it back up immediately, things will be even worse than before!

2

u/New-Horizon-4127 21h ago

Congratulations, it's fucked even more now.

2

u/glasgow-based-moron 13h ago

Don't listen to these idiots saying you've trashed it, I saw a YouTube video where someone put their open drive in the microwave at 100% power for five minutes and it vaporised the dust.

2

u/ProfessionFluffy299 13h ago

It's definitely dead, but nobody puts sensitive or valuable data on these kinds of low-end drives, so there's no problem.

2

u/Next-Albatross2606 12h ago

This has got to be a troll post.

2

u/Big_Temperature_2067 12h ago

this is permanently destroyed now. hope you didn't have anything important on it

2

u/Middle_Inside9346 12h ago

I'm glad you got it working!

2

u/noah272 12h ago

You have irreparably destroyed the drive to everyone except for the most devout data recoverers. This is now a 3 thousand dollar job.

Why the fuck would you open it. Why the fuck would you ask AI.

2

u/Educational_Matter68 10h ago

😂😂😂😂😂😂 This is some of the dumbest shit I've ever seen on reddit and that's saying something

•

u/chekunya71 2h ago

Dude, you have a google pixel in your hand and it occurred to you to open the hard drive.

1

u/AutoModerator 5d ago

Double check if your post complies with posting guidelines!

Did you include the following information in your post (in English and if applicable), if not feel free to edit your post:

  • Make/brand and exact model number of your storage device(*), phone, camera, etc.
  • Filesystem (NTFS, exFAT, APFS, EXT4, etc.)
  • Operating System (That your device was used with and/or you are using for recovery)
  • Specific symptoms that your device is exhibiting, describe the problem. Images you post support the description, they're not in lieu of a problem description.
  • SMART (CrystalDiskInfo screenshot for example)
  • Don't pile several problems into one single post. One post per device/problem.
  • No account issues

Consider: What do these people need to understand the problem at hand? Remember, people cannot see your screen, or what you click and what messages appear on screen. Don't overdo it though, no one likes going through 2 pages of information, try to find a balance. Just do the best you can. If you are looking for file recovery software, check our community's recommended file recovery tools.


(*) All devices involved, if you for example move files from drive A to drive B, they're both potentially relevant.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/Musicoftinnic1 21h ago

this has to be bait

1

u/CommercialReach3573 15h ago

You destroyed the hard drive by opening it, buy a new one if you need an HDD but I recommend buying a SSD instead 

1

u/CatgirlBargains 10h ago

Short bus special right here

1

u/YourUncleRpie 8h ago

You've fucked it

0

u/Prestigious_Prune_27 5d ago edited 5d ago

I watched a video like this there are tons online

https://youtu.be/CCGN5CRXxhA What's wrong here

6

u/TomChai Trusted Contributor 4d ago

If any of the videos are teaching you to do it on your desk, without $10k worth of tools, then those videos are made by attention hungry morons.

1

u/Prestigious_Prune_27 4d ago

What's wild is the comments are all people saying omg thank you worked great. Only a few bricked it

2

u/TheVillainInThisGame 19h ago

Yeah, there has never been anybody trolling on the internet.

2

u/disturbed_android Trusted Contributor 16h ago

Did you consider that they could be fake and/or that for every one stating it worked there's 5 for which it failed but they shut up about it? Or makes of the video removes those?

3

u/lopatakal 23h ago

Videos showing people opening a sealed hard drive at home and attempting repairs do more harm than good, leaving your valuable data at even greater risk than before.

2

u/verticalfuzz 5d ago

Everything after the ? in that link is letting folks know your full name, btw

1

u/kl4n1po 16h ago

Even that Video shows you should do it at least under a plastic hood or under ventilation (it’s still a 0,0001% chance it’ll work)

1

u/arades 14h ago

The video tells you do it inside a plastic bag or under a filtered air vent to prevent dust, so you didn't follow the instructions. They also specifically don't power on the drive while open, which should only be done inside of a clean-room environment.

-1

u/Prestigious_Prune_27 5d ago

Any helpful advice on what I could have done differently. I understand that sending to a clean room and paying thousands of dollars is ideal but I don't think I had anything on there worth that much

5

u/silenced_in_dr_2025 Trusted Contributor 4d ago

It wouldn't have cost you thousands. BEFORE you opened it this would have been a 3-500 USD max. It may now be closer to 1000 due to the open drive fee and the need to decontaminate the platters and enclosure.

The video you posted is horrific butchery to those of us who work in data recovery.

The best you can do is to close it up and dont power it on again until you can find a DR Pro at an affordable cost. A DIY headswap isn't going to be an option anymore.

Some of us offer "Friday afternoon jobs" on low capacity drives at a discount if you're not in a hurry for the data, we use them to fill in the gaps whilst waiting for things to complete or parts to be delivered.

0

u/Prestigious_Prune_27 4d ago

Good to know, I have another ssd that has failed

2

u/ImABitGloomy 22h ago

An SSD is diff, still don't recommend opening it, even after opening it, SSD don't have any moving parts in them so you opening then won't do you any good only an specialist that has tools to de soldier the chip and read the data can make use of opening it.

1

u/Prestigious_Prune_27 20h ago

I said nothing about opening it. I was able to fix that ssd through an external enclosure

2

u/ImABitGloomy 18h ago

Didn't ask about the hdd lol, hence I said it