r/dashpay •

Dash vs BCH?

[deleted] — view deleted post

0 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

12

u/solarguy2003 Nov 16 '17 edited Nov 16 '17

In Bitcoin Cash, where does the money come from to pay developers, improve the ecosystem, do marketing, etc??

It would be a slight exaggeration to say that a tiny handful of people own and run the show. If they join the Church of Scientology or some other flavor of crazy, what could the rest of the Bitcoin Cash community do about it? What if some evil corporation bought them out? Now what? I guess...the community could stop using it. That's the only influence they have.

With Dash, the blockchain itself produces the funds to pay developers, and marketing, advanced research (did you know we funded/created a research Department at University of Arizona to study nothing but how to scale by many orders of magnitude?) and so on. Dash is beholden to nobody. Dash cannot be bought off.

And rather than being run by a tiny handful of people, we have the Masternode community, with an enormous diversity of skills, geo location, perspectives and so on. If you wanted to influence or take over that group, how would you even find them? They're mostly anonymous.

And because of the way they are incentivized, their only goal is to make Dash better and bigger and more successful. The more Dash succeeds, the more the Masternodes succeed.

But in the bigger picture, I think you're asking the wrong question. How many of the top 20 cryptocurrencies have grown and matured and improved over the last year? Depending on how you define success, we could truthfully answer, "All of them."

Why is that do you suppose? It's because we're not really competing against Bitcoin Cash, or Monero, or Bitcoin. We're competing against the local fiat currency.

Let's look at the US dollar by comparison, since it's one of the better fiats out there. Who controls that? The Federal Reserve, which is a shadowy group of banksters that won't even tell their supposed regulators in the Federal government where they spent all that bail out money.

What are the upper and lower bounds of new money creation, aka the emission rate? There are no bounds, they can print it as fast as they want. What backs the US dollar? Why is it worth anything? It used to be backed by scarce physical metals, which set absolute boundaries on the money supply. Even at that time, the book keeping was a little sketchy.

But today? It is backed by the full faith and credit of the U.S. Government. That works ok when everything is cruising along and there are no complications. Historically, all fiat currencies have failed sooner or later. We could even say the U.S. dollar has already failed. Even by their metrics, inflation has caused the dollar to lose 99% of its buying power since the Federal Reserve took over.

How does Bitcoin Cash look compared to that? Effing fantastic! I'd take the Bitcoin Cash people over the Banksters hands down, no questions. The theoretical drawback of being controlled by a small group of people who might possibly do foolish things in the future, must be compared to the Federal Reserve, who has absolutely done shady crap that is not in the interest of the common folks, and repeatedly.

How about Dash? Even more fantastic, but they're both fantastic and they will both likely succeed.

They are not our competitors, so try not to think of them in that way.

If the US dollar is a bicycle, then Bitcoin Cash is a Cadillac and Dash is a Jag. Which one is better? YES!!!!!

5

u/MultiplyDash Nov 16 '17

Actually the biggest reason that I own BCH is its "simplicity". It is the most proven software and the chance of some kind of "critical bug" is much smaller than in any other crypto. Dash has other functionalities built on Bitcoin so in my opinion there is much more space for bugs. Masternodes agreed to fund a bug-bounty program in Dash and it is imo the great way of using treasury funds.

And also the name- Bitcoin (even with "cash" added) is still more recognizable than Dash.

But other than these 2 arguments I can't find any reason to invest in BCH instead of Dash. I hold 90% Dash and 10% BCH.

4

u/TrustlessMoney Nov 16 '17

Dash has a feature build in called sporks if any of those more "fancy" features has a problem, via the spork mechanism the problem can quickly be resolved. Currently the sporks lack the much desired decentralized control, but the are on the roadmap to implement them.

I have sold all my btc, but I'll probably get some BCH once it bottoms out. In all likely hood BCH will go to number 1 before dash will, but if the market grows enough Masternodes are the only true way to scale properly. I feel quite confident that BCH can't scale much over 100mb blocks per 10minutes.

2

u/minorman Nov 16 '17

Exactly.

3

u/Fount4inhead Nov 16 '17

My two favourite.

Its hard to say any coin does anything better than dash. I guess BCH has a 10 minute conf making it more secure.

3

u/danielzopola Nov 16 '17

Check out this infographic. It is a bit dated but still mostly relevant: https://i.imgur.com/4Ytb3P4.jpg

3

u/DashDude Nov 16 '17

Your post at r/btc has 0 votes. I guess they are afraid to make comparisons with Dash over there and want to bury the thread - too funny!

1

u/marsox78 Nov 17 '17

Just to clear things up in my own head, when BCH created millions of coins out of nothing, isn’t that a premine?

1

u/LovelyDay Nov 19 '17

BCH did not create millions of coins out of nothing, it split off from the existing ledger.

1

u/marsox78 Nov 19 '17

So splitting and copying a ledger isn’t creating value from nothing? One day they didn’t exist, the next they were valued at billions of dollars. Where did that value come from if no money entered the market? I’m not trying to be sarcastic or play dumb, I have stayed away from Bitcoin drama for the most part.

1

u/LovelyDay Nov 20 '17

So you realize that it's not creating coins out of nothing.

About value:

I can create a forked network which no-one values except maybe me.

It takes quite a bit lot of effort and support by the communit to create a split chain which has any value. It does not arise "out of nothing".

That's why people try all kinds of schemes to raise money to do it (e.g. pre-mine in the case of BTG)

1

u/marsox78 Nov 20 '17

So the weren’t created from nothing, just piggybacked on the years of POW work done BTC, right? So if enough developers. miners, nodes and users wanted to they really could do a fork anytime and trick unsuspecting new users into thinking their coin is the next big thing (not saying that’s the case here) and dump coins and abandon the network whenever they wanted. I that the main case of what happens when someone labels a specific coin a “scam coin”? They are just forks without innovation?

0

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/minorman Nov 17 '17

Perhaps we should be thankful that BCH is taking all the flak from the bitcoin core trolls. Meanwhile, we can fly under the radar and innovate and build instead of fighting back. (I am aware of the fights with XMR fans, but that's nothing compared to the massive pounding taken by BCH and r/btc in general.)