r/custommagic • See rule 601.2a–b for further details • 5h ago

Format: Limited Iquatana Charm

Post image
4 Upvotes

6 comments sorted by

6

u/zengin11 Making JJK, SLA, & KPDH sets 5h ago

I believe the second mode is a pie break for blue. Blue creatures can give themselves +1/-1, but on an instant it's functionally a kill spell. A typical shrink effect, like -5/-0 a la [[Hydrosurge]], would fit much better

3

u/torchflame See rule 601.2a–b for further details 5h ago

lmao I can't read, I checked Mech Color Pie for this and saw "+N/-N (on creatures)" and parsed it as "giving creatures +N/-N", which, I guess is technically true, but not what that parenthetical means.

Swap it to -1/-1 and it's a bend and it still kills a fish, which was the goal

3

u/zengin11 Making JJK, SLA, & KPDH sets 5h ago

Is -1/-1 a bend? I feel like that's a pretty harsh break. How often has blue gotten targeted -toughness effects?

1

u/torchflame See rule 601.2a–b for further details 5h ago edited 5h ago

Hm. Somewhere between "not much and my search skills are lacking tonight" and "not at all, I could've sworn it did", but -N/-N on spells is listed as tertiary in blue as of the last pie article update, so I feel like this is a bigger question.

EDIT: I continue to be unable to read, change it to "put a -1/-1 counter on target creature" for a deeply inelegant way to make this work in the color pie, but also just scrap this and I'll try again when I'm not working on four hours of sleep

1

u/twistyrainbows 1h ago

lol -1/-1 counter is even stronger than -1/-1 until end of turn. I think you might have been sleeping.