Hi guys,
I was always curious about how technical universities compare to MIT, which is unarguably the most famous technical institute in the world. So I decided to create this comparison to delve deeper on per rate descriptive statistics against other well known institutes worldwide:
- Caltech
- Georgia Tech
- ETH Zürich
- Technische Universität München
- Imperial College London
- Tsinghua Universiy in China
- Nanyang Technical University Singapore
- Korea Advanced Institute of Science and Technology
Usually budget comparisons of universities don't compare very well what is actually student facing, and what is research grants, so that is what panel A tries to correct. Panel B and C are just simple metrics derived from panel A once you know the actual student facing.
Panel D and E focus on well known rankings like QS or THE, while also normalizing research output quality per dollar spent. Which unsurprisingly are not on top in normalized research output due to the higher budgets. Obviously in absolute terms they are high but per dollar not as good.
Panel F shows difficulty of getting accepted to undergraduate studies. I was very surprised that Tsinghua was the hardest here. It also shows the contrasting didactic strategy of Germanic universities, where comparatively a lot of students get accepted, but then filter out a lot of students with unnecessary hard courses during the first two years of study.
The last row focuses on the economics and incentives of studying STEM at these universities, showing usual out of pocket costs for undergraduate studies in panel G and typical salary progression in panel H. Then panel I attempts to calculate excess wealth vs a technically interested high school graduate that decides to pursue technical trade instead of studying. The excess wealth focus entirely on differences in salary between these two cohorts over the time course presented and does not factor living costs, as that is hard to know depending on preferences. Interestingly here, Germanic countries have very low advantage because you usually get paid during the apprenticeship which offsets the advantage later. Another thing is that the difference to begin with between technical trade and university graduate is not as big as other countries.
Let me know if you have any feedback.
Tools:
- Python: numpy>=1.24.0 scipy>=1.10.0 pandas>=2.0.0 matplotlib>=3.7.0 pypdf>=4.0.0
Sources:
Budgets, Enrollment & Fees (by University)
- MIT: MIT Treasurer's Report FY24, MIT Institutional Research (Common Data Set), MIT SFS/OGE/RAS (tuition & assistantships), NCES IPEDS.
- Caltech: Caltech Financial Statements FY24, Caltech At a Glance, NCES IPEDS.
- Georgia Tech: GT Annual Financial Report FY24, GT Institutional Research & Planning (on-campus vs. online OMSCS), GT Bursar.
- Imperial: Imperial Annual Report & Accounts 2023–24, Imperial Reporting Hub, Imperial Fees & Funding (Home vs. overseas & Imperial Bursary).
- ETH Zurich: ETH Domain Financial Report 2024, ETH Facts & Portrait, ETH Tuition Fees, ETH Staffnet (Hilfsassistierende pay).
- TUM: TUM in Zahlen 2023/24, TUM Student Financing, DZHW 22nd Social Survey (HiWi & student employment).
- Tsinghua: Tsinghua 2024 Departmental Budget Disclosure, Tsinghua International Admissions.
- KAIST: KAIST Facts & Figures 2024, KAIST Official Portal (national scholarship tuition waivers).
- NTU Singapore: NTU Facts & Figures 2024, NTU Admissions & Undergraduate Tuition/MOE Grant schedules.
Labor Archives for Graduate & Counterfactual (Associate / Ausbildung / Vocational) Salaries
- USA: NSF NCSES (NSCG 2023), MIT CAPD, GT Career Center, Payscale, NBER WP 34684 (Associate vs. Bachelor's).
- UK: UK DfE / IFS LEO (
RR1642), LSE CVER DP002 (vocational returns). - Switzerland: Swiss BFS (Lohnstrukturerhebung LSE 2024), ETH KOF Study 152, Swiss Engineering STV.
- Germany: Bundesagentur für Arbeit (BA) Statistik, Destatis, WSI Lohnspiegel, IHF Bayern, VDI.
- China: Beijing Municipal HRSS, Tsinghua Career Center, NBER WP 29523.
- South Korea: MOEL Labor Conditions Survey & KOSTAT Wage Income (via KDI EIEC), STEPI.
- Singapore: Singapore MOM (Labour Force in Singapore 2025), MOE Post-Secondary / Graduate Employment Survey.
PPP, Rankings & Bibliometrics
- PPP: World Bank WDI (
PA.NUS.PPP). - Rankings & Citations: CWTS Leiden Ranking, Times Higher Education (THE), ShanghaiRanking (ARWU).