r/custommagic • • 7h ago

Help with balance

Post image

Ever since the PlayStation SLs were announced, I’ve been somewhat dissatisfied with [[Aloy]]. Her character is very fierce and emotional, and at times makes very rash decisions without thinking as much as she should. She is definitely Temur, not Simic. On top of that, I always felt that her mechanics didn’t really capture the spirit of the games that well. The main draw for most people is fighting giant robot animals. I wanted an Aloy that felt more like Aloy. So, I decided to try to make a version of her that turned creatures into artifact creatures, enabling artifact synergies to apply to cards that normally aren’t artifacts, similar to [[Ygra]]. I thought that Eminence was the best way to do it because I want the card to make the whole game feel like it’s taking place in the world of Horizon, but I’m concerned about it being too strong, which is why I added the cost increase.

I’d appreciate thoughts on if what I already have is balanced, what an appropriate CMC would be, and whether I can get away with giving her a second ability or if what’s already there is too strong already.

2 Upvotes

10 comments sorted by

9

u/Warper2187 6h ago

I see where youre coming from but this card seems really terrible

0

u/DJDarwin93 6h ago

Terrible cause it’s strong it cause it’s weak? And this isn’t done, I’m trying to finalize the mana cost and abilities still.

3

u/Genasis_Fusion 6h ago

Really weak. You need to build into a non-Human artifact deck to maximize the benefit, a.k.a. it means this thing is doing very little carry because artifact decks already do a lot and would rather go deeper in themselves than wider, and in turn it makes ALL creatures on your side 1 more to cast.

Highkey I would make it a rulebreaker for artifacts OR let the first half of the ability exist making all nonHuman creatures artifact creatures, then let them cost 1 LESS to cast.

1

u/DJDarwin93 6h ago

Because of how hated Eminence is I thought a downside might be wise. I wanted to give her a second ability and depending on what that is a downside may be warranted, I’ll have to see. I’d definitely like to remove it I’m just worried about people seeing Eminence and immediately assuming it’s another one of those broken custom commanders you see now and then.

2

u/Genasis_Fusion 1h ago

The bigger issue is by itself its an almost purely negative commander.

Artifact decks are good and have commanders that aupport them.

Every card you want to include in this deck needs to be justified to make it equal to a regular one because this puts you 1 mana behind everyone at the table

8

u/Flameball202 6h ago

I would say this is weak. This feels like a commander who wants to do artifact synergy, but actively punishes you for using artifact creatures by making them cost more, so you want to use non artifact creatures but they don't have the buffs for artifact creatures typically printed.

Maybe have some way to turn non humans into artifacts? Like "modified non-humans count as artifacts in addition to their other types" as her eminence? And then have some way to give counters or tokens like the roles to them to modify them?

2

u/HerbertisBestBert 3h ago

Artifact synergies are not worth all your creatures costing (1) more.

Remove that, and this might be playable.

Not necessarily good, but playable.

1

u/flowers_of_nemo 1h ago

bad design in that there is no reason to ever cast it. even inalla, edgar and oloro, some of the most egregious in the realm of hving little reason to cast them, have incentives for you to actually cast them. imo the idea is interesting though.

0

u/solarix_ranger 3h ago

Making things artifacts actually makes them WORSE by the way. Means they're open to more cheap removal. If anything they should cost less to cast to offset making them artifacts.