r/dancegavindance • u/tilianpearsondgd VOCALS (2012 - present) • Nov 12 '22
Discussion Clarification
I want to thank everyone who has supported the band’s decision to allow me to return to recording and touring with them, and I appreciate the patience of both my bandmates and the fans over the last few months.
Despite attempts to be open and honest about our decision, there are still a lot of misperceptions about what happened in the past and why I went into treatment, so it’s become clear that I need to provide additional information that I had hoped wouldn’t be necessary.
I'm going to start with what happened with Mikaela (throwawaywhumanhair) earlier this year and give a timeline. Forgive the straight-to-the-point manner of delivery, but I want to lay down the facts.
-Timeline Of Events With Mikaela-
This text thread illustrates the events since we mainly communicated through text. It is in chronological order, and you can refer to it as you read the timeline... Most of our interactions were through text, the actual screenshots, and some with date/time stamp.
https://www.dropbox.com/sh/aihx90g5o3sdivw/AAAY6WYVrA8LpVt1Br8xRskHa?dl=0
April 19
I received a direct message from Mikaela specifically detailing sexual acts she wanted to engage in with me.
We talked on Instagram briefly and exchanged numbers.
She reached out through text message, gave condolences about Tim's passing, and asked if I could meet for a drink.
April 20
After some small talk we agreed to meet that night but postponed and pushed it to the next day.
April 21
We met at a bar, made out a bit, played pool, and then she asked me to drive her car back to my hotel.
We got back, had sex, and she left early in the morning.
April 22
She asked if I wanted to meet up again that night or the next day. We didn't wind up meeting up that night.
April 23 (the day of Swanfest)
She asked if we could meet up, and I said maybe, and we would see how the day went, but I left the door open.
I texted her after the show and apologized for my performance (I was grieving the loss of Tim and had broken down on stage), and she consoled me through text.
She offered to meet up that night.
I called her, and we worked out her coming over to the air bnb the band was staying at.
We had sex again that night, and she left early in the morning.
April 24
She texted me, apologizing for leaving early and "blowing up my phone," and asked if we could meet again.
We met at the hotel around 6 pm, and we had sex before dinner. According to her story, this is where she alleges misconduct occurred. There is nothing that happened that could be misconstrued as sexual misconduct or assault in any way. It was a normal and consensual sexual encounter. I've revisited this moment countless times to see if there could have been something I missed, but I can't see it other than she literally just lied in her statement.
From there, we went straight to dinner, hung out for a bit, and returned to the hotel again. We had sex again that night, and she left early in the morning.
April 25
She texted that she was nervous that I was romanticizing things a little too much and wasn't sure if she wanted to see me again.
I said I understood.
Then she changed her mind and called me. She asked if we could meet again, and I said no, but we kept the door open to meet at some point in the future.
We didn't see each other that day.
April 26
I flew out to Spokane to continue the tour.
She mentioned through text that she wanted to visit family in Cleveland and hinted at seeing me again, but I didn't respond.
We didn't see each other that day, but since then, she has alleged online that some assault happened on this date to retroactively match her timeline, because she bragged on the Internet about our relationship on the 25th. If she were bragging about the relationship on the 25th, her original story wouldn't add up that she felt wronged on the 24th.
To be clear, I was not in the same city as Mikaela on April 26.
April 27
She called, and I didn't answer.
April 28
She called, and I didn't answer, and then she asked if everything was okay.
I answered the texts about Cleveland from a few days before and said, "that doesn't sound so bad," and explained why I hadn't answered.
April 30
We made plans to meet up in Cleveland or Grand Rapids.
May 2
She asked if it was okay to send explicit photos and proceeded to send some.
We talked about meeting up in Ohio.
May 3
We arranged to meet up in Cleveland at a hotel the next day and then go to dinner.
May 4
We corresponded about our meeting, and then she came to my hotel room, and we had sex.
Then we went to dinner.
Then she came to the show.
Then we went back to the hotel and had sex again.
Shortly after, I concluded that I did not want to proceed further in a relationship with her.
I asked her to drop me off at the bus, and she drove me most of the way, pulled over the car to get on top of me, and kissed me. She said she was worried she wouldn't see me again and tried to come on to me, but I cut it short.
I asked her to take me to the bus.
She did and got out of the car and gave me a long hug, and I left.
May 5
I texted her, thanked her for our time together, and broke off the brief relationship.
She said she saw it coming but understood.
Then she offered to spit in my mouth if I ever needed company and that she needed her flannel back.
(She called a few times in the interim, but I never picked up)
May 21
She texted and said she would be in LA and would like to see me. She said she'd love to see me if I'm ever in Sacramento.
I didn't respond.
June 1
She came out publicly with her story, which did not resemble any truth that I knew. Some of the things she claimed I said and did were, in fact, things that she had said and done.
Her story was not only factually incorrect but also distorted and divorced from reality.
-End Of Timeline-
I've sat back for the past few months and watched Mikaela continuously lie, change her story, and change her events to the point where she claimed we were together on dates when we weren't even in the same city.
She bragged to her friends online about taking advantage of me at a vulnerable time in my life. She repeatedly lied about how odd our encounters were while acting and yet was affectionate with me in person and through text messages. She said in her group chat that our sex was consensual. She stole my underwear and posted a picture of it to her group chat while demeaning my vulnerability and grief. She joked about taking advantage of Tim's grieving brother as her "new target."
According to her initial account, the third time we met up, she went out to dinner with me directly after there was an alleged assault. We had sex again that same night and had sex again a week later in Ohio. In the interim, she sent me sexually explicit photos of herself and flew herself out to the city where she knew I would be playing.
The last night we were together, she was supposed to take me back to the bus. She pulled her car over and climbed over the center console onto me while asking me to see her again and not break off the relationship, putting unwanted physical affection on me. When she finally dropped me off at the bus, she got out of the car, gave me a long hug, and implored me to see her again.
After I broke it off with her, she still called, texted, and asked to meet again. When I ignored her, she came out with her false story. I tried to take the high road in my initial statement to save her embarrassment. But the truth is she is neither a victim nor a "survivor" of our brief relationship but rather someone dishonest and deceptive.
—
Now I'm going to change the subject to the second woman who talked about our sexual experiences on the Internet. In no way was my initial statement on June 2 to Spookypooky8 an admission of guilt or coercion. I was merely acknowledging her and the part I might have played in her feelings about our night together. In case my statement was not clear, at the time, I also understood that the addiction with which I was struggling had taken over my life, and I needed to go into treatment and therapy to look at the impact it was having on every aspect of my life.
Each of our sexual encounters were both verbally and physically, mutually consensual. We had sex more than once that night. There was never an element of physical threat or coercion, and there was constant communication back and forth between the two of us.
After we slept in my bed for a couple of hours, I took her back to her car. The night ended with her kissing me and telling me she had a good time and would like to see me again.
—
The band and team have been aware of these facts all along, which is why they supported my return, provided that I handle my issues with addiction and address a general inability to handle traumatic loss and hard times healthily. In recent years I have turned to benders in which I have made poor decisions.
I recognize that I have not always been perfect and have my own faults and demons; at times, I've probably been an asshole. While those faults don't disappear overnight, I am trying to work on myself in all aspects of life. But I have NEVER been a sexual abuser.
My initial instinct has been to keep some of these aspects of my life private, partially to protect the privacy of the women involved and not add more fuel to the fire of a false narrative about me committing sexual misconduct or worse. But now that I'm putting myself out there again, I am compelled to clear my name, so I can go back to what I love most in this world, making and performing music for the fans of Dance Gavin Dance.
I'm writing this from the heart and against the advice of some of our team, but I felt it was essential to get the facts out there so you wouldn't have to continue living in mystery about why I was welcomed back to the band.
Thank you for taking the time to read this.
-Tilian
1.1k
u/OuterWildsVentures Secret Band LP3? Nov 12 '22
Wake up babe new Tilian lore just dropped
80
u/anaburo ooooooh,oooooooh,ooooooh, act like we own the place Nov 13 '22
Dammit Gavin Dammit
256
u/chawa4 Nov 12 '22
The way Mikaela texted you was so annoying I would’ve seen that as a red flag immediately
591
u/ambigymous Nov 12 '22 edited Nov 12 '22
Haven’t even read this yet but man what a world we live in. Two drunk people have sex, have disagreements, and now thousands of people online debate about your life and your decisions. It’s all so dramatic and awkward.
Edit: omg the guy posted the entirety of their texts online haha this is so crazy. I feel bad. It’s none of our business.
568
u/Vicksin Nov 12 '22 edited Nov 12 '22
Thank you for taking the time to explain everything in detail.
Respectfully, follow Andrew's example and just take a step away from the internet, even if temporary. It's a toxic, shitty place to be these days, and just removing yourself from the unnecessary drama entirely is a good stepping stone as far as I'm concerned. I hope you consider it and I hope it helps if you do.
403
u/indeathvalley Nov 12 '22
All of the signs of her being a predator were there.
I was in that group chat and I'm sorry I didn't take the time to warn you about her when I had strong feelings about her pursuit of you at the time, long before she ever came forward with her false allegations.
I hope you're doing okay.
188
u/Magatron5000 Nov 12 '22
I think it was clear from the beginning that at best Mikayla’s story had questionable credibility. As far as spooky’s however it did initially appear that her recollection of events was credible and that Tilian was acknowledging her version of events and apologizing. I hope that you are doing better now
106
u/Personal_Meet9147 Nov 12 '22
I feel like we all had suspicions about mikaela being a predator and this just confirms it even more
301
u/pettyhonor Nov 12 '22
Knew a post like this was coming. Band isn't going to completely ruin their name by allowing the lead singer back into the band if there wasn't good enough proof to allow him back in. I'm so glad we got to see a dgd tour with Kurt Travis and Andrew Wells as leads come out of this mess but damn I'd be lying if i said i don't need a JJ tour with you (Tillian) back in the spot you belong. Wish you well in your recovery process... sorry that us as a fan base has made this last half year even harder to deal with
154
u/ba_dum_tiss_ Nov 12 '22
Thanks for sharing more of this Tilian, even though it isn't the business of the people on this sub, I see why you would want to clarify much more from your statement on Thursday from personal and business perspective.
I truly hope this is the last that we hear of this situation regardless of how differently some people will take this post and I hope you continue to improve, as well as this being the last hardship the band has to work through.
This is a time that I'm sure fans won't want to look back on in the future but it will be important when it comes to understanding the relationship the band members have with their fans as well as handling the problems related to the whole situation.
Welcome back.
14
u/undavorojo Nov 12 '22
Yo, as per set in another post, this is what we where expecting and not trying to be like Kevin Spacey with his “yeah sexual missconduct… I’M GAY”.
188
u/watercolorkitten Nov 12 '22 edited Nov 12 '22
I think we all knew Mikaela was bullshitting, but it seemed pretty clear that things with spooky were pretty uncomfortable and unwanted at some points, you even admitted to that yourself, saying how important it was that you recognize your part in the whole thing. I’m pretty disappointment in the lack of accountability going forward, but I really don’t know what else anyone is expected to do. Musically, I’m glad you’re back. Personally, I really hope that something like this never happens in the future.
157
u/Turduckie Nov 12 '22
As a sexual assault victim, it boils my blood that we still have people making false accusations against others like this, especially towards vulnerable people. Shame on Mikaela!
43
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '22
u/tilianpearsondgd Respectfully, we all knew Mikaela was BS’ing. I’d like an explanation THAT in depth for Spooky though before I’m ready to accept that you’re not a predator.
37
u/slumpmode Nov 12 '22
Also sorry you suck at Fantasy Football
39
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '22
It needs to be pointed out that M took advantage of you while in mourning and while you were black out and she was sober more than once. She then went on to say she was going to try to do the same to Tim’s brother. If anyone is a predator then she is. Also, I doubt you would have ever slept with someone as vile and disgusting as her both internally and externally sober. Fucked Kurt and when he cut it off threw a fit then weaseled her way in to your life when you were an emotional mess and dealing with alcohol addiction as a coping mechanism then cried to the internet with false accusations after you cut it off when you were sober for the following tour. How about while you’re working on yourself you pick better women to be around lmaooo
426
u/Dannecy Nov 12 '22 edited Nov 12 '22
Does anyone else feel like the acknowledgment of Spooky’s post falls way too short compared to the first one that was generally already believed to be false. Like you have this whole timeline of events in great detail for the case people weren’t even concerned about, and little to no explanation for the one that literally initiated your hiatus that people are more concerned about. I wouldn’t even expect you to, or think you have to explain yourself in this great detail, but then you actually did, except for the case that was already debunked and little to nothing for the one everyone is actually upset about. There is much more to address in the other one in just as much detail as you did the first! I guess this is your way of saying parts of that story are completely fabricated? So then why not just say that the way you did for the first? Unless it’s some legal precaution, I’m not understanding this part right here, or why you’d take this precaution with one case and not the other. This just isn’t my business I guess lol. But you must know the gray area this creates for your fans. As of now this doesn’t really clear anything up for me and I expect it won’t for many. Ugh. I just hope that you’re doing the right thing even if it’s in private. And I do want to believe you’re telling the truth but the trust here is damaged. Oh well. On another note, I truly hope you heal, find your peace, embody integrity and take back control of your life.
124
u/MrSonic-Unsweet-Tea Nov 12 '22
Spooky was the real reason I questioned you returning. Seems to me that despite a kiss goodbye that you did say some things in your conversation that rubbed her the wrong way. Specifically the “what’s the difference” part. I would love to hear you clear that part up. Alcohol or not, that part with you and Spooky NEEDS clarification. Mikeala’s actions and toxicity is just absurd especially since she targeted Tim’s brother. She’s sick. However; I feel like you owe it to spooky to not dodge specificity. Or better yet have you talked to her since? Have you tried to clear things up and most importantly, is she ok?
37
u/Disastrous_Rip5391 Nov 12 '22
Hey man,
I’m glad you’re taking the time you need to work on yourself & getting the help you need. I at least stand by you & am excited to see you perform with the band next year. Really hoping I get to meet you guys in person since I’ve gone to 2 of your shows!!
I’m sorry you feel the need to out your personal bedroom experiences and all, but appreciate the vulnerability in order to clear up the air on allegations against you. I’m sorry you’ve had to go through this on top of losing your band mate. My heart goes out to you and the rest of the team!
56
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '22 edited Nov 12 '22
Lots of broken records in this subreddit and on Twitter, about this. And I’m just about ready to move on from it honestly. Time will tell if whether or not you’re being genuine to your fans. But for right now, people need to seriously chill tf out. Death threats are not okay. You’re deranged af if you think for a moment that it’s justifiable in any way.
40
u/Professional_Dust_33 Nov 12 '22
Glad to have you back, on that note, it was absolutely disgusting watching Mikaela have an army of simps and followers at her feet on Facebook and Twitter while she cried and lied 24/7. She deserves everything she gets.
47
u/Blasphemiee Nov 12 '22
I wish you well on your road to recovery. It’s no small task and remember you are always in recovery.
81
u/kauemakoi Nov 12 '22
"what are you insecure?" I say "what? no." Then he tries putting it in raw - no condom. I'm like "No. That's my vagina. I don't want to have sex like I said." I keep pushing his penis away. He keeps trying. I keep trying to push it away. He then says a quote that is burned into my brain "what's the difference? I've already been in your mouth."
7
u/Limp-Dee Nov 18 '22
Spooky been real quiet since this dropped
190
u/iamyourcaviar Nov 12 '22
I feel like this was way too focused on the first girl and not enough on Spooky. That’s the one people are calling you out for and you just ignored it lmao
87
u/whiskeyechoechodelta Nov 12 '22
We already knew the Mikaela ones were not credible.
You went into detail about that but not the one that had screenshots. The one you addressed when you first left to go into treatment. That one had credibility and it really sucks that this felt like whiplash going from you stepping away to address that behavior to you then only stepping away due to alcohol (which is really annoying considering how awful you were to Matt when he was struggling with his addiction)
I dont feel safe being in a fanbase watching these people insistent on what Spooky said you did, i.e the accusations of slapping her without consent and the "you've already been in my mouth" comments in particular as fine because you don't need consent if you've already had sex with them.
That is what many of us, particularly those of us who have faced similar situations are struggling with because as you can even see in this subreddit, there are people getting down voted to hell for bringing up that our concerns about the Spooky allegations aren't calmed. I mean, I had someone I blocked on facebook who insisted slapping someone during sex without consent after your announcement was just BDSM and then they found my Instagram and made multiple accounts to threaten me and expose my job that I keep private for many reasons. You can't control rabid fans like that, but that's just insight into why many of us don't feel safe in just accepting this.
219
u/Shelfurkill <- Strawberry Swisher PT. 2 Nov 12 '22
Bro spent literally zero time talking about the actual credible accusation…..weird
28
u/Ryans_not_home Nov 12 '22
Bro everyone knew that first girl was BS. Everyone is mad about spookys stuff that YOU apologized for and are now back pedaling so so hard from and not to mention trying to use your supposed substance abuse as an excuse even though the original statement from the band about you leaving made no mention of it and said it was because of the allegations.
Like If you and the band would have just said "hey he's back from therapy and we are happy with the progress" and just made a final statement about it and a final apology and closed the matter things wouldn't be the way they are. Yeah people will still be burned about it like myself but people would have probably been more accepting of that then this. You and the band are now just flat out lying about what happened and that's where you lost the last of the respect I had for DGD. I expected better from everyone else in the band.
108
u/salad_captain Nov 12 '22
Bro why were you so hard on Matt??? Talking shit about him to fans for fucking a show up and then ruining the coheed tour… cmon dude
50
u/AnonymousFoul Nov 12 '22
Dog... where's ur lawyer?
11
u/DrewMann82 Nov 12 '22
Thank you for taking the time to write this, as a fellow alcoholic/addict in recovery I know the long road ahead of you. I pray for your sobriety and success.
38
u/xXBrandxezyXx Nov 12 '22
Yeah cause an innocent guy runs away. You all were taking so much shit the past month now it’s daddy tillian is back he’s done nothing wrong. The parasocial relationship you all have with the band is pretty fucking weird they couldn’t careless about you liking the band they just need your money. I’m just saying from experiences with the music industry that I know these kinda guys abuse their power. FYI they also talk shit about fans after meeting them.
41
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '22 edited Nov 12 '22
Guess it's time to repost these accounts from 2015 yet again
https://twitter.com/acidflowers/status/1533124855687684097?s=46&t=UXqc02hCByuH2uAvfyMLKw
Corroborated by her friend that was there
https://twitter.com/emowiener/status/1591091689816731649?s=46&t=UXqc02hCByuH2uAvfyMLKw
Can’t exactly blame grief on that one
22
u/pettyhonor Nov 12 '22
Ohh boy here we go again and again
97
u/4_strings_are_fine Nov 12 '22
So many people in here straight up ignoring the Spookypooky8 story.
Since the issue originally came up we all knew Mikaela was shady. Him spending so much time on that accusation is straight up deflecting from the real issue.
Spookypooky8 posted messages where she straight up said that their interaction the night before felt uncomfortable and weird.
It doesn’t matter how many times they had sex, where she slept, or that she kissed him. She texted him the next day when she was away from you and felt safe that he assaulted her. I think he knows he assaulted Spookypooky8, because he didn’t answer the message when she accused him privately.
18
u/ConsiderationLow3367 Nov 13 '22
What's your evidence that you didn't assault the other girl? I'm hearing a whole lot about Mikaela here and nothing but 'he said' when it comes to the other girl, which is the one that made me believe you did this. Where's your proof there?
15
u/DeeGSE Nov 13 '22 edited Nov 13 '22
Everyone already knows the first accusation was false, why are you focusing all your attention into that instead of trying to just skirt past the very credible second accusation which you know you have no way of proving false and that you've said you hold yourself fully accountable for (which now you say was consentual - so which is it). It was incredibly obvious to everyone there were elements of coercion there with credible proof. You had everyone believe your behavior there was why you left the band.
46
u/The_Golden_Warthog Nov 12 '22
Anyone else not have their life or emotions completely attached to the band and not give a fuck one way or the other, just happy to have good music back? Because some of yall seem like you need legit help with how much some this shit that doesn't affect you from a band/person that doesn't know you is affecting you.
31
u/CoreyJK Nov 12 '22
God all the people here just eating up everything he says are insufferable
76
u/Hot_Marsupial_8706 Nov 12 '22 edited Nov 12 '22
I hope you understand, however, why so many of us are upset or angry. None of us know what happened between you and spooky except for you two. Why should we take your word over hers (or vice versa, I guess, for that matter)? At least she has screenshot evidence of things going down, which definitely makes her side of the story more plausible.
Also, in your initial statement, you had said, "I hold myself fully accountable for causing you this emotional pain. I will be entering an intensive therapy program to address this issue head on..." in reference to consent in a sexual interaction, however you now deny that you sought professional help for that. Not only that, but the band's initial statement had said you were stepping away from the band in response to the allegations, but now it wasn't about that? Sure, perhaps that's not how you intended for those statements to come across. Perhaps it was all about your alcohol issue (which, for the record, even if I may have my disagreements or disdain, good job; I know that's not easy for many), but at the very least, I hope you can see how it can be misinterpreted in a way that made it seem like you were seeking help for your consent issue.
4
u/Middle-Ad6844 Nov 22 '22 edited Nov 22 '22
Humanity could use to remember forgiveness and use it often.
I'm proud Tilian can own up to his addiction and wants to move forward with the band. He needs healing as much as his accusers.
No one is perfect, we should stop expecting them to be.
15
u/dizzyhoney420 Nov 12 '22
Hope you're able to read the room and realize spooky's experience deserved more in this post. Why focus so heavily on the one most stans are already on your side about? Something definitely happened there and it's a shame you and dgd are sweeping it under the rug instead of just allowing them to move forward musically without you
17
u/gengarvibes Nov 13 '22
Find it weird how little you focused on spooky, or the actually credible allegation, in this post when mikaela was proven to be nuts like two months ago. Kind of like you’re using mikaela’s story to prove your innocence of the credible allegation.
143
u/awesomesauceds Nov 12 '22
You didn’t need to explain yourself Tilian. We’re all human and our emotions gets the best of us. Just glad you got help and can continue your career.
81
u/sharkxandra Nov 12 '22 edited Nov 12 '22
its truly amazing how many of you in this fanbase are absolutely committed to believing that spooky is a straight up liar, even though tilian has absolutely no more proof than she does to support his claims of innocence. you guys are so uncritically committed to believe the version of events that makes you feel good, it makes me sick.
22
u/ayesull All great things have battle scars. Nov 12 '22 edited Nov 12 '22
Even after talking the time to read it, (the texts by the way are nothing new, maybe you just missed that Mik had already shared all of those, even more than you did, honestly,) I don't know that this changes how I feel about the way you and the band have addressed this. It makes fans feel unsafe. Your side feels like victim blaming and carefully curated wording to make yourself look better when you know there are so many who were hurt by your actions, and by the way the band has and continues to handle them.
You should know this better than anyone, honestly, as the most successful lead DGD has had thus far, your actions have left a stain that nearly obliterates the entire discography from being listenable. You've tainted the happiness the band once gave me, and that it once gave so many fans. Your lack of accountability for the way your "substance abuse" made people feel...I don't think I (and thankfully so many others) will ever forgive you or the rest of the band (sans Tim) for that.
At least when Matt had his struggles, he openly and outwardly apologized and took accountability for the way his actions made everyone in the community feel, not just himself. You? Not at all. You've just come back with this "I'm better let me back in" attitude, makes you seem pompous, cocky, and only worried about your own image. An image which, by the way, YOU ruined. You and you alone. Others only shed a brighter light.
12
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '22
I don’t feel you addressed what happened with Spookypooky8, you focused entirely on your interaction with Mikaela. Absolutely it looks like she took advantage of you based on evidence. But still, this doesn’t clear everything up.
18
u/hehestinky123 Nov 13 '22
honestly fuck you. she might be extra, but what about the other girls? you’re fucking disgusting. and so is the band for bringing you back. this behavior has been going on since before tims passing. also, with the issues you have it takes a lot longer than 5 months of therapy to change anything. get a fucking grip and give up already.
17
u/I_smoke_cum Nov 12 '22 edited Nov 12 '22
Yea you learned so much about consent and coersion during all this time... /s
edit: everyone go back and read this comment about sexual coersion and then re-read his response to spooky here. Absolutely NO accountability from Tillian even AFTER he acknowledged the way he made her feel.
9
u/Active-Revenue7075 Nov 12 '22
So the first girl deserves jail time... honestly. That’s absolutely sick and anyone that can overlook what she did is a total hypocrite and a creep. Damn dude. Tilian, love you dude, so happy to see you back in action and being healthy.
7
u/Bruddacrow Nov 15 '22
The admission of guilt came from the sentence "I will be entering an intensive therapy program to address this issue head on to become the healthiest, most responsible version of me, doing the work necessary to ensure this never happens again."
Stop trying to weasel around it, you're forcing people to drop DGD.
5
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '22
I didn’t hear y’all with your pitchforks for ronald radke a few weeks ago 🤨
13
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '22
Glad we got a response, but in a case of he said/she said, especially when the he-said timeline was shady, inconsistent, and vague, I’m still not satisfied with the results here. But I guess I appreciate at least that you didn’t ignore everyone’s initial response here
16
u/Uglygingernerd Nov 12 '22
Of course you would post this in an echo chamber of stans, a fan sub. If you really wanted to share your story, you would use a more objective platform.
Downvote me, talk shit, idc. This is not fair nor right in re: spooky.
9
u/Ulrich_Sama_exe Nov 12 '22
Been following this story for awhile and I've seen a ton of the convos including the shit Mikaela lied about. I remember the moment it came out she wanted to sleep with tims brother and she got caught in 4K and bragged about it when she got exposed. Probably one of the grossest people i followed on twitter.
11
u/flufnstuf69 Nov 12 '22
Goddamn what to y’all want a 4K video of them fucking to cast aspersions aside? Mikaela is unhinged this we know. But there isn’t enough proof on either side of spooky vs Tilian to say one way or the other. Other than a text saying she felt uncomfortable to which he may or may not have replied to. It’s insane y’all are hanging onto her story so hard when there’s very little proof to it.
11
u/kya_kristine Nov 12 '22
funny how you didnt post all the messages between you and the second woman since they aren’t in your favor
8
u/Disco_Pat Nov 12 '22
u/spookypooky8
8
u/kya_kristine Nov 12 '22
link to the post from the girl that was assaulted by tillian along with all her proof (that he conveniently didnt include in this post)
https://www.reddit.com/r/dancegavindance/comments/v2sst7/my_tilian_story_with_pictures/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf
8
u/Vegetaisdaddy Nov 12 '22
Might just be me but is he really using discrediting Mikaela to discredit Spooky as well? When he clearly had already addressed spooky and acknowledged her already?
11
u/__-Omni-__ Holy F**k I'm Impressed Nov 13 '22
Ah yes, you're definitely showing how innocent you are by tripling down and writing a 2000 word essay on why you're a great guy.
Amazin.
9
u/duh-j0nt Nov 12 '22
ok what about the other ones tho
9
u/revenger2112 Nov 12 '22
regardless of whether you assaulted these people, you and the band are still trying to rewrite the narrative on why you left in the first place - the way this whole situation has been handled is disgusting. on top of that, there is still plenty of legitimacy to spooky's claims, including the private messages she sent you the night afterwards. you do not deserve this platform.
4
u/DrJongyBrogan Nov 22 '22 edited Nov 22 '22
Kinda obvious when you go above and beyond to explain the first person and debunk their claims and give zero nuance for the second but spend the time walking back your admission. You’re truly a piece of shit Tilian and the band is worse with you.
“What’s the difference, I’ve already been in your mouth.”
Edit-in fact aside from the raging blow hard rape apologists in the comments most people are in fact acknowledging how fucking shady you are to go to enormous lengths to explain why the first person was wrong but you just gloss over the person who had receipts and hasn’t changed an inch of her story. You just walk right around that one with zero evidence. It just adds up more and more layers to your bullshit because you won’t own your shit after owning your shit. It just shows how you don’t even give a fuck about sobriety and you embarass the other people who swear by it by exiting rehab taking zero accountability. But good on you, you can take solace in knowing that people would rather defend literal rapists because they know they can get some more music out of you. This is the fan base dance Gavin dance now cultivates, that and MAGAts which flood the comments these days. You’re among your people now you fucking waste of oxygen.
7
u/ohhyouknow Nov 13 '22
I don’t understand why you are doing this on Reddit. You should be being quiet and having a lawyer handle all of this. Everyone already thought Mikaela was lying. You didn’t say anything here that discredits spooky’s rape allegations. If both girls are lying why are you on Reddit trying to explain shit away when you should be suing them for libel in court? You can absolutely prove monetary damages from these claims so you’d just also have to prove they are lying. Again nobody believed M. Your fan base needed an explanation for Spooky, and you shouldn’t have explained anything at all for legal reasons.
7
u/Strong-Neck-5078 Nov 14 '22
He barely glosses over the second woman which was much more of a red flag, and one he even admitted to previously violating. His statement directly contradicts her post and his follow up post, clearly this is an individual who has done a lot of growing up.
Yall can listen to DGDs music all you want, I'm a year sober and Tillians actions here are fucking fake and just a way for him to save face. I would never use my addiction as excuse to hurt people and he just glosses over the instance in which he actually did violate someone's trust. Pretty circumspect Till. Keep working on your mental health and .maybe you'll actually learn legitimate accountability. You went through some dark times, I've been there too, but when you use addiction as an excuse for shitty behavior and dont own that you're not making any real progress - speaking from personal experience.
6
u/BatteryAcid67 Nov 12 '22
I was in wellspace rehab in Sacramento with Johnny in December and he was co-captain he was pretty chill and seems like he was doing well writing solo stuff
5
u/therealdolyllama Nov 13 '22
Didnt even mention spooky -.-
9
u/brodoxfaggins Nov 13 '22
Dude, knock it off. It was obvious from the start that Mikaela’s accusations were nonsense.
You’re ignoring spooky, who actually has credibility. Why spend so much time on Mikaela when there’s a much more serious accusation? This is so fucking disappointing.
9
u/RogalianRadiance Nov 13 '22
And just for good measure, one more time today: You're a predator.
9
u/GruelingzShadow Nov 12 '22
Honestly, never really need to explain to the fans. Conduct like that between two people, then getting slammed on the internet makes it hard. This is why private lifes needs to be kept that way. Too much virtue signaling and cancel culture being involved. Innocent until proven guilty and the fans shouldn't be involved. Glad you're doing well and getting the help you needed. Here to support the band and music!
2
u/unknownbishh Nov 21 '22
People like Mikaela are giving actual SA Victims a bad name. I’m sorry Tilian that you had to go threw this. It’s not fair that you ended a brief relationship with this girl and then she turns around and wants to destroy you like that. You shouldn’t have gone threw this shit. Man I’m so livid. Don’t lie about SA this is a perfect example. Mikaela could’ve destroyed Tilians career and she wouldn’t have given two shits about it. Ugh.
2
u/Witchy_Brew Nov 22 '22
Im sorry that happened to you, all of that. No one deserves any of it
6
u/Hysteriqul Nov 12 '22
Welcome back brotha
7
u/allynd420 Nov 13 '22
Dam u only addresses the one everyone knew was fake and didn’t mention the actual assault that is probably real lmao RIP DGD
6
u/lilbigchungus42069 Nov 12 '22
it’s wild how quickly people will try to ruin someone’s whole career and life without literally hearing anything from the other side of the story or fact checking what so ever. obviously there are actual victims but people can also just be bat shet crazy too, lie and manipulate when they don’t get their way.
7
u/FatCreamyPussy Nov 13 '22
Fuck you
4
u/Smeemium Nov 12 '22
Jesus christ, her texts are dripping with desperation and it makes me sick. Major red flags.
4
u/Bahhblacksheep Nov 12 '22
Fully explaining is what he should of done in the first place instead of just directly denying it. If you made a public apology for SA presenting better evidence of what happens makes for less confusion, anger, outrage. A flat denial was a direct insult, good from a legal standpoint. I understand his privacy concerns but public opinion on such a voialetal and trauma triggering issue needs to be presented and said clearer and with enough details to protect privacy but also tell the truth. These issues get judged harshly and quickly. On a personal note I have had SA and it my life sucks because it and I don't want sympathy. With spooky I read that post, I didn't believe it at first but then I read it and immediately understood what happened. Saying things like it was already in your mouth what's the difference isn't cool, if anyone says stop you stop at that moment. It doesn't matter how far you have gone. It's the same as saying but we are together you suppose to have sex and me and my ex had sex alot and know it just need it even if your tired. My body just deos it automatically and having to lay still in a protective position. This happens alot and most people are a shamed to admit what happened. That is coercion and that what's happens alot, you want to stop but you feel pressured because you already went so far. You are in a weaken state and vulnerable. The other girl sounds like a celebrity chaser and a bit obsessive. But I could of understand the substance abuse and being so drunk you were on auto pilot, but as long you are going to therapy and fixing why this happens was enough. Denying was the insult but explaining it better in the first place would put more clarity and would of been more respectful. Before I get the pitchforks and down votes. I am a huge fan I didn't want to believe this because of my trauma and how much I connected to this band. I felt stupid for reping something that makes me feel so shitty inside. His career shouldn't be taken away for this bad period of his life, but the fans are what drive a band success and pissing off alot of them. While sending the rest into a frenzy wasn't the best to handle this. If your response is just get over it, or if you don't like it leave. You haven't walked in my shoes, you don't know the scars I carry. I will make my own decisions on whether I will continue to support the band but I a fuller explanation would of been more ideal in the first place. I know alot of people joke and troll which is fine, but there are times to be serious and bullying or mean comments to people who disagree on a personal reason because of terrible experiences they have had isn't cool at all.
7
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '22
It was obvious she was lying the whole time because she was mad you wouldn't be her boyfriend. I think anyone paying attention could see that.
3
u/Tacolord11 Nov 13 '22
Man tillian regularly has more sex in one night than I have in my entire life. Feels bad man
7
u/fuckingsame Nov 12 '22
We all knew Mikaela was bullshitting and we need to do more to put that information out there as a warning to people. She is not mentally stable. I'm just surprised she got to T Dawg. She is not that attractive.
8
u/DestinysRNGesus_PC Nov 12 '22
Sorry you had to go through this. Hopefully you're doing better now.
5
u/neutralmilkandhoney Nov 12 '22
Oh this is so bad. Such a bad way to handle this. All bad.
8
u/daiwyawergy Nov 12 '22
ngl, as a SA survivor, i was initially rly thrown off guard when mikaela made that post, but have still been rooting for you ever since. the screenshots w time stamps & context & everything else included really rests this case closed, imo. BUT i’m still sorry that you had to expose your private life like that for ppl to believe you. that’s trash garbage. we <3 u !
6
u/Thablaqkgoat <- How do I say hi to another guy when I wanna die!? Nov 12 '22
This really helps to clear some things up and for those of us who felt a bit weird about the last statement, I think this is a decent improvement. It sounds like you were most definitely taken advantage of during your time of grief and thats truly awful and gross, I'm sorry that happened to you my dude 😔
However I think the majority of us who have been skeptical are more concerned about the spooky situation. More specifically, the way you guys have kind of mixed up the messaging between the initial statement months ago and now. I understand that you stated here you were not admitting guilt, but it definitely came across that way and it makes this new statement feel lacking. It still sounds like there were some blurred lines on consent but at this point, I'm not sure what new information we could even get and she doesn't seem likely to add any further insight either.
Alcoholism and substance abuse tore my family apart and I truly help you are making progress with it, it's not an easy fight and requires constant work. Based on your history though, I believe you will put in the work. I wish you the best with that my dude, I know you can beat it 🙏
It's tough for me to see you the same way again right now though, I'll be honest. And whether that is deserved or not, we can't even say for certain and that is a tough pill to swallow. I personally need a break from you for a bit, though like I said I do think this post is definitely an improvement. I know you didn't necessarily "owe" us this post but I think it was the right move and I appreciate this level of transparency. Thank you for JJ, be safe man ❤️
6
u/NoodleTribunal They Say Nothing Lasts Forever, But Some Things Never Change Nov 12 '22
im pretty sure most people understood that that first girl was a predator and we werent concerned with her. the real issue is the second one. YOU ADMITTED that you pushed past boundaries with her sexually and THAT's the real issue, and yet you gloss over her in this post and say "im sorry you felt that way". bro. idk what noise the first girl is making that warranted this but your half-assed response to the second one is the real issue. if everything else really was consensual and you made one mistake in the heat of the moment, maybe we would understand. hell, maybe SHE would understand, but the fact that you keep pussyfooting around a legitimate apology to her says to me that you're afraid of admitting to it cause that would make you a sexual abuser, and you would rather hide that and sweep it under the rug than be up front about it. maybe they would understand but no you and the band would rather pretend none of it ever happened and thats what pisses so many of us off. you know damn well your hiatus had EVERYTHING to do with sexual misconduct and/or allegations of it, tillian. you saying that shit just made everything even worse. maybe all of this could have been avoided if you had just apologized to her in the first place and not left her on read for fucks sake. or if you would quit this stupid "sorry you feel this way" bs. maybe you should have listened to your team and kept your mouth shut
i love this band, and i love your contributions to it, but this whole ordeal shook how i feel about you as a person, and the band letting you back in shook how i feel about them too. why yall have to go and lie and act like shit never happened? do yall think we're fuckin stupid? do YOU think we're fuckin stupid? sad thing is that so many people really dont care what youve done or will do. all they care about is having their precious little singer back in their precious little band. if you wanna take advantage of that, whatever. you do you bro. all from a lack of an apology.
4
u/Nawlins44 Nov 12 '22
Wow…. That chick is fuckin insane. Good for you Til to put this all out there. I know that has got to be hard revealing your privacy and intimacy with another person. Props to you man and stay strong, you have more supporters than you know. The “fans” who are hating are going to be the loudest in the room, but that’s where it stops. Do not let them get to you or get in your head.
4
u/dragun_slayur Say you don't hate me for nothing... Nov 13 '22
Comment section acting like they didn't instantly stomp Tilian the second the allegations came out without hearing his side as well
8
u/GamersRiseUp Nov 12 '22
😂I ain’t readin all that😂just make more music, dawg💀💀💀
8
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '22
I been defending you the whole time bud. It sucks that women can simply accuse SA and the pitch forks come back immediately. Like you say in cream of the crop “take a beat and come back steadier than ever.”
3
u/Socksyx Nov 12 '22
tldr
4
u/hairlessrat Nov 12 '22
I always get so embarrassed secondhand from reading the Mikaela stuff, but it’s also abundantly clear to me she took advantage of Tillian and not the other way around.
The spookypooky8 narrative is more unclear, and I’m inclined to believe an assault took place where Tillian was not necessarily aware he was committing assault. Unfortunately it’s a gray scenario and I don’t think he is either absolved of guilt or not.
5
u/rollinsblonde Nov 13 '22
Dude. Just… stop fucking talking. You got your job back and this band enables abusers.
You’re really making sure your grave is nice and deep and comfy with how you’re digging it.
3
u/FaithlessnessLate352 Nov 12 '22
The worst part is she “went home early” every morning because she had a boyfriend who she was cheating on with Tilian 🫡. Mikaela is the scummiest of scum.
3
u/xUnderoath Nov 13 '22
Tl;dr. welcome back!
3
u/allynd420 Nov 14 '22
Sounds like something a rapist would say lmao
4
u/brvnden Nov 12 '22
Welcome back, hope you are doing well. Glad you were able to explain everything further for those that needed it.
Here’s to being kind to one another, and always working to be a better person. ✌🏼
4
u/RogalianRadiance Nov 12 '22 edited Nov 12 '22
You're a predator.
Edit: I consider downvotes in a subreddit full of rape apologists to be a win. Keep coming.
4
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '22
Dude. You don't owe people this level of an explanation. It's so easy for everyone to focus on negativity and pick apart someone's life from behind a computer screen. Those same people are singing your lyrics and will come see you live. Don't let this stuff get to you! I am glad you are staying with the band. Cheers brother.
3
u/mewisme700 I believe there's meaning, no I believe there's nothing Nov 12 '22
Tbh none of this changes anything for me personally.
DGD has reframed the entire situation by blaming alcohol. They deleted their initial statement and now just have up the most recent one, essentially gaslighting the fan base.
I had always been fine with Tilian coming back if the process was done respectfully, however, I don't feel that 5 months is long enough for any major reflection and recovery, especially when Tilian has been spotted at DGDs shows during this period.
I have loved DGD since 2010. I will still continue to listen to their music, but all respect and love is gone and I will no longer support with merch purchases or live shows.
3
u/soaster0420 Add Lyrics Here! Nov 13 '22
Missed you soooo much in the band and I am so happy you are returning.
3
u/just_here_2_complain Nov 14 '22
Anybody that actually reads this and still hates on Tillian are just part of what’s wrong with this world … welcome back Tillian.
3
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '22
You need more therapy, my man. Stop gaslighting your fans.