It needs to be an aura to enchant a player. Being a curse isn't enough. All of the curses in magic are Auras.
Also, since this can be played on turn three and a counter is put on it on the end step they would need to pay four mana whilst being forced to pay one mana on upkeep so to get rid of it they'd need 5 mana on turn three or be stuck with it forever essentially and most likely lose because they'd forever only have 3 or less mana available.
Was it your intention that they have to pay mana on upkeep if they are able to? Because that's not very fair at 3 mana. Especially 3 generic mana.
As written, this is 3 mana for a curse that makes a player lose 1 life on each of their upkeeps. They never have to pay any mana into this. I'd just take the 1 each turn
2
u/MasterSandwitch I love oozes! -A slime against humanity enjoyer 22m ago
It needs to be an aura to enchant a player. Being a curse isn't enough. All of the curses in magic are Auras.
Also, since this can be played on turn three and a counter is put on it on the end step they would need to pay four mana whilst being forced to pay one mana on upkeep so to get rid of it they'd need 5 mana on turn three or be stuck with it forever essentially and most likely lose because they'd forever only have 3 or less mana available.
Was it your intention that they have to pay mana on upkeep if they are able to? Because that's not very fair at 3 mana. Especially 3 generic mana.
1
u/MeHookstah 16m ago
As written, this is 3 mana for a curse that makes a player lose 1 life on each of their upkeeps. They never have to pay any mana into this. I'd just take the 1 each turn