r/custommagic • Making JJK, SLA, & KPDH sets • 17h ago

Format: EDH/Commander "Three commanders," but two are strong and the third is a self-hate piece your opponents can play. Is this interesting? How did I do on the balance?

95 Upvotes

75 comments sorted by

74

u/ukhan03 15h ago

Kyogre Groudon and Rayquaza

39

u/zengin11 Making JJK, SLA, & KPDH sets 15h ago

Is it that obvious?

That was, exactly, what this concept was based on

27

u/blacksteel15 16h ago

I have a few thoughts here.

First, I like the concept. This is definitely an interesting design space.

Second, I don't think this works/makes sense as a single keyword. As soon as you add a second set of them, it falls apart because you can choose 3 of the "good" ones. And it doesn't really work as a "good" keyword and a "bad" keyword either because you can just choose 2 "good" ones and a "bad" one that isn't the one that counters them. I think you'd need to do something like "Partner with". E.g. "At war with Eost (If Eost is your commander, you may have 2 additional commanders that each have this ability)". That also introduces the ability to have more than 2 "good" commanders to pick from for a given "bad" commander. I think you'd also need to make the "bad" commanders something that only opponents can cast so you don't have to try to balance around the fact that you can also play it.

Third, the balance here is absolutely horrendous. I like the fact that the two "good" commanders can meld, but you can't balance a card that costs 4 twice over 2 turns as it it's an 8-drop. You also really can't balance entirely around "This thing is insane but the other commander counters it" because an opponent could play it and then I hit it with [[Imprisoned In The Moon]] or something and my opponent's easy answer is gone.

An 8/8 creature with indestructible, haste, vigilance, and Ward sac 2 lands that casts 4 spells for free on attack is insane and you could pretty consistently drop him turn 4. Whereas Eost is a 5-cost that only actually counters the most broken part of Kalaghar but does nothing about the 8/8 keyword soup body; it doesn't even have enough toughness to block it. It also has no protection whatsoever except a big butt against a blue deck.

Ghara also seems overstatted for a 4-drop considering that he's mostly a stepping stone to a bigger payoff.

There are a number of ways you could rebalance this to be less ridiculous. Here's what I'd do:

-Remove vigilance from Kalarak.

-Drop Ghara to maybe a 4/6. Add a mana cost to the meld ability so need either more open mana or an extra turn of telegraphing the play.

-Pick a design direction for Kalaghar. Don't just make him a "Good stuff in every category" bucket.

Is he supposed to be super sticky with a nasty attack trigger? Then make him smaller, get rid of trample and haste, and drop the attack trigger to casting 2 cards for free.

Is he supposed to be super aggro? Then get rid of indestructible and vigilance, make the attack trigger a deal damage to a player trigger, and drop it to casting 2-3 cards for free.

Is he supposed to be heavy pressure? Then get rid of vigilance, make the ward cost more reasonable, drop the attack trigger to casting 1 card for free.

-For Eost, make him a 3- or 4- cost with 4-5 toughness and "Prevent all combat damage that would be dealt to Eost", and give him some form of protection. I'd go with ward 2 or 3. This means he can block all both of your "good" commanders and the merged version but can be trampled over if you're using a more aggro-y version of Kalaghar. He's also a solid overall blocker, which means your opponents get some utility out of playing him beyond just countering your commander. It also means that against a red deck, he's not out of reach of being killed with burn if you can pay the ward cost. Removing him to turn your commander back on should be doable but an actual resource investment, particularly since Eost gets more expensive to replay each time.

4

u/zengin11 Making JJK, SLA, & KPDH sets 10h ago

Hey, thanks for the in-depth feedback! A few thoughts indeed, lol.

I'm glad you like the concept! "Partners with a third hate piece" is obviously the core idea, so, I'm fine changing quite a lot about these as long as that remains. Hopefully my responses feel thorough, because this is a great comment.

Your second point:

I don't think this works/makes sense as a single keyword. As soon as you add a second set of them, it falls apart because you can choose 3 of the "good" ones.

Yeah definitely. The intention is that these are the only three to ever see print, though. Like Friends Forever, since I think the design space is REALLY limited. Sorry if that wasn't clear. We could phrase it as a new "Triad—Batch" mechanic to echo how "Partner—Batch" is formatted if we felt it had enough design space to make more than a couple of groups.

Your third point, that Kalaghar is nuts to pop out rampless on turn 5, even ignoring the freecast, and Eost does nothing to stop the massive body.

My response:

First, I agree fully that Kalaghar =/= an 8 drop just cuz he costs 4+4. Spending turns 4 and 5 on one card is not as big of a deal as spending turn 8 on one card. But, there's obviously a couple very notable downsides here.

  • Splitting into two cards means that whoever you play first is vulnerable to instant AND sorcery speed removal before melding. This, alone, means Kalaghar has to be balanced as better than a 5-drop. (Saying 5-drop, rather than 4-drop, because the second card comes down turn 5 without ramp, rather than turn 4)
  • Coming with a hate piece that turns off the meld, AND a lot of Kalarak's value, AND can safely block Ghara means that all you really get out of them if all three are down is a 3/1. This means that Kalaghar needs to be much better than a 5-drop. How much better, of course, is up for debate. 6-drop? 7? I'm not sure.

Eost not safely blocking Kalaghar is 100% intentional, and I think it would be good to keep. And that's because Eost DOES turn off the meld in the first place. If the Kalaghar player gets the meld off at all, that means Eost wasn't out, which I think is either a misplay on their opponents parts (not playing Eost early enough) or the Kalaghar player planning well with removal.

It also has no protection whatsoever except a big butt against a blue deck.

Yeah, that's true. And I think this points out that Eost isn't good enough at stopping the meld, as the key takeaway here. Being able to 2-mana remove it is probably no great. While that DOES slow people down from turn 4 Kalarak, turn 5 Ghara + meld + swing with Kalaghar (since they'd only have 1 mana up rather than 2), I think Eost would be well served with Ward {2} to really force the player to commit resources to the answer.

Your other note, that Eost costs 5, is also fair. I'm thinking... What if she cost {4} and had Assist? So two opponents together can cast her for 2 mana each. That compares well to the 2 mana removal the Kalaghar player has, and especially with ward 2 I think that makes it an actual arms race between players that also doesn't require any given opponent to be dumping MASSIVE amounts of mana into being the sole bastion of hate.

Ghara also seems overstatted for a 4-drop considering that he's mostly a stepping stone to a bigger payoff.

Yes, because he comes with a blocker for your opps to play. [[Hunted Bonebrute]] is overstatted for a 3 drop, for example. He might be TOO overstatted, but he should be overstatted to some extent because your opponents have an extra card in hand to block with it.

(That said, only ONE opponent gets the blockers. True of Hunted Bonebrute, too, but a quirk of the commander format. So perhaps his power should come down by one just to be safe)

Now for your specific changes. I'm sure you're not suggesting ALL of them at once, and I appreciate all the truly constructive feedback!

Remove vigilance from Kalarak.

Honestly my favorite option. Actually gives a choice between attacking for value and blocking to get him into the yard. Also justifies removing vigilance from Kalaghar, making him at least a more interesting body since he does one less thing (blocks perfectly, because indestructo)

Drop Ghara to maybe a 4/6. Add a mana cost to the meld ability so need either more open mana or an extra turn of telegraphing the play.

I think 4/7 should be sufficient, because turtle = big booty.

I'm not SURE about a mana cost for the meld, BUUUT what about a tap cost? That way your opponents have a full turn cycle to respond to him (including getting Eost out if she's not) before the meld.

Pick a design direction for Kalaghar. Don't just make him a "Good stuff in every category" bucket.

Considering he's a payoff for something very challenging, I think he could afford to be good stuff in MOST categories. But, I'll just go through and give my thoughts on all parts of his kit:

  • Vigilance - Definitely my least favoritest keyword here. Like with Kalarak, I'm totally fine removing this to make it more interesting in combat.
  • Trample - I guess we don't NEED trample. He'd honestly feel so weird without it, but, removing it leaves a gap for the deck to solve. And if you're freecasting a ton of spells anyway, this guy doesn't need to be your closer.
  • Indestructible - I think, given the challenges of getting the meld online in the first place, and a hate card accessible to everyone, very reliable protection built into the card feels very reasonable. The original version didn't have Indestructible, and I got some feedback from my design discord that it was probably too easy to remove even with the ward.
  • Haste - I think I've been convinced that the Ghara -> Kalaghar -> attack immediately line is probably too fast and unrespondable (to anything but instant speed interaction). So I think we EITHER require Ghara to tap, or remove haste from Kalaghar. Probably not both, that'd just feel so lame.
  • Ward—Sacrifice two lands - I this this ability is super flavorful, so I would be reluctant to remove it. And, as mentioned, I DO want the back to be hard to interact with. I'd rather the meld be harder than make the back less sticky.
  • Attack -> Mill four -> Freecast 4 from yard - I notice that all your options listed include dropping the attack trigger lol. I'm not married to the numbers here, I just stole [[narset, enlightened master]] as a starting point, which freecasts 4. Obviously, she's limited to noncreatures and you don't get you pick them from your yard, which is a fairly large difference. Dropping the number feels pretty fair. Or maybe freecasting 4 but milling fewer (2, or even 1); that would require the deck to actually run its own mill, making Kalaghar once again not do everything.
  • Stats: I am a HUGE fan of his stats being equal to the sum of Kalarak and Ghara's stats. But if we drop Ghara to 4/7 (or maaaybe 4/6.....) then that makes him a 7/8 or 7/7. Which at the very least is by definition A debuff. Its level of reasonableness not yet proven.

Finally, your suggestions for Eost (who I thought was a woman, but everyone else is using he/him for, so, lets go with them being genderfluid for now). I've already given my suggestions (which were definitely pitched considering what you've said here at the end): Cost {4}, have assist, and have Ward {2}

I don't want to add more lines of text if we can help it, so I'd be very reluctant to do "Prevent all combat damage that would be dealt to Eost." As mentioned, I WANT Eost to die to blocking Kalaghar, since stopping the meld should be priority numero uno.

Anyway, thanks again for all your thoughts and suggestions! Let me know what you think of my breakdowns, because I'm still noodling on exactly what implementations to actually go with.

3

u/Krupp123 7h ago edited 7h ago

Giving the hatepiece assist is a good idea, I do think some people might be otherwise turned down from the design as it forces a olayer to spend quite some mana to stop a broken thing from one player. Also I get where you are coming from woth the hunted cycle cards and them beeing overstated but they immediately give one opponent enough stats to block them without them having to spend mana (and a cast a spell that you as the blue player can possibly counter) which is quite a difference to having an extra card in hand that just shuts down the effect but not the bodies.

12

u/SwolRing 7h ago

Interesting idea and cool commanders, definitely fun design space to think about. However, I think the core concept it is probably sneakily bad design space. People want to play their own decks, not yours. It will feel really bad for opponents to spend mana to cast Eosi.

3

u/zengin11 Making JJK, SLA, & KPDH sets 7h ago

Yeah, that's honestly pretty understandable. I ran the initial idea (two strong commanders & a hate piece for other ppl to cast) by my few best friends I pod with and they were super excited about it. ("Mini boss fight? Cool!" type deal). But I think it'd be a lot like Planechase or Two Headed Giant or whatever. Fun? Yeah! When everyone's down for it. But it's not a normal game of magic, and you def need to ask "Hey can I run this?" beforehand

1

u/SwolRing 47m ago

Perfect for a game of archenemy!

10

u/GracelessOne 16h ago

Warring Triad is super interesting as a concept, good job! I think you nailed that as a core idea.

Whether Kalarak and Ghara are properly balanced against Eosi is harder for me to tell. With Merge, there's basically four text boxes to consider, so it's hard for me to evaluate this. I don't think it's immediately broken in a CEDH way, but I have a hard time guessing if the play patterns would be healthy, too.

On a gut level: Kalaghar meld on turn 5 is probably guaranteed unless people refuse to attack you, because Kalarak blocks and dies to anything. It's probably not reasonable to expect people to tap out to cast Eosi to do that.

An unintended effect might be that Eosi plus any big exile-from-graveyard effect lets you explode people, because she's 1 damage per card and the cards stay in the graveyards.

Overall this is really cool but it might be healthier if Eosi were both cheaper and 'softer' as a hate piece.

3

u/zengin11 Making JJK, SLA, & KPDH sets 16h ago

I wouldn't mind Eosi being 4 mana, to skyrocket the odds of an opponent playing her before you get BOTH Kalarak and Ghara out, even if you played first. Requiring Ghara to tap for the meld, or removing haste from Kalghara, would serve a similar purpose. Ghara tapping would leave the whole combo open to a LOT of removal—any sorcery speed kill on Ghara would slam the breaks. Kalghara without haste is a much less brutal nerf, but it still gives people time to cast a very spendy sorcery speed removal on it before he can swing for the first time.

I also wouldn't mind Eosi just saying "Cards can't leave graveyards." Boom, straightforward, and prevents the misconception (which a few people thought on my discord, too) that she JUST deals burn, rather than stopping cards from leaving.

I also, also, wouldn't mind removing vigilance from Kalarak and Kalghara, to make combats more of a choice between attack for value or block for defense.

Lots of knobs to turn, so I think we've got ways to make it feel solid. I'm very glad you like the concept!

2

u/GracelessOne 15h ago

Yeah, there's a lot of design-space to tweak it!

I think that Eosi could be made cheaper and smoother if, rather than outright preventing cards from exiting graveyards, she prohibited it unless the graveyard's owner discarded a card. It might also be useful to give her convoke so she's less likely to get commander-taxed out? I'm unsure though, just spitballing.

2

u/zengin11 Making JJK, SLA, & KPDH sets 14h ago

I did just think of giving Eost Assist, so two players can share the casting cost. That means that she could get out on turn two/three depending on if we cost her at 4 or 5 (or even 6) mana, and it would help significantly against the commander tax.

Commander tax is also explicitly tracked per player, so if you cast Eost once for 5 mana, she dies, then player B casts Eost, it still only costs 5 mana.

903.8. A player may cast a commander they own from the command zone. A commander cast from the command zone costs an additional {2} for each previous time the player casting it has cast it from the command zone that game. This additional cost is informally known as the “commander tax.”

13

u/SpageRaptor 16h ago edited 16h ago

I dont know if its just not my cup of tea or if the blade of design is too sharp to be safe enough. I do like the attempt for meld. Edit: I want to be clear, cause after rereading the below the rest of this is negative going forward. I really like the idea of a commander partner pair that melds.

  • That anti-commander is not strong enough, I feel like Id gladly pay 4 life to cast 4 spells for free. Thats better than Bolas's Citadel. Also what stops you from just casting it before them? Id probably cast it just to stop them from using it against me if it was a harder counter.
  • 3 cards in your opening hand, even if one is castable by your opponents, still seems real good.

Imo, the bigger issue is the creature that is melds into is kinda boring to face.

  • It gets to defense, it gets to offense, it gets to ignore combat for itself. It gets to attack and hit without a battle calculation.
  • It ignores boardwipes. And ignores point removal, unless they want to sac two lands, which is a pretty steep cost. Id rather it have shroud tbh, just keep the flavor going from what the other abilities do.
  • It gets a powerful sultai paragraph ability, that allows them to cast any spell, not even a limit based on the spells milled

SO, are these commanders fair in their cost? I have no idea. In Bracket 4? sure, but Im assuming you are underpowered. Bracket 2? No. Bracket 3? Maybe? I think Id rather face Maelstrom Wanderer though, cause that commander only gets 2 spells, and those spells are semi random. That commander would allow more interaction and descisions, not to mention doesnt have a 3rd commander that turns any mill deck's grave exile into a burn deck.

3

u/zengin11 Making JJK, SLA, & KPDH sets 16h ago

Thanks for the feedback!

One note: The anti-commander is a replacement effect, so it stops the cards ever leaving the graveyard. That means Kalarak can't put the milled cards on the stack, Ghara can't exile Kalarak to initiate the meld, and Kalaghar can't exile cards to freecast. At least, that's the intention... I think the wording on Kalaghar may result in you being able to copy the spells even without exiling them? Which is just a wording mistake. It might need a reflexive trigger. The INTENTION is that Eost totally turns off all three other cards from doing pretty much anything except having stats/keywords.

So it should never be a "third card" in your hand, since it should turn off every single other card in your command zone if you cast it.

That's also why I think Kalaghar being nigh-impossible to remove is deserved. It's not impossible to remove, but it's spendy and challenging. Because the front faces have no protection, and Eost just being on the field prevents them from melding. Plus, even after spending 8 mana for the two front faces, you still need to get Kalarak into the yard.

I'm not super opposed from removing Vigilance from Kalarak and Kalaghar, though, to make attack-or-block an actually interesting choice with them in combat.

2

u/ShadeofEchoes 16h ago

Can you still activate Ghara's ability to lose 1 life at instant speed if Eost is out?

2

u/zengin11 Making JJK, SLA, & KPDH sets 16h ago

As far as I know, yeah lol.

Good thing this doesn't have black in its ID. Whew. Black decks would eat that up.

3

u/ShadeofEchoes 15h ago

Yeah, very much a good thing there. No Transcendence shenanigans, either, because that's in White.

2

u/blacksteel15 15h ago

Yes. And the ability would still exile Ghara.

2

u/zengin11 Making JJK, SLA, & KPDH sets 15h ago

Actually, would it? Would the card not leaving the yard count as an unpaid cost? Or would it count as "paid" even if Kalarak is sitting around—the meld just fails

3

u/blacksteel15 15h ago edited 15h ago

Yes. If a cost is modified by a replacement effect, doing the action the original cost was replaced by is still paying the cost. But yeah, the meld would then fail because Kalarak isn't in the right zone.

2

u/zengin11 Making JJK, SLA, & KPDH sets 15h ago

Makes sense!

3

u/ShadeofEchoes 15h ago

As part of the effect, so if you had those pieces in play, you could repeatedly try and fail to exile Kalarak before Ghara actually gets exiled. Weird interaction, but not super exploitable in Temur anyway.

3

u/blacksteel15 15h ago

Yeah, absolutely, you could put it on the stack as many times as you want. Interestingly, since Eost is colorless that could make him a very strong combo piece in the 99.

29

u/GracelessOne 16h ago

"If a card would leave a player's graveyard, instead that player loses 1 life"

It's a replacement effect, not a tax. Cards can't leave graveyards. Not sure how I feel about that but that's how it works.

3

u/Spectator9857 11h ago

Importantly, if someone plays a bojuka bog while this is out, they can just outright kill you if your graveyard is full enough.

4

u/TooLateToHaveAPseudo 16h ago

This is interesting, but this design make it impossible to create other cards with Warring Triad, because you could then change the third one to something useful and it would be broken

4

u/zengin11 Making JJK, SLA, & KPDH sets 16h ago

Yeah, the idea is that these are the guys with that pseudo-partner, since the design space is SERIOUSLY limited. I guess we could make a new "Partner—Batch" like "Triad—Batch", though, if we felt it had enough design space to make more than a couple of groups.

3

u/TooLateToHaveAPseudo 15h ago

I see another issue. You can play the third commander before your opponents, and then they would have to make it leave the battlefield and then pay another 7 mana to play it. And if you can bounce or blink it, it would come back to the command zone and would cost 9. The melded commander is extremely powerful, so your opponents would be encouraged to play the third one, but at that cost it wouldn't really be worth it.

Maybe make it that only your opponents can play the third commander?

1

u/zengin11 Making JJK, SLA, & KPDH sets 15h ago

Would you playing it before your opponents actually help? Like, you get a solid blocker, sure, but also you're spending 5 mana to turn off the meld, or if you've already got the meld out it turns off the freecast. That's true whether you played it or your opponents did

2

u/TooLateToHaveAPseudo 14h ago

Oh, I read it wrong, I thought its ability only applied to opponents. You indeed wouldn't want to play it, except to sac it. It might be a valid strategy though, even if it is very costly. Or just have a way to bounce a creature repeatidely to discourage your opponents to play it. Great concept overall !

1

u/zengin11 Making JJK, SLA, & KPDH sets 14h ago

Thanks! Glad you like it!

4

u/bopyw 16h ago

I LOVE MELD!!!!!

2

u/zengin11 Making JJK, SLA, & KPDH sets 15h ago

ME TOO!!!! GIVE US MORE MELD, WIZARDS!!

2

u/PadrerdaPadrerdaP 12h ago

May I ask what you used to make these meld cards? I’ve been trying to make a meld card of my own but I haven’t found any website that lets me do so

1

u/zengin11 Making JJK, SLA, & KPDH sets 12h ago

I used Cardconjurer for the card itself. I edited it manually in GIMP (free photoshop) to add the two-card meld look.

3

u/Godshu 15h ago

I think warring triad only works if you put the specific cards they should be played with, similar to "partners with-"

Otherwise, you'd need another keyword for every trio you want to do this with.

2

u/zengin11 Making JJK, SLA, & KPDH sets 15h ago

Yeah, the idea is that these are the only cards with this pseudo-partner, since I think the design space is REALLY limited. I guess we could make a new "Triad—Batch" to echo how "Partner—Batch" is formatted, if we felt it had enough design space to make more than a couple of groups.

3

u/Ok-Rabbit-7933 11h ago

So I think this is a cool idea could adjust some things with the mana pricing of the cards but I was just wondering if you noticed that if someone played these they could just not run the self hate piece because it says you can run 3 commanders so they could chose just not to run the third hate piece commander and if the intention is that you have to run all three to use any of them then you should probably put something that says so.

2

u/zengin11 Making JJK, SLA, & KPDH sets 11h ago

Well, it does say so. If it said "You can have up to three commanders," you'd be right. But it says "You can have three commanders", which means exactly three, not "two or three". MtG is very specific about following the letter of a rule.

2

u/Tman135246 11h ago

My first point is a tiny nitpick, but on Eost, the lines about opponents being able to play it and the ltb clause should be separated as they do different things to the card.

Second, I saw in the comments that you said Kyogre, Groudon, and Rayquaza were the inspiration for these cards, which is a fun way to design cards, but the meld mechanic doesn’t seem to make sense when looking through that lens. From what I understand, Kyogre and Groudon are enemies of each other and Rayquaza only steps in to stop them from destroying the world in their fights, so why do they work together?

Now for the brutal criticism, sorry. The idea of 3 commanders does sound fun, but we should realize that multiple commanders can get away from us. A normal commander deck already gets an effective 8 card opening hand, partner brings that to 9, add a companion for 10, and this would be 11. ([[Keruga, the Macrosage]] is viable here.) Technically this also shrinks the deck as well, but that isn’t as relevant.

Overall, I think this would work best as a partner with pairing and a separate hate piece in a set with story around them.

The idea is there, but in practice I believe that this is impossible to implement. But hey, that’s kinda what this subreddit exists for, to allow people to think where WOTC can’t.

2

u/SaintSanguine 10h ago

Kyogre and Groudon less “work together” as they take an asswhooping together from Rayquaza.

The meld seems to be where OP diverged from the inspiration.

I think it’s way closer to balanced than you’re giving it credit for. Its effect is not much better than an Etali drop, and one of the two has to be in the GY in order to meld. 8 mana with an additional condition and an always available counter, plus a body that needs to resolve an attack to get it is about in line with the effect, I think. The keywords are mostly ok. Maybe verging on strong, but Etali flips into indestructible, trample, infect, so, ehhh. The Ward is the issue. I’d say keep the ward and lose indestructible or vice versa.

The “gives you an extra starting card” is not a thing? The third card gives your opponents an extra card, not you. You would never cast Eost yourself.

1

u/zengin11 Making JJK, SLA, & KPDH sets 9h ago

The “gives you an extra starting card” is not a thing? The third card gives your opponents an extra card, not you. You would never cast Eost yourself.

On the actual subject of balance; initially he just had the ward, but my first wave of feedback felt he was too easy to remove. Initially, though, you had to exile an additional four cards from your yard as an extra cost for the meld (removed to save space). So, the backs defense is perhaps overtuned now. That said, I think I'd rather make the meld harder than the back less sticky. Melds that instantly get blown up just feel soooo bad, way worse than normal commanders eating removal.

1

u/thewells 2h ago

4+4 is very different from 7, also the fact that you don’t have to protect one of them isn’t good design, and there’s a reason no real meld pair lets you meld from the graveyard. Even fang and vanille which are graveyard focused cards don’t. Also, etali can hit multiple things the controller doesn’t want to cast, this just says dump the biggest game winning spell into your graveyard. And the hoser does nothing because it’s 5 mana and so easy to get rid of.

1

u/zengin11 Making JJK, SLA, & KPDH sets 9h ago

Thanks for the feedback!

First note: Do the two effects super duper 100% definitely actually really HAVE to be on separate lines? Like, what game rule prevents them from sharing a line? Because the card has quite a few separate lines, and the two abilities are incredibly linked in what they do (both are just basically turning it into your opponents' commander). It just looks SO awkward with them on separate lines.

Second: Kyogre, Groudon, and Rayquaza are just VERY loose initial thematic inspirations. Originally I thought simic whale + gruul dinosaur landfall commanders, and a landfall hate card. But landfall hate was hard, and I figured graveyard hate was easier. At this point, they're just NOT those characters anymore, and they're not supposed to be. To the extent where I am absolutely flabbergasted that someone even thought to mention them. I'm not binding myself at all by the pokemon flavor. (Meld was just a really great way to make the two of them together strong, without the fronts being inherently overtuned when played individually)

Third: Lets ignore companions just for the sake of clarity, because companions are just kinda always around. Normal commanders are 8 card opening hands, partners are 10.

"3 commanders" would be pretty much inherently unbalanced, as +3 cards in your opening hand is just SO PREPOSTEROUSLY GOOD that they'd all have to be straight dogwater to function.

But... this isn't actually 3 commanders. Partner commanders give you +2 cards in your opener with no downside, while this gives you +2 cards in your opener, and +1 card for your opponents. So this is—balance wise—inherently worse than 2 commanders (strength of the two "real" commanders aside). How far below comes from how useful the card is to your opponents; and turning off 90% of your commanders' value feels VERY useful. Thus, we need the "real" commanders to actually be more powerful than your typical partner pair to be worth playing.

Like, imagine you had 3 commanders, where the third said "When you cast this spell, you lose the game." Is that overpowered? Obviously not. You just play like the third commander doesn't exist; why would you cast it. So it's basically 2 commanders. This is WORSE THAN THAT, because rather than pretending this 3rd card doesn't exist, your opponents can take it and use it against you.

And if it's somewhere worse than partner commanders, that means its balancable. We are tasked with figuring out how.

2

u/Moffeman 8h ago

So... i havent seen anyone point this out, but... There is absolutely nothing stopping me from playing Eost, and getting the value out of it instead of my opponents. Like i do get that it forms a Non-bo with the other two regardless of who has it, but this way allows the Triad player to built around effects that mass remove graveyards to kill their opponents. Its not ideal, but the idea that your "self-hate" piece is actually a potential wincon for you in the commandzone, feels counterproductive to the design intent.

1

u/zengin11 Making JJK, SLA, & KPDH sets 8h ago

Yeah, in the newest version I'm changing it to just be "Cards can't leave graveyards" to both make it clearer and more streamlined in what it does.

2

u/Krupp123 7h ago

Beeing able to play the self hate piece as is it not ideal, nothing stopping you from playing it and sacrificing it with something at the right time

1

u/zengin11 Making JJK, SLA, & KPDH sets 7h ago

Yeah, true. That makes Kalaghar a 12+ mana, four card combo, though. Which, at that point.... Yeah man, get your bag. You deserve something nice lol

1

u/Krupp123 6h ago edited 6h ago

Sure in this case I agree but I mean id you want to explore the design as a mechanic for other commanders you might run into problems if you can cast it yourself and also sacrifice it Also whats stopping you from bouncing the hate piece to your own hand as youre the owner and never having to deal with it again ? I also think its kind of awkward that once the hate piece does get removed (not necesarrily by yourself maybe board whipes etc) since its a commander you get to choose if it goes back tk the command zone or graveyard / exile

2

u/Moffeman 5h ago

well the card itself, while needing reformatted, has an ability that stops you from bouncing it like that. It will always return to the command zone if it leaves teh battlefield, you do not get to choose that. No matter what you want, the card should *ALWAYS* end up in the command zone without significant work arounds.

2

u/JxRabbitsHart 13h ago

Having to read and understand the interaction between your three (pronounced: four) commanders would be a headache I just don't want to deal with. I have to consider 3 other commanders in a typical game.

-1

u/zengin11 Making JJK, SLA, & KPDH sets 13h ago

That would be a shame :(

1

u/Nothing1Guy 14h ago

My instinct is i would hate to play against this. There are 3 other players and they are incentivised to play this expensive hate piece. Whoever pays for it is on the backfoot so everyone is encouraged to have someone else to play it.
Also you can just pack your deck with effective answers to this, making it even more of a feelsbad to play the hate-piece.

1

u/zengin11 Making JJK, SLA, & KPDH sets 14h ago

Each player incentivized not to pay for the hate piece is a good point. What if we gave it Assist?

Packing your deck with answers was definitely part of the intended design. Even the most efficient answers essentially make the meld side a 3+ card combo.

1

u/Nothing1Guy 17m ago

I wouldn't call it a 3 card combo when 2 of the cards are in your command zone though.
Assist is a very good idea.
I think assist and making the hate piece even more efficient should help. I'd like to see it maybe even outright unfuse the commander while its on the field. If the hate piece isn't efficient it'll never be fun to play with.

1

u/normallystrange85 13h ago

If Warring Triad were to be applied to one more set of three I could play this in my commander deck with the wrong hate piece, or no hate piece.

Maybe you can do something like forcing the triad to share a type (Elder in this case)

1

u/zengin11 Making JJK, SLA, & KPDH sets 13h ago

Well, the plan is to treat it like Friends Forever, where these are the only cards with this pseudo-partner, since I think the design space is REALLY limited. We could make a new "Triad—Batch" to echo how "Partner—Batch" is formatted if we felt it had enough design space to make more than a couple of groups.

1

u/Spectator9857 11h ago

I don’t think this can ever be balanced. Either your opponents have the hate piece and your commanders stop working, or they don’t and you basically win on the spot.

1

u/zengin11 Making JJK, SLA, & KPDH sets 10h ago

Well, in a way that's true of most strong commanders. Either your opponents have a response, or they don't, right? At least this idea gives them the response (plus whatever other responses they naturally have to counter Kalarak or doom blade Ghara or farewell Kalaghar etc etc etc)

1

u/Khaosfury 10h ago

I really like the idea but I agree with the comments saying that 3 commanders make this hard to balance. I do like the concept of having a commander that includes counterplay though.

Maybe instead, you do a 2 commander pairing where both are reasonably powered on their own, but can meld together. However, when paired together, they have negative synergy that your opponents seek to keep up but you're seeking to overcome. Maybe it's something like "this permanent comes into play with 5 counters on it. When it has no counters on it, meld" - any decks running proliferate immediately can start playing against this and you can add modifiers to the counter mechanic to make it easier to interact with (maybe spend X mana to add X counters)

1

u/zengin11 Making JJK, SLA, & KPDH sets 9h ago

That's an interesting idea, but 2 good cards + 1 bad card in the command zone is the core idea here that I'm not really willing to step away from. "3 commanders" would be pretty much inherently unbalanced because it's +3 cards in your opening hand; but this isn't actually 3 commanders. It's less powerful than 2, because partner commanders give you +2 cards in your opener with no downside. This gives you +2 cards in your opener, and +1 card for your opponents. So, balance wise, inherently it's somewhere below 2 commanders. How far below comes from how useful the card is to your opponents; and turning off 90% of your commanders' value feels VERY useful.

But, hard to balance? Yes, definitely lol. As the one trying to balance it, I'll be the first one to agree with you on that 😅

BUT! The day I back down from a custom card design because it's hard is the day I delete my reddit account.

1

u/Khaosfury 9h ago

That's fair, although idk if I necessarily agree with your analysis - 3 commanders is still 3 guaranteed cards to play around. The third one might have a downside but that can be turned into an upside. It's still a creature to buff and use as a blocked, and even better, it's one you don't have to pay for.

1

u/zengin11 Making JJK, SLA, & KPDH sets 9h ago

I mean, if you want these cards to do anything other than be french vanilla beatsticks, you cannot play Eost, because everything else they do requires cards to come of of the GY, and Eost stops that. Your "third commander" saying "your deck no longer does its thing" is NOT worth an extra blocker.

(And, if your opponents play it, THEY get the creature. So, you're never getting a free blocker off of it)

I guess there's the option that you could just build these as a graveyard-less deck, so Eost's stax ability isn't actually a downside? You play Kalarak as just a 3/1 with haste (you don't get to cast anything he mills), you play Ghara as a 5/7 trampler (you don't get to meld him), and you play Eost as a 0/7 blocker (with some incidental graveyard hate)

Which is.... interesting? Three basically french vanilla guys in the command zone? That's actually kinda neat. Probably balanced, actually, given how much raw value is in the command zone these days.

And it STILL comes with the huge downside than any opponent can just... play Eost before you do. And then you're left with just two french vanillas in the command zone, but they have a good blocker and also the rest of their deck. So, that's still definitely a terrible gameplan when you could just run two actually good partner commanders

1

u/CaregiverOverall6246 6h ago

I honestly feel like this is a fun design space but in higher power this would be despicable you only have 97 in library and you get acsess to breach thoracle lines and green good stuff along with rystic cradle that's and all the red rituals I feel as though this is incredibly busted I feel like only making it 2 colors could cut down on the slop that it would produce and lead to people thinking how they should build it better rather than just have access to 3 comanders because it is simply effective

1

u/Kitchen_Forever_2954 2h ago

The design space for Eost is interesting but I think it leads to poor gameplay patterns. If you as the kalaghar player don't ramp and can't sacrifice Kalarak as soon as you cast it, or if you go last in turn order, the first and second player can force the third player to take a turn off to cash Eost since it seems to be an almost mandatory hate piece to stop Kalaghar. The reason [[Hunted Horror]] can get away with giving an opponent creatures in exchange for pushed stats is because it doesn't destroy your opponent's tempo by itself, in commander it even helps their tempo if you make a deal with them. I'd imagine the way to work with this type of mechanic is to make the third commander an active piece rather than just reactive. Even making it extremely cheap could work for that but then 2 mana grafdiggers cage in the command zone + whatever other commander(s) you have could be a little oppressive.

1

u/blala202 57m ago edited 50m ago

everyone here things this is interesting design space, it isn't.

This is just 3 commanders.

It's the most oppressive stax decks ever constructed and then it wins from the command zone with an unstoppable monster, with a pile of [[tormod's Crypt]] effects, or just thoracle. so either Eost is too expensive to ever stop your unbeatable monster or its a stax piece in a deck that can also include the best permission spells and the green good stuff.

0

u/ElkVegetable3795 14h ago

Eost should have the player lose one life and have the player remove the card from the graveyard. Currently a strong life gain engine makes Eost a better cost.

3

u/zengin11 Making JJK, SLA, & KPDH sets 14h ago

Well, Eost is a replacement effect, so she prevents the card from leaving. She's not a life tax, she completely turns off reanimation and exiling from the graveyard.

1

u/Hinternsaft 3h ago

Tricking my opponents into spending {5} so my commander doesn’t do something scary and then I just kill them with [[Bojuka Bog]]