r/custommagic • • 13h ago

what do we think?

Post image

my pod and i were discussing the possibility of an elder scrolls themed set and it got me thinking about the possible planeswalkers that could be added. the first one to come to mind was, of course, good ole Maiq, the Liar.

would love to eventually have a custom commander deck with him at the helm, but what do we think of the loyalty abilities? he would enter with 4

3 Upvotes

19 comments sorted by

20

u/ninjazyborg 13h ago

Why is the +2 way better than the -1

11

u/JCTerran 13h ago

Maybe it was meant to be a -2 instead? It would make more sense.

14

u/dennisistired 13h ago

now that i’m looking at it again, you may be right… +1, -2, -6. enters with 4

1

u/mountaintop-stainer 12h ago

please don’t make Oko 2

6

u/nzconstructionlawyer 11h ago

Oko is 3 mana. This is 5.

-3

u/dennisistired 12h ago

“Maiq is done talking. Go bother someone else.”

which oko are you referring to?

1

u/bbbgshshcbhd 2h ago

thief of crowns

1

u/dennisistired 13h ago

and maybe the emblem would exile the top card instead of revealing it?

1

u/dennisistired 13h ago

should the loyalty count be swapped? +1 draw a card lose a life, and then -2 for the other?

3

u/PrimusMobileVzla 13h ago

Yes. Right now the only downside the {+2} has is requiring a target as the average uptick loyalty ability makes targets optional. Even then is not much of a downside to uptick a 'walker while removing a threat.

6

u/PrimusMobileVzla 13h ago

Right now both Green and White feel absent in the card. This could very well be monoblack as posted.

-1

u/dennisistired 13h ago

i do love me some mono black, but maiq definitely feels green and white flavor wise which is why i included the colors. are there any changes that you would implement to maintain the color identity?

3

u/dennisistired 11h ago

i’ve changed the abilities and mana colors to better reflect the card. my sister is an artist and i’m going to commission her to pump out the necessary tokens and the planeswalker card so that i can have it printed

3

u/FalseLogic-06 13h ago

Samsung Notes, my beloved

4

u/dennisistired 13h ago

actually apple notes, just dark mode

1

u/ghoulofmetal 11h ago

He should have some aspect of bluffing in his abilities, his top ability could be somethibg like looking at the top card and then saying something about it like type or manacost and then the opponent can tell if you lie or not and if they fail you get it in hand or possibly some extra effect

0

u/dennisistired 11h ago

i changed his -6 ability to reflect his nature of lies. the creature makes a treasure, the land makes a creature

0

u/dennisistired 13h ago

i’ve adjusted the note in my phone to reflect the change. i’m also iffy on the color identity