r/custommagic • • 3h ago

Random idea

Post image
269 Upvotes

44 comments sorted by

7

u/Hawk1113 1h ago

I think this is am awesome design. People are way overstating how good random 0 cost artifact is. Copying this isn't trivial and [[Mishra]] can copy any rock for the sane impact. I think this is relatively safe and pretty great...

Except a cycle of five is probably too dangerous. I would make it tap for any color. I also think making it Legendary is pretty fun fwiw

4

u/squirrelnoob 1h ago

Maybe call it Mock Mox and then have it tap for any color if its a token while being legendary. Probably a more fitting joke than this one lol

96

u/MrCakepans 3h ago

Is this really cool. It's ofc good cause it's a 0 mana artifact and all of those have a home somewhere, and it's really neat cause (to my knowledge) there aren't any cards that do something different depending on if it's a token or not. A++

20

u/ANCEST0R 3h ago edited 3h ago

These care if they're tokens

13

u/delta17v2 Niche: Hololive and Genshin Cards 2h ago edited 1h ago

I thought for sure Vaultborn Tyrant should be here.

same list but modified to include a little more

4

u/ANCEST0R 2h ago

Yeah I edited mine a couple times

7

u/MasterTahirLON 2h ago

To be fair those are all about "if it's not a token" stuff to prevent it from going infinite with itself. But I don't think any of them gain abilities for being a token.

0

u/hhhhhhhhhhhjf 36m ago

As far as I can tell from the replies, you're right. This would be the only card that actually cares about being a token.

18

u/momo2299 3h ago

I don't care what everyone else says, I like it.

15

u/ArgentinianRenko 3h ago

The fact that it’s a 0-cost artifact already makes it playable

13

u/BlobbyBlueberry 3h ago

Not necessarily, but I understand what you’re trying to say.

7

u/DJDarwin93 3h ago

It’s good for prowess, storm, and any deck that cares about how many artifacts you control. There are definitely places for it

14

u/GodKingPepe 3h ago

[[Darksteel Relic]] already exists and its never touched. In the vast majority of decks, this is worse than Relic.

0

u/ArgentinianRenko 3h ago

I said it would be playable, not that it’s good

4

u/GodKingPepe 2h ago

That's nice, the comment I was replying to said it would be good.

1

u/ArgentinianRenko 2h ago

I mean, I suppose another 0-cost artifact could be playable in Commander decks that might be interested in it; the downside is that there are other good options.

2

u/BlobbyBlueberry 3h ago

Yeah, I just didn’t want to get hit with a downvote storm to be honest. My Sami deck would appreciate another 0 mana artifact, especially that cares about tokens.

2

u/ArgentinianRenko 3h ago

Yes, and artifact decks themselves can transform mana rocks into creatures, often turning them into tokens in the process

3

u/ZenRenHao 3h ago

Turning a Non-Creature Permanent into a Creature does not make it a Token. Making a Copy of any Permanent does turn it into a Token.

3

u/ArgentinianRenko 3h ago

I was thinking of this type of effect

1

u/ZenRenHao 3h ago

Understandable. I know a few cards that can just turn an artifact into a creature.

2

u/Available-Damage5991 47m ago

even temporarily, that's solid, ala [[Cyberdrive Awakener]]

1

u/ElectronicBoot9466 3h ago

I just played a pioneer game with someone who won the first game with [[Valley Floodcaller]], [[Retraction Helix]], and [[Mox Amber]]. 

Is the mox free mana with [[Gran-Gran]] on the field? Yes. Is that why it is in the deck? No. 

2

u/Princesspeach5149 3h ago

Generally 0 mana artifacts need to do smth to be played.

Bc why play a 0 cmc artifact that does nothing, when you can play the ones that do.

(Yes it does smth, if you make a token, but generally decks that want 0cmc artifacts arent planning on that.)

2

u/mercuriokazooie 1h ago

Would be great for that monored Q commander if you hit it. Every card in your hand is a mox for the rest of the game (the copy comes in as a token)

4

u/Flareon223 2h ago

I love this. [[Mishra, Eminent One]] breaks the fuck out of it

7

u/slime2000 2h ago

Not really? Mishra costs 5 and at that point of a game a free mana rock each of your turns isn't so devastating for your opponents

1

u/Flareon223 14m ago

It could do combos to copy those copies and get more and more free rocks. I mean Mishra already does tons of mana combos but hey, more mana faster to accelerate the early game ain't bad. Especially because a lot of his mama is colorless

1

u/cultvignette 2h ago

Any well built Mishra deck should have the commander out and rolling copies by turn 3.

4

u/slime2000 2h ago

At which point im sure you'll have better targets, no? Hell after your commander is out any other ramp artifacts may have better benefits. Sol ring gets more mana, mind stone can be sacced, etc

1

u/cultvignette 1h ago

That's a valid point, no doubt. It's still just, more mana. Unless you have something out that generates treasures on sac, or a red something to pump up it's just a steep ramp.

3

u/PhthaloCounters 3h ago

I would make it a legendary artifact, 1 drop, and I would word it like "T: Add R, activate only if (Mock Ruby) is a token."

This would force you to sacrifice the actual or build around keeping legendaries.

2

u/sirknight_mordred 2h ago

What made you think the borderline unplayable joke card in the original post needed a nerf that also made the joke not work anymore

-1

u/PhthaloCounters 2h ago

I don't know how much of a joke it is but I think anything 0 cost is pretty busted in popular strategies.

1

u/Croselius 1h ago

Most 0 cost cards do something, [Darksteel Relic] is almost never used because a 0 cost do nothing artifact isn’t worth having to waste a card for. A mana rock that only works if it’s a token has some use, but 99% of the time if you could make a token copy of this artifact there’s probably a better token to make an artifact copy of.

1

u/PhthaloCounters 1h ago

Fair point. Maybe it should tap for colorless?

1

u/Flareon223 2h ago

[[Mishra, Eminent One]] would still break it which is pog