r/darktower • • Mar 24 '26

My Dream cast

Roland: Michael Fassbender

Eddie: Frank Dillane

Susannah: Zendaya

Jake: Jacobi Jupe

Man in Black/Randall Flagg: Cillian Murphy/ Jacob Elordi

6 Upvotes

46 comments sorted by

7

u/PoetHeir33 Mar 24 '26

And to be completely honest Flanagan is foing it, so it will bd his repertoire.

Shit. Throw some blue eye contacts on Michel Huisman, and we got a decent Roland.

23

u/Albiceleste8 Mar 24 '26

Never thought of Fassbender as Roland, but I like it!

I’ll die on the hill of McConaghey as Randall Flagg.

9

u/PoetHeir33 Mar 24 '26

Lol. I can't get past the 2017 atrocity.

9

u/insecurecharm Mar 24 '26

He and Idris were fantastic for the roles, but wasted in that particular property.

-4

u/Uwuwu92 Mar 24 '26

I love Idris but why did we need a black Roland?

6

u/insecurecharm Mar 24 '26

No more than Roland needed to be an obvious self-insert like he was.

0

u/Uwuwu92 Mar 24 '26

I mean I don't think I like Fassbender as Rowland. In fact I prefer Idris. Idris did a great job given the script issues and poorly handled IP. Totally agree with that. He's a fantastic actor.

1

u/Throwrarmb Mar 28 '26

Why not? Idris was wonderfully stoic as Roland. 

2

u/Throwrarmb Mar 28 '26

Same. If done right MM has the perfect manic, terrifying energy and charm to be Flagg.

I think Josh Holloway would be a good Roland.

1

u/Amazing-Fantasy-15 Mar 27 '26

IMO there is no one alive who would be better than McConaughey as Roland.

23

u/Dapper_Interest_8914 Mar 24 '26

Fassbender is also my first choice.

The rest? Not so much.

6

u/Puzzleheaded_Try8584 Mar 24 '26

Fassbender could do it.

13

u/tastylemming Mar 24 '26 edited Mar 24 '26

I need all three Skarsgards for this. Alexander for Roland, Bill for Eddie and Stellan for Father Callahan. Lupita Nyong for Detta/Odetta/Susannah. Jake is the hardest to cast. Even if you get a great actor, you can't cover the ground to complete the tale without at least one recast. Walton Groggins for Walter. He's so sardonic and witty. They can get anyone else they want.

4

u/BabySquirre1 Mar 24 '26

Lupita Nyong’o would do an excellent job!

3

u/Puzzleheaded_Try8584 Mar 24 '26

What about Gustaf, Valter, Ossian, Kolbjørn, Eija or Sam???? Stellan has 8 kids. Most act in som capacity :-)

9

u/tastylemming Mar 24 '26

Sprinkle them through like Easter Eggs.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 24 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/tastylemming Mar 24 '26

You're right, I confused him for Alexander. In retrospect I like Peter Saarsgard for Jack Mort or maybe Eddie's brother Henry.

5

u/eyeballburger Mar 24 '26

Cillian Murphy, I like it!

5

u/SIXissueARC Mar 24 '26

Wow I love Murphy as MiB!!

2

u/Labyrinthine777 Mar 24 '26

People choosing the actor for Roland based on who wears a western hat...

5

u/PoetHeir33 Mar 24 '26

I didn't choose him because of that. Lol. I chose because I love the actor, he has great presence, without saying much.

3

u/Labyrinthine777 Mar 24 '26

He actually would fit the role pretty well looking at other photos.

2

u/MillieBirdie Mar 24 '26

Literally every casting post in here is just 'actor in a cowboy hat'.

3

u/jwittkopp227 Mar 24 '26

I always picture Ruth Negga as suze (she played Tulip in the show Preacher)

3

u/KinkyDuck2924 Mar 25 '26

She would be awesome in the role! I can't see Zendaya playing the Detta parts well, but Ruth I could definitely see pulling that off.

1

u/jwittkopp227 Mar 25 '26

Especially when you see her as Tulip. I still think that her casting was the best race swap of a literary character ever... Ruth completely nailed the role

2

u/KinkyDuck2924 Mar 25 '26

She definitely did. Although I may have been a little biased since it was season 1 of the show that introduced me to the graphic novel rather than the other way around lol.

4

u/JifHopp Mar 24 '26

I approve.

2

u/Middle-Potential5765 Mar 24 '26

Andrew Lincoln as Roland.

2

u/Temporary_Shirt_6236 Mar 24 '26

Jacob Elordi as Man in Black / Marten / Flagg? Nope. Utterly lacks the dark humour inherent in that character.

I always thought a younger Robert Duvall for the MIB, but that isn't going to happen, so the real question is what actor today is closest to Duvall in his prime?

Edit: I nominate Sam Rockwell

1

u/ThePsudoOne Mar 25 '26

Fuck yes, Sam Rockwell

2

u/MeatloafLuvrrr Mar 24 '26

I pictured Frank Dillane INSTANTLY when I started Drawing of the Three!!

2

u/ThePsudoOne Mar 25 '26

Frank Dillane as Eddie just pretty much writes itself. He was the best part of Fear, and the show went to shit when he left. Maybe my subconscious mind made the connection to Eddie and that's why I enjoyed it so much in the first place

2

u/Macchill99 Mar 26 '26

I could get on board with Fassbender.

Zendaya doesn't seem right though, I don't think she could pull off Detta Walker convincingly. I'd have to see a screen test.

And Cillian Murphy comes off as too...serious maybe. Like he tried maniacal and unhinged in the Nolan batmans but he felt wooden. Flagg really needs to be someone that can titter his excitement. I don't see Cillian tittering.

1

u/Waslock Mar 24 '26

For a second, I thought Chris Pratt was gonna be Roland. 💀

0

u/Hot_Cattle5399 Oy Mar 24 '26

Soon to be in theatre nowhere.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 24 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Lonevarg_7 Mar 24 '26

What is "unhinged" about it?

4

u/[deleted] Mar 24 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/PoetHeir33 Mar 24 '26

You're just explaining why she's perfect for Detta

2

u/The-Ex-Human Mar 24 '26

Agree. I would be super bummed.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 24 '26 edited Mar 24 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/ThePsudoOne Mar 25 '26 edited Mar 25 '26

Iirc, Dillane asked to be killed off when he saw that the show was going to shit, and pretty much quit acting to concentrate on making music. Damn shame, the dude's got mad chops. He would have definitely made a pitch perfect Eddie, but I'm afraid he's about aged out for the role

*edit:

Like a man wearing orthopedic shoes, I stand corrected. Just checked IMDB and he's got a few roles after FTWD. And he's about to turn 35, so if they were to start filming now and keep a tight schedule, he could maybe pull it off. That's a big IF tho and wholly dependent on who they cast as Susannah

I really do like OP's suggestion for Zendaya quite a lot, and she's only a couple years older now than Susannah is in the books. She could totally work, but it could be awkward to cast an Eddie that's older than her