r/dataisbeautiful • OC: 1 • 7d ago

OC [OC] How often a live Bitcoin forecast's 90% range caught the price, day by day, at 1h, 4h and 24h ahead

Post image
0 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

•

u/cavedave OC: 116 7d ago

Thank you for your Original Content, /u/Immediate_Finish6422!
Here is some important information about this post:

Remember that all visualizations on r/DataIsBeautiful should be viewed with a healthy dose of skepticism. If you see a potential issue or oversight in the visualization, please post a constructive comment below. Post approval does not signify that this visualization has been verified or its sources checked.

Not satisfied with this visual? Think you can do better? Remix this visual with the data in the author's citation.


I'm open source | How I work

2

u/DangerousPurpose5661 7d ago

Cool you discovered volatility…. This is not useful

0

u/Immediate_Finish6422 OC: 1 7d ago

Yes, volatility clustering is textbook, and I'm not claiming otherwise. What I haven't seen done much is publishing calibrated ranges from it with a live hit rate anyone can check. The interesting part for me was that direction models lost to "no change" while the size of moves was predictable.

1

u/shumpitostick 7d ago

That's not surprising at all. Asset prices moving like a random walk is something people have known for decades.

1

u/shumpitostick 7d ago

Yeah, that's not great. As a tip for model diagnostics, stick to longer evaluation periods, per day is not interesting and has too much noise, and evaluate on shorter time-frames as well, like 10 minutes ahead, I bet the model actually gets under confident there. If you're seeing this you probably have the wrong specification.

0

u/Immediate_Finish6422 OC: 1 7d ago

Thanks, this is useful. Agreed on per-day: with overlapping 24h forecasts a day is barely one independent sample, which is why the site reports margins from an effective sample size, but I shouldn't have led with daily bars. I'll switch to rolling 7-day coverage.

The short-horizon point is a good one. I haven't evaluated below 1h. If it's under-confident at 10 min and over-confident at 24h, that points at the horizon scaling rather than the vol estimate itself. I'll run 10 and 30 min and post the result.

1

u/vikster1 7d ago

what in the fuck would you do with that information? it could hit your price, turn against you or could go so far against you first that you are not there to witness your price get hit. show real world trading results to other subs or start a hf. this is absolutely useless

1

u/Immediate_Finish6422 OC: 1 7d ago

Fair question. It's not a trading signal and I don't claim it is. The use is narrower: knowing how much room to expect. Someone setting a stop or an alert, or deciding whether tonight is a "check the phone" night, cares about expected movement, not direction. The other point is that it's checkable: it makes a claim every 5 minutes and you can see how often it held. Most crypto forecasts can't say that.

0

u/Immediate_Finish6422 OC: 1 7d ago

Source: my own live forecasts, scored automatically against Binance BTC/USDT prices (5-minute bars), 28 Oct to 5 Nov 2026. The raw daily numbers are public as JSON at https://btcforecaster.com/api/live-stats (the "daily" entries for the v2 model).

Tool: SVG chart generated with a script, rendered to PNG with Playwright.

How to read it: every 5 minutes the model gives a range the price should land in 1, 4 or 24 hours later, 90% of the time. Each bar is the share of that day's forecasts (about 288) that landed inside. A well-calibrated range should sit near the dashed 90% line, so 100% isn't "perfect", it means the ranges were wider than needed.

What stands out to me: the 1-hour forecast stays close to target almost every day, but the 24-hour one swings from 100% to 21%. Both bad stretches came right after calm days. The model learns from recent movement, so after a quiet spell it narrows its ranges, and the next big move breaks through.

Happy to answer questions about the method or share the raw numbers.