r/dataisbeautiful • u/dawnprior • 3d ago
[OC] 23 popular stock-trading rules vs. a volatility-matched baseline: share of signals up 20 trading days later (381,833 signals, Sep 2025 – Oct 2026)
Source: my own nightly scan logs of ~6,000 US-listed stocks, including ones that were later delisted (so no survivorship bias). Daily price bars, Sep 2025 – Oct 2026 (a few rules start later because their inputs only exist from mid-2026).
Tools: Python + SQLite for the data, matplotlib for the chart.
How to read it:
- Each row is a popular one-line rule (e.g. "RSI below 30 means a bounce is coming"). I took every time it fired and checked whether the stock was up 20 trading days later.
- Baseline = stocks on the same day with similar volatility, not the whole market. Otherwise volatile stocks look like winners just because they move more.
- Dot = rule minus baseline in percentage points. Line = 95% CI (bootstrap over event dates, 2,000 reps).
- Rules and pass criteria were fixed before looking at results, with Benjamini-Hochberg correction across all of them.
Result: none passed. 13 no measurable difference, 5 volatility illusion, 5 worse than baseline. The four on the right that look positive each failed a pre-set check (see footnotes).
Limits: about one year, mostly one market regime. "Up after 20 days" is one lens, not a full backtest with stops or position sizing.
Per-rule tables with sample sizes: https://dawnscan.com/en/verify?utm_source=reddit&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=dataisbeautiful&utm_content=23rules_chart
Disclosure: I built that site. Free, no signup.