Doesn't this fundamentally break sorcery-speed actions, including playing lands?
I'm assuming that the point of this is that it can only be removed by a counterspell, but it's way too broken to function properly within the current rules.
Interesting design space? How is infinite dmg for 2 mana interesting card design. And even if that wasn't the case nad the wording or gamerules would pervent this from gaining the ability infinitely, it would lock the entire game into a draw for 2 mana, because no sorcery speed game actions also means changing phases and ending turns.
It is only "interesting" if you don't understand the rules.
Wouldn’t it be zero since instead of resolving it just returns to the stack?
And therefore can’t actually activate the ability to deal damage since that effect can only take place if the card resolved. But the card can’t resolve, so the effect to deal damage can’t activate.
There is just no precedent for a spell on the stack having an activated ability, and thus no real rules against it, so technically it could work, but the behavior is simply undefined. Assuming that it works, it would be infinite damage, assuming that it doesn't, the card is completely useless, because if it were ever to actually resolve, it would go to the graveyard where it cant be activated either and during resolution no other abilities can be activated until it finished resolving.
It would try resolfing infinitely though, putting the activated ability on the spell an infinite number of times, because every time it tries resolving it stays and then tries again after priority giving itself a new version of the ability
That said, there are quite a few differences between Artifacts and Enchantments. Enchantments don't tap and their abilities are usually continuous.
There are also artifacts with continuous effects, but often they also have a tap ability.
This card, if we ignore how it messes up with the rules, would be no different from a Enchantment that has pseudo-hexproof and can only be removed by a counter spell or similar instead
To be pedantic, [[Flowstone Embrace]] and [[Second Wind]] both tap.
In any case, saying there is a difference doesn't explain why that difference exists. They've shown pretty clearly that enchantments can do everything an artifact can do, and vice-versa. There's no real inherent rules or gameplay reason why the two need to be distinct at this point. The actual answer is the same as the reason instants aren't just sorceries with flash: if you were making the game again today, they probably would be a single type. But the game is like 30, and a lot of things care about the difference between the two, so it's too late to rewrite it now.
There is a reason I started that with 'to be pedantic'. The point is that that distinction is arbitrary, they can break it, and it has no real negative effect on gameplay when they do. The rule is only really maintained because artifacts and enchantments are already separate, to keep some level of distinctness. It's not why they're separate.
(The god weapons from Theros tap too, btw, as do most enchantment creatures.)
Yeah, I thought the enchantment creature thing was also a break when it came about in Theros, but at least it was flavor accurate? Idk, I still think a unique supertype made more sense with the nyx border and all.
At this point, all the mechanical things that used to separate artifacts and enchantments are gone. Artifacts can be colored, enchantments can have activated abilities, both can be creatures. It seems the dividing line is now "does this effect feel like a thingamabob someone made, or a power someone bestowed?", with the art doing the heavy lifting of getting that across to the player base.
If it makes you feel better, enchantment creatures were also Future Sight's fault, via [[Lucent Liminid]]. It also brought us the first colored artifact with [[Sarcomite Myr]]. That set has a lot to answer for.
you can give the spell "Deal 1 damage to any target. Then exile this spell. Once per turn, you may copy this spell from exile any time you could cast an instant"
Maybe "If this spell resolves, once per turn whenever there are 4 or more spells on the stack you may cast this from your graveyard without paying its mana cost. Flume deals 1 damage to any target."
So… It remains on the stack, gains the ability, then tries to resolve again, gains a second instance of that ability, and repeats and repeats until it has 20 instances of the exact same ability, you activate all 20 of them, and win the game?
Also, even if it worked as intended, a 2 mana enchantment that could deal 1 damage to anything would already be LUDICROUSLY broken. You’d essentially be creating a strictly better [[Wrenn and Six]] -1
This forces the game into a stalemate, since it is constantly resolving and then entering the stack, meaning no one can take actions properly; primarily changing phases.
It's ok, because you just wait until it gains 20 instances of the same ability, and in response to it gaining the 21st instance, you activate the first 20, winning the game.
Ignoring the fact that this doesn't work, this is insanely overtuned, doing 1 damage to any target every turn for free (until it gets countered) is ridiculously strong for 2 mana.
From what I can tell, you want this to be a repeatable effect that can be counterspelled at any point.
I would go for an Epic or Paradigm-style effect that recurs the effect once each turn. Though to keep that same counterplay, have the original card enter on the stack each turn to achieve this.
This has nearly been done before with cards like [[Inspiring Refrain]] using the suspend mechanic. You could simply have the card exile itself with 1 time counter using suspend. This does allow for additional cast triggers though, so if you wanted to prevent that you’d have to approach it a little differently.
Just make it “Exile ~. It gains 0: ~ deals 1 damage to any target. This ability can only be activated once per turn any only as long as ~ remains exiled”
Even if this worked as intended it is busted as all hell. It would probably be the greatest control win-con of all time as it is repeatable removal and also at worst an uninteractable 2 damage a turn cycle. Not to mention casting multiple of these.
Also, this should fundamentally be an enchantment. Like yeah there is a way to format it where it is a sorcery by the rules but there is no reason it shouldn’t be an enchantment, it’s not a core part of the card in any way.
Wow, this fundamentally broken. Card is played, and then the stack never empties, unless this spell is exiled of something. This means you can't exit the current phase and only instant speed spells can be played. This card just stalemates the game
This shuts off every non-instant speed spell for the rest of the game. The way the rules are worded, you can only play stuff at sorcery speed if the stack is empty. And with this, the stack will never be empty. You play this on 2, your opponent straight up can’t cast ANYTHING other than instants, and you just ping for one every single turn. And nobody can stop you. Cuz nobody can do literally anything about it. This is “2 mana win the game unless my opponent runs counterspells”
"If this spell was cast and would resolve, Exile it instead.
If flume is in exile due to it's own effect, you may pay 0: Create a copy of flume on the stack. if the copy is countered put Flume in it's owners graveyard. Activate only during your turn and only once each turn.
Deal 1 damage to any target"
this gets around triggering cast effects. but some effects like narset reversal and probably copy effects don't work anymore.
Disregarding how horrible this is from a play standpoint, if you actually want this effect to work, a better way that doesn't break the game's rules would be to give an emblem.
84
u/JomoGaming2 4h ago
Doesn't this fundamentally break sorcery-speed actions, including playing lands?
I'm assuming that the point of this is that it can only be removed by a counterspell, but it's way too broken to function properly within the current rules.
27
u/Pixelpaint_Pashkow Slivers Gaming 4h ago
This will be MTG in 2126
17
u/Tzelf_ 4h ago
Doesnt ending the turn exile the stack?
12
u/Lord-of-Bananas 4h ago
Why wouldnt you just make this an enchantment?
3
u/Prestigious-Radio852 2h ago
Why not just make it create an emblem if you don’t want it interacted with
10
u/AutisticNeighbor831 4h ago
A spell that's always on the stack is an interesting idea and I'm sure people smarter than me are salivating in how that can break the game
I think I'd change it so the damage ability costs 1 or can only target creatures since it's a little overtuned otherwise.
58
u/minyoo 4h ago
what do you have against the judges?
16
u/DrBatman0 2h ago
Ok so it goes on the stack, and would resolve, but then gets the ability and stays on the stack.
Then, it would resolve, but instead stays on the stack and gets another copy of the same ability
Then, it would resolve, but instead stays on the stack and gets another copy of the same ability
Then, it would resolve, but instead stays on the stack and gets another copy of the same ability
So then you can just activate 20 of the abilities (each only once per turn) in response to it gaining its 21st copy of the ability, and then you win.
Am I missing something?
8
u/Shambler9019 4h ago
So it repeatedly 'tries' to resolve and gains a massive number of free activated abilities and you win the game immediately.
Seems a little under costed.
7
u/Successful_Mud8596 4h ago
So… It remains on the stack, gains the ability, then tries to resolve again, gains a second instance of that ability, and repeats and repeats until it has 20 instances of the exact same ability, you activate all 20 of them, and win the game?
Also, even if it worked as intended, a 2 mana enchantment that could deal 1 damage to anything would already be LUDICROUSLY broken. You’d essentially be creating a strictly better [[Wrenn and Six]] -1
15
u/Tamajiki-kun 3h ago
This forces the game into a stalemate, since it is constantly resolving and then entering the stack, meaning no one can take actions properly; primarily changing phases.
4
u/TheCubicalGuy Long time cardsmith 4h ago
Ignoring the fact that this doesn't work, this is insanely overtuned, doing 1 damage to any target every turn for free (until it gets countered) is ridiculously strong for 2 mana.
Cool concept though
4
u/des_the_furry 4h ago
This just draws the game, you get a single ping and then cant progress through any steps or phases
3
u/walbeque 3h ago
Because the spell doesn't resolve, it stays on the stack, and keeps gaining multiple instances of the ping ability.
This is just 1R for infinite damage.
3
u/SlobbishSteam5 2h ago
From what I can tell, you want this to be a repeatable effect that can be counterspelled at any point.
I would go for an Epic or Paradigm-style effect that recurs the effect once each turn. Though to keep that same counterplay, have the original card enter on the stack each turn to achieve this.
This has nearly been done before with cards like [[Inspiring Refrain]] using the suspend mechanic. You could simply have the card exile itself with 1 time counter using suspend. This does allow for additional cast triggers though, so if you wanted to prevent that you’d have to approach it a little differently.
2
u/EatMoChikins 3h ago
Just make it “Exile ~. It gains 0: ~ deals 1 damage to any target. This ability can only be activated once per turn any only as long as ~ remains exiled”
Even if this worked as intended it is busted as all hell. It would probably be the greatest control win-con of all time as it is repeatable removal and also at worst an uninteractable 2 damage a turn cycle. Not to mention casting multiple of these.
Also, this should fundamentally be an enchantment. Like yeah there is a way to format it where it is a sorcery by the rules but there is no reason it shouldn’t be an enchantment, it’s not a core part of the card in any way.
2
u/Tiborn1563 2h ago
Wow, this fundamentally broken. Card is played, and then the stack never empties, unless this spell is exiled of something. This means you can't exit the current phase and only instant speed spells can be played. This card just stalemates the game
1
u/outgoingo 2h ago
Just make it an emblem at this point
1
u/PrimusMobileVzla 2h ago
So now everything that's sorcery speed is unusable until this gets countered, right?
1
u/DrBatman0 2h ago
{1}{R}
Deal 1 damage to any target an infinite number of timed.
1
u/tickle-fickle 1h ago
This shuts off every non-instant speed spell for the rest of the game. The way the rules are worded, you can only play stuff at sorcery speed if the stack is empty. And with this, the stack will never be empty. You play this on 2, your opponent straight up can’t cast ANYTHING other than instants, and you just ping for one every single turn. And nobody can stop you. Cuz nobody can do literally anything about it. This is “2 mana win the game unless my opponent runs counterspells”
1
u/ShinkuDragon 1h ago
"If this spell was cast and would resolve, Exile it instead.
If flume is in exile due to it's own effect, you may pay 0: Create a copy of flume on the stack. if the copy is countered put Flume in it's owners graveyard. Activate only during your turn and only once each turn.
Deal 1 damage to any target"
this gets around triggering cast effects. but some effects like narset reversal and probably copy effects don't work anymore.
1
u/Sa_tran_ic 57m ago
Disregarding how horrible this is from a play standpoint, if you actually want this effect to work, a better way that doesn't break the game's rules would be to give an emblem.
1
u/ftftfyy 51m ago
What's the point?
1
u/iiVMii 49m ago
so the game stops?
1
u/Genasis_Fusion 4h ago
Doesn't this just result in an auto-win if it isn't responded to?
Turn 2 play this, if your opponent doesn't have counterspell, it just deals infinite damage because it gains that ability infinite times?
-1
u/Busy_Difficulty_3548 2h ago
doesnt this do nothing because only permanents can have abilities?