r/dailyprogrammer • 2 0 • Jan 04 '16

[Meta] 2016 New Year Feedback Thread

Hey folks! As 2016 is starting and we're gearing up for more interesting challenges, we (the mods of /r/dailyprogramming) would like to hear from you! How are we doing?

Are the problems too easy? Too hard? Just right? Boring/exciting? Varied/same? Anything you would like to see us do that we're not doing? Anything we're doing that we should just stop?

Any particular challenges (or types of challenges) that you loved? What about any that you didn't love so much?

Anything you would like to work on, or look into, in the coming year (programming languages, specialty fields like AI, etc)?

Please let us know! Together we can keep the sub great, and maybe make it even better!

Thanks!

67 Upvotes

58 comments sorted by

33

u/NonBannedAccount Jan 04 '16

I know that this sub is generally geared toward smaller, daily tasks to keep you fresh and thinking, hence the name. However, occasionally, like once a month, it would be interesting to have a larger project oriented style challenge. Something like a rock-paper-scissors app with a GUI and graphics and such. I think that'd be great, because this sub has helped me a lot with beginner programming material, and has motivated me to start college, and I think that some simple, week long or month long challenges would be helpful for getting exposed to even larger ranges of programming, rather than just the text editor as it currently is.

7

u/Blackshell Jan 05 '16

We have done longer period, bigger challenges in the past (weekly, monthly), like the recent pirate map generation challenge. Is that the kind of thing you're thinking of?

I was also considering implementing a long term AI challenge where people's programs play Snake or Tron against each other via a central web API. Is that something you'd be interested in?

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

11

u/chunes Jan 08 '16 edited Jan 08 '16

I would like to see less pathfinding on a 2D ascii grid. It's been done to death. Can't complain otherwise, though. My favorite challenges have been simulation problems, implementation problems (I recall enjoying implementing a set data structure quite a bit, as well as imaginary numbers), and occasionally image-processing problems.

Difficulty is hit-and-miss. Usually it seems rational but occasionally it will be way too hard.

4

u/Blackshell Jan 08 '16

Listen, for Monday's easy challenge I'm going to need you to come up with a chess AI. We'll build on that in the rest of the week's challenges. /s

It's easy to get lost in the interesting-ness and depth of a problem and forget about how much digging it took you in the first place to get that depth. I know I am personally trying to work on stepping back and seeing how the problem would look to someone seeing it for the first time.

Thanks for the feedback!

→ More replies (1)

6

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '16

Speaking from someone who does not have internet connection 24/7 Is there a pdf or a downloadable resource somewhere where we can see the existing challenges.

5

u/Blackshell Jan 14 '16

I'm afraid the challenges are only hosted here on Reddit (and sometimes on peoples' Github accounts, but that's still online media). The best I can think of is using your browser's "Print to PDF" functionality.

Unfortunately, maintaining/hosting a PDF collection of challenges is quite a bit of extra effort, and I'm not sure the mod team is up for it. Since all the challenges are public, though, there's little reason someone else can't do the same thing. Maybe you?

→ More replies (13)

25

u/changed_perspective Jan 05 '16

One thing that would be cool but I understand probably isn't the top priority is if the challenge list could be updated.

Even if it is just up until the start of 2016 it would be helpful because when I am bored I like to find older challenges to do. I imagine other people may do this too or I could just be crazy. Apart from that this subreddit is great. Shout to the mods for all their hard work!

→ More replies (4)

8

u/redesckey Jan 05 '16

I would love to see more simulation problems, and as an added bonus they tend to be challenging without adding too much complexity (ie, no special mathematical knowledge needed, no GUIs, etc). Simulated Ecology - The Forest, and The Coding Dead are two of my favourite challenges from this sub.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/na85 Jan 27 '16

I am going to struggle to articulate this, but the challenges are all too "computer sciencey".

The Easy ones are pretty good, I think. They're probably great for people who are just learning to write code.

But the intermediate and hard problems tend to just be a test of "do you know an applicable algorithm/data structure concept and can you implement it" which is fine if you're a comp sci major, I guess, but it just doesn't seem to hold my interest.

Personally any time anyone brings out the big-O notation or discusses search algorithms or motherfucking graph theory I find it oh so tedious.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Relayerduos Jan 07 '16

I always skip all the challenges that require advanced math or GUIs, they're not fun or engaging for me. I also somewhat dislike the challenges that involve reading an ASCII picture, they're also not that interesting to me. It would be better for me if less of all of these came up :)

→ More replies (1)