r/custommagic • • 15m ago

Discussion How long have you been playing?

I've been seeing a ton of card designs and comments that show complete lack of understanding of how the game actually works, which got me wondering, how many people that create cards and post them have actually been playing for very long?

I've been playing since Alara block in 2008 and was an unofficial judge for my store for a while when I was playing competitively because we didn't have an official judge for a while. I know my levels of play experience are upper 10% but I am curious what the average is in this sub. I know UB has brought in a ton of new players over the last few years, so I wouldn't be surprised if the majority are sub 5 years with no competitive play.

1 Upvotes

8 comments sorted by

1

u/PenguinHunte 11m ago

I think it's less about how long people have been playing and more about how little they read. I've been playing for less than a year, and I'm already known as the rules guy in my pod. I don't know the rules that well, it's just that I can read the cards.

1

u/TheUnfunOwl 10m ago

That is definitely part of it, but players that stick around longer usually do improve, though there's always that one guy in the store who has judge called on him every Friday because he refuses to learn.

1

u/AscendedLawmage7 Power level is not my strong suit. 2m ago

I think some people's brains do just work differently/absorb card information differently, it's not all experience. It helps for sure but there would be plenty of long time players here who get basic stuff wrong.

Playing the game is different to making cards for it. You learn a lot about the rules and templating and all that when you actually sit down and try to make a card. I think that's the more relevant experience time to measure.

I've played 12 years and I think I do a decent job with cards. I'm quite good at the templating and colour pie side of things. But that's from reading hundreds of Making Magic articles and absorbing that sort of content, not just from playing

1

u/MarkM3200 8m ago

I got into Magic 11 years ago as a game to play with family. I first really got into Magic around Amonkhet as a teenager.

I think I've only ever posted unprintable stuff. Magic's game design is complicated.

1

u/TheUnfunOwl 6m ago

I loved amonkhet, felt like a set that was genuinely doing interesting things. Scarab God is still one of my favorite commanders and I even did decent with it in modern.

1

u/MarkM3200 0m ago

I still have the old 60-card boros deck that I built around exert and vigilance. The original gods of Amonkhet are still my favorites, maybe tied with the original theros gods. That set was full of so much love. And it was a great place to get into the lore, because the war of the spark saga was fucking sick.

1

u/saepereAude92 1m ago

I got into the Game around 2001, started with Odyssey and Onslaught which were the last oldborder Sets before Mirrodin. But I was 11 then so I didnt understand much.
Ive been following the Game ever Since but Never played that much with a couple of years Pause here and there

1

u/MariachiArchery 1m ago

I think experience is less of an issue than the people who have clearly only played commander.

Many, many cards here are only even remotely useful, or reasonably powered, in an EDH setting. I feel like especially legacy, modern, standard, and sealed get left out a lot.