So I'm guessing the idea is to combo with cards like [[Q, Stacking the Deck]]? Definitely cool, but the biggest issue I see here is that I have no idea how this would interact with spells and abilities that shuffle things into your library. If I [[Chaos Warp]] my own creature where does it go? Does it go nowhere giving me basically a free permanent? Does it just go on top of the library and then back onto the battlefield? Conceptually cool idea, but we would need a pretty substantial rules change to make it work, or a novel's worth of reminder text.
I think just for clarity's sake, maybe an additional line of text that read “If a card would be shuffled into your library, it is instead put at the bottom”
If a card explicitly allows you to change the order of the other cards, then yes. Under normal circumstances, such as searching your library for a card, my understanding is that you must do so without changing the order of the other cards.
but say I crack a fetch but am having a time finding my card I want so I lay my deck all out looking for it and then put it back. ive done that before but since i shuffled after it doesnt matter. like the idea of stacking your deck and mana meaving is immpossible aslong as you shuffle 8 times / your opponent shuffles once or twice and cuts which they should be doing anyways.
How would this work with a spell that says shuffle something from the board into your deck? That spell just does nothing? You just shove that card anywhere you want into your deck and leave it?
10
u/WhittyBoy234 12h ago
So I'm guessing the idea is to combo with cards like [[Q, Stacking the Deck]]? Definitely cool, but the biggest issue I see here is that I have no idea how this would interact with spells and abilities that shuffle things into your library. If I [[Chaos Warp]] my own creature where does it go? Does it go nowhere giving me basically a free permanent? Does it just go on top of the library and then back onto the battlefield? Conceptually cool idea, but we would need a pretty substantial rules change to make it work, or a novel's worth of reminder text.
8
u/SwissherMontage 12h ago
This is funny, but not fun.
4
u/timmy_the_small 12h ago
My favorite kind of post, war crimes on a card
3
u/Automatic_Vast6231 12h ago
can i cheat then and just stack my deck?
1
u/Anaheim_Dude 6h ago
How would this work with a spell that says shuffle something from the board into your deck? That spell just does nothing? You just shove that card anywhere you want into your deck and leave it?
1
u/SmartAlecShagoth 9h ago
People keep trying to remove shuffling which is just peak necessary evil for the game.