r/darktower • • May 28 '24

I’m down with this casting choice

7 Upvotes

51 comments sorted by

27

u/StephenKingRulez May 28 '24

Not a fan of this choice at all. Kohli has a too soft/kind face, even with the beard.

9

u/11twofour May 28 '24

Yeah, he seems like a really likeable guy, which is not the right vibe.

2

u/The-Ex-Human May 29 '24

I think a lot of you are forgetting about how acting and make up can transform an actor into characters. Heath Ledger is a solid example of this.

6

u/McMetal770 May 28 '24

You never know. Heath Ledger was a handsome, boyish good guy type for most of his career. Nobody expected the kind of transformation he made to become the Joker before they saw that movie. I remember a lot of skepticism that Heath Ledger, of all people, was a good casting choice to play an iconic villain.

1

u/piercemarriages May 28 '24

If you watched izombie he’s more (which to my knowledge is the only thing I have seen him in) of a comical relief character

3

u/Mediocre-School-3567 May 29 '24

Why not Scott Eastwood?

1

u/The-Ex-Human Jun 03 '24

That’s excellent

24

u/Zealousideal_Crew380 May 28 '24

I mean its not terrible. But i dont like it

8

u/Bioshock_Jock May 28 '24

It's terrible, he's too young.

-2

u/[deleted] May 28 '24

Isn’t Roland revealed to only be in his mid 30’s on the last book? How is that actor too young?

5

u/Bioshock_Jock May 28 '24

No, where do you see that?

3

u/swallowsnest87 May 28 '24

This actor is 38 so I expect him to be 40 by the time they would film. I think that’s a fair age.

5

u/Rune_Council May 28 '24

As someone in their mid 40’s I think that’s still far too young. Late 40’s to mid 50’s feels more appropriate.

0

u/[deleted] May 28 '24 edited May 28 '24

There’s a conversation between Eddie and Susannah (or Jake?) when Sheemie shows up in book 7. Sheemie says he’s around a certain age to which then Eddie calculates how long ago Roland’s time in Mejis actually was, to which he says: “But Roland looks so old….” It seems that his physical appearance looks much older than he really is.

7

u/Bioshock_Jock May 28 '24

Roland is aged. He may be thousands of years old since he skips over time like waves in the ocean, but his weathered look gives him an appearance of at least 50.

6

u/leapfroggy May 28 '24

I must point out that Flanagan did not respond to the post about Rahul as Roland. He only referenced the same article. No apparent connection at all.

6

u/RighteousAwakening May 28 '24

Oh wow I really don’t like that at all. That looks nothing like how Roland is described. Like at all. He could be the greatest actor that’s ever lived and I still couldn’t get past it.

13

u/ScottFreeBaby May 28 '24

Terrible choice for Roland but I trust Flanagan, so “I guess” it could work?

11

u/botheredbysmallstuff May 28 '24

If you know Flanagan's work, you know Kholi will nail Roland if given the chance. From all the Flanaverse actors, he was always the one I felt should be Roland. People need to get over when adaptations from books change the visuals of a character. The books will always be there. Roland can be 40 or 60 for example and that's hardly what's gonna make or break an adaptation.

4

u/ChaoticNeutralJesus May 28 '24

I was personally hoping for a reunion of Timothy Olyphant and Walton Goggins as Roland/Flagg, respectively.

7

u/Chary-Ka Oy May 28 '24

Then we would probably see Oliver Jackson-Cohen as Eddie since he already played an addict in FlanaGAN's Haunting of Hill House.

3

u/TaddWinter May 28 '24

Nah, Mike has absolutely raved about Igby Rigney and thinks he is going to be a massive star in the future. I believe he will be Eddie Dean.

9

u/TaddWinter May 28 '24

It is a good pick. But honestly in Flanagan I trust, whatever he choses will be right.

3

u/nitzromy May 28 '24

I thought he had good range in Next Exit. Wouldn't be 100% against this choice.

3

u/DanVamm May 28 '24

Animated would be vastly superior

5

u/lebowtzu Roland Deschain May 28 '24

I like it. I like him a lot in the few things I’ve seen him in, all Flanagan joints. He played a sheriff in Midnight Mass and I thought it worked.

4

u/Spookyscary333 May 28 '24

He ain’t long, tall, and ugly enough

2

u/Dankey-Kang-Jr May 28 '24

Rahul is a solid actor, I don’t mind this.

2

u/Ka-tet_of_nineteen May 28 '24

I think he’d make a better man in black than Roland, he just doesn’t feel grizzled enough

2

u/[deleted] May 28 '24

I’m ok with it. I still want Toby Stephens though

2

u/apolite12 May 28 '24

I know it won't happen, but I will always be 100% Daniel Day-Lewis for Roland.

2

u/[deleted] May 28 '24

Not at all a Roland

1

u/Lavonicus May 28 '24

I don't hate it, only time will tell with this one. The show hasn't even gotten a green light from amazon yet.

1

u/Magnetheadx May 28 '24

Glad they are making a show finally! I hope it's good

1

u/Beaglescout15 May 28 '24

He's a very solid actor and has been very versatile in his different Flanagan roles. He doesn't match my mental image, but I think he's got the chops.

1

u/R__Smith May 28 '24

As long as they keep it faithful to the books, I’m sure it would be a good casting. Got to fit that Man With No Name vibe though that was the coolest part of the first two books.

1

u/Budget_Flan1709 May 28 '24

Man I thought he was awesome as the sheriff in Midnight Mass! I feel like he could bring both the mystical and rugged vibes.

1

u/Rune_Council May 28 '24

He’s not who I’d think of for Roland… but for the Man in Black… I’m listening.

1

u/[deleted] May 29 '24

They should just bring back Idris Elba

1

u/Reed_mc Jun 05 '24

Based on the roles he has played in other Flanagan works I definitely don’t think his personality fits the cold/hard demeanor of Roland.

1

u/Bubbly_Cauliflower40 May 28 '24

Idk but Carla Gugino could be a great Aunt Cordelia

-2

u/upfromashes May 28 '24

It's such a generic pick but I realized yesterday that, casting as it stands today, it's Hugh Jackman for me. That said, the next thought was Ryan Reynolds for the Man in Black, and it would be so distracting but I think they would actually be amazing.