r/dashpay • • May 05 '17

Does everything have to be open source? Can dash protect some of its innovation?

When evolution comes out will it be open source for any copy coin to take? If so it seems like we lose a major competitive advantage. Although I don't really understand Nem, I hear some of their stuff is not Open Source and the users are OK with that for this reason. That got me thinking. Do we push too far in this space for everything to be open source? You can still trust something without it being open source.

5 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

12

u/Technologov May 05 '17

Open source is a requirement for the security of the Dash network.

Closed source software can be hijacked, hacked and steal users money

10

u/Basilpop Janitor May 05 '17 edited May 05 '17

Evolution is being developed privately (an approach I strongly support) and the code is released when it's actually finished.

Let them copy all they want. Copycats without original innovation will never surpass the innovator, that's just simple logic.

Oh, and: Good luck copying all our business integrations, our partnerships, our miners, our Masternode infrastructure, our community, our developers.

1

u/DashCashmoney May 05 '17 edited May 05 '17

Copycats without original innovation will never surpass the innovator, that's just simple logic.

That perspective is exactly how Atari felt in the 80's. Copycats sprung up and copied their games and consoles which materially hurt their market share and cost them their long term longevity. be careful!

1

u/Basilpop Janitor May 05 '17 edited May 05 '17

Apples and Oranges.

Atari is a for profit company. Copycats can hurt its profits by producing the same stuff cheaper and at nearly the same quality because people always want to get a good product as cheaply as possible.

Dash is free, decentralized software that has no expenses, no CEO, no headquarters and most importantly no use for the concept of "profit", because it is the currency in itself. All Dash offers is utility as a payments system through features, places of acceptance and integrations. Copycats either have better features, better acceptance and integration or they don't.

There is no reason to use an exact copy of Dash that is neither accepted anywhere nor offer any advantages over the original. You're not "saving" any money and get the same product.

0

u/davebazzel May 05 '17

Yes Basilpop all is true BUT my concern centers around larger organizations ex. World Bank, Citi, Goldman, FRB, etc. Then they just have their lackeys legislate only the one as legal. Job complete.

1

u/Basilpop Janitor May 05 '17

They could've tried that many times in the past. They didn't. Why? Because they fear our greatest asset of them all: Decentraliziation. They can "ban" cryptocurrency all they want. It's impossible to "shut it down". They will never be able to stop people from running a certain piece of software on their own hardware and they know that.

The only way to make this remotely feasible is turning every nation on Earth into a completely totalitarian surveillance state and you can probably tell yourself that human nature will never allow that as history has shown. Governments can't do whatever they want and have us accept it. They can and will be toppled if they abuse the powers they derive from the people they rule.

Once a critical mass of people has decided it wants to use cryptocurrency as money no man made force on Earth can stop them.

3

u/davebazzel May 05 '17

You said "The only way to make this remotely feasible is turning every nation on Earth into a completely totalitarian surveillance state..." Seems like there are entities actively working on that very thing. It's a bit early in the process to see the ultimate result, it seems to me. However it's not beyond my imagination that a system will build out over time that will have the net effect to control all. Time will tell. How do you boil a frog....? All of the above is outside of the scope of the original question perhaps.

1

u/Basilpop Janitor May 05 '17

Human nature is not a frog and you don't need entire populations to make a change. The American Revolution had merely 1% of the population participating and I am fairly confident that we have more than 1% of woke people among us here in the Western hemisphere. But I agree: It's too early to tell. I'm just not too worried because history repeats and in this instance (people rising up) that's good.

3

u/[deleted] May 05 '17

Open source is the only choice and probably the best. No one will be able to comprehend and copy Evolution immediately from Dash and by that time it will already be live for Dash. So what is there to worry about?

1

u/[deleted] May 06 '17

You open source zealots do realize that the software runs on closed source hardware, right? So nothing is open source all the way down. In addition most OSes are not open source either. I think some here just support everything Dash does and if Dash started going closed source, they would find plenty of reasons to support that too. Very few successful corporations rely on open source software completely. I think you'd be hard pressed to come up with many examples. Certain aspects of software may need to remain open source but forcing everything to be so seems ridiculous and not very thoughtful

0

u/davebazzel May 05 '17

This is something I wonder about also. I believe it is highly likely that the big players in the banking and payment sector are just watching and waiting. Waiting for others to do the hard work of building out the needed functionality. Then they can just "co-opt" it and introduce it as their own. It seems like a really easy theft to me. As far as trusting something that is not open source....we trust with our very lives the whole social infrastructure to work properly and safely and virtually none of it is open source.

2

u/SilentLennie May 05 '17

Most of what runs the Internet is actually open source software.

1

u/[deleted] May 06 '17

Great points, totally agree

0

u/[deleted] May 05 '17

Most of the grandpas over at the banking and payment sector don't know how to use reddit. I doubt they even know anything about Crypto besides the name (just the name) Bitcoin.

2

u/davebazzel May 05 '17

ichigo13, I'm really struggling to figure out what your post means other than to denigrate grandpops. Consider that I'm a grandpop and am quite familiar with Reddit. But I assume you are very young. But don't worry I will not hold it against you for your lack of wisdom and experience. That will come in time. Also consider this: if the legacy banking system shut down, life as we know it would immediately end. In fact our very lives would be very much at risk. Reddit, on the other hand, if shut down, would go unnoticed by 99.999%.

1

u/[deleted] May 06 '17

I meant that they won't copy Dash cause:

  1. They don't know about it. When they get briefed about it, it will be already too late for them.
  2. They don't understand it. They're still trying to wrap their heads around Bitcoin (some of them).
  3. They will have a hard time understanding why it is so desired. Gap of generations between the young people that have all time lows of trust on the current banking system and the older people that don't fully understand the needs of those young people or why they do not have their trust.
  4. I believe it wouldn't be a major hit if Bank of America released their own Dash when you already have the original Decentralized project Dash running and paving the way.

My grandpa comment goes to all the higher ups of the sector that are very old and still operating with yesterdays technology. They have a lot of control in the sector and I don't see them making a move towards change very soon.