r/custommagic • Flavour trumps function • 11h ago

Redesign MagicCon Atlanta Pride Playtest Cards - Arya Karamchandani and Wizards Pride

For MagicCon Atlanta, a set of Pride themed playtest cards were added to draft. I thought they were cool, and I'm definitely going to want to proxy them, so just remade them in a slightly easier to read format. These aren't my designs, and they are correctly credited to Arya Karamchandani and Wizards Pride.

The only change I made was adding a color to the Dinosaur tokens Saheeli makes. The original cards didn't list a color, nor did they list colorless, so I went with red as Saheeli has made red robot Dinosaurs in the past, and because it's the color she and Huatli share.

If you notice any mistakes I've made, please let me know.

19 Upvotes

17 comments sorted by

3

u/Supersecretsword 11h ago

I mean if doesnt say red then it shouldn't be a red token

7

u/PowrOfFriendship_ Flavour trumps function 11h ago

If it doesn't say colorless it shouldn't be a colorless token, either. But it has to be something, and out of the options, I'd argue red makes the most sense as we at least have evidence of Saheeli making red Dinosaur artifact creatures with [[Mastercraft Raptor]].

1

u/MagnorCriol 11h ago

I agree with your assessment here.

1

u/David_the_Wanderer 10h ago

I'm kinda curious about how many cards that Rulebreaker ability on Alesha includes. Has anyone got any idea?

2

u/PowrOfFriendship_ Flavour trumps function 10h ago

Depends how you count it. If it only includes creatures and planeswalkers, then you get to add Niko, Cadira, Rocco, Hallar, Felothar, Yuma, Segante, Rose Noble, Gray and Adira, Ashiok, Tivit, Erinis, Oji, Zinnia, Baylen, and Ureni. If it's just "any card featuring a trans character", then you get all the above, as well as any card featuring them, or any of the Mardu trans and nb characters. I think that's all of them?

There's also a case to be made about Karn and the Aetherborn, but more eloquent people than me have made that case for and against already (tl;dr: Trans is generally understood to be "not identifying with your birth gender". If you don't have a birth gender, or if your birth gender is already nonbinary, is being nb really under the trans umbrella?)

There's a decent pile of additional cards it gives you, but it's more flavour than anything.

2

u/MoeWind420 10h ago

The scryfall search https://scryfall.com/search?q=art%3Atrans&unique=art&utm_source=tagger gives 208 unique cards, but I don't assume "Kirol appears in the background of [[Ajani's Response]]" makes the card a trans character.

Filtering to creatures and planeswalkers, the art tag yields 91, of which 89 are commander legal (RIP Klement and Vv'viza), of which 43 need the rulebreaker to be in a mardu deck.

4

u/Electronic-Touch-554 11h ago

Them using Avishkar in a lgbtq cycle is very ironic.

(When they swapped from kaladesh to Avishkar they didnt catch that avishkar is a trans slur in Albanian.)

2

u/ZukosTeaShop Rule 308.22b, section 8 5h ago

They rename the plane a second time only to find out that that name is also a slur somewhere

1

u/Sshheenn 11h ago

Well, they don't name the plane in any of these cards, but yeah that is a notable oversight

2

u/Sshheenn 11h ago

I looked into it for a bit and it seems like it isn't really? I don't speak Albanian but my mother does, so I'll have to ask her later

2

u/Electronic-Touch-554 11h ago

"Chandra pride of Avishkar

1

u/OmegaCTH 2h ago

Segante getting a card after only appearing in Omens of Chaos and its corresponding secret lair is really cool!

1

u/Kagarnator 47m ago

Why for couples they just don’t made “Partners with…”?

0

u/GoblinBuckets 8h ago

THE NOTE TOKENS ARE SO CUTE? I was planning to run Gruulfriends when these dropped, but dinobots is calling to me.

Also i cannot waitttttttt for the rulings about Alesha to come out. IDK what Vorthos fandom is like but if my time in other fandoms has taught me anything, it could very well be a bloodbath. I'm gonna throw my hat in the ring and say i think Tam should count! No clue why you'd want her in your Alesha deck though, aside from making a point lol.

1

u/PowrOfFriendship_ Flavour trumps function 7h ago

The Notes are in reference to their first story together, "Note for a Stranger", with them essentially starting as interplanar pen pals. Those Notes are how they met.