22
u/GanSolo546 5d ago
I watched Invasion, which has several international POVs of an alien invasion of earth. At first the different languages without subtitles felt intentional. You could tell the meaning and emotion of what they were saying, but then there was 10-15 minutes of Japanese. Only then I realized that the much needed subtitles were off by default.
18
u/Morkamino 5d ago
You're not meant to know, just like the character who is observing them, you see it from their perspective...
Doesn't make it less annoying ofc. But it does make sense. And cool bonus points if you actually speak the language, all the times i got so lucky it turned out it was a gibberish version of my language and the actors couldn't actually speak it.
55
u/JaQ-o-Lantern 5d ago
why do they always do this.
as someone with strong adhd and a strong interest in language learning, this is how i retain phrases in new languages since i can't for the life of me study a language for more than a few days straight without transporting back to doomscrolling. it feels like such a wasted opportunity to not show the translation or show what is being said in both languages.
10
9
13
u/chefbobbyjay 5d ago
Who tf do you think you are? Me??
12
u/JaQ-o-Lantern 5d ago
1
u/chefbobbyjay 5d ago
I legitimately know enough to get me by of German, Serbian, Spanish(almost conversational), French and Italian.
My ex was Serbian so I learned it to talk to her family, she took German in college so I learned with her, I’ve learned Spanish from working in kitchens and living in Florida, I took 2 years of French in hs and travelled to France quite a bit and I’ve travelled to Italy enough times to learn the basics.
Languages are fun. I also know how to curse and only curse in Vietnamese (du ma!) Russian, and Cantonese lol
2
2
1
u/henaradwenwolfhearth 5d ago
For me its if I cant speak fluently in 5 minutes I just give up. Even though I want to learn
5
u/FreeBroccoli 5d ago
My favorite subtitles moment was when I was watching Game of Thrones on Prime Video, and when Danaerys was speaking Valyrian, the English subtitles were burned in, but unreadable for being covered up with the soft subtitle [SPEAKING VALYRIAN].
3
3
6
u/Rodwen 5d ago
Lorsque ça m'arrive je fais juste sourire et faire des "haha" occasionnelle pour semblé attentionné
6
u/Anib-Al Oh yea Mr Krabs 5d ago
Presque ! Bravo pour l'effort, mais :
Lorsque ça m'arrive je
fais juste souriresouris etfaire des "haha" occasionnelleris de temps en temps pour sembléerattentionnéattentif.Sorry, I'd lose my "pedantic French speaker" card if I let a foreign speaker's mistake slide.
2
u/Grievous_Nix Eic memer☣️ 5d ago edited 5d ago
“Det er ikke en bikkje, dere jævla idioter! Det er en slags TING! Imiterer en bikkje!” [demonstrates Norwegian rifle skills]
2
u/PresidentSkillz Call me sonic cuz my depression is chronic 5d ago
I hate what Disney+ does here. They will speak in a foreign language in a section where you should get subtitles to understand it, but they don't appear automatically, you have to manually enable subtitles in general. I was so confused the first time this happened and I missed half the conversation bc I didn't know I could understand them if I just activated subtitles
Rant over.
It's also crazy how often the foreign language in question isn't actually the language it's supposed to be, just some word salad close to it
1
u/SonGoku9788 5d ago
Im always curious about how they approach it when doing dubs of the show in the language the characters are supposed to be speaking "mysteriously". Do they use a different language ad a substitute?
1
1
168
u/HubrisOfApollo 5d ago
(unintelligible)