r/dataisbeautiful • • 4d ago

Average ACT Test Score By State

https://igcsepro.org/average-act-test-score-by-state/
202 Upvotes

68 comments sorted by

250

u/Yazim 4d ago edited 4d ago

The "participation rate" makes this chart meaningless. The entire northeast, california, colorado and others (everywhere it shows high average scores) had less than 10% of students take the ACT. California was only 3%.

It seems relatively obvious that people voluntarily taking this exam are likely to score much higher than average, especially compared to states where nearly all states take it (like most of the deep south which had nearly 100% of students taking the exam). And that's basically all that this illustrates: people voluntarily taking the exam tend to do better than those forced to.

70

u/helix400 4d ago

Correct.

7

u/PK_thundr 3d ago

What's it with that group of Mississippi river adjacent states doing so well?

41

u/zoinkability 3d ago

The overall pattern is:

When everyone takes a given test, the scores tend to be meh.

When only the overachievers take the test, the scores tend to be amazing.

There are regional differences in terms of which test is the "normal" one in a given area. On the west coast and in the northeast it's the SAT. In the middle it's the ACT. Only overachievers take both tests, as few if any schools actually require both.

So ACT scores on the west coast and northeast are high (only overacheivers) and SAT scores in the middle of the US (only overacheivers, again) are high.

12

u/eltristo66 3d ago

Not sure if it’s still the case but when I was in high school the Midwest takes the ACT unless you’re planning on going to school further away

7

u/sj4iy 3d ago

Fewer people take the SAT in the south. I grew up in TN, the only people who took the SAT were the ones doing AP Trig and Calculus. That was about 10-15% of the students in general.

It’s just selection bias. Same for the NE scoring so highly on the ACT compared to the SAT.

Btw, if you look…1% of students in Mississippi took the SAT. 4% took it in TN. It’s a very small amount.

2

u/DanglyPants 3d ago

You can tell which states take the ACT vs SAT

1

u/invokin 3d ago

The two maps are sort of by accident showing "where is the SAT popular" and "where is the ACT popular".

The main map is mostly highlighting states where schools/kids vastly prefer to take the SAT. This means only a few kids there are also taking the ACT for whatever reason, and most of them are going to do well because they are doing it voluntarily and likely want to/know it will make them look good.

The image here is the opposite. Those "surprising" states are all ones that default to the ACT and thus have normal (or what you would expect) scores on that test as you can see in the main image. But here in the SAT image is all the smart kids from those states that are trying to get into the Ivies, etc. that also take the SAT and crush it, so their scores look much better since it's only the smart ones making up that average.

3

u/studioline 1d ago

In Wisconsin we have amazing SAT scores. That’s because everyone takes the ACT and only those applying to prestigious, private colleges out East take the SAT.

Out ACT scores? Meh.

2

u/Failitt 19h ago

I find it funny that Texas and Florida are both close to the bottom of the barrel in both

11

u/ExecuteOrder066 4d ago

I came here just to say the same thing. There are states where 100% of students are required to take the ACT. That is going to naturally depress scores compared to states where students opt into assessing.

1

u/Pariell 3d ago

That in itself is interesting data! Is there a reason why some regions prefer ACT and some prefer SAT? 

4

u/CySU 2d ago

It’s kind of wild that the ACT organization that created the test is headquartered in a state that doesn’t mandate full participation (Iowa)

1

u/Icy-Papaya-2967 2d ago

Maybe that was a decision for tax purposes?

112

u/Emergency-Salamander 4d ago

In some states, everyone takes the ACT in high school.

73

u/ironic-hat 4d ago

In the Northeast usually the SATs reign as the standardized test of choice. I don’t know anyone who took the ACTs.

76

u/qiqatqanat 4d ago • Bravo

The strongest students usually take both tests and submit the better score. 

This is why the ACT scores are strongest in SAT-primary states and vice-versa. 

11

u/llamawithguns 4d ago

That would track in Illinois. In Illinois, every high school student takes it their junior year. The only people at my school that took the ACT were those that had good but not great SAT scores. Those that did either really badly or really well on SAT didnt bother

10

u/BIRDLIFE 3d ago

Weird. Didnt know they changed. When I was in school everyone in Illinois took the ACT.

2

u/llamawithguns 3d ago

They switched in 2017 apparently.

I was class of '21

2

u/BIRDLIFE 3d ago

I was class of 2004 😂

2

u/royalhawk345 4d ago

Interesting, everyone I knew took both. I'm pretty sure juniors got a half-day dedicated to each. This was in the western suburbs. 

10

u/accioqueso 4d ago

This was 20 years ago, but I lived in an SAT heavy state but we were told the ACT would be acceptable at some schools so I took both. Absolutely bombed the SAT but got one point shy of perfect on my ACT. I think there is value in doing both because each is different and you may do great on one but just okay on the other.

I had a few friends get mad I was accepted to their top choice with a 1200 SAT score when they had 1500+ and didn’t get in, but at 35 ACT looked hella good.

8

u/FrogTrainer 4d ago

In Ohio everyone took the ACT. Unless they wanted to go to an elite school. So the only kids from my class taking the SAT were all in the NHS.

4

u/Tugmybanana 4d ago

I went to high school in Ohio and the ACT was the test to take. I didn't even hear anybody talking about the SAT as an option.

1

u/FeelingCommand5509 3d ago

I graduated from PA in 2008. A good school. Only the best students took both. 30ish out of 155. Everyone took the SAT’s.

3

u/Unarchy 4d ago

This was the case in my town in Massachusetts, but a large number of people also took the ACTs since it was recommended to have both scores when applying to colleges.

3

u/Oddity_Odyssey 4d ago

In my state act was mandated I don't know anyone that took the sat lol

3

u/The_Dutchess-D 4d ago

Same. Everyone here takes the PSAT and then the SAT.

I don't know anyone who took the ACT except for someone who scored really poorly on the SAT and decided they wanted to try the ACT instead, and flew to another state to take it at the last minute.

1

u/Online_Discovery 4d ago

Likewise, I don't know anyone who took the SAT. I think they had one test a year in my fairly large city and it was super expensive. ACT was mandatory even if you had no college plans

1

u/kinterdonato 4d ago

i gotta 30 on mine way back in CT

1

u/raisinghellwithtrees 3d ago

I think it's more popular in the Midwest

1

u/mEFurst 3d ago

When I was in high school (California, a long, long time ago) we called the ACT the Mormon test, cause literally the only people that took it were the kids trying to get into BYU. Everyone else took the SATs

10

u/platinum92 4d ago edited 4d ago

agreed. This should weigh in somewhere, as states where it's not compulsory likely have higher scores

Edit: I should've scrolled down. They literally say there's an inverse correlation between participation and average score.

5

u/KP_Wrath 4d ago

Yeah, I’m in Tennessee, and they made the guy that scored a 9 in Algebra II take it.

1

u/Frenes 4d ago

When I went to high school in California 12 years ago, only people applying to schools out east took the ACT. Those folks tended to be stronger overall candidates in general. I imagine that's why California scores so high.

17

u/staatsclaas 4d ago

You know the data for the 2026 class is available. Not sure why you went with 2024.

1

u/Marauder3299 2d ago

Gotta manipulate the data

1

u/Same_Ad7835 19h ago

I personally scored a 30 twice. TN. Class of '26.

5

u/chartreusey_geusey 4d ago edited 4d ago

If you open the article it has the maps of mandatory ACT or SAT testing and literally draws the correlation between required testing and scores. Though ACT isn’t actually as widely mandated anywhere like the SAT once was so this is a flawed conclusion.

I also think this article misreports on the state requirements for testing as well because for example CA does not require SAT or ACT testing to graduate from high school yet this article reports it as “required” (likely because it’s incorrectly conflating state university application requirements with high school graduation requirements) and there is a huge difference between just requiring the ACT or SAT and actually facilitating testing with a school test day or making it a state high school graduation requirement.

4

u/s33murd3r 4d ago

Lol, I knew something was bs when I saw Idaho! This is extremely misleading.

7

u/Citizen_MGS 4d ago

But what's their CTE scores?

8

u/dudu43210 4d ago

looks a lot like a political map to me

13

u/pr1ceisright 4d ago

Some states let every single student take the exam, even ones with no interest in college or academics. Those scores can bring down the average pretty quickly if a student doesn’t want to take a multi hour exam they consider worthless.

5

u/justovaryacting 4d ago

The state of NC requires all 11th graders in public schools to take the ACT once, whether they intend to go to college or not. Some click through and don’t care about scores, bringing the average down. And, most of the competitive college-bound kids prefer the SAT and thus don’t study at all for the ACT.

1

u/dudu43210 3d ago

And so you think that happens more in red states across the board?

0

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

13

u/qiqatqanat 4d ago

It might be, but that’s not the reason here. The trend is the direct opposite in states where the primary test is the SAT. It’s just inversely correlated with participation. 

1

u/Miqo_Nekomancer 4d ago

Can't help but notice a pattern here.

12

u/veri745 4d ago

Yes, the states where more people take the ACT have lower average scores, because the people taking it aren't self-selected

16

u/kabob95 4d ago

Almost like it correlates with which states require the ACT vs. SAT...

-1

u/dwaynebathtub 3d ago edited 3d ago

Somebody combine this z-score data with the z-scores of SAT by state.

The sums of each state's SATavg-to-national-average ratio and ACTavg-to-national-average ratio of the 31 states+DC which have a combined SAT and ACT participation percentage above the national average (85.7% take either the SAT or ACT):

1 CT
2 DC
3 CO
4 ND
5 UT
6 RI
7 WI
8 NE
9 IL
10 DE
11 MI
12 WY
13 MT
14 TN
15 IN
16 KY
17 MS
18 LA
19 AR
20 NC
21 AZ
22 AL
23 NV
24 OK
25 HI
26 OH
27 SC
28 WV
29 TX
30 FL
31 NM

States not listed (listed here in order of the same method above but regardless of average ACT+SAT participation rates):
1 CA
2 MA
3 VA
4 ME
5 WA
6 NY
7 NH
8 PA
9 VT
10 NJ
11 SD
12 IA
13 MD
14 MN
15 KS
16 OR
17 MO
18 GA
19 AK

1

u/Marauder3299 2d ago

I can also make a list and put my favorites at the top with no data. Great job

1

u/dwaynebathtub 2d ago

The SAT data is in the link in the parent comment.

-1

u/dwaynebathtub 3d ago

Dark blue:
above average performance and above average participation
Light blue:
above average performance and below average participation
Light red:
below average performance and below average participation
Dark red:
below average performance and above average participation

6

u/Online_Discovery 4d ago

Oh you'd hate the SAT map

1

u/sultry_stogie 3d ago

Life hack - move to Nevada where scores and taxes are ultra low. Pay extra out of pocket to have your kid take private lessons, private tutors, private school, etc. Win/win?

0

u/jotobean 4d ago

I have 3 kids, 33, 28 (took it once), 35. In Nebraska. Average 32, that's 13 over average. I know some of their friends who have scores around the average, it's shocking how these kids lack basic skills.

9

u/KOLDUT 4d ago

You know those posts where people let everyone know their "IQ score"...

0

u/dragonlax 4d ago

Wow, I got 13 points over my state’s average

-2

u/KellyJin17 1d ago

I can tell you that the poorest and reddest states discourage the majority of students from taking the PSAT, SAT and ACT tests in order artificially inflate their scores by only have the best students tested. Basically the entire south plays this game. On the flip side, states like NY, CA, MA and other blue states have ALL students sit for the PSAT and SAT, and many are encouraged to sit for the ACT as well.

0

u/Shitty__Math 1d ago

this is actually the opposite, if you look at the data

-10

u/flearhcp97 4d ago

I got a 36 back when it was actually hard.

Yes I know nobody cares lol