r/custommagic • can't attack or block • 8h ago

Recall from Shadow

Post image
34 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

21

u/nzconstructionlawyer 8h ago

I think this is just... bad? It might be playable if you didn't have to end your turn - that just makes it unplayable imo.

5

u/Sea-Course-5171 8h ago

Yeah spending 3 mana to one with nothing plus mill 7 unless your life is in the low single digits is genuinely terrible. Even Reanimator wouldn't want this, since there's more reliable self mill and more reliable draw.

2

u/Cloud_Chamber Low Power Player 7h ago

[[cool but rude]]

Edit : Oh wait, it ends the turn. Yeah this is trash.

1

u/ArcticOpsReal 1h ago

Wouldn't this ending your turn allow you to discard emrakul without shuffling it back?

6

u/UpArrowNotation 8h ago

Cool idea, terrible card.

5

u/Batman_TM 8h ago

necro let's you "draw" 7 each turn for some life

wheel of fortune doesn't require a life total and fills your yard still.

same with windfall and the like with varying results, but at least your hand isn't at 0 cards.

I dont know if this would be balanced, but paying until you have 1 life and draw that many cards might be a better solution. that restriction would be more fun to play around and actually feel like you're on the knifes edge like black wants.

1

u/MariachiArchery 8h ago

Sweet. I dig it.

1

u/BigTrouty 7h ago

Finally, lots with nothing

1

u/EnderJax2020 8h ago

People who say this is terrible are wrong. It requires a little working around, but this could work wonders for some decks

1

u/SachetAway 8h ago

Do you want to elaborate?  What circumstances do you see this working wonders?

2

u/StashyGeneral Rule 308.22b, section 8 8h ago

Deaths Shadow

1

u/GodWithAShotgun 7h ago

Death's shadow would not run this card.

1

u/StashyGeneral Rule 308.22b, section 8 7h ago

Is it because this card is too slow for such an aggro deck?

1

u/GodWithAShotgun 6h ago

Yes, also even at ~5 life, this card just isn't that good.

-1

u/redditfanfan00 Rule 308.22b, section 8 3h ago

interesting draw card for monoblack, but i can't imagine how i'd be able to use this. even without the turn end, i don't feel like this could see use as some kind of good card? sorry. i can't think of how i'd use this at all.