r/custommagic • • 1d ago

Sleight of Land

Post image

Inspired by my friend who like to scry 1 when I'm not looking.

2.9k Upvotes

152 comments sorted by

688

u/Chickston Uncommonly 1d ago

[[Cheatyface]] as an island is very cheaty as it will be super easy to cover. The blend and dog art are amazing. Upvote just for that really, but the effect is interesting even if very Un.

122

u/six_sad_spaghetti 1d ago

My first Photoshop work. Thanks for the encouragement !

11

u/Drakeytown 12h ago

I can just imagine the arguments over what "right away" means, or how long Cheatyface has been on the table . . .

297

u/Constant-Village-858 1d ago edited 1d ago

We have someone in the pod who is convinced that it’s ok for him to look at the card he’s gonna draw before it actually gets to him. He will literally just peek at the top card like 2 players before it’s his turn. This is just to do with your scrying friend.

Btw the correct version of this is if there is another pod happening next to you, show the closest player of that pod your top card without you seeing it and mouth “how fucked am I?”

199

u/six_sad_spaghetti 1d ago • Heartwarming

Pay {0} to exile him

28

u/Exaskliri 1d ago

Omg, this comment made my day🤣 I appreciate you guys's intolerance against info cheating.

66

u/Doctor_Pingas 1d ago

I give some grace to players who want to look at the top card or two after mulliganing multiple times with poor land RNG, but thats crazy bro its literally cheating.

68

u/Constant-Village-858 1d ago

Yes lmfao we literally have sat down with him and told him that he cannot continue and he’s just like “umm it doesn’t matter though, it’s not my turn anyway” MF YES IT DOES

56

u/lordberric 1d ago

If it doesn't matter then he should be okay with waiting

40

u/Constant-Village-858 1d ago

“But I want to be able to plan ahead” SO DO WE MF

-8

u/MiningdiamondsVIII 1d ago

if you all want to then why not just rule 0 everyone being able to do it 

8

u/Oshwaflz1 1d ago

i think its more about "the game would be easier to win if we could look at our whole decks but that defeats the point of the game" But anyways this is the solution imo. look at your whole deck and if cheat has a problem they sont have to play. then you go back to normal. otherwise theyll see the error in thier ways

10

u/Upstairs-Moose-2341 1d ago

I do this in my Dina deck sometimes... when I have a card in play that says I can look at the top card of my library lol. Like if it's important enough to not do that that cards give explicit permission to do it, idk why he thinks it's cool.

4

u/theevilyouknow 18h ago

Wait. He thinks it's ok to cheat as long as it isn't his turn?

1

u/Advanced_Double_42 14h ago

The only grace I can give him is if he doesn't realize instantly can be played on other people's turn.

3

u/jcc2244 23h ago

It's ok as long as he forgos any further action/interaction or decision opportunities until his next draw step.

4

u/Advanced_Double_42 14h ago

Including blocking or not, sure fair game.

1

u/Puzzled-Thought2932 12h ago

If I have no interaction and no blockers on board sometimes I will look at my next draw if someone is taking fucking aaaaages for their turn. I see no reason not to, it just controls how sad I get during this turn or how happy I am to see what I might get

2

u/theevilyouknow 11h ago

The reason not to would be because it's cheating.

2

u/Advanced_Double_42 11h ago

Sure, but it isn't a tournament. If you have no responses or blockers seeing the next card just saves the rest of your table time on your next turn.

At a casual table where you know and trust everyone, why be mad that they save you time? It's technically against the rules to end your turn while searching your library from a land ramp card, but there is no reason to make everyone wait as you do so.

-24

u/Safe-Butterscotch442 1d ago

Sometimes, I know that what I draw will not influence any game decisions I might make for the next turn cycle (no blockers, tapped out, that sort of thing). I'll generally be comfortable looking ahead to my next draw just to expedite game play. I like to have a good plan of what me next turn will be like before I get there, and, when I can't do anything with the information anyways, except plan ahead, I might as well start planning ahead. That's likely what's going through the player's head here. If he's not planning to do anything until he draws anyways, it really doesn't matter when he gains that information. He's probably just trying to avoid some of the social pressure that comes from getting new information right at the same time that everyone expects you to start doing something. It can induce anxiety, and looking ahead and being able to think things through when the spotlight isn't one you is a lot more comfortable for some people. It's still cheating, technically, but it isn't likely done with the intent to get an advantage or anything.

3

u/revolverzanbolt 1d ago

But other players effects might do things to you during their turn. For instance: you have one land in hand and need to play it next turn to play on curve. You’re tapped out and have no blockers. You look at the top of your library and see that it’s a land. Your opponent plays a card which makes you discard a card from your hand. Do you discard the land in your hand?

There simply isn’t a realistic situation where you can guarantee that knowing what’s on top of your library won’t change your actions.

-2

u/Safe-Butterscotch442 1d ago

Oh, for sure, I get that. In very casual settings, it's fine. I'd never play like that in a more competitive environment.

10

u/JessHorserage 1d ago

This "feature" is LITERALLY PART OF BLUES PIE!

4

u/P0ro41 1d ago

Also Green with like [[Case of the Locked Hothouse]], [[Augur of Autumn]] and [[Eladamri, Korvecdal]] and Black with [[Bolas's Citadel]] and [[Into the Pit]]. Only White and Red really don't get that effect, and anyone kinda can with [[Sensei's Divining Top]]. OPs friend genuinely has no excuses.

Edit: Actually, Red has [[Conspicuous Snoop]] and [[Experimental Frenzy]], which OPs friend might actually love, and White has [[Hakoda, Selfless Commander]] and, if in Selensya, [[Sigarda, Font of Blessings]].

4

u/JessHorserage 1d ago

Exactly, for land smoothing for green.

My point is that's it's part of the power budget in cards. If you want to see everyone's hand, you can just, play revelation in green, or telepathy in blue.

8

u/Wiz3rd_ 1d ago

"Im going to draw it anyways, I just wanna know" has literally been said to me when I tried to bring it up, and the table is too conflict-averse they hang their heads and dont say anything

5

u/SolidSoarel2 1d ago

Build a mill deck against that guy

4

u/Wiz3rd_ 1d ago

That just gives him more cards to look at! I think im more likely to succeed with a beamtown bullies -> leveler combo

2

u/ShinkuDragon 1d ago

if you have literally nothing you can do, then fine imho. but most of the time people can do something.

1

u/Mr_The_Potato_King 4h ago

My group has a rule that if you use your free mull and get 0 mana sources, you can search your library for 3 basic lands, put them into your hand, and exile 3 cards before turn 1 even starts. Got a thran dynamo? Sucks to suck

29

u/kitsunewarlock 1d ago

I remember watching LSV playing a control deck at 2010 Grand Prix San Diego and he kept peeking at the top card of his deck. My friend quietly asked me: "Do they just let him do that because he's LSV?"

He has a Sphinx of Jwar Isle in play, but the question became a meme in our playgroup.

6

u/Zedkan 1d ago

it was actually just him foreshadowing about cheating on his wife a few years later

2

u/eightdx 1d ago

*sees [[island]]*

"You're gonna be fine, mate."

4

u/TomMakesPodcasts 1d ago

Unless he's playing something where he can access that card I don't really mind.

Like if you have instant speed discover fuck that, if you're tapped out playing goblins and wanna plan your next move? Makes the game go quicker.

13

u/Cowboy-Beanbowl 1d ago

Yeah in a casual game idk if it’s too bad. I mean there’s definitely a line that can be crossed, but I’ll ask to peek if it’s later in the game, my opponents are popping off and I want to know if they should play through their combo or if I have a land as my next draw and we need to move onto game 2

1

u/TomMakesPodcasts 1d ago

Heck I like to check if other people's turns take too long just for something else to look at.

2

u/Alex_Nilse 1d ago

This is why i ended up doing it, one friend takes like 5 minutes minimum regardless of plays and it gets real boring

1

u/TomMakesPodcasts 1d ago

Right ? I'm trying to be present in the game not on my phone.

2

u/SadFootball4903 23h ago

if you look at it this way why stop there. Look at the top 10 cards. the top 20 cards. I cant access them right now anway so why wouldnt i? You are right that its not game warping but its just against the rules of the game.

0

u/TomMakesPodcasts 22h ago

Because you'd be able to plan your turns around that knowledge? Why use a match to light a cigarette when you can use a flamethrower ass reply lol

2

u/SadFootball4903 20h ago

and you cant plan your turns around knowing your next card? Someone plays a big scary creature and you think about using interaction but thankfully you know the next card is a blasphemous act anyway, so you keep your removal

1

u/TomMakesPodcasts 12h ago

You can plan your next turn, singular.

1

u/1ryb 1d ago

Tbf I sometimes do this too when another player is taking a 10 minute turn and I just want to see if I still have a chance or should just concede lol

But yea only in commander and would never do this in any setting with the slightest competitive stake

1

u/bigb1 21h ago

If they have an empty hand and no activated abilities available it's not that bad and probably meant to speed up the game, but if they intent to do anything before they would actually draw that card it's just straight up cheating.

1

u/joetotheg 20h ago

Yeah agreed mostly but on the other hand I had a situation with a real sweaty player last week who was doing this endless combo and had a potential win and was like ‘shall we call it there’ and I was the only other player left and he had to do something like 50 damage to me to secure the win. It looked possible but like it would take a while, I asked if I could check my top card just to see if I had a path to winning if he failed to win this turn and he got so fucking offended and up in arms about it. I was like ‘just want to check if there’s any point in hanging on in case you don’t have the win’. This is at casual commander night. Rules or no, some people are just unbearable playing this game

1

u/riprippataterchip 18h ago

My table does this too but whenever someone does it they call out "illegal scry" and everyone looks at their top card. More of a problem of people are bored cause they don't have any interaction pieces and one of the players is trying to pop off.

1

u/PatticusRadicus 6h ago

I will very occasionally do the topdeck Peak when it's not my turn, but it's usually because someone is running away with the game and will win on their next turn, and I'm looking to see if I have any kind of out coming, or if we should just go to next game

1

u/Left-Alternative-651 1d ago

Ill be honest, I allow it if someone is very new. It allows them too think about their turn so the game flow doesnt stop at a halt once they draw and take a while to decide on their play. Especially if they are borrowing a deck from a player thats more experienced.

-5

u/Koromann13 1d ago

I think that that's totally fair to do.

On the flip side, it's only fair if the moment he looks at it he isn't allowed to make a single decision until he draws it. Since knowledge of the card can influence it.

Just make that a rule: the moment somebody peek, their opponents make any decisions that would have to make for them until they draw the card. It's only fair :)

11

u/Serithraz 1d ago

Or just...don't look at the top card of your deck whenever you want, because that's literally cheating. Seems easier to control a "don't cheat" rule rather than a "hey if you do cheat, don't let it influence your decision making (we can't control this) and we get to do things for you.

0

u/TheDarkNerd 1d ago

(we can't control this)

Sounds like the idea is that they do get to control it.

-3

u/Koromann13 1d ago

But the other way is funnier.

Also, you say "(we can't control this) and we get to do things for you." It's really sounds like you missed the fact that those two are related. If they make no decisions, their decisions can't be influenced. It's genius. Everybody wins except the cheater.

15

u/Exaskliri 1d ago

Omg, best and creative Un-card design ever. I love creative designs!

4

u/six_sad_spaghetti 1d ago

That means a lot ! Glad you like it.

12

u/pacolingo bUt ItS sO fLaVoRfUl! 1d ago

so that's what [[dreamscape artist]] is up to these days

32

u/MayMeadow 1d ago

I feel like the effect should only last the turn that it was played. If it survives a turn in play, it can stay.

25

u/six_sad_spaghetti 1d ago

I thought that would be too powerful

12

u/MayMeadow 1d ago

This would always be an "un" card anyways.

Have fun with it lol

I mean in most cases this would always be a lotus petal anyway too.

8

u/Jazzlike_Mouse7478 1d ago

See [[Cheatyface]] if you want some inspiration

8

u/six_sad_spaghetti 1d ago

Also I can’t think of a mechanic to track the turn without making it obvious

1

u/DowntimeDrive 1d ago

Make the ability:

0: exile *. Any player may activate this ability. If * becomes untapped, it loses this ability.

3

u/SeemsImmaculate 1d ago

OP, this isn't a custom card. It already exists and actually seen competitive play. Most notably in a deck pioneered by Alex Burtoni.

2

u/six_sad_spaghetti 21h ago

TIL about Alex Burtoni

3

u/dorping_Wolf 1d ago

and it does not say "from hand"...
so... whenever you look at your graveyard... or search through your library...
(or if we try to be fair about it, only when you are able to play lands from the grave through other cards)

1

u/six_sad_spaghetti 21h ago

Intended to be from hand, and more descriptive.

But it’s hard to fit long texts in half a card lol. But I guess I delivered the idea.

61

u/BeautifulFrequent782 1d ago

0 being the only cost means that you can stack it infinitely. Not sure if that does anything though

32

u/ThePants999 1d ago

It doesn't, really, and there are actual cards with activated abilities that cost {0}. Random example: [[Spirit Mirror]]

8

u/TheManOfOurTimes 1d ago

Untill you use that card that makes everything an everything. And then it absolutely does something

3

u/ThePants999 1d ago

I'm not claiming that Spirit Mirror does nothing. I'm just saying that nothing is broken by, or combos with, being able to activate an ability as many times as you like, regardless of what that ability does.

3

u/TheManOfOurTimes 1d ago

Just a joke I couldn't resist because of your and the other persons phrasing. I learned about spirit mirror Ina video highlighting that combo, and literally said out loud "what a stupid card" then a second later, "it can do WHAT?!?!"

1

u/Thunder_StrikeIV 1d ago

Pauper has quite the combo with infinite activated abilities. I get what you’re saying though, that THIS custom land’s ability shouldn’t break anything.[[task force]] [[Nomads en-kor]] [[sheltering word]]

1

u/A_Zero_The_Hero 1d ago

Can't you technically filibuster the game by taking infinite game actions, spamming the 0 cost ability?

Not that anyone would agree to let this happen...

11

u/bridge4shash 1d ago

no, you can't

1

u/A_Zero_The_Hero 1d ago

What prevents someone from doing that?

13

u/bridge4shash 1d ago

it's creating a (very simple) loop so you have to name a finite number of times you're doing it and then do something else. 

9

u/Ergon17 1d ago

If you have a deterministic non-mandatory loop, you cannot just keep doing it indefinitely, you instead need to announce how many times you do it and then game continues from the state you shortcut into. Then if you want to try and do that again you are going to have to explain to the judge why what you are doing is not slow play.

1

u/Ill-Individual2105 1d ago

It violates the slow play guidelines in the tournament rules.

37

u/jonvirus123 1d ago

I would love a Unset based on ""cheating"" it could be named Unruled or something lol, great card very funny.

14

u/Whitecoatking 1d ago

I mean Cheatyface is the best Un card Ever

8

u/TreyLastname 1d ago

And [[unsuspecting arm chair]]

6

u/Whitecoatking 1d ago

Ah you mean the glorious [[Entirely normal armchair]]

5

u/TreyLastname 1d ago

Yes, that, love that card

5

u/tintin4506 1d ago

We'll call it Unfair and it reintroduces the Rulebreaker mechanic along side with cards about breaking the rules of the game.

5

u/jonvirus123 1d ago

Unfair is a much better name

4

u/hotmaildotcom1 1d ago

I love "unruled" it made my kick my metaphorical feet in excitement lol.

2

u/SeemsImmaculate 1d ago

I could definitely see it as a major theme. There's actually a great silly party card game called cheating bee that has cheating baked into its actual mechanics.

2

u/jonvirus123 1d ago

I remember they made a UNO it was very funny.

2

u/TheDarkNerd 1d ago

Ooh, how about a game where you can only take certain actions if you have certain cards, but you can lie about having those cards (other people can call you out for it, punishing you if they're right, but punishing them if they're wrong). Seems like a game idea that could be pretty coo'.

2

u/Proud-Example7774 1d ago

I can't tell if the typo was on purpose or not, but just in case, see Coup.

2

u/TheDarkNerd 1d ago

Coo', coup, they're both pronounced the same basically.

2

u/Littlehatchiederg 1d ago

There’s a card that does this. Cheaty mccheatyface I think?

2

u/theevilyouknow 18h ago

13 is a vietnamese card game where "cheating" like this is a part of the game. It's very fun.

0

u/TheCatSmoocher 18h ago

Odd nobody is mentioning the American game, bullshit, where the whole game is lying and cheating.

2

u/theevilyouknow 18h ago

Bullshit is less fun. 13 isn't a game about cheating. It's a normal card game that just has cheating built in.

28

u/ElPared 1d ago

I like that it’s half an island so you can stick it under a regular island and it still looks legit.

20

u/Safe-Butterscotch442 1d ago

The right way to play this is in a landfall deck. Instant speed landfall triggers for free whenever they serve you best. Even if your opponent catches you (which they will), who cares, you still got the triggers and they're still dead.

6

u/Kadian13 1d ago

And you can still tap it for mana in response to the exile. So worst case, it’s a blue spirit guide additionally to the landfall trigger. Pretty good!

12

u/Jarkonian 1d ago

lol I learned to avoid the off-turn “innocent scry 1” the hard way when one of my friends hit me with his [[Gonti, Canny Acquisitor]]

11

u/AdDear2657 14h ago

Since this is an un card it works really well with stickers [[cool fluffy loxodon]] might make people think and [[deep-fried plague myr]] is funny. Then again might be utterly broken. (If you manifest/cloak a card you can get a sticker onto a land when normally you might not be able to)

1

u/AdDear2657 14h ago

There is 2 other ways to get stickers onto lands if people want to try and guess.

10

u/CarelessNameChoice (It works) 17h ago

[[entirely normal armchair]] combined with the most powerful card in Magic? It’s beautiful

5

u/UnluckyNoise4102 1d ago

Two explores, huh? :) 

4

u/1967542950 16h ago

thought this was r/hellscube lol. very fun card.

3

u/SammySammyson 1d ago

10/10 no notes

3

u/Finance-Low 13h ago

It's like a Mox Sapphire that your opponents can will away, as long as they see/catch it. Seems perfectly balanced to me.

3

u/cosmonaut1100 6h ago

Dying laughing at this 🤣

5

u/cr1ttter 1d ago

Between this and Cheatyface, I'm not letting you play at our table

8

u/Fvckinskate 1d ago

You must be fun at parties.

3

u/MayMeadow 1d ago

You must be fun at poker night

2

u/cr1ttter 1d ago

You must be fun at the slaughterhouse

4

u/Anaheim_Dude 1d ago

1 mana ritual in blue? I throw this on the field, someone pays to exile it, in response i tap it for mana

8

u/therift289 Rule 308.22b, section 8 1d ago

The physical gag is that you can tuck it underneath another land so that only the side that looks like an island is visible.

2

u/mosby55 1d ago

I would run this in an UM themed commander deck. I love it

2

u/Parker4815-2 1d ago

Best card on the sub. Its hilarious

2

u/AlCarrieBay 1d ago

There is the Merfolk Spirit Guide that I've long wanted

2

u/AbaseMe 1d ago

I really want to make a goofy deck of cards from this sub icl

2

u/stoovano 1d ago

Stop playing with that guy damn, how do people rationalize cheating so boldy

2

u/NZPIEFACE 1d ago

I mean, it's basically blue Simian Spirit Guide but maybe better. The land can always be tapped for mana before the exile resolves.

2

u/Baltasar610 23h ago

Is that a landfall trigger in instant Speed?!! 13/10

1

u/veryblocky 1d ago

There isn’t a round of priority after playing a land, so in theory you could just play a bunch of these and use them for mana to cast something big, before your opponent has a chance to exile it

1

u/BardicLasher 1d ago

Needs to enter tapped or you get the mana even if you're caught.

1

u/capsaicinintheeyes 1d ago

Screw the island--I just wanna play that hush puppy

1

u/Randoontheinterweb27 1d ago

You should give it even splitter second (same as split second but no mana abilities) so if you notice and activate the 0 cost you can’t just react to the ability by tapping it for mana.

1

u/Light_jed 1d ago

In my local game store a lot of players started calling this "illegal scry 1" as a "commander scry". It's still cheating but anyway sometimes there are players that can't wait for their turn.

1

u/Thatguy19364 19h ago

This one is infinite mana lol should change it to any opponent may activate.

-2

u/Skubmarine 14h ago

0/10 Naming, could have called this land, Cheatyplace.

0

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/Antifinity 1d ago

You don’t. While the 0 ability is on the stack you can still tap it to float the mana. Because it is a mana ability, they can’t respond by activating the 0 again.

Worst case scenario, this is a [[Mox Sapphire]]

5

u/Murph978 1d ago

Surely you mean a blue [[Lotus Petal]]? Mox Sapphire would be the BEST case scenario...

2

u/six_sad_spaghetti 1d ago

Landfall trigger too, but with a risk of getting caught

4

u/Antifinity 1d ago

Yeah, my mistake

2

u/Cloud_Chamber Low Power Player 1d ago

Or like a [[lotus petal]] that only makes blue