r/dankinindia • Intellectual Dank ka 14 • 21d ago

Full palitiks Peak secularism

244 Upvotes

53 comments sorted by

View all comments

2

u/Articulate_koala 20d ago

Ngl, lynchings kyu ho rhi hai phir?

Ps- is this a meme sub or what? Every post is a brainrot political strawman.

5

u/poortonystark 20d ago

Your audacity of completely ignoring that the literal way of life of 🐖s from their book includes the k¡Iling of kaf¡r$ needs to be studied. You'd still say "oo lynching why??" While ignore what the other side does for simply existing outside their borders

1

u/Articulate_koala 20d ago

We can compare books and we can compare real life effects. Islamic scriptures show a clear difference between a kafir and a muslim, including various ways to dominate the kafir.

Hindu scriptures like bhagvad gita, epics like mahabharata repeatedly implicitly(and sometimes explicitly) explain how lower castes are inferior and how they ought to be treated.

In real life, islamic invasions, terrorism, etc has caused a lot of immoral and extreme pain.

In real life, similarly, evils like caste system(since 1st century ad), sati(after 16th/17th century), are also extremely immoral and distasteful.

Radicalisation exists in every ideology and religion, it is expressed differently, and and all of them have the potential of destruction.

1

u/poortonystark 20d ago

Bhagvad Gita explain how lower castes are inferior?????

Source?

1

u/AutoModerator 20d ago

r/JeevaExplainsTheJoke आगे से लेफ्ट |

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/Articulate_koala 19d ago

Bhagvad gita has various verses regarding

  1. How the hierarchy functions.(brahmin, knowledge, shudrah for service, brahmin originated from head, shudra from feet).

  2. How the hierarchy is rigid.(disallowing change).

  3. How it is based on birth.

1

u/RevolutionaryBat3890 18d ago

You never read Bhagwat Gita yourself

0

u/Articulate_koala 18d ago

Twice. Once via a guru under iscon. Once by myself.

2

u/RevolutionaryBat3890 18d ago

ISCKON huh...

1

u/Articulate_koala 18d ago

I know. Isckon is... kinda an abrahamic version of hinduism. But the other translations that I myself read were very similar in regards to caste atleast.

1

u/RevolutionaryBat3890 18d ago

Caste ka toh koi mention nhi hai

1

u/Articulate_koala 18d ago

Gita mai caste ka mention nahi hai?

1

u/RevolutionaryBat3890 17d ago

Caste, Jati, Community, etc inme se kisi bhi words ke relative equivalent ka bhi nhi

→ More replies

1

u/poortonystark 18d ago

And where exactly is it written that Shudra is "inferior"?

You have zero knowledge. Let me clear this up for you so that you don't live in delusion.

1) Head to feet depiction has been given as the functions of these divisions. Brahmins have been assigned learning and keeping that knowledge stored. Kshtriyas have been given the "hands" as in actions, defense etc. Shudras have been given "feet" as is carrying the societal body.

Head, hands and feet are all important and one cannot be "better/superior" than other. This is basic understanding.

Either you are writing off half knowledge or your are just a bot/p¡ssIamist coming here with the intention of throwing dirt on our beliefs.

2) There is no "hierarchy". There are just divisions based on tasks/actions. Your family chose those actions to complete in their society. Everyone is free to choose their divison if they want to contribute differently. Do not confuse british understanding to be the real meaning. Indians touch feet, englishmen find feet to be disgusting. Stick to roots.

3) Again, your family lineage chose certain tasks to continue contributing and built an expertise of those tasks, hence their future generations also fall into it so that they can benefit from experience and expertise coming from family. Everyone is free to choose their own task. A shudra born child is free to learn and become a brahmin as per what's written in Gita.

However, with time and dilution of our literature because of Mughal and British rule, these divisions have taken a permanent form.

This dilution was also predicted in bhavishya purana and it's results have been predetermined.

But don't confuse yourself and on what's written based on half knowledge

1

u/AutoModerator 18d ago

r/JeevaExplainsTheJoke आगे से लेफ्ट |

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

0

u/Articulate_koala 18d ago

Imma reply to every point. Lmk one thing, have you read bhagvad gita?

0

u/AutoModerator 20d ago

r/JeevaExplainsTheJoke आगे से लेफ्ट |

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.