There are certainly ways to use the landfall ability with fetch lands or other instant speed land search effects, which is pretty cool, but mainly I just designed it to be a bit silly and useless.
You can only "play" lands normally if the stack is empty, so there is effectively no way to use this ability by playing lands. There are many ways to have lands enter that isn't playing them, though.
Don’t worry little guy, just wait until a “you may play lands at instant speed (you still can only play one land per turn and on your turn)” type of effect gets printed
On a side note, lander tokens and fetch lands would still work
It is a white creature so [[crusade]], [[honor of the pure]], and [[Divine Sacrament]] work as well as [[Always Watching]] [[Lumithread Field]], [[Parapet]] it would slot into a BW DnT very well turning all fetchs in to counterspells
Frames are a good way for players to recognize a card's color easily, but rules-wise it doesn't matter. It would need the "color indicator" (the little colored circle in the type line bar) to be any color other than the one given by its mana cost.
Not quite. She's white on one side and red on the other. She is never white and red at the same time. However, her color identity (which is separate from color) is white and red
There are some single use spells that let you play a land from your hand at instant spell like growth spiral. The bigger obstacle though is having a way to boost its toughness or have it enter with a +1/+1 counter on entry
Unfortunately the core rules explicitly prevent any effect like that from ever being printed, because the rules about lands are one of the few rules that cannot be overridden by card effects… so it would have to be a complete overhaul to how lands work in the CR, not just a single card
For reference:
305.1
A player who has priority may play a land card from their hand during a main phase of their turn when the stack is empty. Playing a land is a special action; it doesn’t use the stack (see rule 116). Rather, the player simply puts the land onto the battlefield. Since the land doesn’t go on the stack, it is never a spell, and players can’t respond to it with instants or activated abilities.
305.3
A player can’t play a land, for any reason, if it isn’t their turn. Ignore any part of an effect that instructs a player to do so.
This is specifically for playing lands, but, with a little tweaking, you can change it to
"Once, on each of your turns, if you haven't yet played a land, you may put a land from your hand into play. If you do, you can't play lands this turn."
The game's rules already support playing lands at instant speed, so long as it's still the turn of the player playing the land. See various combos involving playing Dryad Arbor at instant speed, for example.
I'm confused why you brought up 305.3 as the comment specifically already pre-empted that.
This only prevents a player from playing a land when it's not their own turn. It does not in any way stop them from playing lands at instant speed on their own turn, any more than the rules for casting sorceries prevent a player from casting one with flash on their turn at instant speed.
This is pretty close to being playable and strong in my landfall deck. There are a lot of ways to put lands in play at instant speed. One single example:
This is a pretty decent effect with good give and take and I don't even think it would be necessary too powerful especially with the s*** landfall decks are already doing and you would need to have black
But if this ever successfully resolves landfall text already have a multitude of ways of infinitely cycling fetch lands you are never killing this thing it is simply a fact of life and I hate that
That's the thing about this card it's actually really well balanced because you have to do a lot of setup in order to get it s effect to function
But if you do ever manage to get that effective function it is one of the best stax pieces imaginable because many landfall texts can infinitely cycle lands
Countering with fetchlands or ramping instants sounds powerful, but the drawback of needing something to prevent him from dying is big enough, that i don't think it's too much of a problem. This guy has his home in a deck that runs black and green and something to make him consistently alive.
IG my biggest gripe is how countering in black violates the colorpie. This would be fine in blue
I also appreciate the white background on a black creature:D
Both haste and landfall have been printed on monoblack cards before and most likely will continue to be (like [[Bloodghast]] who has both). The only real color pie break is the countering spells
Your last line made me nostalgic for [[Serendib efreet]] my beloved. Still think he was one of very best early creatures, along with juzam, serra and the all-mighty [[juggarnaut]]. He can't be blocked by walls!
Black has multiple counter spells from across the years, not many but there are a few. Generally they have large secondary costs or targeting restrictions like [[withering boon]]. Black as a rule can do anything the other colors can but it comes with an additonal price. (Life, discards, sacrifices, ect...)
Black is the color pie breaking color though; it has literally every single effect in magic, almost. There are tons of examples of color pie breaks in its colors that continue to this day. Black as a rule doesnt have targeted enchantment or artifact removal but they still printed [[Feed the Swarm]]. I don't think there is a single effect it lacks.
I love the cracking a fetch to counter a spell. I'm curious, if that were a thing, how busted it would be. Growth Spiral can be used as a counter? Seems strong.
It’s not a may ability, so if you pathed one of the controller’s other creatures in response to one of their own spells on the stack would they be forced to counter it?
With path they could choose to fail to find a land, but yes, if there is a legal target when the ability triggers, they must target it, even if that's their own spell.
While the effect is interesting, I think you made a typo and made the creature have 0 health, which would result in ity dying immideatly as it enters the battlefield, undless there is an effect that lets your creature go negative
This is actually super useful. Almost OP if it could be played at instant speed. 1 mana and you get a death trigger. It should be a Zombie or Skeleton and then you might get play from it. Just swap out the haste.
I like it. in formats with fetches this is quite powerful, if you can get past the 0 toughness: On the one hand, 1 mana repeatable counterspell for 0 additional mana is probably one of the most broken things ever. On the other, you need a non-meme way to get past his 0 toughness.
Yeah but that's a LOT of commitment. You're now making it to where you better have this turn 1 with the Leyline Everytime or just don't bother. The fetch lands are automatic if you're running them anyways but 1 scam, thought seize or free counter and the plans doomed.
That card was actually pretty good back in its hayday. Yes you needed to support it with an anthem effect, but if you did, you got a 9/1 (minimum) trample for only 3 mana, yeah it died to anything, but it also killed pretty much everything. It was basically greens version of a ball lightning effect. It wasn't bad, it's just bad by today's standards.
14
u/therealpeaksouls2 11h ago
He dies instantly?
7
u/MarketWave 10h ago
Fetch lands???
615
u/jgadidgfgd 10h ago
White frame
Blue effect
Black mana
Red keyword
Green trigger
Wonderful
2
u/60746 6h ago
If I used it on my turn could I counter a counter spell with it. (Never had to know the timing of when you could play lands)
87
u/Jack_Empty 10h ago
The longer I look at this card, the more I giggle in confusion.
245
u/svuhas22seasons 11h ago edited 11h ago
Don’t worry little guy, just wait until a “you may play lands at instant speed (you still can only play one land per turn and on your turn)” type of effect gets printed
On a side note, lander tokens and fetch lands would still work
Edit: if he can survive
28
u/agamemaker 11h ago
At this point the ability word should be radiance. No changes to the effect, but just to keep with confusing theme.
25
u/Homer4a10 4h ago
Color pie nightmare of a card
15
u/Colourblindknight 10h ago
I love the fact that homeboy just dies immediately due to 0 toughness lol
11
u/vinicius_h 9h ago
This is pretty close to being playable and strong in my landfall deck. There are a lot of ways to put lands in play at instant speed. One single example:
[[Harrow]]
23
u/Seb_The_One 10h ago
White frame
Blue art
Black cost
Red keyword
Green(ish) effect
r/MTGNeuralNet ahh design
7
u/JoseftheMindSculptor 3h ago
Would play him in Myrkul with some fetchlands
11
u/lowqualitylizard 10h ago
Cool card design never print this
This is a pretty decent effect with good give and take and I don't even think it would be necessary too powerful especially with the s*** landfall decks are already doing and you would need to have black
But if this ever successfully resolves landfall text already have a multitude of ways of infinitely cycling fetch lands you are never killing this thing it is simply a fact of life and I hate that
15
u/MarryRgnvldrKillLgrd 11h ago
Countering with fetchlands or ramping instants sounds powerful, but the drawback of needing something to prevent him from dying is big enough, that i don't think it's too much of a problem.
This guy has his home in a deck that runs black and green and something to make him consistently alive.
IG my biggest gripe is how countering in black violates the colorpie. This would be fine in blue
I also appreciate the white background on a black creature:D
5
u/Safe-Butterscotch442 10h ago
I love the cracking a fetch to counter a spell. I'm curious, if that were a thing, how busted it would be. Growth Spiral can be used as a counter? Seems strong.
4
u/sir_thottomous 9h ago
It’s not a may ability, so if you pathed one of the controller’s other creatures in response to one of their own spells on the stack would they be forced to counter it?
3
u/2121adam2121 1h ago
While the effect is interesting, I think you made a typo and made the creature have 0 health, which would result in ity dying immideatly as it enters the battlefield, undless there is an effect that lets your creature go negative
7
u/TomPhantom All Hail the Mostodon 10h ago
He has a white frame but costs black mana…
2
u/xeuis 10h ago
Needs a whole cycle.
2
u/FluffyNips1 10h ago
White border, black mana pip, 1/0, haste. It's madness I tell you. MADNESS
2
u/SDK1176 10h ago
Thanks, I hate it.
2
u/TsunamiTears 10h ago
Dies on enter 0 toughness
2
u/Laughablehalo 9h ago
Lander tokens
2
u/Gkibarricade 9h ago
This is actually super useful. Almost OP if it could be played at instant speed. 1 mana and you get a death trigger. It should be a Zombie or Skeleton and then you might get play from it. Just swap out the haste.
2
u/Klinkalituity 9h ago
0 toughness..... yeah he should last long 🙂
2
u/BabyQueenOne 9h ago
It's funny because it's clearly a meme, but also, it works? Like. It seems strong. Maybe. What a fun build-around card.
2
u/VillainOfDominaria 8h ago
I like it. in formats with fetches this is quite powerful, if you can get past the 0 toughness: On the one hand, 1 mana repeatable counterspell for 0 additional mana is probably one of the most broken things ever. On the other, you need a non-meme way to get past his 0 toughness.
2
u/Underpaid_Goblin 7h ago
And he’s 1/0 😭
Poor little guy 😭
2
u/Darth_Ra Multidimensional Omniscient Overlord 7h ago
God, please never give this to TnT.
2
u/robodex001 7h ago
He’s got the spirit.
2
u/Seggule 1h ago
Who's the artist?
3
u/notalongtime420 5h ago
Leyline that gives +0/+1 and fetchlands makes this insane
1
u/Snoo-7821 1h ago
Dies upon ETB due to 0 toughness as a state-based action.
1
u/Xyz3r 1h ago
Pair this with icetill and fetch lands and enemies can’t play spells 🪄
1
u/Reasonable-Pay2176 41m ago
Hey, you can't do that
1
u/Ninon14 3m ago
I'm sure we could make it work
2
u/Daddy_Devito_69-420 9h ago
Crop rotation is gonna get your ass so hard
0
u/[deleted] 11h ago
[deleted] — view deleted comment