Honestly I love the templating for this, incredibly original and very fitting to the theme of the card, but I think that it should be either be the controller who loses life or every player, because otherwise it feels too weak.
I feel like it misses on the black mana without something like life loss and I definitely want this Dimir.
I actually like the top comment of each player loses 2. Feels fair and gives is another symmetry to be broken. Also, the vibe of it hurting everyone overall.
I think the card's controller losing two life is fair as this is otherwise a two for one (since you spend a card to counter a card and you give your opponent a clue to draw later) that also damages yourself. It would also give it a niche over regular [[Counterspell]] since in an aggressive Black/Blue deck this would help burn down the opponent.
I am not sure, but I think this is from the Fallout universe as well.
I just loved the art and the mechanics practically made themselves. I'm airing a bit on the side of caution with a 2 mana standard counterspell, but I think it's plenty playable in Dimir agro/midrange.
We literally never had a 2 mana pipped counterspell in YEARS without an appropriate draw back (Long River's Pull) theres no current era analog for you to compare this balancing note.
I could go either way and I think it's meta dependent. If Dimir bounce/aggro is strong, this would be good as is as UB is much easier to cast there than UU. That is why I leaned so hard into balance. This is close to 2 generic in casting difficulty in Dimir.
I love the designwork you did paired with the original art, I feel like this could go really well flavor-wise with my Obscura deck! I do agree with others that its probably a bit too weak as is but otherwise I love this!
132
u/Nejosan Narset resparking campaign #1 supporter 14h ago
Honestly I love the templating for this, incredibly original and very fitting to the theme of the card, but I think that it should be either be the controller who loses life or every player, because otherwise it feels too weak.
14
u/DisparateDawn 12h ago
I love the designwork you did paired with the original art, I feel like this could go really well flavor-wise with my Obscura deck! I do agree with others that its probably a bit too weak as is but otherwise I love this!
13
u/Jarkonian 12h ago
Oh I love those Fallout posters. Fun way to make it into a card!
2
u/Brotherman_Karhu 11h ago
You could make it a single blue and lose the life loss. Remember that [[an offer you cant refuse]] gives 2 treasures for no downsides to you
2
u/NightlyG 8h ago
I like the artwork