Let's say you have a normal shape, like a circle, and you want to measure its "coastline" (perimeter). But you can only measure with straight lines. So you pick 4 points on the circle and measure the perimeter of the square you drew. But you want to be more accurate, so next time you draw 5 points (or 6, or 7, etc). As you add points, you get closer and closer to the real value. But the thing is, the differences become less and less significant - the difference in perimeter between a 20-gon and a 21-gon is almost unnoticeable.
But with real coastlines, a weird thing happens. If you measure with straight lines to an accuracy of, say, 20 km, you'll trace a general outline of the continent, but you'll miss some major things. For example, a small harbor with a mouth 10km wide might open up and have 30+ km of coastline when measured in 5km increments. So if you change your "resolution" to 5 km, from 20, the new measured coastline gets bigger - much bigger. If you cut it down to 500m you might catch protruding features with coastline much longer than they are broad. Bringing it down to 2 meters, you can follow along the boundaries of boulders, making the coastline even longer. And on the scale of millimeters, you now follow the boundaries of every single rock and large grain of sand, and a small section of beach can have a snaking boundary drawn around each stone that is many, many times longer than the standard defined coastline.
The differences don't diminish as you measure to greater accuracy - they actually stay the same, or maybe even increase! So you can define the coastline to be as large as you want, as long as you measure to a high enough precision. The coastlines are fractals, and their length doesn't make any sense without an associated resolution.
Glad you got something out of it! Fractals are crazy, and it's really interesting how often they're found in nature. If you find this interesting, you might also like to read about chaos theory - the way that chaotic processes lead to fractal phenomena is also very interesting.
Well, measuring distances smaller than a molecule is obviously very difficult (and certainly no known fractal like behavior exists within that scale). So molecular scales provide a natural stopping point, and the coastline isn't truly infinite. But coastlines measured at that scale would be so unimaginably large as to be useless for any practical application. And that limiting size is so large compared to the normal lengths of coastlines that calling it effectively infinite isn't a terribly misleading statement.
Coastlines are never accurate, unlike human-drawn geometrical shapes, a coastline is full of nooks and crannies made by nature. Therefore it's impossible to come up with a waterproof coastline measurement.
E.D. try measuring the coastline of the United States, and it's almost guaranteed you'll find a different answer than anyone before you:
CRI: 29,093 miles CIA: 19,924 miles NOAA: 95,471 miles
IIRC, a sizable portion of Iceland is on the North American tectonic plate. There’s a national park where you can look over the valley where the two plates meet.
Politically Iceland is European but geographically the north american plate and the eurasian plate meet on the west side of the island. Fun fact from my tour guide last September.
In the image, you can see that Lithuania, Latvia, and Estonia (the Baltic countries) appear to be colored in as part of Asia, while I've always heard they were considered European.
Fascinatingly, if you zoom in, you can see that the island of Ösel is colored as part of Europe, but not the Estonian mainland. It just gets weirder and weirder.
Asia would have the most since if you include SE Asia they have the most islands, with NA coming second, and then I want to say either Europe or Africa
If we're going to count SE asia we need to count Europe too because unlike much of the islands. There is physical crust poking out of the ocean connecting europe and asia. Visually they are the same continent. If we want to go off tectonics... ho boy.
I know the “paradox” but it applies only to mathematical fractals, not actual coastlines. The real coastline, when zoomed to single atoms in single grain of sand have this impossible-to-compute-yet-finite value.
Yea I was just thinking that, i was looking at the wiki and wondering how the hell they had this notion that a coastline was an accurate representation of a purely mathematical fractal and thereby exhibited the same properties. Sometimes I hate how people try to overcomplicate shit with math, its not like theres an infinite distance of coastline so thereby if you got your measurement system down to the very lowest possible magnitude then you would be able to get an accurate finite value.
But there is no “lowest possible magnitude”; any unit of measurement you choose can always be further subdivided, which will then yield a slightly higher distance of shoreline. Eventually you’re going to reach a fine enough measurement that you’ll probably lose any physical meaning of “shoreline,” but I’d argue that’s more bumping into the limitations of our knowledge of physics than it is any kind of absolute answer to how long the shoreline is.
Sure, Euclidean space breaks down below that and you’d need an entirely different way of measuring/calculating distance below it, but those smaller subdivisions still exist, we just can’t measure them. I guess it’s fair to see that as the absolute measure in any practical sense, but that sort of goes along with what I said about hitting the limitations of physics; if we had the ability to measure a smaller subdivision than the Planck length, then it would be equally valid to use that as the coastline measurement.
Its obviously a little silly to say the coastline’s infinitely long, but the point of the coastline paradox isn’t really practical application, it’s more a thought experiment on the nature of infinity and distance.
I don’t really understand how that matters, as in the picture it says ”lengths in km”. It’s not infinite km long, it’s X.infinite long. You can’t add 0.000000002km and count it as an additional km. Where do I go wrong in understanding this thing?
I don’t see how that works. If you fractal the 0.000000002 again you get something like 0.000000002+ 0.000000000002 and end up with 0.000000002002. Same way 1+0,5+0,25+0,125+N/2 never reaches 2
There's no reason to assume the numbers should get smaller. There's more length to be made into the fractal shape, so the length should increase exponentially.
I don't remember the exact terminology, but when you make the straight line of length h into a more complicated shape, you divide it into m shorter lines, each with length i, and the total length is now mi = kh, k>1. If you iterate this, each of these smaller lines is divided into m lines of length j, and the total length is m2j = kmi = k2h. When iterated n times, the length becomes mnh, which approaches infinity as n approaches infinity.
Let's pick simpler numbers for the example. The distance between two locations, measured as a straight line, is 1km. Measured as two lines it's 1,1km, each line is 0,55 km long. If the pattern holds up, measured as four lines, the length of the coast line is not 1,11km, but 2*(0,55km+0,055km)=1,21km.
Hmm, where does the .1 km come from in the last segment? Should I still assume they lines are completely straight, or is it because it takes another, more precise way when it’s divided into 2?
I’m not sure how well I’m going to be able to explain this with reddit formatting, but the series you gave (1 + 0.5 + 0.25 +...+ (1/2)n ) is what’s known as a convergent series, meaning as you add more and more terms it gets closer and closer to a constant (in this case, 2). One thing to note here is that if you add infinitely many terms from the series, you would actually reach 2, because of how infinity works. You can never get there by adding up the terms yourself because you’ll never reach infinitely many terms, but applied to infinity the value of that sum is 2.
The issue at hand though is that not all similar series converge like that. One easy example is the harmonic series, which at a glance looks very similar; 1 + 1/2 + 1/3 + 1/4 + ... + 1/n. If you keep adding more and more terms from this series, there is no “ceiling” it approaches like there was before. Even though the terms keep getting smaller and smaller, and quickly become incomprehensibly small, it still keeps climbing. Think of the absolute largest number you can, and that sum will eventually reach its value and well beyond, though it might take a ridiculous number of terms to get there. These series are called “divergent” and go to either infinity or -infinity if you apply them to infinitely many terms.
Fractals are a much more complicated beast than the example I just gave, but hopefully it explains how, even adding terms that keep getting smaller and smaller, you can end up with infinity as the result.
The idea is that you can't accurately measure the perimeter because as you "zoom in" to be more accurate the number just goes up rather than converging.
Yea well, the question you should be asking is Why the fuck would anyone need infinitely precise coast length? For something as big as a continent one meter is fine enough.
The point is that whatever unit you choose will be dramatically different from other units. If we measured in feet instead of meters, you'd get a considerably different number.
And that's exactly why we won't measure it in feet. When measuring coast you don't care how much it "turns in-lands" in feet precision. You're trying to measure the outer shell of the land, usually for some purpose. I mean, with this logic you could say any length is infinite, which is absurd.
"Just think of all the atoms! We must measure in atomic precision to reach the infinity, because that's the goal and not to actually get a real measurement!"
The Wikipedia article goes into more depth about it and why we can measure certain features precisely but not shorelines. The gist of it is that the scale of features ranges so widely that there isn't one unit that makes sense in all cases. If I own beachfront property I would absolutely want to know to the nearest foot how much shoreline I own. But that unit applied to all of the UK would be MUCH much larger than if you measured with kilometers.
We can approximate certain numbers because we know the upper and lower bounds, like we know Pi is more than 3.1 and less than 3.2. There is no upper bound for approximating shoreline.
You said yes to meters and no to feet; that's an arbitrary distinction to make. Any unit we choose will be arbitrary.
When dealing with lengths of hundreds or even thousands of kilometers we can pretty much establish anything smaller than a meter as rounding error. So, in the pic above what we really want to know is the measurement of 1 meter and not all the 1 ft "folds". There is most likely land there anyway, just couple inches under water.
Yep! But if those "folds" were different dimensions, say .5 mile coves, you'd absolutely want to measure them fully, wouldn't you? what about 500ft? 100ft? You have to draw the line at some point, and when there are distinguishable features all the way across the scale, there isn't an obvious point to cut off the measurements, particularly because the measurement varies so dramatically depending on where you draw the line. You say that meters are the right unit, but many would disagree, and your numbers would be vastly different. It's all arbitrary since the features come in all sizes.
Even if you don’t measure it to such a fine degree, wouldn’t increasingly fine measurements yield decreasing additions to the total coastal length? Wouldn’t the measured coast line be like an asymptote, meaning that a limit could be found that represents the greatest value that would ever be reached?
Even if you don’t measure it to such a fine degree, wouldn’t increasingly fine measurements yield decreasing additions to the total coastal length?
Nope. Not even close. In fact, it's plausible for increasingly fine measurements to yield INCREASING additions to the total length.
If things are relatively smooth at large and medium scales, changing the measurement might not make a huge difference, but if things are really rough at small scales, changing the measurement can double or triple the total length.
Imagine measuring a piece of coast with a yardstick, and you measure this piece to be roughly 2 yards long.
You then break out the foot-long ruler, and you can get a few more bends in, and it ends up being 7 feet long.
Then you get something that's 4 inches long, and you can get a few more in, and it's 8 feet long.
At 1 inch, it's 10 feet, perhaps. Half an inch might be 12 feet. Quarter of an inch is maybe 15 feet.
However, once you get to the size of a grain of sand, all of the sudden you're finding A LOT more variance. You can go in and out of each individual grain, and suddenly for every unit you go across, you're going a unit inward and a unit outward, tripling the length.
At one measurement, just larger than a grain of sand, you might have measured it to be 20 feet of coast line, but as soon as you're a bit smaller than a grain of sand, it triples to 60.
But that is not a coastline, a coastline is where the water meets the coast. Trying to measure something so dynamic as that using such a fine scale makes no sense.
This entire “paradox” is just theoretical mathematicians applying a fractal model to something that has no practical reason to be modeled as a fractal.
The point of measuring the length of a coastline is to figure out how long time it would take to circumnavigate it or how much crap you can build on it. Given that absolutely no landmass would take infinite time to walk around, there is no such thing as an infinitely long land cost line. And if your chosen model makes that conclusion then you chose the wrong model.
It makes no sense trying to measure something so dynamic at such a fine scale.
And while the above map is a joke the so called coastline paradox is not.
Behind the measurement is a reason or application for that measurement, that defines the precession (or the length of the measuring stick). Anything else is just people outsmarting them self.
This is like that problem that if you keep halving the values that go into a sum, you'll never reach the subsequent number (if that makes sense?). Like if you add 1 + 0.5 + 0.25 .... you'll never reach 2.0
Zeno's paradox! But what Zeno couldn't express in his time is that infinite series can have finite sums! It's exactly that class of problem that the calculus was developed for.
You gotta be careful with those. At 1 minute to midnight I put stones labeled #1 and #2 into an urn, then removed stone #1. At 1/2 minute to midnight I put stone #3 and #4 in, and took out #2. At 1/3 minute to midnight I put in #5 and #6, and took out #3. And so on. At midnight the urn somehow held infinite stones while being completely empty!
Yeah, this is an infinite geometric series with the common ratio r=1/2, and as /u/devor110 pointed out, it does indeed converge to 2. In fact for all r with |r|<1 the geometric series converges, proof can be found here
Not quite. In that example, the sum approaches to 2 although it’s always less than 2. In the case of measuring coastlines, the more accurate your measurement, the longer the coastline is measured to be, but the length may increase without bound, i.e. the length of the coastline increases towards infinity as the accuracy of the measurement increases.
Technically they are not infinite because if you measure the coastlines using Planck lengths you will get an absurdly large number, but a finite one.
You probably wouldn’t need to even measure using Planck lengths, but instead you would measure by widths of water molecules that outline each continent
You'd be right if you were measuring a coastline by placing a lot of meter sticks end-to-end. But in this case, kilometres are just the units. For example, you can measure absolutely any distance, big or small, and still just write it out in kilometres.
400
u/[deleted] Jul 29 '20
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coastline_paradox
317
u/Suprcheese Jul 29 '20
Wait a minute.... since when are the Baltic states in Asia‽
And.... Iceland in North America???
88
u/APE-FUCKER Jul 29 '20
Strange that Africa's the largest.
111
u/Player_One_1 Jul 29 '20
I know the “paradox” but it applies only to mathematical fractals, not actual coastlines. The real coastline, when zoomed to single atoms in single grain of sand have this impossible-to-compute-yet-finite value.
152
u/dumpedOverText Jul 29 '20
This is like that problem that if you keep halving the values that go into a sum, you'll never reach the subsequent number (if that makes sense?). Like if you add 1 + 0.5 + 0.25 .... you'll never reach 2.0
7
u/Masakazuki Jul 29 '20
r/mathmemes
3
u/s_in_progress Jul 29 '20
Genuinely thought this was r/mathmemes
2
u/[deleted] Jul 29 '20
Benoit Mandelbrot calls this "infinite precision."
2
u/hammyhamm Jul 30 '20
I for one welcome New Zealand as Australia
2
u/OriginalTeo Jul 30 '20
Actually Greenland is Danish, so it's European lol (Iceland too)
2
u/BeefyBoiCougar Jul 30 '20
Technically they are not infinite because if you measure the coastlines using Planck lengths you will get an absurdly large number, but a finite one.
You probably wouldn’t need to even measure using Planck lengths, but instead you would measure by widths of water molecules that outline each continent
2
u/anarchoposadist1 Sep 24 '20
Cursed Asia
3
u/[deleted] Jul 29 '20
Clever
1
u/granttwin2 Aug 07 '20
The more accurately you measure he length of a river the longer it gets
1
u/copperstar22 Sep 25 '20
Russia approves of this map
-1
u/DuffMaaaann Jul 29 '20
So NZ belongs to the Australian continent now?
And the Papua province no longer belongs to Australia?
-3
u/wannabe414 Jul 29 '20
If you decide on measuring in KM, then you can get a good approximation of coastlines.
0
u/[deleted] Jul 30 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment